The PokéCommunity Forums

The PokéCommunity Forums (
-   Writer's Lounge (
-   -   Fic of the Month: July '11 Nominations & Suggestions (

JX Valentine August 16th, 2011 1:48 PM

Fic of the Month: July '11 Nominations & Suggestions
And welcome to our first-ever nominations post for Fic of the Month! This time around is a quick-fire month, but we hope that, if this turns out being at least mediocre to awesome, we'll be able to start earlier next time to give us a bit more time to ***** out our fics decide carefully which ones should be in the running.

Here's How It Works
At the end of this post, you'll see a massive list of fics. Pick one to three fics and post their titles here. (Obviously, none of your nominations can be one of your own fics.) You can also explain why you're nominating that fic. Or not. We honestly don't care either way, so feel free to format your nominations post however you'd like.

Yes, you can nominate something that someone else has already nominated, although to be most effective, you'll generally want to avoid seconding/thirding/whatevering. As in, while we don't really care at this point if you do nominate something someone's covered, we'd prefer it if you didn't, really.

In the last week of the month, we'll gather all the fics that you chose and create a new thread for voting. You'll get one vote, but all of the votes will be anonymous (so don't be shy about your decision). Once that week is up, we'll take a peek at which fic got the most votes. Whoever does will be crowned the Fic of the Month, and the rest of you get pats on the back. If there's a tie, we'll hold another voting session until someone finally decides.

Simple and straightforward on your part, right?

To clear things up, not everything that gets posted within a month is eligible for being nominated. Here's the requirements to get on the list:

1. Because this is Fic of the Month, only fics updated within a one-month period are eligible. As in, they need to have posted a chapter (or the entire fic needs to have been posted, in the case of one-shots) on the forums any time between the first of the month to the last day of the month in order to qualify on the most basic level. Announcements, reviews, and review responses do not qualify a thread for nomination if the last chapter was not posted within the same month.

In this case, because we're nominating fics for the month of July, only fics with chapters posted between July 1 and July 31 qualify.

2. SWC fics (i.e., fics written for a writing contest hosted by PC) are not eligible. This is because they already receive attention from said contest, so it's rather missing the point of the Fic of the Month competition.

3. Because this is Fic of the Month, poetry is not eligible.

4. The thread must not have been closed for any reason. Yes, kids, breaking forum rules automatically gets your fic booted from the running. Sorry.

5. Fics that have already won Fic of the Month are also not eligible unless this is a completely new version. For example, let's say IanDonyer's Volkner's Tale had won Fic of the Month in its original version. The new version is still eligible because it's technically a different story. However, if Dagzar's Mentor wins Fic of the Month this time around, it's not eligible for further nominations, even if Dagzar adds new material to it. This is just to be fair and allow multiple fics to have the chance at getting on the rec list.

6. You must post your fic on PC to qualify. Sorry, but I'm pretty sure not that many people would like to download and open a PDF or DOC in order to decide whether or not they'd like to nominate you. (Note: This is a proposed rule. Please feel free to voice your opinions about whether or not you'd like this one set in stone.)

What's In It For Me?: Perks of Being Fic of the Month
If nominated, winners for Fic of the Month will receive the honor of having their fic listed on a stickied archive thread for posterity. (Note: This thread will not be up until after we get something to put in it.) That means more attention can be directed towards your fic, and you get to walk away with bragging rights.

There may be other perks in development as well.

Eligible Fics
Just in case you need a refresher (and because I'm crazy), here's July's batch of fics. I will most likely never do this again unless I happen to be bored for August's nominations too.

Note: All non-Pokémon fics and crossovers will have their fandoms listed in italics. Fics that have had at least one nomination will also be in bold.

New Friends by miley810
The Legion by lord of flames
The BattleGround by miltankRancher
Crushed by Misheard Whisper
Here Comes the Sun by IanDonyer
My Reasons by JX Valentine
The Pokémon Academy by Impo
The Forgetton Glitch by TheBowsinator
Evening Starhea by Townes
You Can't Change a Rainbow's Colors by Sweet Candice (My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic)
Pokémon: Generation Alloy by luxuriate
Pokémon Journeys: Kanto by Spikey-Eared Pichu
The Lost World of Giratina by Gothitelle.
Pokémon: Wuji Crisis by NatureKeeper
The Azure Pumpernickel by EmeraldSky
Dialga and the Reverse World Master by Gothitelle.
Remix: Dedication through Light and Darkness by The Yellow Flash
Codename: PokéPony by AdvancedK47 (Pokémon/My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic)
Gallery. by Full Metal (original fiction – see Notes)
Hydra's Rise by Legendarian Mistress (Digimon)
"Hunting Wishes" Diary of Bronze by Tcoppy
Father's Day by Onyx_X (original fiction)
Pitched, Stomped, and Shattered by Gothitelle.
Of Actresses and Engineers by Lysabeth
Some short stories by Onyx_X (original fiction – see Notes)
Gliscor Returns by Elgyem
The Bonds of Friendship by Etoire
Rebirth of Sinnoh – Volkner's Tale by IanDonyer
Hoso Havoc by EmeraldSky
Blood Red Ruby by RetroRoller
Lavender Town Theory – 4 Years Later by RetroRoller
Moonlight Heartbreak by Misheard Whisper
It Ain't Easy by Baibanira
Reshiram & Zekrom story by justinrpg
"The sun is shining, the birds are chirping, the children are playing and we're all going to die." by IanDonyer (Dragonball Z)
An Apple a Day by delongbi
Elite Academy by TurtleKing
For All the Right Reasons by Daydream
Infinity by RIOLURULES
The Scary Door by RetroRoller (original fiction)
Those Slaves… by TheBowsinator
Elements: Book 1, Fire by alaskapigeon
Running Through Daisies by Scourge of Nemo
The Stranger in White by Townes
Pokémon: Negaverse Rising by Dialga's Song of Time (Pokémon/Sailor Moon)
Pokémon Olympus by Dialga111
Harmony in Memory by TheSmartOne
Mentor by Dagzar

