moments. vs Comic Tragedy

[Comic Tragedy]

Freestyle Extravaganza - Round 1
moments. vs Comic Tragedy

This Battle's Presets:

Voting will end: 2 days from now (September 12th)
Medium: These contestants chose a tag medium


Rules:

You can only vote once
Take the medium into consideration when voting
If you are in this round of the competition you may not vote
You must have at least have 3 sentences of explanation as to why you voted for whomever you voted for.
No picking favorites, or voting for who ever you want to compete against next round.


Entries:

moments.:
http://i233.photobucket.com/albums/ee207/mattimogalli/touchcouple.png

Comic Tragedy:
http://i91.photobucket.com/albums/k284/andytoe/pujols-1.png

[Ezzo!]

Comic Tragedy gmv.

moments tag was okay but I wasn't too fond of the colors adjustments and the gradient maps used in it. The compo is odd and there aren't that many effects other than a c4d or 2.

CT's tag wasn't his best either tho, the lines seem random and kinda sloppy, and the stars look too crowded in certain areas throughout the tag making parts seem lq. The colors in this one imo are better than moments.

I mainly voted for CT, because of the compo.

[Gummy]

Voting for CT for pretty much what Ezzo said. I mean, they're both sexilicious tags, but when you get down to it, CT seemed to put more time and effort into his tag. My only gripe about his is the low quality effect those stars (and that stock didn't have great quality to begin with).

[THIRTY-SIX]

CT, quite liked the vibrancy and energy the tag seemed to give off.
Liked the incorporation of the hashes. Also I love splatter effects due to personal preferences and what splatters symbolises to me. Doesn't seem like stars to me. Like the way the grey lines go from fat to thin and such, represents imperfection, making it seem like the guy is saying I'm not perfect but I'll do my best for you.

[Comic Tragedy]

We conclude this round of the tournament with Comic Tragedy ahead of moments. in votes, making Comic Tragedy the winner. If you are going to congratulate the winner please do so in her profile, or in the discussion thread.

Great round both of you.

Comic Tragedy Wins.
This battle concludes the first round of the FSE tournament.
Thank you to all of the competitors thus far.