View Full Version : May vs. Dawn--Who's Better
Crystal Hikari
August 9th, 2007, 10:17 PM
A battle can be between anything. But today we're focusing on the Pokemon anime and two powerful Trainers (In their own right)May and Dawn. So, who's better ? Right now, I like Dawn, since I haven't seen May since the end of the Battle Frontier and Dawn's seems better
Dr.Stiles
August 9th, 2007, 10:19 PM
ooooooh this is hard i like may cuz she has eevee squirtle bulbasuar but i like dawn cuz of buneary piplup and pachirisu
hmmm...i like them both equally lol but if dawn were to get an eevee shed be my fav
Always and Never
August 9th, 2007, 10:29 PM
Hikari is hot <33
May is absolutely disgusting.
Even though Hikari is 10 years old, she'll always have a special place in my heart.
Crystal Hikari
August 9th, 2007, 10:42 PM
Okay then, please vote ! And anyone else can post their opinions, too !
Platypus234
August 9th, 2007, 10:46 PM
Seeing how Dawn is just a rehash of May, May wins.
Dr.Stiles
August 9th, 2007, 10:48 PM
Seeing how Dawn is just a rehash of May, May wins.
yah i think so too i voted for may also :D
offtopic but does anyone have animal crossing?
Kenji~
August 9th, 2007, 11:11 PM
I'll have to go with Dawn. Because of May, that little... thing was brought to the anime. I shall never forgive her.
Dawn didn't bring any useless or annoying characters with her, so I like her. xD
Plus, she's just more entertaining than May ever was.
Dr.Stiles
August 9th, 2007, 11:16 PM
I'll have to go with Dawn. Because of May, that little... thing was brought to the anime. I shall never forgive her.
Dawn didn't bring any useless or annoying characters with her, so I like her. xD
Plus, she's just more entertaining than May ever was.
oh yah i forgot may had to bring her little bro with her now im thinking of going on dawns side lol
Crystal Hikari
August 9th, 2007, 11:21 PM
NOTE: May wasn't planned on being a main character when Ash went through Hoenn. It might have been Ash, Brock and Max
Random
August 9th, 2007, 11:29 PM
i think Dawn looks awesome, though with May i didnt like that much, especially her little bro.
Haruka Chan
August 10th, 2007, 12:04 AM
May 100%!
She was first. And Dawn is pretty much just a clone of her. But people act like Dawn is the most perfect thing. Plus..Dawn is pissing me off because she is getting way too much spotlight.
May. Always May. <33
Chaolin
August 10th, 2007, 12:56 AM
Dawn is too stupid for me to like her. May actually used her head every now and then. May wins my vote. :3
Crystal Hikari
August 10th, 2007, 12:57 AM
You're just jealous that Dawn's now in the anime while May isn't (I'm sorry if it offended you)
Me2UJus4Free
August 10th, 2007, 02:08 AM
I like Dawn's outfit, but the outfit can do without her. May had a cute, practical outfit with pants. Dawn wears a little tiny, itty-bitty skirt. May wears pants. Dawn is clone of May, May is a clone of Misty. Therefor, I like Misty better. =)
Haruki Hanai
August 10th, 2007, 11:27 AM
I prefer girls wearing spandex over short pink skirts, though I do like Dawn. I was just very used to May, though, and the klutz personality she had when she started out. She's a better "novice representation" than Dawn was, right now do her at-first secret ambition to become a contest coordinator. Plus, I like May's bandana and overall design. (And maybe her Emerald one too.) DX
Honey-Senpai
August 10th, 2007, 11:56 AM
I don't like Dawn's hat...
Plus, May is very hot in some perspectives, for a Anime girl..
So, May's better.
Waaaai~
~Honey-Senpai~
Vavavoom ♣
August 10th, 2007, 12:05 PM
I prefer Dawn. She is more cute and adorable. However, I don't like that she already caught 4 Pokemon. ~
Shiraishi
August 10th, 2007, 12:24 PM
I like itty bitty pink skirts >_>
Crystal Hikari
August 10th, 2007, 01:14 PM
Well, the reason why I don't like May anymore: HER VOICE !
In the Battle Frontier, they made May sound like a mom, making her older than she seems, but Dawn's voice was high when I first heard, but now I'm used to it
Kayashi
August 10th, 2007, 03:49 PM
I think Jessie's and May's vocals wer the same person.
Anyways, I like Dawn cuz she is hot.
Ryuuji
August 10th, 2007, 04:05 PM
I like Dawn's outfit, but the outfit can do without her. May had a cute, practical outfit with pants. Dawn wears a little tiny, itty-bitty skirt. May wears pants. Dawn is clone of May, May is a clone of Misty. Therefor, I like Misty better. =)
Agreed, Misty 100%...xD
Well, I prefer Dawn, May isn't appealing as Sapphire in The Pokemon Manga,
Even though Miss Berlitz isn't much appealing as Dawn..BUT THIS IS THE POKEMON TV AND MOVIES FORUm, So yeah, I choose Dawn not because she's hot cause she's the 1st Complanion of Ash who loves battling AND Loves Contest
Well I dunno about teh 1st one but She's great at battling, May is just a Contest Girl
Kayashi
August 10th, 2007, 04:14 PM
who's Miss Berlitz???
filler
Bebetrunks
August 10th, 2007, 04:14 PM
Dawn, she is far more talented at the moment and caught on to things with lightning speed. May wasn't very talented at all.
SilencedShooter
August 10th, 2007, 04:16 PM
Misty is better than both...
And I'll make my decision on May and Dawn if they ever end up in a contest together.
(I hate Max with a passion)
Jordan
August 10th, 2007, 05:24 PM
Arghh. Remember kids, they're 10 years old (at least when they first start). I don't like either, really. *braces self for beating* I agree with orange man.
Jordan.
Rick TH
August 10th, 2007, 05:33 PM
Well, Misty is the coolest and best of them all. But, if I really had to choose between the two. I think it would be May.
It really is difficult to choose, seeing as they both started off as clumsy beginners with no idea as to how to batttle.
That's all I have to say about it.
Manaphy1128
August 10th, 2007, 05:41 PM
Not a hard choice for me..
I vote May. May is, or has, better charecter personality or design. She isn't as streotypical as I think Dawn
joyce : the fluffy pirate~
August 10th, 2007, 05:46 PM
I'll vote Dawn. Untill the day now I've always wondered how that they possible come up with may her.. haircut T-T
but.. I see Dawn more as a FireRed/LeafGreen-Girl clone. I mean, the hat? & the skirt? It's just practically the same o_o
It's such a pity that they didn't brought her into the anime. I would definitly vote for her then..
Shinji_
August 10th, 2007, 11:38 PM
I think May xD, May has WAY more experience and Dawns pokemon are 2nd rate T_T Meaning they're bad compared to Mays Maybe 1on1 Dawn would win if her darn Piplup evolved xD
Brock_Lee
August 11th, 2007, 01:28 AM
May is definately da cooliest!
G14c30n
August 11th, 2007, 01:36 AM
Dawn is the sexiest of all. I will have her if she's ever real. NO ONE ELSE WILL WIN HER OVER! D=
Pikachu2007
August 11th, 2007, 04:08 AM
I like both of them. They're all have very good personalities (which I find attractive in both cartoons and real people), and they're voices are pretty. Dawn's, to me, sounds a LOT better in the English dub than the Japanese version. But Misty's my fav.
