Map Rating Thread

[Xray]

@thethethethe
Hm.. it seems a bit different but it looks good i like the tree tiles
7.5/10

[Erimgard]

Prof 9:
7/10
it's good...but it just seems a little bland. try adding some more rocks and stuff to the ground level where you walk

4The:
9/10
quite good. the only thing is that some of the houses are centered in their little grass yards, and others are slightly lower...so that they overlap the boarder...

[~Satoshi Sugimori~]

@ cartman
Looks really good..:)
7.8/10

@ Prof.9
Looks great but I don't like the rimply rock that is sticking out...
8/10

@ thethethethe
Uhmm...
your tree palette looks awfully alot like mine...
But it looks good it's a very nice revamp from ecruteak...
8/10

[SSJ4 Furatman]

Okay this map is of the Starting town in my new hack - GoldLight Town:
http://i186.photobucket.com/albums/x43/FurankiPkmnMaster/StartingTownPkmnSP.png
I still have to think up a name for it.

If your wondering, where did your Rival's house go?
It is the small one, your rival is poorer than you, and Makes fun of you to cover that up.

[~Satoshi Sugimori~]

Okay this map is of the Starting town in my new hack:
http://i186.photobucket.com/albums/x43/FurankiPkmnMaster/StartingTownPkmnSP.png
I still have to think up a name for it.

If your wondering, where did your Rival's house go?
It is the small one, your rival is poorer than you, and Makes fun of you to cover that up.

Wow you are getting better and now I will give a tip:
The trees that stand alone and the sides that are standing to an roas or open area don't need shade so use the tree nest to the tree you are using if you look closely you will see that that tree doesn't have any shade..:)
And i'll give your town a 8/10

[SSJ4 Furatman]

Thanks. Yeah, I noticed well I corrected it.

[cooley]

@poke-roy: TTTT had those palettes a long time before you. xD
I'll post my map a bit later.
-cooley

[~Satoshi Sugimori~]

@poke-roy: TTTT had those palettes a long time before you. xD
I'll post my map a bit later.
-cooley

really O sorry TTTT..hmm...then it's okay and I think I don't have to change them or he would have PM'd me about it..:) YAY..:D

[cooley]

Well Like I said, Here is my map. And believe it or not, It is a route, and it is incomplete.
http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x18/Cooley833/Route3.png
DO NOT STEAL PALETTES PLEASE!!!
The black circles are where IMPORTANT people will stand. Comments, suggestions, plz.
-cooley

[destinedjagold]

A little error there, but nah.., tha map still looks good.
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa154/destinedjagold/Route3.png

8/10

[cooley]

Thanks for Rating it. I've decided to remove that tile.
Well, I'm off to start my scripting for my hack! ;)see yah.
-cooley

[thethethethe]

really O sorry TTTT..hmm...then it's okay and I think I don't have to change them or he would have PM'd me about it..:) YAY..:D

I have had those palettes in my hack for a while, but I got them from ♠εx's Rombase, I'm still going to change them anyway...
Well, back on topic, I was looking at Rocket's Revenge, and I decided I'd do some palette editing. Well here's the outcome, please don't steal the palette. It will pretty ovbious if you do...:)
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/route1.png

[swampert22]

@thethethethe I love the Rockets Revenge pallete - it looks really spooky and fitting for the game.

Here is a map from my hack. This is Reyfia Town, a small mountainous retreat, where the monks from the monastery in the hills above come and tend the gardens.

http://img156.imageshack.us/img156/1930/reyfiatownll0.th.png (http://img156.imageshack.us/my.php?image=reyfiatownll0.png)

Like it? Please rate and I may post more...:)

oh and P.S. I had to post on imageshack because for some reason I cannot upload to PokéCommunity?!

[johnlycett]

I have had those palettes in my hack for a while, but I got them from ♠εx's Rombase, I'm still going to change them anyway...
Well, back on topic, I was looking at Rocket's Revenge, and I decided I'd do some palette editing. Well here's the outcome, please don't steal the palette. It will pretty ovbious if you do...:)
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/route1.png

Yeah xD Thats some nice work thex4(your names to long to say) Its really good the night pallet, But the map itself could have a few paths on it otherwise love it. the grass should have sections not all scatted around the place.

[~Satoshi Sugimori~]

@ TTTT
That palette is great..:D
It really looks nice..8.5/10

@ Swampert22
Looks good..
Like the houses..:)
I think it's a 7/10..

[Corona]

Here is the oh so smexy Coron Town :D

http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g135/Laplace2/CoronTown.png

[Zanacross]

Here is the oh so smexy Coron Town :D

http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g135/Laplace2/CoronTown.png

woa love the signs and trees

its great

9/10

[~Satoshi Sugimori~]

Here is the oh so smexy Coron Town :D

http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g135/Laplace2/CoronTown.png

I don't like the tiles much...
5.5/10...

[SSJ4 Furatman]

Map Name: Route 660

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: This Is the First Route in My New Hack it leads to the second town/city from the first one.

http://i186.photobucket.com/albums/x43/FurankiPkmnMaster/Route660.png

[Zanacross]

Map Name: Route 660

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: This Is the First Route in My New Hack it leads to the second town/city from the first one.

http://i186.photobucket.com/albums/x43/FurankiPkmnMaster/Route660.png

nice

I think you should learn how to edit the pallets

Would make it look even better

[SSJ4 Furatman]

nice

I think you should learn how to edit the pallets

Would make it look even better

I know, I'm making the maps first before I do pallete editing, but yeah the palletes will be changed.

[Zanacross]

good good

meh

Ill post some new maps up soon

When i get my old pc settings back
Where can i get all the hacking tools from?

not wak a hack doesent work for me.

[cooley]

Don't Spam, Zanacross. That is not the place to ask that sort of question.

@Cartman: You have some errors in your map, The only thing was The ledge, And something Reaaaaaaaaaallllly small. 7.5/10 ;)

[johnlycett]

Here is the oh so smexy Coron Town :D

http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g135/Laplace2/CoronTown.png

Don patch xD, haven't seen Donpatches old tiles for a while now in a map
7/10 it's very neatly done

[zel]

Well, I'll just try to be around this thread a bit more often since I'm not hacking for now, cause I want to help people improve their mapping, and, who knows, maybe this could also help to improve mine as well ;)

I'll just post something about the last five published maps...

cooley(Route Map): The left part of the map is pretty original, with all those "empty spaces", however there seems to be too much empty space at some areas (close to the mansion, close to the sign and close to the route's entrance), I would have used a bit more flowers (or at least, some of the road tiles) on the last two, and maybe extend the "lake" a bit more to the north and make it like the player wouldn't be able to reach the important person on the west unless they were to take the correct way (teasing the player? Maybe... :badsmile:)
The small patch of sand also has a problem because in that place you'd need a sand tile with a turn to the right and a turn to down... I think there isn't such kind of tile Hope that is somewhat understandable -_-
Overall, a decent map. I guess the grass is one of the things you have to add later.
Rating->8/10

thethethethe(violet map): I'll just judge the mapping, 'cause in reality I didn't like the outcome of those palettes, but that's just a personal opinion.
So, regarding the mapping, it's perfect in all aspects, no signs of empty spaces, and it seems like a challenging map. I would fix only one thing though, I'd move that sign one tile up, 'cause that way it would seem like we can read it from its front (hard to do it with that ledge below currently)
Unlike johnlycett, I think having grass scattered is a bit more original touch.
Rating->9/10

swampert22(Reyfia Town): The only critic on it is that the new house tiles seem to have too strong outlines, making them too obvious to notice they are something new, when you compare them to the FR tiles. However, I don't see anything strange on the mapping, maybe all the roads are a bit too wide, I'd go with variation.
Rating->8/10

Corona(Coron Town): It would have been better not to make just a square border with trees and then fill the inside, you should have played a bit with more trees so it wouldn't be so square.
The green plant from D.Patch is pretty confusing, one could mistake it for a cut tree by how tall it is.
Other than that, the map is not that interesting (yes, I know it's the starting town, hopefully the next town or routes maps will be better)
Rating->6/10

Cartman(Route 660): Some similarities with thethethethe's maps on that map, however, you seem to have used a bit less tiles variation, so I'd suggest to take a look at thex4's map to get some inspiration (you could use the road tile if you need more variation on the middle of the lower left part of the map)
Rating->7/10

[SSJ4 Furatman]

Well, I'll just try to be around this thread a bit more often since I'm not hacking for now, cause I want to help people improve their mapping, and, who knows, maybe this could also help to improve mine as well ;)

I'll just post something about the last five published maps...

cooley(Route Map): The left part of the map is pretty original, with all those "empty spaces", however there seems to be too much empty space at some areas (close to the mansion, close to the sign and close to the route's entrance), I would have used a bit more flowers (or at least, some of the road tiles) on the last two, and maybe extend the "lake" a bit more to the north and make it like the player wouldn't be able to reach the important person on the west unless they were to take the correct way (teasing the player? Maybe... :badsmile:)
The small patch of sand also has a problem because in that place you'd need a sand tile with a turn to the right and a turn to down... I think there isn't such kind of tile Hope that is somewhat understandable -_-
Overall, a decent map. I guess the grass is one of the things you have to add later.
Rating->8/10

thethethethe(violet map): I'll just judge the mapping, 'cause in reality I didn't like the outcome of those palettes, but that's just a personal opinion.
So, regarding the mapping, it's perfect in all aspects, no signs of empty spaces, and it seems like a challenging map. I would fix only one thing though, I'd move that sign one tile up, 'cause that way it would seem like we can read it from its front (hard to do it with that ledge below currently)
Unlike johnlycett, I think having grass scattered is a bit more original touch.
Rating->9/10

swampert22(Reyfia Town): The only critic on it is that the new house tiles seem to have too strong outlines, making them too obvious to notice they are something new, when you compare them to the FR tiles. However, I don't see anything strange on the mapping, maybe all the roads are a bit too wide, I'd go with variation.
Rating->8/10

Corona(Coron Town): It would have been better not to make just a square border with trees and then fill the inside, you should have played a bit with more trees so it wouldn't be so square.
The green plant from D.Patch is pretty confusing, one could mistake it for a cut tree by how tall it is.
Other than that, the map is not that interesting (yes, I know it's the starting town, hopefully the next town or routes maps will be better)
Rating->6/10

Cartman(Route 660): Some similarities with thethethethe's maps on that map, however, you seem to have used a bit less tiles variation, so I'd suggest to take a look at thex4's map to get some inspiration (you could use the road tile if you need more variation on the middle of the lower left part of the map)
Rating->7/10


I took your suggestion and added some more Tile Variation, thanks zel!

