PDA

View Full Version : ~The Less Popular 'Rate the signature of the person above you: INSIGHTFUL VERSION!!~


Allstories
May 5th, 2005, 11:34 AM
(I have added emphasis to important details for those of you with tiny brains)

No, this isn't quite like the 'Rate the signature of the person above you' game. This is slightly more serious. YOU'RE PLAYING WITH THE BIG KIDS IN THIS THREAD. Here you will be required to actually give a decent paragraph of insight and constructive criticism to the signature of the person above you. I don't want any "I like it lol 9/10". I don't want "I dunno wat that is 0/10". In this thread you have to give an honest, unbiased, INSIGHTFUL opinion. Give actual constructive criticism. All reviews must be AT LEAST ONE PARAGRAPH LONG.

SADM
May 5th, 2005, 12:22 PM
Okay you signature is fairly simple which is good so 3/5
forighn language is sufistacated so 5/5
I understand forgihn language 5/5
Who is corvax 0/5
funny green guy 4/5
18/25

Allstories
May 5th, 2005, 12:27 PM
Paragraphs! Paragraphs! You're setting a bad example for the entire thread!

Samuri Scearious
May 5th, 2005, 01:45 PM
Okay. Let's see... It pretty much just a picture. Fairly well. But it could use a bit more. So it will not have the highest score. I would most likely give it a 4/10. It could use some improvements.

Draik
May 8th, 2005, 10:39 AM
Hmmmm...You could use some images, Try and make the font bigger. Use a banner instead of big, red text. Good poem. Give it a little improvements. 5/10.

Kylie-chan
May 8th, 2005, 09:12 PM
Alright, but if this turns into flaming, locky locky. I'm only letting it stay open because it's different... mostly, although I'd encourage the main thread to be "insightful" too.

^ I'll give you a 5/10. It's not terrible, but it's not terrific either. It's just a bunch of animated pictures and the usual stuff. Although, I like the pictures. ^^ Try lining them up, and colouring the text, and making it smaller, because smaller coloured text is more attractive IMO. ^^ But, you're using decent punctuation and spelling, so kudos to you for that. X_X
Also, Allstories, please rate the signature above. x.x