I'm in favor of this. Since I was last here I've started writing more short stories, which are probably harder for most to comment on.
I haven't done much browsing here yet, but a quick glance shows a lack of summaries. I personally don't commit to anything longer than a short story unless I can gauge my own interest at the start, and without a summary the first several lines will suffice (which may not be fair). Improved organization and display of stories might help.
Something along the lines of a weekly critique swap would be interesting, too.