Requester Ranking
Attention both Card Requesters and Card Artists! Behold my idea for keeping everyone happy in this wonderful forum! A Requester Ranking System!
Card Artists: Get people to follow your directions, and give you feedback.
Card Requesters: Get recognition for your awesome request that follows the proper format. Try to get the highest score on every card you request!
Here's how it works. Requesters, you request a card from a participating artist. They make your card, then judge you on how accurate your request was. They can also give you bonus points for extra things you add to make their lives easier. Artists, by participating, you will probably see an increase in the number of people following your request format.
How to get in: Artists, simply make a post here with criteria that you are looking for. When people request to be graded, you add their name to your post here, and grade them in a new post. Requesters, all you have to do is tell the artist you would like to participate.
The Object: Requesters, beat all your friend's score from a certain artist! Make an awesome request and be friendly, and see your score rise. Compare your score to others to see how you rank.
An Example, and My Criteria:
Base=0. Positive=Good, Negative=Bad.
Name: Mewtwo-EX
Score: +20 (could be higher, lower, or negative)
Form
Points for Request:
+5 for Animated
+3 for Standard
Uses an official form:
+5 for adding useful info to the official form
+3 for the official form
+1 if missing info
-1 if not official
-3 if not official and missing info
The Post
Double Posts:
-5 per post
Badgers:
-1 per post ("When will my card be done?", "What's taking so long?", "Do it as soon as possable")
Keeps Requesting Same Card while it's still in the works:
-3 per extra request ("Hi, I'd like card X". an hour later, "Hi, just so you know, I'd like card X". 30 minutes later, "Hey, don't forget, I want card X")
Easy to Read/Grammer/Punctuation:
+3 for exceptional
+1 for standard
-1 for substandard,
-3 for terrible
The FollowupFollows Up:
+1 for Posting "Thanks, blabla"
Suggests Improvements:
+3 for an excellent suggestion
+1 for a suggestion
-1 for a put down
-3 for a severe put down
Is Active on the Thread
+1 for helpful post
-1 for spammy post
PMs
Message:
+1 for Friendly RE
+1 for Easy to read
-1 for bad grammar / punctuation
Question:
+1 for question not answered in TCard FAQ
-1 for question already answered in FAQ
Bonus
+1 for general niceties
Well, that's my category list and point ranking. Artists, make up your own depending on what criteria you are looking for. People who have requested from me, if you'd like to be scored, send me a PM, or post it in my Request thread.
Mewtwo-EX
TCards...Want One? Ranking
Form (If you are on this list, PM me to see your full score breakdown, or to be removed from the list)
Name: metabee14
Score: 18
Name: RayquazaMaster
Score: 10