PDA

View Full Version : B/W: Garbodor VS [Sawsbuck]


Kaori
March 25th, 2012, 06:53 AM
http://i.imgur.com/IOdLU.png

Another Weekly Poll! :B & This time I bring to y'all, Sawsbuck VS Garbodor.

http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Which one gives you the better impression & why?
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Which Dream World art do you prefer?
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Against each other, which one would win the battle?
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?

Discuss, Discuss, Discuss!

Squirrel
March 25th, 2012, 07:00 AM
Garbodor! I think it looks better, it has a better typing and its generally a more interesting Pokemon. :3 Plus it'd totally beat Sawsbuck in a battle. I think Garbodor would get a lot better press if they hadn't of made its mouth and face so derpy D:

Ephemeral Euphoria
March 25th, 2012, 07:03 AM
Which one gives you the better impression & why?
Sawsbuck because of its more promising capabilities as a fast and rather menacing physical sweeper not to mention that Garbador feels more like a Muk rehash if anything. That and I like the unique typing of Sawsbuck as well.

Which Dream World art do you prefer?
Garbador because I've never seen a pile of trash pose so proudly before.

Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
The Spring Form. Simple yet elegant.

Against each other, which one would win the battle?
Garbador would win imo due to the type advantage and bulk which would probably end up saving it from a Jump Kick from Sawsbuck if the Jump Kick wasn't a Critical Hit first.

Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?
In the end I'm going with Sawsbuck. Deer tend to be more appealing to the eye than trash and I'm a rather harsh critic when it comes to appearances.

Halcyon
March 25th, 2012, 07:11 AM
I'm not sure how those two are related, but I'll answer it anyway. XD

Sawsbuck gave me a better impression, as it comes off as regal and collected, and I prefer to be with clean stuff. I like the winter form of Sawsbuck best. Even though I think Garbodor is able to defeat Sawsbuck with its poison attacks, it doesn't really matter to me, because Sawsbuck is still awesome regardless.

Sawsbuck, all the way. :P

deoxys121
March 25th, 2012, 07:17 AM
Which one gives you the better impression & why?
Sawsbuck. I love the concept of it changing its form with the seasons, and unique Normal/Grass typing. Whereas, Garbodor, just another Poison-type representing another type of pollution. Meh.

Which Dream World art do you prefer?
Again, Sawsbuck. In Garbodor's pose, it just looks like "Rawr! I'm a pile of trash! Fear me!" Sawsbuck looks like "Meh, I'm a deer. Your argument is invalid."

Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
Winter. The white tufts of fur look awesome, imo.

Against each other, which one would win the battle?
Sawsbuck used Nature Power! Nature Power turned into Earthquake! It's super-effective! The foe's Garbodor fainted!

Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?
Sawsbuck, hands down.

And I'll add this much: Sawsbuck has access to Chlorophyll. This means Sawsbuck rapes in sunshine. Again, your argument is invalid.

psyanic
March 25th, 2012, 07:55 AM
I like Sawsbuck a lot more in terms of design, and that includes its Dream World art. Specifically, I like its Spring form because it's so simple and there are pretty flowers. But I'd have to say Garbodor would definitely beat Sawsbuck, mainly because of its type advantage and its ability to take any hit Sawsbuck can throw at it.

giradialkia
March 25th, 2012, 08:31 AM
Which one gives you the better impression & why?
Sawsbuck is definitely more visually appealing in my opinion, but from playing White I find that Garbodor is harder to beat in battle most times (thus is better to use, in battle). That and the obvious type advantage. So in terms of looks, Sawsbuck wins, but in terms of practicality, Sawsbuck wins.
Which Dream World art do you prefer?
Sawsbuck.
Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
I think I like the Summer form the best, as I very much like all the green leaves on his antlers. Just.. 'cuz.
Against each other, which one would win the battle?
Garbodor, the type advantage makes that a given.
Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?
Errrrrrrrrr.. I guess Sawsbuck Summer form, because it looks better than Garbodor, altogether. Meaning I'd lose the battle, but whatever.