Crystal Hikari
August 11th, 2007, 11:19 AM
Dawn's Pilup will evolve in Sinnoh like Ash's Aipom, I know how many people say Piplup won't evolve it will lose it's bratty attitude, but when a Pokemon evolves it keeps it's attitude in check, so Piplup, Aipom, Buneary, Turtwig and Buziel, they'll all evolve. And when Piplup evolves into Empoleon, Dawn has the chance to beat May, which she will
SilencedShooter
August 11th, 2007, 03:31 PM
How can you be so sure Dawn would beat May? The anime seems to support pokemon with a type disadvantage winning, so I wouldn't be surprised to see Blaziken beat Empoleon...But hey Dawn could win too, there's no telling.
Jordan
August 11th, 2007, 04:30 PM
Actually Blaziken has a type advantage. Fire inflicts normal damage, and fighting inflicts double damage to Empleon. Empoleon also has a type advantage against Blaze but Blaziken gets a net win.
Jordan>
SilencedShooter
August 11th, 2007, 04:49 PM
See that's why I chose Treecko.I like Pokemon with only 1 type, I hate double weaknesses.
Soari
August 11th, 2007, 05:09 PM
I would Prefer May she's much better than Dawn (hikari) Hikari is cute too But I like May more <3
Me2UJus4Free
August 11th, 2007, 09:37 PM
See that's why I chose Treecko.I like Pokemon with only 1 type, I hate double weaknesses.
Keep in mind that most double type Pokemon have their advantages, too. Swampert for example, only has weakness and that's grass. Being part ground type, it's resistant to electric attacks.
/ Off topic.
In a battle between Dawn and may, May would win.
yoshikiller995
August 12th, 2007, 01:19 AM
Misty, she just kicks total butt.
If they do, do more seasons with Ash, there should be a starting trainer who is a boy and then Misty should join up with them.
Crystal Hikari
August 12th, 2007, 11:30 AM
We're not talking about Misty, only May and Dawn, as far as I'm concerened, she's long gone from coming back for another region, but she'll be doing cameos
Z!$H!
August 12th, 2007, 02:31 PM
Dawn rocks she should be ash's new house wife
SilencedShooter
August 12th, 2007, 05:52 PM
Lol, Ahs's NEW wife?
Have I missed a few episodes are something?Ha.
Akio123
August 12th, 2007, 05:58 PM
We're not talking about Misty, only May and Dawn, as far as I'm concerened, she's long gone from coming back for another region, but she'll be doing cameos
Her seiyuu said in her blog because due to fans she maybe coming abck permently.
Chibaymega12
August 12th, 2007, 09:34 PM
sorry, but Dawn is a talentless, patentialess n00b
I've watched her train, and her contests, she says she's doing "combonations", even though she's doing one move 0.o she has no talent in the appeal. Though, she has come up with some nifty battle strategies, whereas that's where may lacks
may though, has a very good appeal patential, her combos amaze me, and the way she uses her knowledge of her pokemons likes and dislikes on the spot to make a great appeal is great! She lacks in battling, she tries to show off her pokemons appeal a bit too much in most of her battles, and when she tried to fix it, she ended up over powering it a bit and losing points, she needs to find a healthy median between the two, like Dawn already has.
if they were to use fusion ear rings from DBZ, they'd be a great kick ass Co ordinator!
Random
August 12th, 2007, 09:38 PM
if they were to use fusion ear rings from DBZ, they'd be a great kick ass Co ordinator!
lets see Dawn and May fused to together, make... "Mawn" what a silly thought :P
thats your coordinator chibay ^-^'
Chibaymega12
August 12th, 2007, 09:49 PM
xD, tahts funny, i didn't think about the names combined, it could be Day too!
Z!$H!
August 13th, 2007, 05:12 AM
sorry, but Dawn is a talentless, patentialess n00b
I've watched her train, and her contests, she says she's doing "combonations", even though she's doing one move 0.o she has no talent in the appeal. Though, she has come up with some nifty battle strategies, whereas that's where may lacks
may though, has a very good appeal patential, her combos amaze me, and the way she uses her knowledge of her pokemons likes and dislikes on the spot to make a great appeal is great! She lacks in battling, she tries to show off her pokemons appeal a bit too much in most of her battles, and when she tried to fix it, she ended up over powering it a bit and losing points, she needs to find a healthy median between the two, like Dawn already has.
if they were to use fusion ear rings from DBZ, they'd be a great kick ass Co ordinator!
Yeah she is a noob but cute and smart she will be ash's new house wife
Random
August 13th, 2007, 05:17 AM
Yeah she is a noob but cute and smart she will be ash's new house wife
LOL, maybe thats going a little too far into the anime. >.<'
You can only dream :laugh:
Plus as the series goes, she wont be a n00b anymore, and yes i do admit she is a lot smarter then she appears.
Z!$H!
August 13th, 2007, 05:21 AM
LOL, maybe thats going a little too far into the anime. >.<'
You can only dream :laugh:
Plus as the series goes, she wont be a n00b anymore, and yes i do admit she is a lot smarter then she appears.
Than we have to request cartoon makers to make her ash's house wife
SilencedShooter
August 13th, 2007, 05:32 AM
Than we have to request cartoon makers to make her ash's house wife
why do you keep saying housewife?
Z!$H!
August 13th, 2007, 05:38 AM
why do you keep saying housewife?
Cause they are made for each others
Shiraishi
August 13th, 2007, 06:43 AM
Yea, shouldn't they be celebs like Marina on the magazine cover?
Me2UJus4Free
August 13th, 2007, 11:15 AM
Cause they are made for each others
That doesn't make any sense.
Crystal Hikari
August 13th, 2007, 01:21 PM
If Dawn and Ash decide to marry Dawn WON'T be a housewife, she'll be doing what she loves--traveling around Kanto (or Sinnoh or wherever they decide to live) being a roving Coordinator. Dawn'll win maybe two Ribbon Cups and maybe pair up with her "husband" and win one as a couple. But, hey this is all in my imagination....
Mikefox124
August 13th, 2007, 07:25 PM
If Dawn and Ash decide to marry Dawn WON'T be a housewife, she'll be doing what she loves--traveling around Kanto (or Sinnoh or wherever they decide to live) being a roving Coordinator. Dawn'll win maybe two Ribbon Cups and maybe pair up with her "husband" and win one as a couple. But, hey this is all in my imagination....
Dawn's...10.
May's...also 10.
iRaiza
August 13th, 2007, 08:03 PM
Dawn, so much cuter than May. I even use her in Diamond and Pearl ^.^
EeveePkmnMaster
August 13th, 2007, 09:12 PM
I may not be bi, but Dawn is cuter indeed. Even though May uses two pokemon Ireally like. it has to be Dawn, she's more animated, funnier and more of spirit!!