[cε׀׀]

Nice comments zel;)
And,
Its been a while since i posted any maps so here goes:
Game:FR(Its a pokemon Eruption map)
Name: Route 2
Map:http://i224.photobucket.com/albums/dd117/Lordfreakalot/route2-1.jpg
Hope you like it ;)
P.S DONT STEAL THE PALS PLEASE!!!

[destinedjagold]

too brightly colored and some tiles have no use there, for instance, the ledges... also, wrong usage of the ladder tiles there...

5/10

[cε׀׀]

Yes thanx for the advice destinedjagold,
ill be improving

[SerenadeDS]

Its been a while since i posted any maps so here goes:
Game:FR(Its a pokemon Eruption map)
Name: Route 2
Map:http://i224.photobucket.com/albums/dd117/Lordfreakalot/route2-1.jpg
Hope you like it ;)
P.S DONT STEAL THE PALS PLEASE!!!

Not that bad. Palette looks good. I spot mapping errors, but you should know were they are. Otherwise, pretty good!

~7/10~

[mithsu]

7/10
I like the map, but the stairs to go down arent the good ones!

[cooley]

Nice comments zel;)
And,
Its been a while since i posted any maps so here goes:
Game:FR(Its a pokemon Eruption map)
Name: Route 2
Map:http://i224.photobucket.com/albums/dd117/Lordfreakalot/route2-1.jpg
Hope you like it ;)
P.S DONT STEAL THE PALS PLEASE!!!
I think that map is good. 9/10. It will definately be good in my hack, and I'll
Give you credits too. ;)

[BlackRainbow*]

Not that bad map. But i see alot of errors and paletts are not completly changed as you can see in sand corners are still with orginal colors.
6.5/10

[cε׀׀]

Thanks everyone!
For the advice and ratings, ill try improving,
Ill post more maps later.

[Kristian]

i found this old map on my computer, i just wanna see what you guys think of it..
name: (have no idea)
game: FireRed
map: in spoiler..
http://img265.imageshack.us/img265/9272/oldmapci4.png

[Zanacross]

meh nice map 7.10
grass looks allright

meh
another person with danasoft thing i started it off

[suoert]

hi guys, i've been working hard to improve my mapping skills. please see for yourselve how much this map improved.

Map name: Violet city
Game: Fire Red

old:
http://img249.imageshack.us/img249/1205/violetcitykt4.jpg
new:
http://img251.imageshack.us/img251/1050/violetcitynewmg3.png

[zel]

Let's go for another round of mapping checkout:

Celebi_XD(Route2): Good to know more people are into the "sad" palettes as me, but anyway, I'm just here to judge the mapping :P
It certainly looks original, and nice for just being the second route in the game. However, regarding the problem destinedjagold spotted on that map. Just look at all your ledges, they are all either pointing down or right, so we aren't supposed to go from the right to the left, is that the way it should be? In the end, I think you have overused the ledges.
Also, yep, you should create your own "going down" stairs, those you picked don't look that good on the map.
In any case, I like how you used different tiles, and how it seems the map has different "areas" within the same map, just put a bit more of effort into the tile fixing and it will be better.
Rating->9/10

Kristian(have no idea map XD): It is a bit small to be considered a forest, and it should have a bit more of road tiles if it was supposed to be a Route Map, but still, I like how you distibuted the trees and grass around (sounds as if you've been paying attention to Marz' mapping tutorial)
The road at the north is a bit too wide, though.
Rating->7/10

suoert(Violet City): Well, it's a GSC map, so nothing much to comment on mapping (you forgot a signpost close to Sprout's Tower)
I have noticed that probably you have a tiles border problem at the northwest of the map (after the small surfing), am I right?
I would have sticked with the original tiles for the green ground, it looked better than the new one, but at least you have fixed many tiles problems from the past (however, I don't like the palette of the trees, too bright in my opinion)
That's it, as I said it's a GSC map, so mapping something already mapped is not something to show your mapping skills (look who's talking, ah? XD)
Rating->7/10

[suoert]

Let's go for another round of mapping checkout:

suoert(Violet City): Well, it's a GSC map, so nothing much to comment on mapping (you forgot a signpost close to Sprout's Tower)
I have noticed that probably you have a tiles border problem at the northwest of the map (after the small surfing), am I right?
I would have sticked with the original tiles for the green ground, it looked better than the new one, but at least you have fixed many tiles problems from the past (however, I don't like the palette of the trees, too bright in my opinion)
That's it, as I said it's a GSC map, so mapping something already mapped is not something to show your mapping skills (look who's talking, ah? XD)
Rating->7/10

well, actualy there is something new right above this map. it's a little secret area, i will post it when it's ready.
And you are right about the pallete, i don't quite like it either.

[cε׀׀]

i found this old map on my computer, i just wanna see what you guys think of it..
name: (have no idea)
game: FireRed
map: in spoiler..
http://img265.imageshack.us/img265/9272/oldmapci4.png
Ummm i like your maps Kristian;)
The only thing is that the grass look quite scattered,
so it would be best if you put the grass in different places
like in squares or rectangles(gamefreak style)Thats what i do with my maps.
7/10

hi guys, i've been working hard to improve my mapping skills. please see for yourselve how much this map improved.

Map name: Violet city
Game: Fire Red

old:
http://img249.imageshack.us/img249/1205/violetcitykt4.jpg
new:
http://img251.imageshack.us/img251/1050/violetcitynewmg3.png

Ummm first thing: I like the new palletes mate,
they look nice, but i can see some errors on your maps,
like on the trees etc. But in the other hand it looks pretty
good: 7.5/10
Let's go for another round of mapping checkout:

Celebi_XD(Route2): Good to know more people are into the "sad" palettes as me, but anyway, I'm just here to judge the mapping :P
It certainly looks original, and nice for just being the second route in the game. However, regarding the problem destinedjagold spotted on that map. Just look at all your ledges, they are all either pointing down or right, so we aren't supposed to go from the right to the left, is that the way it should be? In the end, I think you have overused the ledges.
Also, yep, you should create your own "going down" stairs, those you picked don't look that good on the map.
In any case, I like how you used different tiles, and how it seems the map has different "areas" within the same map, just put a bit more of effort into the tile fixing and it will be better.
Rating->9/10

Rating->7/10
Thanks for the advice and comments zel, yes i had a few problems,
with that map(i couldnt find the downstairs tile lol)
And yes i do like sad palletes :D
And thanks for the wonderful rating:) (Am i dreaming?)

[Prof. 9]

Here's my map (remake)!
http://img135.imageshack.us/img135/1658/ecruteakcitydv9.png
It's Ecruteak City!
It is EXACTLY the same. The only difference is that I use new FRLG tiles.
If you want to compare it with the old version, use these links!
http://img135.imageshack.us/img135/1658/ecruteakcitydv9.png
http://www.vgmaps.com/Atlas/GB-GBC/Pokemon-GSC-Johto-EcruteakCity.png

Small note: It IS possible to use this map in a hack. However, you'll need to import a LOT of tiles, and change a whole lot of palettes.

[Dr.Razor]

Here's the map of the route 1 in Pokemon Jaune Eclair:
Edit: Sorry for credits.I'll post the map again.

[cooley]

Shouldn't you give Credit to the original creator of those D/P houses?
The maker is on PHO, can't remember name.

Anyways, I see some errors. I can tell you edited route 1 too, by looking at the way the Grass is positioned.
8/10. Try not to make the Grass in a square shape. The people playing can easily Get past the grass

without batttling wild pokemon. Like I said 8/10

@prof.9: Please don't make a remake, And we all know how ecruteak City looks like. You just changed the tiles.

Be More original. 8/10 also

[TSK]

It's a rather big image.
http://i3.tinypic.com/66ug1mb.jpg

[destinedjagold]

wow... it's nice...

7/10...

I wonder how'd ya make it big...

[TSK]

wow... it's nice...

7/10...

I wonder how'd ya make it big...
A-map>map view size>double,I forgot to turn it of before using print screen ;)

[Corona]

Here's my map (remake)!
http://img135.imageshack.us/img135/1658/ecruteakcitydv9.png
It's Ecruteak City!
It is EXACTLY the same. The only difference is that I use new FRLG tiles.
If you want to compare it with the old version, use these links!
http://img135.imageshack.us/img135/1658/ecruteakcitydv9.png
http://www.vgmaps.com/Atlas/GB-GBC/Pokemon-GSC-Johto-EcruteakCity.png

Small note: It IS possible to use this map in a hack. However, you'll need to import a LOT of tiles, and change a whole lot of palettes.
10/10

Even though its just FR tiles you used them to all that they can be used

[Martin Yiu]

Zoomed x2 in AM, I suppose, then PrintScreen command and cropping in Paint, but IDK. Anyways, I would use different palette colours (more bright green) and roof tiles on the gate building. Maybe the blue house should have a window. Anyways, I see no big map errors at all, except the small trees, you should fix them. I like the map overall, so I give it 7,5/10.

