Ah, I just realized how different our views are on this is.(zekrom/reshiram joke set aside)
Your idea is literally the "community" creates a game, putting a whole lot of emphasis on the community as a whole being able to bend the game as they personally themselves see fit.
Mine, however, is more of an emphasis on the "create" part, allowing the community create a game together, not in a literal tense, through the best ideas that the community as a whole decided.
Well, whatever you decide is really up to you, and I agree that the community should cooperate together and make something worthwhile. Its been nice constructively arguing with you.