Chelc
August 13th, 2007, 10:00 PM
My vote goes to May. She was the first female protagonist from the games to travel with Ash, and she introduced Contests to the show, which gave us something else to watch besides Gym Battles. Plus, her rivals rocked (and she had a canon shipping with one of those rivals, too ;)) and she had awesome character development. <3
Dawn just doesn't interest me at all. Her whole storyline is just plain boring, imo. I think it'd be better if she wasn't a coordinator, cuz all she has going for her is being more girly than Misty or May, and her pokemon and their awesome personalities. Even her rivals are pretty much boring. :/ Yeah - I don't hate her or anything, but she could definitely be more interesting.
Mastermind
August 14th, 2007, 07:26 PM
When it comes to estetics, I think Dawn would come first, May's hair was horrible, I wondered why it was short in back and long in the front, even without the bandana... Dawn's hair is better, and girls with skirts make me laugh. When it comes to attitude, I attached myself to May more than anything. Like it was previously said, I would have preferred seeing the girl from Pokemon Leaf Green. I like her appearance better than the two otehrs. And I never really liked Misty, I was so happy to see her replaced by May.
Jorah
August 14th, 2007, 08:46 PM
Dawn. May was rather irritating at the start. I don't think Dawn and May are exactly like each other, otherwise I would like them both exactly the same. There is some difference, I'm just not sure. Dawn is more confident in herself and is much more "get up and go" or whatever the saying is. I like May, I just like Dawn more.
I don't understand how May is like Misty though...Misty (in Kanto, before her personality died) was rather tempermental, wouldn't be afraid to argue her point, a bit of a tom-boy and loves water Pokemon. May at the start didn't like Pokemon at all but came to like them. She just kind of liked cute Pokemon, liked shopping and was more girly and could be rather whiney at times. She had character development and became a confident co-ordinator. So I don't know what kind of character development Dawn is going to have.
Crystal Clair
August 15th, 2007, 05:13 AM
I personally like Hikari a lot more than May.
DP is my favorite era (along with Johto). AG is my least favorite era. And part of what made DP nice was Hikari.
About Hikari's girlyiness, it's girly-ness done right. And I love her skirt, it looks like something from out of Mario (the pleats remind me of flower petals)! And Hikari has very pretty hair.
I'm content now with Hikari and with the show right now. Better animators would be nice though... along with some more Shinji and no Gary.
btw - the only thing I hate about Hikari is IkariShipping. If any Pokemon character goes with Shinji it's Ash. Besides IMO it gets the cutest hints in the show now (Shirona episode).
I still love Misty and she still holds a place in my heart but I know had Hikari been the first girl and Misty the newest, I would like Hikari better.
Me2UJus4Free
August 15th, 2007, 12:00 PM
btw - the only thing I hate about Hikari is IkariShipping. If any Pokemon character goes with Shinji it's Ash. Besides IMO it gets the cutest hints in the show now (Shirona episode).
Ash/Paul (Hehe... Paul).
And who May was anything like Misty. Misty feisty and May was not. It's so obvious!
I don't like Dawn's hair. It baffles me more than May's. Just how do you get clipped sideburns and a ponytail?
Crystal Hikari
August 15th, 2007, 01:00 PM
I don't like Dawn's hair. It baffles me more than May's. Just how do you get clipped sideburns and a ponytail?
Look at it ! She has it mostly in the back, (no ponytail !) clipped up by two yellow hair clips !
http://content.answers.com/main/content/wp/en/thumb/2/20/160px-DP-Hikari.png
Me2UJus4Free
August 15th, 2007, 01:11 PM
Look at it ! She has it mostly in the back, (no ponytail !) clipped up by two yellow hair clips !
She does too have a ponytail, and stop image leeching! Answers.com does not pay bandwidth each month just so you can leech off their site.
http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y287/ME2UJus4Free/dptrba002.png
See, she has an unusual amount of hair that's thick and ponytail/clipped sideburns.
Pkmn Trainer Alex
August 15th, 2007, 01:17 PM
I'll go with Hikari/Dawn because it took the D/P Generation games and Hikari to get me back into Pokémon as much as I am now. XD Oh, and May annoys me somehow. Especially whenever I see the Manaphy movie on TV...just, ow. x_x
Basically, I feel that Hikari adds a certain flair to the show that Haruka didn't have. And that same feeling had been missing ever since Misty had gone away, so...Oh yea! Max too. Don't like him. Thinks he's all special. Getting his own storylines like he were actually important. Blah.
Crystal Hikari
August 15th, 2007, 01:35 PM
Max wasn't important, he shouldn't have been on the show, he tanked most of May's popluarity beacuse he was so annoying and just so smart, like he knew everything, I don't like those people. and I don't like Max. At least Dawn/Hikari didn't bring an annoying little brother/sister on the show
Jim
August 15th, 2007, 10:38 PM
Dawn has more character than May as more episodes focus around Dawn, but saying that Dawn is a clone of May of sorts so I'm pretty much undecided... I hope in the next season -if there's a next season- that the gang should be: Ash, Misty/May/Dawn and then the Male character from that generation. Something new besides contests and Gym battles for the Male and then May/Dawn would be entering contests or if it's Misty then she can perhaps enter contests or something... Also Pachirisu is godly but that's besides the point. (I just realised how offtopic my post is x3)
Waffle-San
August 15th, 2007, 11:44 PM
May obviously I'll explain later when I have more time.
STM
August 16th, 2007, 07:18 AM
Well, while May wasn't good at first she became very talented, plus she has my favorite Pokemon, Squirtle. Plus she's really cute when shes crying "sad" but true. Although the fact that she brought max into the anime, god it makes me shiver sometimes, but its funny to watch him cry lol. May's cute when she's crying Max isn't, but it sure is funny to watch. So in a way I guess I'm glad about Max. Anyway this is about May, she's a great coordinator, I used to.....yeah to her I know she's only 10, I'm 13, its only a 3 year difference but still, yeah its wrong, I was a hardcore pervert back then, now I do the thing I used to do to May to Tsunade from Naruto she is UBER HAWT. Anyway, I prefer May over Dawn anyway. And the person who said everyone's Pokemon is evolving (cept Pikachu of course), I don't think Turtwig is gonna evolve, if you wanna know why, just go on YouTube and type in Paul vs Cynthia.
Myoko-chan
August 16th, 2007, 07:44 AM
Hikari is smarter IMO.
She actually suggested Ash to use his old pokemon from the older seasons instead of using the team he has now to beat Roark.
But Ash had to be dumb and say no...I mean, he could've used his Corphish or Chikorita or something.
May is dumb.
She keeps trusting Harley or whatever his name is(the guy in the cacturne suit...or woman) after all the times he(or she) lied to her about the contests.
Me2UJus4Free
August 16th, 2007, 07:58 AM
Hikari is smarter IMO.
She actually suggested Ash to use his old pokemon from the older seasons instead of using the team he has now to beat Roark.
But Ash had to be dumb and say no...I mean, he could've used his Corphish or Chikorita or something.
May is dumb.
She keeps trusting Harley or whatever his name is(the guy in the cacturne suit...or woman) after all the times he(or she) lied to her about the contests.
I fail to see how that makes Dawn smarter and May dumber. May would have given Ash the same advice, and Dawn would have trusted Harley as well. The guy's sneaky... and a crossdresser.
Crystal Hikari
August 16th, 2007, 01:31 PM
Harley, the guy's sneaky... and a crossdresser.