Hikamaru
March 25th, 2012, 11:56 AM
Which one gives you the better impression & why? Sawsbuck, I like its design better and I actually use one on my main Black team.
Which Dream World art do you prefer? I like Sawsbuck, looks natural.
Which Sawsbuck form do you like best? Winter Form, I love the fluffy white fur.
Against each other, which one would win the battle? Garbodor would beat Sawsbuck going by type advantages but the 'Buck does have some tricks up its sleeve, including a great STAB Return.
Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor? Sawsbuck. Mine can use Return and Horn Leech like a champ.

http://sprites.pokecheck.org/i/586-winter.gif
Yeah, I'm a Sawsbuck girl. Sorry Garbodor fans...

wombateiro
March 25th, 2012, 01:05 PM
I don't really care about any of them but I voted Garbodor because its design makes me lol.

Kenshin5
March 25th, 2012, 01:14 PM
Garbodor is one of the few pokemon ever created that I wish wasn't. As far as Sawsbuck I like that it showcases the seasonal changes through it's form, otherwise it strikes me as a generic deer like Stantler.

PlatinumDude
March 25th, 2012, 03:48 PM
Which one gives you the better impression & why?: Sawsbuck, because it can change forms with the seasons. All 4 forms have better designs than Garbodor, who doesn't look too good, IMO.


Which Dream World art do you prefer?: I like Sawsbuck's DW art.

Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?: The Spring form.

Against each other, which one would win the battle? : As much as I hate to say it, Garbodor. But then, in the appropriate environment, Sawsbuck can use Nature Power (as Earthquake) to take it out.

Sawsbuck or Garbodor?: Sawsbuck.

shinysweety
March 26th, 2012, 06:17 AM
Which one gives you the better impression & why?

Defenatly Sawsbuck, when I first saw this pokemon it was my fave Unova pokemon. And it's still one of my fave, it defiantly looks, and gives a better impression than ugly Garbodor.

Which Dream World art do you prefer?

I like the Sawsbuck one, the Garbador one was.... okay, but Sawbuck is waaaaaay better looking in all way's. And the dream world art 2.


Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?

I like the Spring form, all those cute flower's. But I like all of them as much, but yea... if I had to pick one it would be spring form.

Against each other, which one would win the battle?

Hate to say it but Garbodor. Poison is effective against grass so it would have the upper advantage.

Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?

SAWSBUCK!!!!!! spring form. ^^

Kae Kyo
March 26th, 2012, 06:30 AM
Sawsbuck gives off the best impression at first glance especially in it's Dream World art, however I do find Garbodor to me more intriguing than anything just because it's quite the unique one. The Winter Sawsbuck tends to be my favorite since Winter is my favorite season behind Spring. Overall, I think Garbodor will win in a showdown between the two mainly because of the type advantage, although Sawsbuck has access to Nature Power which can be quite dangerous to Gabodor. I'd say it comes down to how you decide to play each of them.

vaporeon7
March 26th, 2012, 09:28 AM
Sawsbuck got my vote 100%. It gave a much better first impression to me than Garbodor ever could. Sawsbuck looks quite good in its forms that aren't winter, whereas Garbodor looks bad, all the time. I don't like either of their Dream World art but I like Garbodor's less than Sawsbuck's. Sawsbuck's spring form is definitely the most appealing to me. The little flowers and the less leaves and fur looks good. In a battle, the only reason why Garbodor would ever win is because of a type advantage. So that is why I like Sawsbuck better, it is actually useful competitively and in-game, whereas Garbodor is useless in both.

Mr. Magius
March 26th, 2012, 01:52 PM
Which Dream World art do you prefer?
Again, Sawsbuck. In Garbodor's pose, it just looks like "Rawr! I'm a pile of trash! Fear me!" Sawsbuck looks like "Meh, I'm a deer. Your argument is invalid."You actually made Garbodor sound more like the victor in that one..

Which one gives you the better impression & why?
I'd say Garbodor. Most people prefer Sawsbuck, but I think Garbodor looks like such a tank and looks like it can take on anything. It also reminds me of Muk.

Which Dream World art do you prefer?
Garbodor, because it looks more menacing. Sawsbuck doesn't look like its in a natural pose.

Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
Autumn - it looks so majestic and royal.

Against each other, which one would win the battle?
Garbodor, hands down, but ya never know!

Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?
I'd have to go with Garbodor. Reminds me of Muk without even sharing any resemblances, so +9001 for indirect nostalgia.

miltankRancher
March 27th, 2012, 02:57 AM
Sawsbuck. I love its design (especially the Spring form. So leafy and such.) also, Horn Leech is awesome. Plus, cool typing and such.

Garbodor... Hm... Is good, I guess.

