Thread: [Pokémon] Painite Chronicles Vol. 1
View Single Post
  #3    
Old April 12th, 2013 (12:40 AM).
AXELXu7's Avatar
AXELXu7 AXELXu7 is offline
Kusari Ninja
 
Join Date: Apr 2013
Location: Sorry, no.
Gender: Male
Nature: Quirky
Posts: 23
Quote originally posted by Astinus:
Your story goes by way too fast. Vincent wakes up in a forest and seems to accept pretty quickly that he can't remember a thing. There's no hesitation on his part about that, and he doesn't seem to really react when he gets any clue about his past. He just keeps moving. A lot happened in these four chapters, and as a reader it's a lot to take in because there's no slow-down. Vincent never takes a break, so the reader can't, and it's just a lot to take in at once.

Another thing that I noticed is that your Pokemon battle descriptions are very...technical. They read exactly as the video game reads, right down to the Pokemon's HP being in the red. Those terms are fine for the games, but in stories, you're not writing about data. You're writing about creatures that are walking and reacting in a world that's real to them. So Raichu's HP isn't in the red. Raichu's not able to run as fast, his fur is black in places where he's burned, there's a few cuts staining his fur red with blood. Zangoose doesn't use Scratch. He charges at Sentret, claws held ready, tearing into his opponent's body with all the strength he can muster. You want to make Pokemon battles exciting to read about because they should be exciting to your characters. It's much more interesting to read about how the Pokemon move during battle than just simple technical terms that most people ignore by smashing the A button.

There's a good mystery here, and it's going to be interesting to see what Vincent can uncover about his past and why he can't remember a thing. The two issues that I pointed out, if you improve on them, can make your story a little easier to get into. Good luck!
I'm not gonna lie, I've been half-assing it up until now just because I wanted to get the story out. If people accepted it, I would turn it into a rom hack. That's why I included the poll. I never considered the delivery.might have to do with its acceptance. I have to start over. Thanks for the criticism. You've paid the most attention.
__________________
-Got a Machinehead, Better than the rest.-

Reply With Quote