[TSK]

http://i10.tinypic.com/4u1mk2g.jpg

[cε׀׀]

Here's my map (remake)!
http://img135.imageshack.us/img135/1658/ecruteakcitydv9.png
It's Ecruteak City!
It is EXACTLY the same. The only difference is that I use new FRLG tiles.
If you want to compare it with the old version, use these links!
http://img135.imageshack.us/img135/1658/ecruteakcitydv9.png
http://www.vgmaps.com/Atlas/GB-GBC/Pokemon-GSC-Johto-EcruteakCity.png

Small note: It IS possible to use this map in a hack. However, you'll need to import a LOT of tiles, and change a whole lot of palettes.
Nice! I like the remake, but i can see some errors.
8/10
It's a rather big image.
http://i3.tinypic.com/66ug1mb.jpg
Ummm nice, some errors but-7/10
http://i10.tinypic.com/4u1mk2g.jpg

Great!
I can see slight errors and think that the grass pal is abit dark.
ohwell-- 7.5/10

[TSK]

Nice! I like the remake, but i can see some errors.
8/10

Ummm nice, some errors but-7/10


Great!
I can see slight errors and think that the grass pal is abit dark.
ohwell-- 7.5/10
In a-map the flower tiles all look like that,if that's one of the thingies you saw.(I edited the map in paint to make it look the way it appears in the emulator)

[OsherStyle]

Nice comments zel;)
And,
Its been a while since i posted any maps so here goes:
Game:FR(Its a pokemon Eruption map)
Name: Route 2
Map:
Hope you like it ;)
P.S DONT STEAL THE PALS PLEASE!!!

10/10 thet awsome ! i love thet

[Ooka]

Well, I know that everyone is going to be rating this map badly because of the palette and probably not even considering the map but this IS supposed to be a Viridian CIty redo.

http://i165.photobucket.com/albums/u54/Ooka_100/Viridian2.jpg

[destinedjagold]

I love the trees.., but the grass is brightly colored, though... Some mountain and pond edges' errors are to be seen... The right side of the map is kinda empty... The rest is looking awesome...

7/10... the grass kinda hurts my eyes... T_T

[OsherStyle]

nice, its too empty..
8/10

[Ooka]

5 buildings, 4 patches of grass, a mountain, and a lake is empty? Wow, then I guess the whole game is kinda empty huh?

[Xray]

http://i223.photobucket.com/albums/dd251/kditsme1300/Accentcity-2.jpg
Please rate

[Ooka]

Well, the normal grass tiles look a little plain, but other than that it looks good.

7/10

[destinedjagold]

A little mountain edge error on top... Everyhing else looks oky. 7/10

[spenceroone3]

Name: Yung stunna's starter map
Rating: 8/10
Reason: I would like to live there, it looks pretty comfortable.
Suggestions: Use block editor on the back of the mountain.

[cε׀׀]

10/10 thet awsome ! i love thet
Thanks for the coment*Yay!10/10 8D*Well, I know that everyone is going to be rating this map badly because of the palette and probably not even considering the map but this IS supposed to be a Viridian CIty redo.

http://i165.photobucket.com/albums/u54/Ooka_100/Viridian2.jpg
Ummm i think the pal is abit bright, and i can see a couple of tile errors on the pond etc. And the right side is abit empty,
else i like it. 8/10
http://i223.photobucket.com/albums/dd251/kditsme1300/Accentcity-2.jpg
Please rate
Ummm i think its abit empty, and you need to add a little more creativity into it ;)
7/10

[spenceroone3]

Very small map today, sorry, but here it is:http://img442.imageshack.us/img442/7382/mapratingeo7.png
.:Game:.
Pokemon Firered
Hack is Poke Story
.:Map name:.
Route 203
.:Brief Description:.
This is route 203 from Sinnoh. It is a couple of years earlier then when humans first came about (They hadn't evolved from Primeapes and Infernapes yet) but Pokemon like having straight grasses. Their is only one event on the whole map, and that is just below the ledge, which is a pidgey that gives you a Potion. Personally I believe this is one of my very best maps. Please comment.

[thethethethe]

@spenceroone3: Personally I'm not a fan of remake maps. I just don't think that a lot of the nintendo made maps don't look 'the best'. Sorry, 6.5/10(added .5 because I can't see any errors)

Well Here's my map.
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/pictue.png

[Blazichu]

@thethethethe: I noticed one error in the map, the door window is yellow <_< Also the map reminds me of Pallet alot...but I'll give it a 7/10 ;)

[thethethethe]

Thanks Blazichu, I'll fix that palette. I thought it looked familiar but I guess I just couldn't pick it. Well I've got a couple more maps.
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/picture2.png
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/picture3.png

[cooley]

Those are maps in your hack? They look Great!
1st - 9/10
2nd - 8/10 ' errors on the bottom edges of lakes.

Very small map today, sorry, but here it is:http://img442.imageshack.us/img442/7382/mapratingeo7.png
.:Game:.
Pokemon Firered
Hack is Poke Story
.:Map name:.
Route 203
.:Brief Description:.
This is route 203 from Sinnoh. It is a couple of years earlier then when humans first came about (They hadn't evolved from Primeapes and Infernapes yet) but Pokemon like having straight grasses. Their is only one event on the whole map, and that is just below the ledge, which is a pidgey that gives you a Potion. Personally I believe this is one of my very best maps. Please comment.
That looks exactly like That route in D/P, you know what it's called....xD
Anyways: 8/10

[Johnny]

Well Here's my map.

Hey TTTT I really don't mind this one I like how you placed the trees ( realistically no tree is lined up with another) Nice work, The hedges down the top look good, You have unique style.

[cooley]

@johnny: I don't see a map.

::.My Map.::
http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x18/Cooley833/PalletTown.png
Just a map, nothing special. Don't tell me the road hurts your eyes....xD

[thethethethe]

Those are maps in your hack? They look Great!
1st - 9/10
2nd - 8/10 ' errors on the bottom edges of lakes.


That looks exactly like That route in D/P, you know what it's called....xD
Anyways: 8/10

They aren't from my hack but I might oinclude one of them.

@cooley's Map. The road hurts my eyes.(Just kidding) You need to palette edit the grass of the black road tiles. And an error above the door on the thing in the mddle. Also you need to palette edit the corners of the lake. And a little block editor problem on the tree below the lake.
6 out of ten.

Well here's a map that IS in my hack. My version of Olivine.
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/pic-1.png

[Gerri Shin]

This is a really old map I made back when I was a mapper. just thought I'd let you all take a gander at it.
(yes, I used Zel's Tileset, only because its the best in my eyes so far, don't knock it b/c of the set)
http://i225.photobucket.com/albums/dd36/girifarig/maps/Sandgem202.png

[cε׀׀]

@johnny: I don't see a map.

::.My Map.::
http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x18/Cooley833/PalletTown.png
Just a map, nothing special. Don't tell me the road hurts your eyes....xD
Wow i seem to like the map!
I really looks good, but try not making maps square.
8/10
Thanks Blazichu, I'll fix that palette. I thought it looked familiar but I guess I just couldn't pick it. Well I've got a couple more maps.
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/picture2.png
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/picture3.png
Wow, i like your maps thethethethe,
They're not square atall, and i see alot of creativity.
8.5/10

They aren't from my hack but I might oinclude one of them.

@cooley's Map. The road hurts my eyes.(Just kidding) You need to palette edit the grass of the black road tiles. And an error above the door on the thing in the mddle. Also you need to palette edit the corners of the lake. And a little block editor problem on the tree below the lake.
6 out of ten.

Well here's a map that IS in my hack. My version of Olivine.
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/pic-1.png
Nice i like the remake!
8/10
This is a really old map I made back when I was a mapper. just thought I'd let you all take a gander at it.
(yes, I used Zel's Tileset, only because its the best in my eyes so far, don't knock it b/c of the set)
http://i225.photobucket.com/albums/dd36/girifarig/maps/Sandgem202.png

Wow i love your maps!
It shows alot of creativity!
9/10

[Alistair]

This is a really old map I made back when I was a mapper. just thought I'd let you all take a gander at it.
(yes, I used Zel's Tileset, only because its the best in my eyes so far, don't knock it b/c of the set)
http://i225.photobucket.com/albums/dd36/girifarig/maps/Sandgem202.png

I am not really a fan of DP pre-maps (In fact, I'm kind of sick of them). For one, you really combined 2 maps. Also, it stays fairly true to the original, which is a bit of a problem. The grass in the route is way too uniform. You need too add spaces in between some grass tiles, and you also need to make the patches less square. Besides that, I also noticed some errors, too. Down by the shore, there are a couple of sand tiles. Also, the trees by the shore need to have sand under them. There is also a less noticible error involving the 2 story house. The roof tiles above the 2nd floor windows need to be fixed. These tiles have the top outline of the windows, and the tiles you used were for the door when you make a 1 story house.
I will not knock the map for using Zel's tileset, but I will knock you for using it. It is always better to use something that you worked hard on, rather than a straight ROM base (Which means at least edit it a bit).

So, in my eyes, that map deserves a 6/10.

Anyway, now onto my map.

ROM: FireRed
Map Name: Route I
Comments: If you were wondering, yes, that is the Professor's lab.

Route I (http://img408.imageshack.us/img408/3708/routeijj1.png)
It is too big to post as an image.

[Frostbite]

Well here's a map that IS in my hack. My version of Olivine.
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/pic-1.png

I really don't like how the trees are fashioned, it's just, ugh.

The fence between the two houses next to the Pokemon Center looks too awkward, replace it with a long tree or something. I really don't like the overall fashion of the brick roads you used, this just look sloppy. I'd suggest you make the road start in the city and make the road leading out to it just grass so you won't have that ugly skinny strip sticking out of there. The rocks, bushes, and flowers on the southern part could be more uniform. And also NEVER use the default blue houses for entire cities/houses, they look VERY ugly! Try using the purple house from the sevii islands, it works well with ocean-related maps like Olivine. However, I do love how you make use of one of those route house tilesets to make the lighthouse. It looks very nice.

Overall your map could be more neater and planned out; not everything just mushed together in one pile.

