PDA

View Full Version : vVintage vs Gummy


Comic Tragedy
September 8th, 2009, 12:29 PM
Freestyle Extravaganza - Round 1
vVintage vs Gummy

This Battle's Presets:

Voting will end: 2 days from now (September 11th)
Medium: These contestants chose to compete with tags.


Rules:

You can only vote once
Take the medium into consideration when voting
If you are in this round of the competition you may not vote
You must have at least have 3 sentences of explanation as to why you voted for whomever you voted for.
No picking favorites, or voting for who ever you want to compete against next round.


Entries:

vVintage:
http://i400.photobucket.com/albums/pp82/veeVin/dm.png

Gummy:
http://i30.tinypic.com/9iwo42.png

Loki
September 8th, 2009, 05:52 PM
omg gummy why. D:<

I hate that stock. Like, no joke. Everything about that stock, I despise. The composition, the overusedness, the lines, but putting that aside, I totally would've liked your tag better if you'd kept the background pure white, killed the wireframes, and did something about that weird quality on her hand. I'm just not feelin' some of the effects you've got going on. It feels all over the place- messy and out of hand.

The sort of sheen that vVintage has going on however is like a jaw dropper for me. I'm not any fonder of that stock than gumgum's, but the depth is really nice for a battle at this caliber, the text is freaking amazing, and I love the light effects. Overall composition is much simpler and nicer, to boot.

Sublime
September 8th, 2009, 06:34 PM
Hm.. I really honestly like Gummy's more. I don't know, the sporadic-ness and all just caught my eye. Maybe I'm just one who prefers a bit more liveliness in GFX XD;

At first, I couldn't really tell what was going on in vVintage's. I really do like the tag, but it seems a bit off for me.

I think I'm just one who prefers a bit more sporadic things in GFX, so I voted for Gummy.

THIRTY-SIX
September 8th, 2009, 09:58 PM
Again with the three thing. :<

I really like the stock gummy used, but not the result of it. The grains really appeal to me but those lines on the right do not gel well with the concept I'm seeing. Should've agreed on icons. I can see the tag working better as that.

On vVintage's I see a slight photomanip which is actually my preferred medium. :p
Also type is preferred on his too.

Mukkamoto
September 10th, 2009, 07:25 AM
I like vVintage's tag a lot more since the depth was well shown, and the colors very warm. Has a dark/warm feel to it which I liked. SO i voted for vVintage.

Comic Tragedy
September 10th, 2009, 03:42 PM
i'm voting for vVitage. Like the simple manip style. Colors are good. And I love the text.
Both great entries.

Ezzo!
September 10th, 2009, 04:57 PM
vVintage got my vote.
Hers has better colors, great depth, good composition and execution. Gummy's tag is way too chaotic in composition and in colors. The effects don't fit very well at all in his tag.

edit: wait wtf i can't vote D:

Gummy
September 10th, 2009, 05:07 PM
vVintage got my vote.
Hers has better colors, great depth, good composition and execution. Gummy's tag is way too chaotic in composition and in colors. The effects don't fit very well at all in his tag.

edit: wait wtf i can't vote D:

Don't worry about voting. The polls don't count anyway.

Comic Tragedy
September 11th, 2009, 04:31 PM
We conclude this round of the tournament with vVintage ahead of Gummy in votes, making vVintage the winner. If you are going to congratulate the winner please do so in her profile, or in the discussion thread.

Great round both of you.

vVintage Wins.