Hilary Duff or Lindsay Lohan

[misty-slave09]

http://cdn.compuserve.com/gallery/i/d/duff3/HDMW_cover.jpg http://i.realone.com/assets/rn/cms/2004/large/Lindsay_Lohan_3_-_MTV_Movie_Awards_-_lg.6389181.jpg Hilary Duff or Lindsay Lohan?
whose a better singer
whose a better actress
who looks better
whose skinner

[bna_li]

All Lindsay. I must say, I was once crazy over Hilary Duff. But she's such a... I don't know how to describe her... Just don't like her no more.

[Karasuma]

I go with Lindsay Lohan, I love her movies and her album rocks as well.

[misty-slave09]

i perfer hilary duff@@@@@@@@

[bna_li]

Er, well, don't spam or you'll get banned.

[Kid Frost]

Yeah, i pick lindsay Lohan in all

[Samurai X]

I'll have to say that it is a tie in my mind, they both pwn. You should put up a poll.

[Camp Kill Yourself]

I like Hillary Duff the most. She`s hot. o.o;

Oh, um, er...and she has that one song about the rain that I like. What`s that called? Coming Clean, I think. I love that song, and I`m not really sure why.

Lindsay Lohan...is okay. I don`t like her as much, however.
I used to.
Now I don`t.
I don`t know why.

[^^NICK^^ v.3.0]

Movies- Lindsay
Music- Hillary
Personality- Hillary

Lindsay seems like she's kind of arrogant. Hillary seems way more humble, and she didn't get all ****ty like Lindsay.

[Blaze]

Lindsay owns, she lost alot of weight so put some on because she didn't wanna be a bad rolemodel.

Hilary sucks, she lost alot of weight and is more arrogant than ever.

[Dark Night]

Lindsay Lohan above all. She's nicer and I love her album!

[Tamer Marco]

Im going with Hillary on this one. For some reason I liked her show... o_0 Thats why.

[Mullet]

I like Hilary Duff a lot better. Lindsay does have one advantage over her, that Hilary will never have...

[Roxas]

I love Lindsay. She's so hot XD And I love her movies. Mean Girls was hilarious.

[Crystal Clair]

Hmm...... Who do I like better, Lindsay, the Rui look-alike or Hilary, the Domino look-alike.
I'd say Lindsay because she makes a good Rui. Honestly, I dont care what they do, as long as they look like a Pokemon character. XD

[Chairman Kaga]

It's like being asked whether I want to be slowly dipped into an acid bath or put in a cage with starving pit bulls. But I guess Lindsay, because even though she's just another Disney-puppet-tween-magnet who sells her image to impressionable young girls and shady mid-40s males, she did a Parent Trap remake years and years ago that wasn't half bad...to someone my age back then...I guess...

[Charaxes]

I like Hilary Duff a lot better. Lindsay does have one advantage over her, that Hilary will never have...

I don't think either one are any good as they're sub par actresses and singers (Duff's sister actually is the better actress and singer of that dynamic) and now both are pulling a Brittany Spears with the sexpot or left field image (I think Duff is getting more gothy), but end of the day, I agree with Mullet, go with the one thing that makes Lohan unique and at least visually appealing.

Quote for her in the future : "My eyes are up here, pig!"

I know, I'm cynical.

(Although Lohan was good in Life Size. Too bad she couldn't be frozen as a 9 year old eh?)

[Geometric-sama]

Once I would have said Lindsay straight away, as she's a better actor and singer, but lately she's not exactly been the best role-model... however, she's still better than Hilary. X3 And I do love Mean Girls.

[Fls4eva]

I prefer Lindsay, she definitely sings much better.. And she looks better too... And I think she acts well as both a child and a young adult...

[The Fly]

I'm not big on either of the two music wise, but I'd prefer Hilary Duff since she's cuter and because I may have liked at least one of her songs.

[Alakazam17]

I voted for Lohan, although I don't listen to either girl's music. She is better looking, and a better actress, is all. :D

[Fitzgeraldo]

Hilary Duff = Teh ultimate hotness
Lindsay Lohan = Yuck

[kami_kami_hi]

i don't like them both, but i'd rather choose linsay...i think hilary is 2 preppy

[Thomas-san]

Hillary Duff has much more of a classic look and she can act much better than Lindsey Lohan. Also Lindsey looks like a skank.

[Ibuberu]

I don't know,for some reason,I never liked Lindsay.So I'm going with Hilary,even though I guess Lohan's movies might be a little better.

[Jack O'Neill]

Let the two of them play Counter-Strike with real guns and live ammo. Hilary can be a terrorist, and Lindsay can be a counter-terrorist. We'll see who'll be left standing once that's over.

[Lust]

Both of them are extremely hot. Hilary Duff is a better singer and Lindsay is a better actress. It's a tie.