That's why I hate Harley. I just like to think he's a Pokemon like Magenton, with no gender, even though it's clearly obivious he's a male
SilencedShooter
August 16th, 2007, 04:19 PM
Well, while May wasn't good at first she became very talented, plus she has my favorite Pokemon, Squirtle. Plus she's really cute when shes crying "sad" but true. Although the fact that she brought max into the anime, god it makes me shiver sometimes, but its funny to watch him cry lol. May's cute when she's crying Max isn't, but it sure is funny to watch. So in a way I guess I'm glad about Max. Anyway this is about May, she's a great coordinator, I used to.....yeah to her I know she's only 10, I'm 13, its only a 3 year difference but still, yeah its wrong, I was a hardcore pervert back then, now I do the thing I used to do to May to Tsunade from Naruto she is UBER HAWT. Anyway, I prefer May over Dawn anyway. And the person who said everyone's Pokemon is evolving (cept Pikachu of course), I don't think Turtwig is gonna evolve, if you wanna know why, just go on YouTube and type in Paul vs Cynthia.
Yeah bro....you don't wanna say things like that.
Chelc
August 16th, 2007, 04:25 PM
Hikari is smarter IMO.
She actually suggested Ash to use his old pokemon from the older seasons instead of using the team he has now to beat Roark.
But Ash had to be dumb and say no...I mean, he could've used his Corphish or Chikorita or something.
May is dumb.
She keeps trusting Harley or whatever his name is(the guy in the cacturne suit...or woman) after all the times he(or she) lied to her about the contests.
Ash wasn't dumb - he knew it was a good idea, but he didn't want to use any pokemon from the previous regions, because you know how Ash is all about using his current team no matter what. I don't see how that makes Dawn "smart," because like Me2UJus4Free said, May (heck, anyone probably would have) suggested the same thing to him.
May's not dumb, either - she's 10-years-old, of course she's going to trust him at first. Everyone has trusted someone that they shouldn't have at some point in their lives. Not trusting Harley was a huge part of development for her character as well.
As for Harley, come on - sure he's pretty creepy, but we love him for it! ;P *shot*
SilencedShooter
August 16th, 2007, 04:33 PM
Nobody likes Harley.....I'll take my flamboyant characterness with James thank you.
Jorah
August 16th, 2007, 08:14 PM
Who said about Harley and crossdressing? James used to all the time. Wonder why he doesn't now, it was so funny. I thought Harley was hilarious, at one point he was one of my favourite characters. When I got back into Pokemon somewhere around Advanced Battle I actually had to ask whether he was a man or woman XD
Darkrai_Enterprises
August 16th, 2007, 08:36 PM
May is a piece of turd. Dawn is smarter,cute,and doesn't have a rag doll for a brother. What more can you ask for? Dawn is perfect in my eyes. Thats says alot coming from me because I have great taste.
Crystal Hikari
August 16th, 2007, 11:06 PM
Dawn is perfect in my eyes. Thats says alot coming from me because I have great taste.
Okay, well the reasons I like Dawn beacuse well I just like how she dresses (not comment on her mini-skirt). She's the Sinnoh girl, and I think she mops the floor with May. Dawn rules, May drools, end of story
Haruka Chan
August 16th, 2007, 11:39 PM
Okay, well the reasons I like Dawn beacuse well I just like how she dresses (not comment on her mini-skirt). She's the Sinnoh girl, and I think she mops the floor with May. Dawn rules, May drools, end of story
Ok. One question. Why the hell are you even in the May club if you're insulting her?
And about the whole May/Dawn intelligence thing. I think May is smarter than Dawn. Yes, May USED to be very ditsy and clumsy. But every girl has those moments. But Dawn just seems really, uh, 'slowish' to me. Wasn't it her who didn't know how to open a pokeball? And then she did that 'OMIGOSH!' gasp thing. Dawn just has that certain thing to her personality. She just reminds me of one of those extreme stupid preppy girls. xD;
And you know Dawn would fall for Harley's tricks as easy as May did.
Charaxes
August 17th, 2007, 01:13 AM
Keep it respectable, people. Anyway, the big difference with May/Dawn is confidence and outlook. But they're interesting in their respective way. Although, personally, I'll go with May because of her realistic neurosis and Dawn is too obnoxious for my tastes.
precita
August 17th, 2007, 02:46 AM
May is a piece of turd. Dawn is smarter,cute,and doesn't have a rag doll for a brother. What more can you ask for? Dawn is perfect in my eyes. Thats says alot coming from me because I have great taste.
You have great taste with an opinion like that? God forbid.
I really like both of them, with May just *slightly* more than Dawn since she brought Contests to the show, whereas Dawn simply repeats the Contest/coordinator storyline. She's still a very, very fun character though.
Both of them in general make Misty look so bland in comparison.
fattyeater
August 17th, 2007, 02:52 PM
may and dawn are both vary bad as characters.but it`s a fight about whos better.i really dont care about this all i want to get is a reponse.simple.may is better then dawn.answer:because i can`t see any character in any anime i go by looks bottom line dawn dresses like a h*****(i know saying this here will get me kicked out)and may dresses much better and max i just want to get a gigatic blender and stuff him in it.....wahts the may club?
Crystal Hikari
August 17th, 2007, 03:38 PM
Byo, I never realized I opened up a "Pandora's Box" here, lock this thread MOD's, before something bad happens (just to be safe)
Charaxes
August 17th, 2007, 07:44 PM
I'll lock it for a day or so, and let everyone cool off. Bah.
And fattyeater, you're on my list. Glares.
Charaxes
August 20th, 2007, 03:21 AM
Re-opening the thread as I hope everyone has cooled down. One slip, and I re-lock.
Sorry for double post.
Crystal Hikari
August 20th, 2007, 12:34 PM
Thanks again, it's just, I never realized something like this could happen
Leon K. Fox
August 20th, 2007, 12:43 PM
I kinda like Dawn...but I'm not sure just yet...
Misty pwns eiter of them when she isn't being bratty though (or mean, like she was to Caterpie in Episode 3)
dragon 122
August 21st, 2007, 02:50 PM
her bulbasaur
oh and why didnt u add msity to the poll
Crystal Hikari
August 21st, 2007, 03:37 PM
why didnt u add msity to the poll
Beacuse this isn't about Misty, only about May and Dawn !!!
Mikefox124
August 21st, 2007, 04:37 PM
Dunno if I posted, but <3 Hikari/Dawn
Siliva
August 21st, 2007, 05:39 PM
Hmmm. This is a tough one. I really like both of May and Dawn's personalities, Dawn's outfit is definantly cuter, but May's isn't half bad either. So, yeah, I like 'em both, but I voted for Dawn.
Crystal Hikari
August 21st, 2007, 06:21 PM
Dawn's outfit is definantly cuter
Just wondering, is that the only reason why some of you like Dawn beacuse she has a mini-skirt ? I like her beacuse she the best character ever and she has a big road ahead of her and there only one wasy for Dawn to go and that's up
Siliva
August 21st, 2007, 09:52 PM
Just wondering, is that the only reason why some of you like Dawn beacuse she has a mini-skirt ?
