I actually get this question (and this kind of club) quite a lot. Though the answer is unfortunately no :( Topics that are exclusive to certain forums, to some degree at least, aren't to be made into a club. The main case of this is with the specific games, but it also goes for things like challenges. And seeing as you can use the individual challenges for both discussion on the challenge, as well as as (that's a lot of as'es) an adventurers log for your progress in the challenge, I honestly don't see that much need of a club.Would it be possible if I made a club based on all the challenges and stuff? We'd have challenge events and then just talk about discussions involving challenges. It'd be nice if you could let it pan out (:
However, I'd say this is acutally more [user]Everlark[/user]'s decision than mine, seeing as she's the one who moderates the challenge forum. The rule on not incorporating topics exclusive to other forums into clubs are mainly to avoid hogging activity from those forums, however in this case, I can honestly only see promotion in activity. It could be a good platform to suggest certain challenges to other people, so if you can get permission from Everlark, I'd be completely fine with it :)