PDA

View Full Version : PokeCommunity's 100 Greatest Songs of All Time


gimmepie
March 3rd, 2013, 07:08 AM
PokeComminiy's 100 Greatest Songs of All Time

Here on the PokeCommunity we have a large mix of members and, as such we have an eclectic assortment of musical interests. That being said I thought it would be interesting for us to create a list of our top one hundred favourite songs of all time, as a community, not as individuals, for our fellow community members to use as an index and for us to share our musical interests with one another.

How it works

1. The list will be constructed in reverse order (100-1) in groups of ten.
2. In each bracket of songs; first, for about 3-5 days depending on activity on the thread, members will be able to submit songs that they would like to be voted on.
3. Once a decent number of songs have been posted we move into the voting for a similar period of time.


The Rules

1. You may only nominate a maximum of three songs per bracket.
2. Listen to songs you don't know before voting.
3. You have a maximum of two votes in each voting bracket. But you can only vote for ONE of YOUR submitted songs.
4. You may not submit a song that didn't make it in the previous bracket. That's an exercise in futility.

Bracket One Nominees

Frank Sinatra - Get Me to the Church on Time (0 Votes)

5sEZ8H8343c


Simon and Garfunkle - I am a Rock (0 Votes)

PKY-smJ6aBQ


Three Days Grace - Never to Late (0 Votes)

lL2ZwXj1tXM


Fallout Boy - Thnks fr th Mmrs (0 Votes)

onzL0EM1pKY


Red - Already Over (0 Votes)

4OUHoFAziyU


Amy Winehouse - Back to Black (0 Votes)

vYGWly_nPFs


3 Doors Down - Kryptonite (0 Votes)

xPU8OAjjS4k


Dead Letter Circus - Here We Divide (0 Votes)

OT33V9FKPH8


The Flaming Lips-The Yeah Yeah Yeah Song (0 Votes)

kjrUOlK2714



Pink Floyd-Atom Heart Mother (0 Votes)

TVI0WgvBGvk


Avicci vs Nicky Romero - I Could Be The One (0 Votes)

6Lh7Zg8WXwU


Rita Ora - Radioactive (0 Votes)

LK-weHI47ro




Voting Has Begun

lineofdeath
March 3rd, 2013, 07:41 AM
I nominate
Frank sinatra: get me to the church on time
And
Simon and garfunkel: I am a rock.

Esper
March 3rd, 2013, 09:26 AM
Okay, so let me see if I understand how this works:

You nominate a song for each tier, and you said that we're going in reverse order so I assume that the first tier we're nominating songs for is #100, or #100-91. Not entirely clear which. And if a song we nominate gets bumped out then it's gone completely?

So just for the sake of my understanding, if I nominate something like Rolling in the Deep right now it's never going to place better than the spot I (or someone else) nominates to? Even if I do it right now and every single person who posts after me says "Yes! That is the best song" and it's unanimously agreed upon to be one of PC's favorite songs ever? I would have to withhold my nomination for a better tier, hope someone else doesn't nominate it, and then hope it wins in the tier I do nominate it because even if it gets second place in the top tier it's gonna disappear from the rankings.

I'm not trying to ruin this. I'm just confused about how this is gonna work. I think the idea is a good one (even if a hundred songs sounds like it would take a year to get)

Dakota
March 3rd, 2013, 10:00 AM
You might want to ask them to put the video in their post also, to make things easier for yourself.

Anyway, I'm going to nominate:

Three Days Grace - Never Too Late
lL2ZwXj1tXM

Fall Out Boy - Thnks fr th Mmrs
onzL0EM1pKY

Red - Already Over

4OUHoFAziyU

gimmepie
March 3rd, 2013, 10:01 AM
Okay Scarf sorry if my instructions were not clear.

By reverse order and in brackets I mean this -

There are ten brackets each will consist of ten decided upon songs. The order of these songs will go from the highest numbered song in that bracket to the lowest, with the higher numbers having less votes that the lower ones.

As for how this works, you raise a valid point that I forgot to consider. My original idea of simply not voting for songs you don't think belong in that tier is probably not the fairest/most accurate. I suggest that if numerous people suggest a song should be higher, it simply get knocked to the next tier. Suggestions?

Edit: A more specific way of what I have said, if three comments suggest a song should be pushed to a higher tier (before voting) then that song is pushed to the next bracket and does not count towards the person who nominated its count for the higher tier but still does for the lower. How does that sound?

DavidtheDeadPhilosopher
March 3rd, 2013, 06:55 PM
Ok, Seems like there are two slots left so I will only nominate 2 for this bracket.

The Flaming Lips-The Yeah Yeah Yeah Song

kjrUOlK2714


Pink Floyd-Atom Heart Mother

Yes, The full song is in fact 26 minutes long. TVI0WgvBGvk

gimmepie
March 3rd, 2013, 11:25 PM
There can be more than ten nominees David. It's just only ten will make the list.

curiousnathan
March 3rd, 2013, 11:46 PM
This sounds like an interesting idea!

My nominations are Meeep I sound like I'm a BB housemate; //still addicted:

Avicci vs Nicky Romero - I Could Be The One
6Lh7Zg8WXwU

Rita Ora - Radioactive
LK-weHI47ro

gimmepie
March 4th, 2013, 02:08 AM
Since there are quite a few nominees I'll probably moves us to voting tomorrow or the day after. Also, please give a small reason why you voted for something (although this is not 100% necessary).