Well, that's ONE of my reasons, but it the most obvious one.
GOPgabe
August 21st, 2007, 10:20 PM
Saying you hate Dawn's miniskirt is a slap against god, same for May's tight shirt. I go for chest over legs. Go May!!
ChrisG14
August 22nd, 2007, 01:12 AM
I chose May. I think that most people that hate May only don't like her because she:
1. Was the first on to take Misty's "place" and the sting is still felt.
2. She brought along her little brother, which I guess bothered people even though he didn't do anything and seemed like a newbie for 40 episodes.
3. She was a coordinator, which somehow "took" time away from Ash's Gym Battles.
So they go with Dawn, who they see as less of an usurper to Misty, and a usurper to May. And they get hypnotized by her mini skirt. :laugh:
Daisuke33
August 22nd, 2007, 04:04 AM
I chose May. I think that most people that hate May only don't like her because she:
1. Was the first on to take Misty's "place" and the sting is still felt.
2. She brought along her little brother, which I guess bothered people even though he didn't do anything and seemed like a newbie for 40 episodes.
3. She was a coordinator, which somehow "took" time away from Ash's Gym Battles.
So they go with Dawn, who they see as less of an usurper to Misty, and a usurper to May. And they get hypnotized by her mini skirt. :laugh:
XD I agree. And besides, Misty, May, and Dawn all wear miniskirts! Not much of a difference if you ask me. If their were wearing pants that be a something interesting to discuss. Anyway I picked May because I she has more experence as a coordinator.
And if she and Dawn were in a pokemon battle right now, May would pwn Dawn ( no offense to Dawn fans ) besides May has a Balbasaur, Squirtle, Eevee, a " wall " of a munchlax, Skitty, Beautifly, and omg Blaziken! Dawn currently has: a Piplup, Buneary, Pachrisu, and a Buizel. Now if some of her pokemon were to evolve that yeah dawn might have a chance but in truth May wins. But despite that I still love Dawn, she is sweet, through she can be annoying at times, you got to love her upbeat personality!
Crystal Hikari
August 22nd, 2007, 04:15 PM
May doesn't wear a mini skirt (nor does Misty), Dawn has and will the be only one to wear a mini-skirt
Siliva
August 22nd, 2007, 10:17 PM
May doesn't wear a mini skirt (nor does Misty), Dawn has and will the be only one to wear a mini-skirt
Technically, May DOES wear a miniskirt. But this is not the topic discussing who has a better outfit.
Crystal Hikari
August 22nd, 2007, 11:06 PM
No she doesn't, but yeah you're right, we're done about talking who was the best outfit, but Dawn would win by a mile, IMO
AnimeDDR110
August 23rd, 2007, 01:38 AM
i thought may was always sweeter. everyone saying dawn because shes new.
fattyeater
August 23rd, 2007, 12:11 PM
hey i`am back from pokemon elite 2000 forums.i came to checkup on you guys..............! wow! i never thought i would get such a negitive response to bring the mods into this.sorry for being such a jerk.knew i would get a negitve response but not this NEGITIVE...sorry to all of you....(maybe i had this comming to me)
Crystal Hikari
August 23rd, 2007, 12:24 PM
Well, Dawn to me is way cooler than May. She reminds me of Misty in a couple of ways. I mean she has that cheerful attitude that Misty had. For May, she wasn't all that sweet, bneacuse she would get angry a lot
Siliva
August 23rd, 2007, 06:57 PM
Well, Dawn to me is way cooler than May. She reminds me of Misty in a couple of ways. I mean she has that cheerful attitude that Misty had. For May, she wasn't all that sweet, bneacuse she would get angry a lot
HAVE YOU SEEN the Kanto season? Misty gets angry every other episode. Well, that could be a stretch, but it's a lot nonetheless. It's taking a lot not to turn this topic into a flame war, so I'll just keep it at that.
Crystal Hikari
August 23rd, 2007, 07:00 PM
Let's end that and start another conversation before anyone says something they'll regret. So, please if anyone has a topic, please post it !
Charaxes
August 23rd, 2007, 08:00 PM
Awesome-o. And we can move on.
Here's a discussion: their various Pokemon choices and why. Discuss.
Crystal Hikari
August 23rd, 2007, 08:05 PM
Dawn's Pokemon are all cute, Buziel is her strong one
May's she also likes cute Pokemon, but she has a mix of types
I like Dawn beacuse she has a Pachirisu, no, but I think she has cuter Pokemon
Haruka Chan
August 23rd, 2007, 08:50 PM
May has a nice variety of Pokemon. And I really love the ones she has. Torchic/Combusken/Blazekin is one of my favorite starters. Skitty is my favorite Pokemon. Eevee is another favorite. Her Munchlax was awesome. Her Beautifly was awesome in contests. I didn't care much for Squirtle and Bulbasaur, but I didn't mind them.
The only Pokemon I like of Dawn's are Pacharisu and Buneary. And I don't really like the fact that she has two water Pokemon. I also don't like how she already has 4 Pokemon.
Jorah
August 23rd, 2007, 08:59 PM
They both have "cute" Pokemon and a strong one to make them look as though they're strong. Although Torchic was cute too and rather weak at the start. Misty had Psyduck as a comic relief Pokemon. Her other Pokemon...did nothing. Togepi did nothing until AG except from a few random explosions (lol) Staru/Starmie did nothing and the other was sent away. Or maybe they both were. Oh yeah, I remember. Starmie was really weak in battle and lost EVERY battle it was in. I'm sure. I don't know. Goldeen...did nothing too. She could hardly use a fish on land. Corsola did battle a bit in Master Quest though.
SheiK
August 23rd, 2007, 09:26 PM
Dawn.
She is better overall, and I think much prettier.
Though I think the dress/skirt can be a degenerative quality for her...
Crystal Hikari
August 23rd, 2007, 10:42 PM
Why don't you like Dawn's mini-skirt ? That's the main reason some people like her !
Jordan
August 23rd, 2007, 10:44 PM
Though I think the dress/skirt can be a degenerative quality for her...
That's not what the fan boys says.
Jordan.
EDIT: In after Dawn fan boys.
Crystal Hikari
August 23rd, 2007, 10:57 PM
I say that makes her look good
Pocky
August 24th, 2007, 03:06 AM
I would have to say Dawn. May just seems too into her stupid little contests. Plus, Dawn's MUCH prettier!
Haruka Chan
August 24th, 2007, 05:03 AM
I would have to say Dawn. May just seems too into her stupid little contests. Plus, Dawn's MUCH prettier!
Dude. Dawn does contests too. o_o Plus she dresses up and everything for her contests, that makes her seem way more into them than May did.
Crystal Hikari
August 24th, 2007, 12:35 PM
Dude. Dawn does contests too. o_o Plus she dresses up and everything for her contests, that makes her seem way more into them than May did.
Yeah Dawn dresses up while May doesn't. Yeah, I agree with what Pocky said, you're just jealous, beacuse everyone says Dawn is much prettier than May. Well, THEY'RE TRUE !