Elite Overlord LeSabre™
March 27th, 2012, 04:44 AM
Which one gives you the better impression & why?
Sawsbuck. As far as deer Pokemon go, he looks a lot more badass than Stantler. Garbordor, well, we threw something resembling Garbordor in the dumpster the other day.

Which Dream World art do you prefer?
Haven't seen DW art, but since I can't imagine Garbordor looking attractive in any way, Sawsbuck wins by default.

Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
Spring. It's the flowers :) And it corresponds with my favorite IRL season.

Against each other, which one would win the battle?
Garbordor gets type advantage, sadly.

Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?
Sawsbuck, especially spring form.

Alli
March 27th, 2012, 02:10 PM
Garbodor is a cayootie. I like Sawsbuck too, but in all its art, it looks sad/mad/snooty/stuck up etc. lol Garbodor has a cool cry and I think it looks cuddly. I hate both their typing, though. Normal/anything other than Flying always seems weird to me, and Poison is just not much better. SO. Squishy squashy smelly stinky Garby.

Yoshikko
March 27th, 2012, 02:26 PM
As much as I don't really like either of them, I'm gonna go with Garbodor (hah Luke will be happy) because I like its typing better and its shape, face and.. attitude? Like Sydian here said Sawsbuck always looks sort of snooty (hahah I love that word it's perfect). I do like its spring form though but still going with Garbodor.

Overlord Drakow
March 27th, 2012, 02:48 PM
My vote goes to Sawsbuck. Only losers vote for trash.

Ghiaccio
March 27th, 2012, 03:53 PM
Which one gives you the better impression & why?
Sawsbuck, because of it looks all elegant and stuff, while Garbador is rather trashy (excuse the pun) and kinda looks like vomit (not the best impression)
Which Dream World art do you prefer?
Sawsbuck, again looks more elegant
Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
Winter, since I already like winter (in real life) the best, and it looks more elegant (yes that again)
Against each other, which one would win the battle?
Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?
Eh I'm not sure, I didn't use either in my first play through and I'm probably not gonna use either anytime soon too so yeah, but based on stats alone and my experience with them in AI battles then I'd have to say... Garbador, with it's type advantage and all (STAB) and the attack:defense ratio of Garbador:Sawsbuck is higher than attack:defense of Sawsbuck:Garbador

But either way, I still like Sawsbuck overall better. I can defend Trubbish but this... not as much

-ty-
March 27th, 2012, 06:13 PM
Which one gives you the better impression & why?
Sawsbuck...It was actually my favorite pokemon initially this generation. Although, I slowly gravitated more toward Serperior and Lilligant as my grass-type in my teams.

Which Dream World art do you prefer?
Sawsbuck. I don't particularly like the dream world art for Sawsbuck, but Garbador looks especially bad in the "artwork".

Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
I have been going back and forth on this one. I initially gravitated toward the winter, then spring, and now I really started to appreciate the Autumn form.

Against each other, which one would win the battle?
Simply because of the type advantages and moveset advantages I would say Garbador.

Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?
But, at the end of the day, I would much rather have a Sawsbuck on my team than a piece of trash.

LuLaby
March 28th, 2012, 02:23 PM
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Which one gives you the better impression & why?
-My first impression went to Garbodor but not because I liked it, but because it is A PILE OF TRASH :P
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Which Dream World art do you prefer?
-I Like Sawsbuck Art more cause ok we have to admit it Garbodor is literally trash :)
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
-I prefer the winter Sawsbuck no particular reason, tho
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Against each other, which one would win the battle?
-Hmmm,Both of them have same base hp if I'm correct and Sawsbuck can easy outspeed Garbodor
Garbodor has a type advantage over Sawsbuck too
Probably Garbodor but still it depends :P
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?
-I guess I'll side with Garbodor cause trash is goood :P

Blue
March 28th, 2012, 02:33 PM
Very good poll and tough to choose!

Which one gives you the better impression & why?

Garbador, although many people will disagree I have my own opinion and it's a unique Pokémon, there is no other like it.

Which Dream World art do you prefer?

Sawsbuck because it looks full of pride.

Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?

Spring, the flowers on the antlers look preeeety.

Against each other, which one would win the battle?


Based on it's speed I'd say Sawsbuck although Garbordor could land some pretty heavy moves.

Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?