4.5/10

[cε׀׀]

I am not really a fan of DP pre-maps (In fact, I'm kind of sick of them). For one, you really combined 2 maps. Also, it stays fairly true to the original, which is a bit of a problem. The grass in the route is way too uniform. You need too add spaces in between some grass tiles, and you also need to make the patches less square. Besides that, I also noticed some errors, too. Down by the shore, there are a couple of sand tiles. Also, the trees by the shore need to have sand under them. There is also a less noticible error involving the 2 story house. The roof tiles above the 2nd floor windows need to be fixed. These tiles have the top outline of the windows, and the tiles you used were for the door when you make a 1 story house.
I will not knock the map for using Zel's tileset, but I will knock you for using it. It is always better to use something that you worked hard on, rather than a straight ROM base (Which means at least edit it a bit).

So, in my eyes, that map deserves a 6/10.

Anyway, now onto my map.

ROM: FireRed
Map Name: Route I
Comments: If you were wondering, yes, that is the Professor's lab.

Route I (http://img408.imageshack.us/img408/3708/routeijj1.png)
It is too big to post as an image.

Wow! I love your map!
It must have took alot of time doing that, and i think its a masterpiece!
I cant see any errors,
And i like your creativity!
9.5/10

[~Satoshi Sugimori~]

http://i128.photobucket.com/albums/p190/Poke-Roy/PSP%20wallpapers/the%20rest/fakemon/Faketowns/AzeleaTownRemake.png
Azelea Revamp...Ratez?:D

[cooley]

A Redo of the Town:
http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x18/Cooley833/NewTown.jpg
Comments. Suggestions

DO NOT STEAL THE PALETTES, OR THE TREE TILES!

[destinedjagold]

nice, but you could just remove the tree in that little island. It really looks sad 'cause it's all alone... T_T

:D Eheheh, anyways, i like it better this time. 9/10 ;)

[EarthsVisitor]

http://img240.imageshack.us/img240/9922/mappvn4.jpg
Feel free to use my palette.
Map in Pokemon: Rocket's Revenge.
Yes, I know there are a few tile errors, I know them already, and have been fixed, this it outdated, please don't post about them.

[♠εx]

I like the map, the use of the palette gives it a nice feel.
One question, do you continue onto another map from the right side?
Down in the bottom right theres a space to walk through.

9/10

[cooley]

nice, but you could just remove the tree in that little island. It really looks sad 'cause it's all alone... T_T

:D Eheheh, anyways, i like it better this time. 9/10 ;)
I can only move it over by one tile. That tree and others, have special events that occur once you have earned the HM: Surf. Be warned it is coming soon.....

[Alizée Jacotey]

Rate this please:



http://img150.imageshack.us/img150/8248/mapuc5.png

[Blazichu]

@*~*TwiLiTeDaRkRai*~*: This map looks alright, maybe not too many holes in the wall or create a massive hole where the water flows from and fix up some waterfalls as they don't appear right. My favourite part is the right hand side, so I'll give this a 6/10.

[~Satoshi Sugimori~]

http://i128.photobucket.com/albums/p190/Poke-Roy/PSP%20wallpapers/the%20rest/fakemon/Faketowns/townandroute.png
My new town and route..ratez?

[Blazichu]

@Poke-Roy: Your map is good and looks original, a little tiling error(one of the trees near the house with the two doors, to the left and a little bit down) and maybe fill up the space behind and below the Pokemon centre, then it should be really good! I'll give it an 8/10.

[zel]

Wow, so many maps I have left uncommented on such a short period of time. Don't expect big comments about them this time ;)

http://img135.imageshack.us/img135/1658/ecruteakcitydv9.png

A remake map... Well, at least I see some effort on the tile edition, and some original touch at some of the buildings (yeah, I'm refering to the Tin and Burned Towers)
I don't really think the rocky path fits Ecruteak.
Well, as you know, its something already mapped so don't expect much on my rating.
Rating->7/10

http://i3.tinypic.com/66ug1mb.jpg

A pretty small map, so that doesn't allows us to see too much creativity there (I'd suggest to avoid posting such kind of small maps, usually from the starting town, they tend to be boring usually)
Just a little touch, I wouldn't use the flower tiles so ordered
That palette doesn't helps either...
Rating->6/10

http://i10.tinypic.com/4u1mk2g.jpg

This one is a bit more interesting on the other hand, but, instead it has many aspects that you should improve. I'd use a bit more the lighter grass path, if it's supposed to be a town (maybe the ground path would work?)
But, definitely, you need to improve the sea on the south of the map (add rocks there, they'll usually make the maps be more filled up with something), and the exit to the northeast (a bit too empty to my liking)
Just fill up those areas a bit more and it'll be good enough, but as I said before, the palette really doesn't helps (it's unnatural)
Rating->6/10

http://i165.photobucket.com/albums/u54/Ooka_100/Viridian2.jpg

The map itself doesn't look that bad, but I'm not a fan of the bright palettes (however, this is more an opinion and wont affect the rating)
You could fill up some areas that seem a bit empty with some flowers tiles. But, the main concern here, is the eastern border of the map. I dont remember how Viridian is originally on FR, but you should put some trees there, just leaving it empty takes some originality, and, since the map is supposed to be a redo, you could add some extra tiles that weren't on the original. Well, that's what I think...
I also wonder about those grass tiles on the city, wild Pokemon there? Hmmm...
I wont rate it that good, because in the end, and you said it already, it's just a mod to an existing map.
Rating->7/10

http://i223.photobucket.com/albums/dd251/kditsme1300/Accentcity-2.jpg

Another starter town map, which means, small map and not that intersting. But, you are missing using one of the light green paths, at least to put something extra on the map.
Additionally, if you could, you should use the other blue colored roof tile for one of the houses. Who says all of the houses should be of the same color?
As I said before, small, I don't really like seeing the starter town's maps...
Rating->6/10

http://img442.imageshack.us/img442/7382/mapratingeo7.png

I see it as a very linear map, but, if it is supposed to be a remake map, then, it's obvious that it won't show that much creativity from you. Unless you have done changes to how R203 originally looked (I don't know, haven't played DP for quite some time)
On the other hand, there's nothing much to add, the map is fine, nothing too spectacular
Rating->7/10

http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/pictue.png

Hmmm... Well, this is different, this looks like a starter town map (which means small), but you have done some changes that made it look quite more interesting than the average (yeah, I'm talking about the use of some trees, and basically, a variety of tiles)
The only thing I don't like is that... green... thing on the entrance to the town, I'd prefer using the posts, but maybe you thought it was more original (and it is, I personally don't like it, it's just that)
A good example for other starter town maps!
Rating->9/10

http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/picture2.png
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/picture3.png

After seeing the previous map, the first one of this pair of maps doesn't look that cool as the other one. I think that I don't like the fact of not having a path on the town.
I think this map turned out to be a bit too small, I think it should have been a bit bigger in relity (stuff is too compressed, that's my impression)
Rating->7/10

Now, regarding the second map, it's another nice route. But, I'm gonna tell you that it doesn't have a good design in my opinion. Why? Because the player will only have to go from left to right, right to left, left to right, right to left, and that is really boring (if that was the effect you were looking for, then you'll be sucessful). I'd think a bit more about the design of how you want the player to walk around the map.
Rating->8/10

http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x18/Cooley833/PalletTown.png

...But it really does...
Anyway, regarding the map, I'd personally have used a few more trees instead of that gray path on the southwest of the map (I really don't understand what that's supposed to be, but it doesn't look good)
About the tile problem thethethethe mentioned (the one of the tree and the ledge with the water), I think that is something that you cannot solve with the Block Editor, so, I'd suggest you to move the tree one step down.
Well, I need to stop seeing the map, my eyes are screaming... XD
Rating->7/10

http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/pic-1.png

Well, something already existing, but you added some minor twists to it. At least, I must say that you must be working a lot on it because of the way the trees are placed. Won't you have problems with the borders?
There's only one thing that I'll ask you for that map, and that is, the use of more rocks on the ocean (unless you are using rocks as the border, but that would make the map too square and boring), add a variety of rocks (randomly, if you want), and the map will be nice.
Rating->8/10

http://i225.photobucket.com/albums/dd36/girifarig/maps/Sandgem202.png

Well, this is in fact a pure remake map (it's interesting to see my tiles generating a DP map, though), so no kind of effort on the generation of a map. Besides that, there are many tiles errors on the sand on the south, and I don't think it's good to have such ammount of grass. Maybe it would have been nice if you added an extra to the map and put the grass a bit more randomly (or at least leaving some open spaces on the grass)
I think that if it had a bit more effort on adding some extra tiles, it could turn out as a better map.
Rating->6/10

Route I (http://img408.imageshack.us/img408/3708/routeijj1.png)

What can I really say, I know you are a great mapper, and showing your maps around here should be something everyone else should see as a way to motivate themselves.
It's a very original map, with tiles variation on the exact measure. I may not like all of your tiles (or maybe the palette, a bit), but still on terms of mapping this is one of the best maps I've seen (only surpassed by that forest map you showed us before)
Rating->10/10

http://i128.photobucket.com/albums/p190/Poke-Roy/PSP%20wallpapers/the%20rest/fakemon/Faketowns/AzeleaTownRemake.png

Hmmm... Another remake map. I'll keep saying that you should improve the tileset if you are gonna keep doing remake maps, at least, that'll show some effort on the overall creation of the map. Else, it's just boring seeing the same tiles available with just a change of palettes.
The good thing about it is that that strange roof made me laugh for a while :P
Rating->6/10

Well, that's all I could quote without turning crazy... So, the rest for later!

[~Satoshi Sugimori~]

Hmmm... Another remake map. I'll keep saying that you should improve the tileset if you are gonna keep doing remake maps, at least, that'll show some effort on the overall creation of the map. Else, it's just boring seeing the same tiles available with just a change of palettes.
The good thing about it is that that strange roof made me laugh for a while :P
Rating->6/10

Well, that's all I could quote without turning crazy... So, the rest for later!