AC Coda X
August 24th, 2007, 01:07 PM
Just wondering, is that the only reason why some of you like Dawn beacuse she has a mini-skirt ? I like her beacuse she the best character ever and she has a big road ahead of her and there only one wasy for Dawn to go and that's up
You know, I was asking the same question. 0_o
Actually, that's the reason I don't like Dawn. Any girl who travels through a country on foot while wearing a miniskirt next to a pervert (Brock) and a kid who's probably going through puberty as we speak (Ash) is hiding something. [/Complete Idiocy]
Alright, I admit it, Dawn is just... meh. I didn't really like it that we had two girly-girls in a row. Thinking about it, the only reason she and May are different as far as things go is the measure of confidence, which isn't really defining enough anymore. I was hoping for a completely different character, and I got... well...
Yeah, major letdown. I'll stick with May, thanks, she was there first and she doesn't wear a miniskirt when she's within three feet of Brock. 0_o
By the way, doesn't anyone else think it's strange that Brock has never gone ga-ga over a lead female character?[/Offtopic]
Pkmn Trainer Alex
August 24th, 2007, 02:15 PM
You know, I was asking the same question. 0_o
Actually, that's the reason I don't like Dawn. Any girl who travels through a country on foot while wearing a miniskirt next to a pervert (Brock) and a kid who's probably going through puberty as we speak (Ash) is hiding something. [/Complete Idiocy]
Alright, I admit it, Dawn is just... meh. I didn't really like it that we had two girly-girls in a row. Thinking about it, the only reason she and May are different as far as things go is the measure of confidence, which isn't really defining enough anymore. I was hoping for a completely different character, and I got... well...
Yeah, major letdown. I'll stick with May, thanks, she was there first and she doesn't wear a miniskirt when she's within three feet of Brock. 0_o
By the way, doesn't anyone else think it's strange that Brock has never gone ga-ga over a lead female character?[/Offtopic]
Well, Brock only really likes older women anyway. At the very least, he doesn't go for girls younger than him, which eliminates all three female leads from his radar.
And while May and Dawn are both girlier than, say, Misty, Dawn is the one who actually participates in more girly things, like fashion and hair-care (which was shown with Piplup in one of the earlier episodes). May was generally lacking in such normal tendencies a girl (Edit: lacking the tomboyish qualities Misty has) actually should have.
And as much as people are obsessing over Dawn's skirt, I still think it worse for people to obsess over May's (I have to be careful how I say this) "assets" for a 10-year-old. x_x
Jordan
August 24th, 2007, 02:23 PM
Well, Brock only really likes older women anyway. At the very least, he doesn't go for girls younger than him, which eliminates all three female leads from his radar.
And while May and Dawn are both girlier than, say, Misty, Dawn is the one who actually participates in more girly things, like fashion and hair-care (which was shown with Piplup in one of the earlier episodes). May was generally lacking in such normal tendencies a girl actually should have.
And as much as people are obsessing over Dawn's skirt, I still think it worse for people to obsess over May's (I have to be careful how I say this) "assets" for a 10-year-old. x_x
At the risk of a warning, I would say that is funny. As for Brock, he turned down a chance to hit on the girl with the Gardevoir in the Sinnoh saga. *gasp* I have yet to form an opinion on this.
Jordan.
Crystal Hikari
August 24th, 2007, 02:25 PM
Assests ? What assests ? I don't remeber her having any assests...
AC Coda X
August 24th, 2007, 02:42 PM
Um... *sweatdrops*
Just look closely. And May's "assets" are slightly more forgiveable then Dawn's miniskirt. Dawn can switch that miniskirt for something else any time she wants, but May's obsessive trait is a part of her body. (Although, I suppose she could stop wearing that bikini she randomly posed in during that one episode...)
May was just as girly as Dawn, she was simply girly in personality as opposed to fashion. I prefer personality. Dawn reminds me of those horribly stereotypic girls you always see in children's television who are like "ZOMG I BROKE A NAIL!"
Really, what's up with that? My sisters are just as girly as Dawn, but I've never seen them obsess like she does.
Crystal Hikari
August 24th, 2007, 02:48 PM
The only thing Dawn obessess about is her hair
Chelc
August 24th, 2007, 05:07 PM
Dude, most girls start getting their "assets" when they're about ~9 or 10 anyway, so I don't see what the big deal is about May's. As the show went on, they kind of decreased (wtf XD) anyway, so yeah - I never understood why people were so obsessed over them when they really weren't that big at all.
Same with Dawn's miniskirt. I do think it is a little bit too short (like the um...shot we got in DP039, that was a little too much if you ask me), but girls wear skirts, so why can't she? It shouldn't be a big deal, seriously - it's just a skirt. o_o But if that's the "main" reason why people like her, then I gotta wonder if anybody likes her for her personality at all. -_-
Yeah Dawn dresses up while May doesn't. Yeah, I agree with what Pocky said, you're just jealous, beacuse everyone says Dawn is much prettier than May. Well, THEY'RE TRUE !
So what if May doesn't dress up for Contests? I think that's a good thing - especially for (mostly younger) girls watching the show. May's confident enough to go out there and win with just her normal attire, while Dawn is showing that you must dress up and do your hair before you even get on stage. :/ Besides, Sinnoh Contests =/= Hoenn and Kanto Contests, so of course May isn't going to dress up (who knows about Johto Contests). As for Dawn being "prettier" than May, I don't see why that matters (it's your opinion, anyway) - because when it comes down to it, it's the personality of the character, not the looks, though that may be a bonus, especially if you're a guy. If that's the only reason you think Dawn is the better character, then...wow. :/ I don't even like Dawn, but she at least deserves to be liked for something other than her appearance. >>
As for their pokemon teams, May wins again for me. She had a variety of different pokemon, while Dawn doesn't (although I'll admit, the personalities of Dawn's pokemon are way better than May's). Like Haruka Chan already said, she has two water pokemon and four pokemon already in less than 44 episodes. May didn't have her whole Hoenn team, which was 6? pokemon, until the Hoenn GF.
And the thing about Dawn obsessing over her hair - it's not just her hair, it's her appearance in general. She always wants to look good, even for Contests, where it's not even mandatory, but optional to dress up. Examples are in DP009 (when she won't come out of the tent because she doesn't want anybody looking at her), DP019 (with Pachirisu, she kept brushing her hair after it messed it up), and DP029 (when the Sinnoh Now News Crew came, she told them to stop and she redid her hair, when it looked perfectly fine). DP011 and DP026 also show how she gets ready for Contests, and she was freaking out in DP011 when she couldn't get her ponytail right. DP026, she was showing off to Kengo before the Contest even started, because again, she knew that she looked "good." Though this all part of her character, sometimes I think she's a little over the top, especially for a 10-year-old. o_o;
Crystal Hikari
August 24th, 2007, 05:30 PM
Characters ? the Dawn's the best, but hey, it's my opinion, everyone has a different opionion on who's better
davadude
August 24th, 2007, 06:12 PM
i say dawn!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i mean; may looks ugly;
and thsat dumb max..