Side notes:
- Although it contains poetry (which is not eligible for the title of fiction of the month) and multiple pieces, Full Metal's thread titled Gallery is listed just once in the above. You can submit nominations for the compilation or specify which one you'd most like to see be placed in the poll, but because everything in that thread will be showcased in the rec list anyway (due to being pretty much on the same page), it's listed as one entity here. If we get enough nominations for particular pieces, then they can be listed separately in the voting thread.
- Same thing goes with Onyx_X's compilation.

Final Notes!:
As of this writing, the system, perks, and generally everything about the new Fic of the Month is in development. Can you think of a suggestion? Have a question? Leave it in this thread as well, and we'll hammer out the details.

In the meantime, nominations for July's Fic of the Month will run from now until next Tuesday (exactly one week from now), and voting will be held until September 1. Sound cool?

Daydream August 19th, 2011 6:18 AM

I'd like to nominate;

Misheard Whisper's Crushed: It was very moving, enough to make me feel like crying. Very impressive considering it's length, too.

JX Valentine's My Reasons: The characterisation was what I really liked here, I think the empathy I gained from it was what gave the story its impact.

This is all I need to do, right?

JX Valentine August 19th, 2011 11:29 AM

Yep! That's all you need to do! Thanks!

...And now more people should nominate just so it won't basically be a poll with yours truly and Misheard Whisper as the only options. XD

Cutlerine August 19th, 2011 12:08 PM

I'll nominate:

Dagzar's Mentor, because it was one of about two stories ever that I liked enough to read all the way through.

Misheard Whisper's Moonlight Heartbreak, because it's hilarious.

JX Valentine August 22nd, 2011 2:23 PM

Just letting you know, kids, you have less than 24 hours to submit nominees before the poll goes up. Right now, we have four fics in line for picking, so feel free to jump in. Remember, your post can contain as little as the fic's name. You don't even have to explain your choices if you don't want to.

Misheard Whisper August 22nd, 2011 10:02 PM

On rule 6: Yes, I think that sounds like the best idea. I get irritated when people post download links in their threads as it is, so I see no reason why they should be eligible for this competition. So yes, I'd like to see that rule 'set in stone', as it were.

And now I feel like a horrible, horrible person because I've not read enough fics to nominate things properly. I'm going to say Rebirth of Sinnoh - Volkner's Tale by Ian Donyer, though, because I did like what I read of that.

totally should have stayed just me and Jax. Best clique-y popularity contest ever lmao

bobandbill August 23rd, 2011 2:15 AM

I agree with rule 6 being set in stone too.

Due to something I wanted to nominate already being said...uh, I agree with the nominations and have no more to add? =p

JX Valentine August 23rd, 2011 10:18 AM

And rule #6 is now officially on the books! Thanks for making my job easier!


Originally Posted by Misheard Whisper (Post 6816089)
totally should have stayed just me and Jax. Best clique-y popularity contest ever lmao

Absolutely. We would have to break our tie via pillow fight.

Also! The voting booth is now up. Go, go, go!

All times are UTC -8. The time now is 8:12 AM.

Like our Facebook Page Follow us on Twitter © 2002 - 2015 The PokéCommunity™,
Pokémon characters and images belong to The Pokémon Company International and Nintendo. This website is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Nintendo, Creatures, GAMEFREAK, The Pokémon Company or The Pokémon Company International. We just love Pokémon.
All forum styles, their images (unless noted otherwise) and site designs are © 2002 - 2014 The PokéCommunity / Poké
PokéCommunity™ is a trademark of The PokéCommunity. All rights reserved. Sponsor advertisements do not imply our endorsement of that product or service. User generated content remains the property of its creator.

Use of PokéCommunity Assets