Lolz thnx..what do you think of my last map?
And the remake was a one timer..;)

[♠εx]

Heres a map from my new hack, it's the starting town.

http://img413.imageshack.us/img413/7176/town1at1.png

[Zanacross]

diffrent

palletd for cliff are wierd

7/10

its a nice map the cliff pallet lets it down i think

[zel]

OK, let's finish the rest of the maps now...

http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x18/Cooley833/NewTown.jpg


Ah, it's a modification of the other map, I see. Well, at least the new palettes make it more nice to the eyes (thought that light green path is always a headache to edit, I'd suggest you to try to find a game with a better path to rip. It's not one of my favorites, and I'm thinking on changing it for my game as well)
I prefered that big mountain instead of the change you did on the top of the map, now it sounds a bit more like a "common map"
Anyway, was it supposed to be a town? With just two houses? Hmmm... I'd put one or two more houses (closed, if you want), because two sounds a bit too few.
I'll give you the same rating, though I liked the other map, with the fixes and the palette of the second.
Rating->7/10

http://img240.imageshack.us/img240/9922/mappvn4.jpg


Even though I wont comment on the errors, since I have to judge what I see, they'll affect the rating
To begin with, it's a wonderful palette to give the impression that its nighttime, this just adds to the originality of the map.
Regarding the map itself, it's good to see two completely different parts on the same map, a small part with lots of green and trees, and a second, more mountainous part (specially, I liked the fact of seeing a few of your plans with the events images)
With the errors fixed this map would be really good, considering them it's...
Rating->8/10

http://img150.imageshack.us/img150/8248/mapuc5.png


It has interesting ideas, though I don't know why water comes from those closed doors.
For the rest, I always like variation on tiles for the same map, and this one has them. The only thing is that maybe that path on the east part of the map is a bit too wide to my liking.
Rating->8/10

http://i128.photobucket.com/albums/p190/Poke-Roy/PSP%20wallpapers/the%20rest/fakemon/Faketowns/townandroute.png


Wow, now that was something different of what you've been showing!
I really love that map, it must've taken quite a lot of time to make it. It has something weird on it (that strange house with that roof we'd be able to walk below), though I don't know if the map itself would classify as a town (more like a forest to me)
By the way, just work on fixing the pallet for the bottom of the trees, the green there doesn't match with your palette for the green ground.
Add some flowers or those patches of flowers you used on the weird house more on the southeast corner of the map, where the PC is located, it'll make it look better.
It's really good, keep it up!
Rating->9/10

http://img413.imageshack.us/img413/7176/town1at1.png

This starting town sounds interesting (the idea of the mapping), however the mapping does not correspond to it. I like the sea and beach part, that one is nicely done, but the town itself needs a bit more of work. I would have used more of those pined trees instead of the unnecesary and lonely headbutt tree, and... just two flowers? Usually the starting town should have a few more than that.
By the way, that thing sounds too weird to be a house. Hope you have something good planned for it, and it's not the town's Lab :P
It just needs more work on the part of the town, the beach and that was good, that's why it gets...
Rating->7/10

[♠εx]

The little red house is a small sea cottage.
I didn't want to overdo the town so I made it a little simple.

[cooley]

OK, let's finish the rest of the maps now...



Ah, it's a modification of the other map, I see. Well, at least the new palettes make it more nice to the eyes (thought that light green path is always a headache to edit, I'd suggest you to try to find a game with a better path to rip. It's not one of my favorites, and I'm thinking on changing it for my game as well)
I prefered that big mountain instead of the change you did on the top of the map, now it sounds a bit more like a "common map"
Anyway, was it supposed to be a town? With just two houses? Hmmm... I'd put one or two more houses (closed, if you want), because two sounds a bit too few.
I'll give you the same rating, though I liked the other map, with the fixes and the palette of the second.
Rating->7/10

Thanks for Comments, I'll take your suggestions into consideration. And I'll Add a few closed houses too. ;)

[thethethethe]

Hmmm... Well, this is different, this looks like a starter town map (which means small), but you have done some changes that made it look quite more interesting than the average (yeah, I'm talking about the use of some trees, and basically, a variety of tiles)
The only thing I don't like is that... green... thing on the entrance to the town, I'd prefer using the posts, but maybe you thought it was more original (and it is, I personally don't like it, it's just that)
A good example for other starter town maps!
Rating->9/10

After seeing the previous map, the first one of this pair of maps doesn't look that cool as the other one. I think that I don't like the fact of not having a path on the town.
I think this map turned out to be a bit too small, I think it should have been a bit bigger in relity (stuff is too compressed, that's my impression)
Rating->7/10

Now, regarding the second map, it's another nice route. But, I'm gonna tell you that it doesn't have a good design in my opinion. Why? Because the player will only have to go from left to right, right to left, left to right, right to left, and that is really boring (if that was the effect you were looking for, then you'll be sucessful). I'd think a bit more about the design of how you want the player to walk around the map.
Rating->8/10

Well, something already existing, but you added some minor twists to it. At least, I must say that you must be working a lot on it because of the way the trees are placed. Won't you have problems with the borders?
There's only one thing that I'll ask you for that map, and that is, the use of more rocks on the ocean (unless you are using rocks as the border, but that would make the map too square and boring), add a variety of rocks (randomly, if you want), and the map will be nice.
Rating->8/10

Thanks for the comments Zel. Since you've posted on all of them I think I have reason to post about your comments and explain myself. Most of these maps I was just making to see how my mapping skills are rated against other people, so 3 out of the 4, I made purely for this thread.

The first one. At first I used the fence but then I had a little skinny green path. So I removed the path from that spot and it didn't look right to me. So I made it the green bush(or whatever you call it) and I liked the look of it so I kept it.

The second and third I was never happy with. I'd do something and then change it to something else. Everything just looked 'incorrect' to me, I'm going to 'fix' the second one. When I'm happy with it I may re-post it(not likely), because I'm thinking of using that as a route in LoD.

Well, I haven't gotten that far in LoD that I can see if the border will have problems. I guess I'll find out when I get that far. I should also explain the arrangement of the trees. I'm sick of seeing trees in line and perfect and straight, in reality, have you ever seen that in real life?. They're all over the place.
Since posting that map I've made quite a few changes. I've taken Frostbites advice and changed the path a bit and changed the houses to the island, and some other little changes/fixes that have hopefully made it look a bit better.

[cε׀׀]

Awwe mann!
Ive missed alot of stuff,
I havent been on PC lately, so Ill rate one map.


Heres a map from my new hack, it's the starting town.

http://img413.imageshack.us/img413/7176/town1at1.png

Wow i like the pals that are used and the seaside idea,
I really like it, Its plain and simple and good.
8/10

[Xray]

Name: Greenville town
Map from: Fire red
Comments: I messed up the grass in Block editor, I an fix it though.
http://i223.photobucket.com/albums/dd251/kditsme1300/greenvilletown.jpg

[Zanacross]

You should add some empty house i think
because it feels too empty.

i would move the mart from where it is to another place

8/10

pals are very nice

[cooley]

My New map, Made by Celebi_XD!
Please Rate. I rate it 10/10.
http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x18/Cooley833/Route3-1.jpg
-cooley

[Zanacross]

10/10

Its one of the best ones ive ever seen.

It's a beautiful map

not too cramped or to empty its perfect.
the pallets really complement this well made map

The water at the top gives it a nice look
and i love the tree's at the bottom.

[thethethethe]

Why are you posting a map made by someone else. Anyway, I give it 9/10 only because the outside of the sandy path was left unpalette edited. It still shows the colour of the original grass. Other than that it looks pretty good.

[cε׀׀]

My New map, Made by Celebi_XD!
Please Rate. I rate it 10/10.
http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x18/Cooley833/Route3-1.jpg
-cooley
OOoo thanks alot cooley;)(You also edited it abit, double thanks;)
You showed my map hehe
It looks darn good, I thought it was worse than this,
Maybe because I was up at night :D
And thanks for the rating everyone :)

Name: Greenville town
Map from: Fire red
Comments: I messed up the grass in Block editor, I an fix it though.
http://i223.photobucket.com/albums/dd251/kditsme1300/greenvilletown.jpg

I seem to like your map,
I like the pals you have used, but i think it could be done
better.

[Kristian]

name: (havent named it..:P)
game: Fire Red..
comments: please rate? and give suggestions =)
http://i231.photobucket.com/albums/ee239/pkmnkristian/mappic.jpg

[cε׀׀]

name: (havent named it..:P)
game: Fire Red..
comments: please rate? and give suggestions =)
http://i231.photobucket.com/albums/ee239/pkmnkristian/mappic.jpg
Ive got to admit, its a really good map, well here are my things to say:
Rating:8/10
Reason:The map is fairly good, The tree's are set up nicely and
The maps not a complete square. But I think that more
things could be addedSuggestions: I would have liked it if you did not make the sea
that much empty, you could have put some rocks or
some other things in it, And try to not always keep,
the sea empty.
Adios!

[Alistair]

What can I really say, I know you are a great mapper, and showing your maps around here should be something everyone else should see as a way to motivate themselves.
It's a very original map, with tiles variation on the exact measure. I may not like all of your tiles (or maybe the palette, a bit), but still on terms of mapping this is one of the best maps I've seen (only surpassed by that forest map you showed us before)
Rating->10/10

Wow, thanks zel. About the trees you don't like, if they are the palm trees, I am working on making new ones anyway. I hate them. And about the palettes, I am tring to find some better ones, too.

My New map, Made by Celebi_XD!
Please Rate. I rate it 10/10.
http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x18/Cooley833/Route3-1.jpg
-cooley

The map is pretty good, but it has some flaws. The map is very cramped. Unless this is the first route, I suggest you expand it, making the paths wider. Since this is a route, It will probably have trainers, which there is very little room for. There is also another layout issue, which is that you can only go one way in the map. This is a serious problem, as if you need to back track, and you do not have a flying Pokemon with you, you are out of luck. It would be highly beneficial to remove the ledge right after the top bridge. Now, there are also a few aesthetic problems, too. One is that the grass is in square clumps. Try making it a little less "shapened" and add tiles of regular ground into the patch. Also, you used two different path tiles. I suggest that, since this is a smaller route, you use only one type. Now, even though this map has these errors, that doesn't mean it is not good. On the contrary, it is a great map. It just needs some tweaking to make it better for actual gameplay.