Jorah
August 24th, 2007, 07:40 PM
I don't know why people care so much about how cartoon characters look o.O I think both May and Dawn look pretty
From what I've seen so far Dawn doesn't really seem over the top in girlyness, except from in the first ep where she tried bringing a whole suitcase full of clothes. In the one where she gets her hair messy and uses Piplup's Bubble to make it straght again and when she's worried about her ponytail in the contest...stuff like that seems normal to me. Or maybe she's just kind of acting more like a teenager over her looks. My friends are like that too...or maybe I've forgotten if Dawn really obsesses over that stuff too much. But I don't ever remember thinking that. If you're going onto a big stage you're going to care about how you look and if you're hair's just been frazzled you will too. I'm not saying she's not girly, but the way everyone was going on about her I was expecting her to pull out a mirror every episode.
You know, I was asking the same question. 0_o
Actually, that's the reason I don't like Dawn. Any girl who travels through a country on foot while wearing a miniskirt next to a pervert (Brock)
XD So true though, so true.
Crystal Hikari
August 24th, 2007, 07:51 PM
She'll put out a mirror only if Pachirisu messes up her hair
Haruka Chan
August 24th, 2007, 08:01 PM
Well Jorah, that's what girly defines as. When girls always have to care about how they look, always have to obsess over their hair, wanting lots of clothes, ect. Dawn does that A LOT. Neither Misty or May were ever that bad. They cared about their looks, and liked shopping, yes. But most girls do.
Dawn is the most girly out of the girls, anybody can see that easily. Both her personality and attire is extremely girly. And it's like sometimes when she's on the show doing something like obsessing over her hair, or looking in the mirror..I want to smack her. Cause she's like too obsessed. (I can be like that too, but it's like COME ON. She's only 10.)It like makes you wonder how she's going to be when she's like my age (17) o_o
Pocky
August 24th, 2007, 08:25 PM
Well, I never really watched the Hoen saga. So I shouldn't really be talking. I've only seen like 2 episodes of DP. It seems like you guys know more about the characters than I do. From what I'm reading, May is the one I should like. I guess Dawn is more feminine than May. I do like May's outfit better than Dawns. A real 10 year old should not wear that. Atleast till she's 16. I guess I will have to change my answer to, May.
May's pokemon ARE better than Dawn's from what I can see. Dawn's are too cute >_<
Jorah
August 24th, 2007, 08:52 PM
Both May's and Dawn's Pokemon are cute though. Except when Torchic evolved. Skitty, Beautifly, Munchlax, Bulbasaur, the baby Squirtle(HATE) and Eevee are all cute.
Well Jorah, that's what girly defines as. When girls always have to care about how they look, always have to obsess over their hair, wanting lots of clothes, ect. Dawn does that A LOT. Neither Misty or May were ever that bad. They cared about their looks, and liked shopping, yes. But most girls do.
Dawn is the most girly out of the girls, anybody can see that easily. Both her personality and attire is extremely girly. And it's like sometimes when she's on the show doing something like obsessing over her hair, or looking in the mirror..I want to smack her. Cause she's like too obsessed. (I can be like that too, but it's like COME ON. She's only 10.)It like makes you wonder how she's going to be when she's like my age (17) o_o
Yeah, she is definatly the girliest out of all of them. But she doesn't seem over the top to me...My sister is 11. She doesn't act as girly as Dawn but I think that's round about the age where you start caring a bit about how you look. But those 3 instances are the only times I can remember Dawn saying anything about how she looks/clothes and stuff...do I need to watch D/P again?
Crystal Hikari
August 24th, 2007, 08:58 PM
Well Jorah, that's what girly defines as. When girls always have to care about how they look, always have to obsess over their hair, wanting lots of clothes, ect. Dawn does that A LOT. Neither Misty or May were ever that bad. They cared about their looks, and liked shopping, yes. But most girls do.
Dawn is the most girly out of the girls, anybody can see that easily. Both her personality and attire is extremely girly. And it's like sometimes when she's on the show doing something like obsessing over her hair, or looking in the mirror..I want to smack her. Cause she's like too obsessed. (I can be like that too, but it's like COME ON. She's only 10.)It like makes you wonder how she's going to be when she's like my age (17) o_o
Once again, Haruka, you're just JEALOUS taht more people like Dawn ! LOOK AT THE POLL !
(Sorry lost my cool again)
Pocky
August 24th, 2007, 08:59 PM
Once again, Haruka, you're just JEALOUS taht more people like Dawn ! LOOK AT THE POLL !
(Sorry lost my cool again)
I think most GUYS like Dawn better because of her miniskirt! Which is pretty shallow if you ask me.
Crystal Hikari
August 24th, 2007, 09:05 PM
Shallow ? That's not shallow ! It's mostly the only thing that makes Dawn attractive to guys, IMO
Haruka Chan
August 24th, 2007, 09:19 PM
Once again, Haruka, you're just JEALOUS taht more people like Dawn ! LOOK AT THE POLL !
Alright, whatever you say. Yes. I'm jealous because my favorite character is less liked. o_o; BTW. Dawn is only winning by 2.
I can say that both Dawn and May have fans that just like them for their body/outfit. Of course you're going to get that with those two. And by the comments in this thread, it seems like a lot of people (including you) like Dawn for her mini-skirt. D:
Shallow ? That's not shallow ! It's mostly the only thing that makes Dawn attractive to guys, IMO
LMAO. You pretty much just insulted Dawn, by saying the only good thing about her is her mini-skirt.
Crystal Hikari
August 24th, 2007, 09:25 PM
I said "mostly", not "entirily" I like her for her snow cap, too
Pkmn Trainer Alex
August 24th, 2007, 09:33 PM
I'd just like to reiterate that I like Dawn because of her personality, and not the shortness of her skirt. x_x Though I don't mind her outfit either. Just, personally, during the Hoenn region, May would either irk me with how she acted, or just not do anything for me. And Dawn brought some life back into the show. At least, for me anyway.
If we have to compare appearances, I actually like both in different ways. One has a natural cuteness and sweet disposition, while the other shows a more dynamic and overall energetic look. If May didn't irk me in the certain episodes and movies she does, it would probably be a lot closer. But yea, this is a personal thing, as I know Dawn irks a number of you all instead. ^^;
Crystal Hikari
August 24th, 2007, 09:36 PM
What does irk mean ? It doesn't make sense
Pkmn Trainer Alex
August 24th, 2007, 09:40 PM
"irk
–verb (used with object)
to irritate, annoy, or exasperate: It irked him to wait in line."
Straight from dictionary.com~ ^^; I didn't want to use "annoy" as much as "irk", for some reason. Maybe I see "annoy" as more negative...
Crystal Hikari
August 24th, 2007, 09:54 PM
Well, you do what you want, as long as you get your point down on the thread
AC Coda X
August 25th, 2007, 12:57 PM
Dawnfanboy, admit it. Your favorite character needs to lose the miniskirt, or at least put something more substantial then her panties underneath the thing. I'm starting to wonder if this argument is between "Who do more perverts like? The girl in the miniskirt or the girl who is very obviously blooming as we speak?"
Dangit, I'll admit that as a character Dawn is interesting. Funny thing? I liked May better. I dunno why, other then Dawn's less-then-modest choice of attire, but I do. And any character who needs a miniskirt to draw a fanbase is just not worth mentioning. That's all there is to it.
Jorah
August 25th, 2007, 01:53 PM
Shallow ? That's not shallow ! It's mostly the only thing that makes Dawn attractive to guys, IMO
IMO liking someone else better because of how they look is shallow.