Hmm... Garbodor, only because I think it will get much less votes and if I personally had to choose I would rate them equally considering I like them both a lot.
__________________

Ultimo1991
March 29th, 2012, 06:26 AM
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Which one gives you the better impression & why?
Sawsbuck it looks more elegant and not well ugly like garbador...
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Which Dream World art do you prefer?
id still have to say sawsbuck for the reasos stated above^
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
Winter, mainly cause i like the colors of its fur^^
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Against each other, which one would win the battle?
id say garbador would win in a non competive type battle but in a competive sawsbuck would totally own!!
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?
Sawsbuck any form is etter by far this is my opinion^^

Forever
March 29th, 2012, 06:51 PM
Kaori. Just because I was on LoA doesn't mean you need to go behind my back and sticky this, wtf. /unstickies

Anyway, Sawsbuck is legit better. Competitively, design-wise, everything. Garbodor is boring. :x Trubbish is cute though!

Oryx
March 29th, 2012, 07:46 PM
Surprised Sawsbuck isn't more in the lead tbh. I like Sawsbuck kinda but it's kinda boring because deer is such a boring concept, even with the seasonal stuff added in the base of "LOOK IT'S A DEER" is boring so I voted for Garbodor. :3

Atomic Pirate
March 30th, 2012, 12:53 PM
On one side, we have Garbodor, the poisonous trash monster. It reminds me of something I would see in a sci-fi or horror movie, looking a bit alien, a bit menacing, and a bit monstrous all at the same time. It has the appearance of something that came from a mothership or a mad doctor's laboratory. Overall, it's not one of the more popular designs of the generation, but it's decent and certainly memorable. On the other side, we have Sawsbuck, the stag-like creature. It has an inventive "seasons" design, with the Winter design sticking out as the best of the forms. Definitely one of the most natural designs of the 5th generation, Sawsbuck is also decent. Neither of these two are really up there with my favorites, but I'd have to go with the monstrous Garbodor as the better of these Pokemon, but only slightly.

Mentalii
March 31st, 2012, 02:00 AM
I voted for Garbodor :pink_tongue:
Because its design is just funny and original. A dustbin Pokémon, I would have never thought they'll make that.
I like Sawsbuck too but it's not as awesome as Garbodor.

IcyIce
March 31st, 2012, 08:29 AM
Which one gives you the better impression & why?
Sawsbuck,I love deer and I love how Sawsbuck has 4 forms

Which Dream World art do you prefer?
Autume

Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
Autum and Winter. I love both colors in them

Against each other, which one would win the battle?
Garbodor would probably win. But I'd still fight with Sawsbuck

Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?
Sawbuck. I do not like Garbodor. Just looks bad in my opinion. Plus I like the animals more.

DipKicks
March 31st, 2012, 10:08 AM
It doesn't matter if the Pokemon is the ugliest thing I have ever seen, interesting designs for me are a lot better than just boring designs. The seasonal add-ons don't make it any less boring.

Garbodor over Sawsbuck

Cassino
April 6th, 2012, 04:23 PM
Which one gives you the better impression & why?
Sawsbuck. Its seasonal appearances are, although baseless gimmickery, relatively interesting. One could keep it in their party for a long time without becoming bored of its backsprite, since it regularly changes.

Which Dream World art do you prefer?
Garbodor's; it strikes a more natural pose.

Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
Winter.

Against each other, which one would win the battle?
Garbodor, purely due to type advantage. Sawsbuck's most useful attacks are Fighting or Grass, both of which are resisted by Garbodor.

Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?
Sawsbuck.

XtinaIsMeLuvinWWE
April 11th, 2012, 10:03 AM
http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Which one gives you the better impression & why?
-Sawsbuck for me, it was one of my favourites as soon as I saw all the new pokémon for this generation.

http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Which Dream World art do you prefer?
-Honestly Garbodor lol :D

http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?
-Spring hands down for me.

http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Against each other, which one would win the battle?
-I'm gonna be boring and say it would depend what moves they used lol :)

http://www.kimsites.net/pokemon/pokeball_gray.jpg Sawsbuck (any of the forms) or Garbodor?
Has to be Spring Sawsbuck for me :)

Rai
April 11th, 2012, 01:00 PM
Which one gives you the better impression & why?

Sawsbuck is overall a much better design. It is creative and it is pretty. There hasn't been a season pokemon or a deer pokemon. Garbodor isn't as creative because it is a rip off of Muk and is... well, trash.

Which Dream World art do you prefer?

Sawsbuck.

Which Sawsbuck form do you like best?

I love the winter one the most.

Against each other, which one would win the battle?

Probably Gabodor because it has the type advantage.