Rating: 8/10

[zel]

http://i223.photobucket.com/albums/dd251/kditsme1300/greenvilletown.jpg

It gives me the impression of an edited version of Pewter. Stuff has been changed, but some parts of the map look empty and a bit boring (didn't you have any other extra tile to put around on the secondary tileset?), or, maybe put some more trees around town?
It's respectable, but as I said before looks a bit like Pewter, even when stuff has been moved around...
Rating->7/10

http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x18/Cooley833/Route3-1.jpg

Some maps are very big and have few stuff, this is the complete opposite, the placement of mountain and rocks looks a bit odd. Still, regarding Don Patch's "can only go one way", I disagree, though I doubt the way to make it work was not planned on purpose: from north to south, there are no problems, just jump a few ledges and that's it. From south to north (and to the house) the only way I see is by surfing.
I'll suggest that you review the map, it's not only about making the map look "nice", but it also needs to make sense (which is the harder part, since it requires you using the brain :knockedou)
Rating->9/10

http://i231.photobucket.com/albums/ee239/pkmnkristian/mappic.jpg

Well, a small map but it looks fine. I don't really like the small green bushes, but, meh...
You could take the suggestion of adding rocks on the ocean, but I guess you'd only need them close to the border of the cliff (because I guess that's an ocean to the right, and since we wont surf over there, there's no real need for rocks (when we play on that map, we wouldn't be able to see them, anyway))
It's a small map made with custom FR tiles (which tends to bore me), so I'm not rating it too high...
Rating->7/10

[destinedjagold]

Hello and good day to everyone! ^^
I would just like to ask you all to rate my map.
This is the only map where I put almost all my attention for 3 days.
This is DESTRAL CITY in my hack.
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa154/destinedjagold/destraltown2.png

Thanks in advance.

[pkmnmaster69]

@destinedjaold: Hm the map looks quite intresting the pallettes look awesome 9/10.

[Scorp Con]

Map Name: Route1?

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: Well... It's Raining!

Mapshot: http://img403.imageshack.us/img403/5100/dasdns6.png

[Zanacross]

^^^^^^^^^^^
That map gets 7/10
you need to make the path with the water over it flow more if ya get what i mean




http://i10.tinypic.com/6p7evsh.jpg

map off ruby
i cant be bothered to change the pallets yet.


ill repost when i change them

[Ranger Dude]

Thats a good map! 8/10 You haven't got much wild grass in. Or is it supposed to be like that? Anyway good work!

[Zanacross]

http://i15.tinypic.com/7ydpb1u.jpg

new map
ruby again
if i start a hack this is the place you would start

[destinedjagold]

Some tile errors... Wrong usage of ocean stone blockers there... 4/10

[cε׀׀]

Hello and good day to everyone! ^^
I would just like to ask you all to rate my map.
This is the only map where I put almost all my attention for 3 days.
This is DESTRAL CITY in my hack.
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa154/destinedjagold/destraltown2.png

Thanks in advance.
Nice map.
Rating:8/10
Reason:Very well done but I can just see one tile error
http://i15.tinypic.com/7ydpb1u.jpg

new map
ruby again
if i start a hack this is the place you would start
Rating:6.5/10
Reason:some tile errors and the map is abit empty

[destinedjagold]

Elow! XD
It's me again, and thanks for rating my previous map, which was Destral City.
Now I'm gonna wish that you'll rate this little route o'mine. It's IRON PATH, that would be available later in the game.
Thanks in advance! ;)
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa154/destinedjagold/myIRONPATH.png

[zel]

http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa154/destinedjagold/destraltown2.png

Obviously, first thing that caught my attention on this map was the four contest-like buildings (hopefully they are not all the four level of contests in the same city, are they? that would be pretty silly). I am not quite sure about having all of them so close to each other and that (I'm not even sure if so many buildings of the same kind should coexist), but, anyway, as an idea it is interesting...
In terms of mapping it looks pretty good, there's also the idea of the cycling road to reach the town, which is something I don't see often around the maps on PC.
The only thing I don't like is the light-fluo-with-red-flowers path, it really disturbs the normal green of the ground.
But, overall, this map includes interesting ideas, and is nicely done, it gets...
Rating->9/10

http://img403.imageshack.us/img403/5100/dasdns6.png

I could be a bit exigent and tell you that you have a few tiles errors around (like, using the wrong tile to end the small pine-like trees, or using the one to end the small pine-like trees in the middle. Or also, using the wrong tiles for the middle of the bigger trees that stand alone), however I'm not that good at explaining those kind of small tiling errors (Don Patch is better at that than me), and in any case, I don't pay that much attention to them (still, they exist)
The map does not such that much creativity, you should try putting more grass in the middle road, not just to the left, because that road will most likely be avoided (and perhaps the trainer should have a battle quite early) I guess it's fine for a Route1...
Rating->7/10

http://i10.tinypic.com/6p7evsh.jpg

How about putting more grass on the part that looks a bit empty?
You should also do something with the area that has that little sand patch (maybe add a few other sand patches to the side?), always add something when you see a part that contains always the same kind of tile, to add variation to your map.
Rating->7/10

http://i15.tinypic.com/7ydpb1u.jpg

Hmmm, even though the map's idea was fine, the mapping was quite bad (wrong tiles used everywhere, and I am not that much of a fan of "trees growing on sand" (unless they look like palm trees))
Again, try adding something where there is a lot of the same kind of tiles (I'm talking about the beach)
Fix those tile errors, and try again
Rating->5/10

http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa154/destinedjagold/myIRONPATH.png

Ah! What a big sized map! (Too bad the player gets to see about 3/4 of the map :P)
Anyway, it's very good (though I'm not sure if you should truncate the high grass tile with the green+border tile... Doesn't look as if it was supposed to be that way)
There's only one thing I think you should be adding, if the map is supposed to be close to mountains, you should be using more that lone rock tile around the map, it'll give you more variety, and in any case, it just adds realism to the map, don't you think?
Rating->9/10

[destinedjagold]

Thanks zel, and to everyone who rated my maps!
yeah, they're the four contests in a Ruby ROM...:)
That really inspires me to go on! Thanks again! and have a great day! :D

[Scorp Con]

I could be a bit exigent and tell you that you have a few tiles errors around (like, using the wrong tile to end the small pine-like trees, or using the one to end the small pine-like trees in the middle. Or also, using the wrong tiles for the middle of the bigger trees that stand alone), however I'm not that good at explaining those kind of small tiling errors (Don Patch is better at that than me), and in any case, I don't pay that much attention to them (still, they exist)
The map does not such that much creativity, you should try putting more grass in the middle road, not just to the left, because that road will most likely be avoided (and perhaps the trainer should have a battle quite early) I guess it's fine for a Route1...
Rating->7/10

I didn't put any grass on the middle, because you will get a starter... in secend town ;)

Newest maps:
http://img220.imageshack.us/img220/8805/firsttownis1.png
http://img209.imageshack.us/img209/2127/secendtownqk7.png
http://img264.imageshack.us/img264/8823/secendroutexf2.png

[cε׀׀]

Elow! XD
It's me again, and thanks for rating my previous map, which was Destral City.
Now I'm gonna wish that you'll rate this little route o'mine. It's IRON PATH, that would be available later in the game.
Thanks in advance! ;)
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa154/destinedjagold/myIRONPATH.png
Nice good map,
It has alot of pathways and good ideas of paths, but I could see some teeny weeny errors of the grass there,
But it gets a good rating>>9/10
I didn't put any grass on the middle, because you will get a starter... in secend town ;)

Newest maps:
http://img220.imageshack.us/img220/8805/firsttownis1.png
http://img209.imageshack.us/img209/2127/secendtownqk7.png
http://img264.imageshack.us/img264/8823/secendroutexf2.png
Firstmap:Nice map, its plain and simple but it could be done better if you hade put some ideas into it.
Rating:7/10

Second map:This one is plain and simple but just a little bit empty, and some tile errors of the fence.
Rating:6.5/10

Third map:Good, this is abit complex than your other maps. I could see no errors there.
Rating:8/10

[Zanacross]

Thank's Zel Ill take your suggestions

I didn't put any grass on the middle, because you will get a starter... in secend town ;)

Newest maps:
http://img220.imageshack.us/img220/8805/firsttownis1.png
http://img209.imageshack.us/img209/2127/secendtownqk7.png
http://img264.imageshack.us/img264/8823/secendroutexf2.png

Your maps are okay but meh

Map one

It's just pallet town with different tile's
2/10
map2
very nice looks good
no errors
6/10
3rd map
These keep getting better
8/10

[TheSilverVersion]

Could somebody rate this?

Name: Morning Rise City (working title)

Game:Game: Fire-Red

Additional Comments: I'm making this as the second city in my hack. The thing in the upper left hand corner is supposed to be a small stadium, with windows built into the wall for the spectators.

I just can't decide weather I absolutely love this map, or if I hate it, and should send it to the recycle...
[img=http://img440.imageshack.us/img440/1485/morningriseqq0.th.png] (http://img440.imageshack.us/my.php?image=morningriseqq0.png)

EDIT: Sorry, I left the grid on with the mapshot. If its a problem to view, PM me and I can upload a clean version..

[~Satoshi Sugimori~]

Could somebody rate this?

Name: Morning Rise City (working title)

Game:Game: Fire-Red

Additional Comments: I'm making this as the second city in my hack. The thing in the upper left hand corner is supposed to be a small stadium, with windows built into the wall for the spectators.

I just can't decide weather I absolutely love this map, or if I hate it, and should send it to the recycle...
[img=http://img440.imageshack.us/img440/1485/morningriseqq0.th.png] (http://img440.imageshack.us/my.php?image=morningriseqq0.png)

EDIT: Sorry, I left the grid on with the mapshot. If its a problem to view, PM me and I can upload a clean version..

Looks nice but you could change the tiles so they will fit better and a few errors etc..I give it a 6.5/10...

[flygonbreloom]

Could somebody rate this?