Well this thread is getting kind of...interesting...but it could get locked if all people are arguing about is Dawn's skirt and May's body o.O
Crystal Hikari
August 25th, 2007, 02:04 PM
NEXT QUESTION, besides the question about thier clothes ended a long time ago !
Jordan
August 25th, 2007, 02:35 PM
IMO liking someone else better because of how they look is shallow.
Well this thread is getting kind of...interesting...but it could get locked if all people are arguing about is Dawn's skirt and May's body o.O
Already locked, but reopened.
Jordan.
Crystal Hikari
August 25th, 2007, 02:42 PM
Someone give us a new question, plesse before I have to ask a Mod to lock it again
Dead Pool Avenged
August 25th, 2007, 05:00 PM
I guess there almost even but ill say may is better.
fattyeater
August 26th, 2007, 12:21 PM
...i just made it even 49 to 49.
Bobby
August 26th, 2007, 06:13 PM
It'll take time to say, as Dawn is still developing as a trainer. In the long run though I think Dawn will be slightly better than May. Dawn has a broader role as a pokemon trainer, while May had one as well, just not a broad.
♥~*Abby*~♥
August 26th, 2007, 07:59 PM
dawn i guess. but that wasnt by much.
Charaxes
August 26th, 2007, 11:55 PM
Gee, I thought people would talk about Haruka's spandex. Imagine when she grows up. Heh.
Anyway, I blame the underground Lolita or Gothic lolita culture that Japan is in right now. We didn't have that a mere 5 years ago, and it's encroaching Pokemon. Of course, Marina and Haruka's were rather risque, but not like Hikari's. I wonder what the next female protagionist will wear or not wear.
Try that.
Rena Ryuugu
August 26th, 2007, 11:56 PM
Misty. XD
Out of May and Dawn... I think that Dawn would have to be the character I like better overall.
SatoshiLuver
August 27th, 2007, 12:45 AM
neither Mistys the best! but i guess Dawn is better than May. I hate may and ash shipperrrssss!
~*!*~Queen Boo~*!*~
August 27th, 2007, 03:09 PM
I like Dawn shes alright. I really never liked May until her Torchic evolved into its final stage of a Blaziken. But if it were between May, Misty or Dawn I'll go for Misty because Misty is a tomboy and I'm one as well
:t354:TG
<Wind>
August 27th, 2007, 03:40 PM
Hmmm... Well this is quite hard but I have to say is Dawn
Marsh-Stomp
August 27th, 2007, 04:28 PM
I like Dawn shes alright. I really never liked May until her Torchic evolved into its final stage of a Blaziken. But if it were between May, Misty or Dawn I'll go for Misty because Misty is a tomboy and I'm one as well
:t354:TG
You just took the Words Out of My Mouth!
That is what I was just going to say, except the last part. :p
♥~*Abby*~♥
August 27th, 2007, 08:08 PM
i prefer dawn. y? cauz she reminds me of, well, me. i always seem 2 obsessing over my appearence. my hair has 2 look perfect, my clothes and shoes have 2 match PERFECTLY, and if my makeup isnt just rite... (2 much/ 2 little lip gloss, eye shadow not matching w/ outfit, imperfect i-liner, etc.) i make a big deal out of it. so therefore, i lyke dawn cauz we have stuff in common. also, her personality is better. and the immodest clothing gets a thumbs up from me. :D
Crystal Hikari
August 27th, 2007, 09:20 PM
^^Yeah, Dawn's a girly-girl, she's a true0blue girly-girl, May wasn't, and Misty was a total tomboy
Drew
August 28th, 2007, 04:03 AM
At first I thought 'Dawn' would be really cool.
But besides the fact that her character design is neat, I don't really care too much for her.
So I'd have to say that May gets my vote.
I didn't really like her too much at the start, but she's become my favorite out of the three females.
fattyeater
August 28th, 2007, 09:03 AM
you know.theres an intresting fact about dawns and mays starter pokemon last forms.thay can both beat each other up because empeon is steel/water and blaziken is fire/fighting.if blaziken hits empeon with a fighting move it will it hurt it badly and if empeon hits blaziken with a water move it will hurt it badly.
Venks
August 28th, 2007, 11:24 AM
The correct answer is Misty. :P
Drew
August 28th, 2007, 05:58 PM
you know.theres an intresting fact about dawns and mays starter pokemon last forms.thay can both beat each other up because empeon is steel/water and blaziken is fire/fighting.if blaziken hits empeon with a fighting move it will it hurt it badly and if empeon hits blaziken with a water move it will hurt it badly.
Maybe its a sign that May and Dawn are equal..?
xp
Either way..
I still like May better, and Misty use to be my favorite, but over the last
year or so I've stopped liking her again.
angelfire9110
August 28th, 2007, 06:12 PM
I like them both, but May goes a bit (okay, a lot) farther for me. So, yeah. May. =)
Tokyopoprock
November 3rd, 2007, 10:09 AM
I think that May was really whiny and apathetic; she was always afraid and I found her simply annoying. I like Dawn much better because she shows bravery and determination much more frequently.
airconditioning
November 3rd, 2007, 12:19 PM
LAWL NECROPOSTING.
Anyway, I hate both May and Dawn. However, since I never watched Advance Generation, I saw less of May, which makes her a bit less annoying in my mind.
Extreme
November 3rd, 2007, 02:29 PM
I think that May was really whiny and apathetic; she was always afraid and I found her simply annoying. I like Dawn much better because she shows bravery and determination much more frequently.
Yeah I agree with you. Dawn is a fighter and somehow she remains girly.
Tsugaru
November 3rd, 2007, 03:00 PM
This is a toughie, Two very hard choices.
With Dawn the things I prefer much more than May is her clothes and her attitude.
Dawn is is a battler and May isn't, I never did really like the whole contest idea with May. May has weird clothes and her voice can get really on my nerves. I still prefer Misty out of the two of them but all in all my vote goes to Dawn.
Chibaymega12
November 3rd, 2007, 04:26 PM
To me, they're both winy, but Dawn is even more clueless than may was in her beggining stages, but Dawn is clearly gifted, whereas may just had to work super hard, so i think if they were to start at the same time, May would've been a MUCH better coordinator, but as time past, prolly about their 5th competition, Dawn would pull ahead, but i think they're pretty even
Spice Curry
November 4th, 2007, 05:08 PM
May had much better character development early on in the series; we knew she was a klutz, a bit girly, not very experienced and all that: plus she had awesome rivals who assisted her development and her relationship with Ash and Brock was more of a student-teacher one.
Dawn is just...there, I guess. She doesn't have many qualities that help her stand alone as a character. She borrows qualities from May, some from Misty, and even a few from the early Ash as well. That too, she's not really interesting HERSELF, y'know? I mean...Pochama and Buizel are much more interesting than she is...and even they've got more character development than she has. And her rivals are kinda dull: Zoey is your typical good-character, and Kengo is as well. Drew was cool in the beginning, and Harley is just...Harley XD
So overall, May >>> Dawn.
Forest Grovyle
November 4th, 2007, 11:49 PM
Tokyopoprock, do NOT bump threads that are more than a month old. Read the rules before posting again.
*locks*
--FG