Name: Morning Rise City (working title)

Game:Game: Fire-Red

Additional Comments: I'm making this as the second city in my hack. The thing in the upper left hand corner is supposed to be a small stadium, with windows built into the wall for the spectators.

I just can't decide weather I absolutely love this map, or if I hate it, and should send it to the recycle...
ht tp://img440.imageshack.us/img440/1485/morningriseqq0.th.png

EDIT: Sorry, I left the grid on with the mapshot. If its a problem to view, PM me and I can upload a clean version..

That looks nice, apart from some minor errors mentioned above.

7.5/10

[thethethethe]

Could somebody rate this?

Name: Morning Rise City (working title)

Game:Game: Fire-Red

Additional Comments: I'm making this as the second city in my hack. The thing in the upper left hand corner is supposed to be a small stadium, with windows built into the wall for the spectators.

I just can't decide weather I absolutely love this map, or if I hate it, and should send it to the recycle...
[img=http://img440.imageshack.us/img440/1485/morningriseqq0.th.png] (http://img440.imageshack.us/my.php?image=morningriseqq0.png)

EDIT: Sorry, I left the grid on with the mapshot. If its a problem to view, PM me and I can upload a clean version..

2/10. It sounds harsh, but sorry, it's my opinion. So many problems with this map.
I'll list a few. I won't mention the windows in the top right hand corner but you should try and get new tiles to make it suit what you think it should look like.

That whole dusty path in the top right hand corner especially the pokemon center roof parts.
The black spot in the green roof.
The bottoms of the flowerboxes infront of the green roofed house.
Both Signposts.
Why is there a double doored house?
Most of the mountain edges.
A lot of the pokemart roof.
Most of the edges of paths.
The house with part of the pokemart roof.

I think that's enough.
You should take a good look at your maps and not mix tiles that shouldn't be used together.

[cε׀׀]

I kind of agree with thethethethe
Your map is kinda full of errors, I see what you were trying to do, but you should sometimes remove the grid to see your mistakes,
There are a whole bunch of mistakes like the paths, buildings etc.
I would rate this map 3/10 sorry

-Celebi

[TheSilverVersion]

2/10. It sounds harsh, but sorry, it's my opinion. So many problems with this map.
I'll list a few. I won't mention the windows in the top right hand corner but you should try and get new tiles to make it suit what you think it should look like.

That whole dusty path in the top right hand corner especially the pokemon center roof parts.[It's comming out of a canyon, but I see what you mean. It doesn't mix up to well with the road...
The black spot in the green roof. I thought you needed that there for the warp to come out back...Guess not
The bottoms of the flowerboxes infront of the green roofed house.
Both Signposts.
Why is there a double doored house? Its supposed to be a barn...:surprised:
Most of the mountain edges.
A lot of the pokemart roof.
Most of the edges of paths.
The house with part of the pokemart roof.I'll probably scrap it, I was trying to make a different looking house for a visitors center...

I think that's enough.
You should take a good look at your maps and not mix tiles that shouldn't be used together.

Well thanks for you imput Everyone. I'm going to redesign it with better fitting edited tiles, and then I will resubmit the changed version.
*Scuries off to learn pallet editing*

[Nytkoi]

Map Name:Mondercose Town
Map Game: Fire-red
Comments:Worked on for 1 hour and 30 min...
It's the best map I've made. Please rate.
http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z227/ataylan/MondercoseTown.png

[EarthsVisitor]

Map Name:Mondercose Town
http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z227/ataylan/MondercoseTown.png

I acutally enjoy this town quite a bit.
The Mountain level are very nicely done, and Houses are nicely placed.
The whole map flows and looks good.
There is one tile error though. For the back of the grass on top of a mountain, you shouldn't be using a mountain tile, there is a grass tile that has a little brown peice on the end of it you should be using.

Some suggestions:
1. The mountain level in the back, I think should be connected, it looks odd, just stopping then continuing again.
2. Eliminate most the use of the green stuff (bushes) in front of the houses, and to block places.
3. The house at the bottom is sort of out of place.

9/10
Good Job!

[Nytkoi]

Thnx. I will fix it later.
YAYA! 9/10!

[- Sigma -]

Mondercose Town
http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z227/ataylan/MondercoseTown.png

Wow, this map, like EarthsVisitor said, is very enjoyable. I can see not many mistakes, all I can see is one, really.

Just the back mountain, where that last flower is. Maybe you can make that area all mountain, it looks a bit glitched like that.

Good luck with your hack, Neminoa.

[Nytkoi]

Wow, this map, like EarthsVisitor said, is very enjoyable. I can see not many mistakes, all I can see is one, really.

Just the back mountain, where that last flower is. Maybe you can make that area all mountain, it looks a bit glitched like that.

Good luck with your hack, Neminoa.


Thnx. I am working on another map.
Oh, and... Your rating?

[Zanacross]

Nice map not complicated at all lol

but i think you should edit the pallets

Thats would be a very good idea.

and mayby edit some tiles.

7/10

[Nytkoi]

My map? Thnx a lot, but by the maps, you're mmaking you
need a LOT of work

[- Sigma -]

Thnx. I am working on another map.
Oh, and... Your rating?9/10. It looks great. XD I can't wait for more of your awesome maps, Neminoa.

[-Link-]

Map Name:Mondercose Town
Map Game: Fire-red
Comments:Worked on for 1 hour and 30 min...
It's the best map I've made. Please rate.
http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z227/ataylan/MondercoseTown.png
Nice one...
9/10.
Like - Sigma - and Earthsvisoter said, the top mountin
looks kinda wird. Good job anyways.

[cε׀׀]

Wow I think thats a very creative map, but the block you used for the top part of the mountain is not the appropriate block that should be used,
else I think that the connections of the paths and the town look absolutely amazing, but i could see a few minor errors. But the map gets an overall rating of:
9/10
Ive seen that you put alot of effort on to it and you may be an expert mapper one day.

~Celebi

[Nytkoi]

Elow! XD
It's me again, and thanks for rating my previous map, which was Destral City.
Now I'm gonna wish that you'll rate this little route o'mine. It's IRON PATH, that would be available later in the game.
Thanks in advance! ;)
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa154/destinedjagold/myIRONPATH.png
Incredible! Extremly well done, mabye a bit too much grass, but overall
FANTASTIC! 9/10
Oh, forgot:
Map Name:Route 345
Map Game:Firered.
COmments: The route after Mondercose, rate please.
http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z227/ataylan/Route345.png

[Zanacross]

Incredible! Extremly well done, mabye a bit too much grass, but overall
FANTASTIC! 9/10
Oh, forgot:
Map Name:Route 345
Map Game:Firered.
COmments: The route after Mondercose, rate please.
http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z227/ataylan/Route345.png

Its very confusing

I don't know if I'm coming or going

Theres a few errors

I still think you need to edit the pallets

but overall 6/10

[Nytkoi]

@Zanacross: Using punctuation wouldn't hurt, would it?

@neminoa: Anyways, I am not very fond of the map of Route 345 you made. Same for the town you made. First: Too busy. Then: Too buggy. All you can do is improve the maps rapidly. It's nice to let your ego grow on people who don't see a good map very often, but if you really want some improvement, you need some constructive criticsm and so I am here. Put less houses. Make the map look natural. My dear, inspire yourself with the real nature. Or at least with hacks of higher quality :P

4/10

Hmmm, okay. I will work on it. Thnx anyways.

[suoert]

here's a map I've been making. I think it's quite nice but that's just my opinion
pleas tell me what I did wrong or what I could improve!
http://img158.imageshack.us/img158/7608/mountainspass2ei6.png

[Zanacross]

That is very very nice

i love the rock pallet
and well all the pallets.

the tree's are even better
10/10

[Nytkoi]

here's a map I've been making. I think it's quite nice but that's just my opinion
pleas tell me what I did wrong or what I could improve!
http://img158.imageshack.us/img158/7608/mountainspass2ei6.png
A little empty and If it's the first town it has too much.
6.5/10
That is very very nice

i love the rock pallet
and well all the pallets.

the tree's are even better
10/10
Tsk. You's give anything with new tiles 10/10

[Zanacross]

A little empty and If it's the first town it has too much.
6.5/10

Tsk. You's give anything with new tiles 10/10

i think this is a very good map and the tiles look very nice

this is also more then you have done.

you've just made it complected.

Also he sas nothing about it being the first town.

[EarthsVisitor]

@neminoa: Anyways, I am not very fond of the map of Route 345 you made. Same for the town you made. First: Too busy. Then: Too buggy. All you can do is improve the maps rapidly. It's nice to let your ego grow on people who don't see a good map very often, but if you really want some improvement, you need some constructive criticsm and so I am here.
4/10

Don't get too elitist, Martin2.
Everyone is held to their own opinion, so what you might think is a good map, I might think differently.
You make it sound like everyone else's opinion doesn't matter, and that we all don't know what we're talking about, or are unexperienced.
:/

Nevertheless

Neminoa: Route 345
Nowhere near as good as your last town map.
The grass is too organized and in very random spots.
The map itself is very unorganized, and has alot of meaningless areas.
The rock sculpture is not good.
Still have tiles error, especially the tip of every mountain, it shouldn't be a mountain tile, it's a grass tile with a brown strip on the top of it.
5.5/10

[cε׀׀]

here's a map I've been making. I think it's quite nice but that's just my opinion
pleas tell me what I did wrong or what I could improve!
http://img158.imageshack.us/img158/7608/mountainspass2ei6.png
Good I like the use of the mountain blocks and the pals and mountain tile look great. But I could see some minor errors so be carefull. 8/10
Incredible! Extremly well done, mabye a bit too much grass, but overall
FANTASTIC! 9/10
Oh, forgot:
Map Name:Route 345
Map Game:Firered.
COmments: The route after Mondercose, rate please.
http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z227/ataylan/Route345.png
Its a fairly good map, I like the pathways used, but like before you didnt use the top part of the mountain tile and there are a few errors I could spot out.
7/10

~Celebi

[thethethethe]

I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map.
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/mapping.png

[Blazichu]

I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map.
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/mapping.png

I don't mind this map, maybe change the grass seeing as it is a DP sort of style and with the house with the bridge. Fix that up so that it is only cliff stairs, the bridge makes it appear strange and also behind that house add some floor grass so it appears that the floor grass goes from front to back.

My Rating is a 8/10.

[Nytkoi]

I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map.
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/mapping.png
That looks pretty good. I think it it gets 8.5/10

[cε׀׀]

I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map.
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/mapping.png

The different tiles are scattered everywhere. Ohwell overall i like your map. Its not square and I could not spot many errors but you used the wrong tile for the top of the mountain there.
Else I think its a very good try.
8/10

~Celebi

[强有力]

Got bored, made a map. Changed the lightness of the pallette, and the actual pallette.
Rate please
Map Name: West Canyon
Info: Have to go through a series of caves to get to the other end.
Map: http://img87.imageshack.us/img87/5200/westcanyontr3.gif

[Infernal Contraption]

Got bored, made a map. Changed the lightness of the pallette, and the actual pallette.
Rate please
Map Name: West Canyon
Info: Have to go through a series of caves to get to the other end.
Map: http://img87.imageshack.us/img87/5200/westcanyontr3.gifI don't see any mistakes, Raeden. Keep up your mapping, it's great!

9/10.

Here's a map I created. Actually, it's the first I ever put up here to be rated. And I won't spoil you with what it is... okay, I'll give you a hint: It's the first city in one of the Pokemon games that have only 4 cities in it...

http://img515.imageshack.us/img515/5827/map01rd7.png

[Nytkoi]

I don't see any mistakes, Raeden. Keep up your mapping, it's great!

9/10.

Here's a map I created. Actually, it's the first I ever put up here to be rated. And I won't spoil you with what it is... okay, I'll give you a hint: It's the first city in one of the Pokemon games that have only 4 cities in it...

http://img515.imageshack.us/img515/5827/map01rd7.png

Well, Its pretty plain, and the orange roffed house, the mountain on the back of it,
that is not the right mountain tile. Put more house and details. Its pretty good besides all that. 6.8/10

[Infernal Contraption]

Well, Its pretty plain, and the orange roffed house, the mountain on the back of it,
that is not the right mountain tile. Put more house and details. Its pretty good besides all that. 6.8/10Well, it's a remake of another game so blame Nintendo lol.
And the back of the orange house, the mountain on the back comes with the tile, so it's not my fault.

[cooley]

Incredible! Extremly well done, mabye a bit too much grass, but overall
FANTASTIC! 9/10
Oh, forgot:
Map Name:Route 345
Map Game:Firered.
COmments: The route after Mondercose, rate please.
http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z227/ataylan/Route345.png
Neminoa, I like your maps, but they have to many mistakes. Revise and edit your maps before you post them.

Overall 8/10 for look.
10/10 for difficulty of getting through
5/10 for mistakes

[destinedjagold]

I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map.
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/mapping.png

Wow, thethethethe, I really like the map. Also, I do tend to fall in love with blue flowers. :D 9/10

I love the trees also and the placements of the houses. ;)

Btw, a small tile error on the mountain edges...

[suoert]

I felt a bit bored so I decided to make a map
Name: ???
Game: Fire-Red
Additional Comments: It's a bit big so it's in the spoiler. It's nothing special, just a random map I decided to make. It only took me about an hour.
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z24/thethethethe_photo/mapping.png

That is a really cool map, but there are some things i didn't like, like those little round bushes, and the fact that there are so many different colors of buildings i just don't like that. but that's just my opinion, other than that a great map 9/10

and also here is a new map from me.. http://img127.imageshack.us/img127/9466/viewsidekd3.png

[destinedjagold]

Simply amazing! I love the new looks of both PC and PKMN Mart! 9/10

[cove_2007]

and also here is a new map from me.. http://img127.imageshack.us/img127/9466/viewsidekd3.png

cool map its definately a 9/10 if not 9.999999999999999/10

[cε׀׀]

Wow that map is amazingly done!
And OMG I love the pokemart and PC!
Its simply amazing.
10/10

~Celebi

[~!Fuddmeyer!~]

Map Name: New Bark Town

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: It's for my Silver Remake, please do not steal it.

Mapshot: http://i13.tinypic.com/721gx10.jpg

[Zanacross]

not another silver remake

its the same as every other silver remake

try to make it diffrent and i may rate it.

[~!Fuddmeyer!~]

More media for my Silver Remake:

It's big so click the spoiler:

http://i16.tinypic.com/6jotbbk.jpg

[Martin™]

It misses out some Pokémon grass... and the normal grass is too unnaturally placed... and the map lost its cuteness of the GBC ages... 6/10. Sorry. I think this could be done nicer.

[Zanacross]

like i said befor i wont rate your maps until u go away from the silver remake idea. we have a silver remake all ready

We dont need another one

why dont ou make a map from scratch like other hackers

[~!Fuddmeyer!~]

People started flaming me for doing a Silver Remake: So here is my first real map. It might be a town in my first official hack, but I'm not sure.

http://i1.tinypic.com/72u3nl5.png

[destinedjagold]

Well, it is really a good map to start in thy hack, RH. :)
But the bushes and the flowers on the uper-right corner of your map is kinda, disturbing...
Btw, if it's a town, maybe you could add at least one more doorless house. But I don't know. It is just my idea, btw.

Oh, almost forgot... 8/10... You could change the tiles to make it look very interesting. :D


Ok, it's my turn. In the spoiler is where my new map is. I wanna know about what you think about it. Thanks in advance. I present to you, Green Valley...
http://i226.photobucket.com/albums/dd210/darkjagold/greenvalley2.png

[Erimgard]

destinedjagold:
looks pretty good
suggestions:
Change up the ground a little bit. put a little more variation. there's just too much of that green tile
Also the map seems a tad to squared...to perfect looking, ya know?

anyway, solid map. 8/10

[cε׀׀]

People started flaming me for doing a Silver Remake: So here is my first real map. It might be a town in my first official hack, but I'm not sure.

http://i1.tinypic.com/72u3nl5.png
Meh...I think its too much of a square.
Note: Dont make maps like totally squares(that i hate)
Anyways I think its really good and simple. Good use of the lighter patches of grass there.
7.5/10

Well, it is really a good map to start in thy hack, RH. :)
But the bushes and the flowers on the uper-right corner of your map is kinda, disturbing...
Btw, if it's a town, maybe you could add at least one more doorless house. But I don't know. It is just my idea, btw.

Oh, almost forgot... 8/10... You could change the tiles to make it look very interesting. :D


Ok, it's my turn. In the spoiler is where my new map is. I wanna know about what you think about it. Thanks in advance. I present to you, Green Valley...
http://i226.photobucket.com/albums/dd210/darkjagold/greenvalley2.png
I think its a really good map, I think the connections of the tunnels are well made. Aside from that, I really like the tiles.
It gets a solid rating of: 9/10

~Celebi

[~!Fuddmeyer!~]

My new map:

http://i12.tinypic.com/8fmiq95.png

I'm really proud of this map. It is the Route that connects at the bottom exit of my previous town. It will be full of trainers. Inside the lone house is a guy that will heal your Pokemon. Rate please.

[destinedjagold]

Thanks for the ratings, guys!

@ pokemonhacker9507,
It looks okay, but you could add some level 2 mountains on those mountains of yours...
Anyways, 8/10

I want my SIDE PATH to be rated! :D
This map is already accessable in Beta 2. Here it is...
http://i226.photobucket.com/albums/dd210/darkjagold/sidepath2.png
Thanks!

[~!Fuddmeyer!~]

Here is another new map!

I think it's my best yet. Also I added grass to the other route map.

http://i19.tinypic.com/6x99oap.png

Now I need to map the starter town and remap my first town.

@ DJG: Love the map! I like the placement of the trees. 10/10

[cε׀׀]

Here is another new map!

I think it's my best yet. Also I added grass to the other route map.

http://i19.tinypic.com/6x99oap.png

Now I need to map the starter town and remap my first town.

@ DJG: Love the map! I like the placement of the trees. 10/10
I like the map. It shows lots of pathways(which I like)
But I saw some errors there:D Anyways its a good map.
7/10

Thanks for the ratings, guys!

@ pokemonhacker9507,
It looks okay, but you could add some level 2 mountains on those mountains of yours...
Anyways, 8/10

I want my SIDE PATH to be rated! :D
This map is already accessable in Beta 2. Here it is...
http://i226.photobucket.com/albums/dd210/darkjagold/sidepath2.png
Thanks!
OMG You always make big maps :D
Anyways I love the map. Its sorta like a seaside jungle.
I like the pathways and placement of trees.
9/10

~Celebi

[~!Fuddmeyer!~]

@ Celebi_XD: Oh.. Where are the errors so I can correct them?

Anyways: Here is the revamped version of my first town.

http://i14.tinypic.com/8ejh2d4.png

[Mimey]

To be honest, I'm not impressed.. There are to many hedges and it's kinda empty...

6/10

[Zanacross]

This new map is alot better mab need a bit more grass

7/10

[rkevinc1]

Map name: Ashes town

Map game: Firered

Comments:Made as the starter town, basically a new improved pallet town (hopefully) don't know how to edit palettes so please do not moan about those. The rock will be for a later legendary event (Raikou)

http://http://img259.imageshack.us/img259/3720/communityteamus6.th.png (http://img259.imageshack.us/my.php?image=communityteamus6.png)

[cε׀׀]

@ Celebi_XD: Oh.. Where are the errors so I can correct them?

Anyways: Here is the revamped version of my first town.

http://i14.tinypic.com/8ejh2d4.png

I didn't mean like those kind of errors. I just meant that you need to tile your tiles properly. And try not to make a map totally square. You need to try placing the trees in different shapes so the map looks original.
________________________________________________
This map:
I think the map is too square, look above for advice;)
Apart from that I think its plain abit but I like the use of licghter patches of grass there. And it would be better if you add alot of creativity into you're maps so that the