[Hack of the Year] Elimination Round - 2008

Best Mapping: Pokemon Distant
Best Scripting: Liquid Crystal
Best Storyline: Pokemon Distant
Best Newcomer: Pokemon Distant
Most Graphically Appealing: Pokemon Distant
Most Interesting Feature: Liquid Crystal

Best Mapping: Pokemon Distant
Best Scripting: Liquid Crystal
Best Storyline: Pokemon Genesis
Best Newcomer: Pokemon Congbu
Most Graphically Appealing: Pokemon Distant
Most Interesting Feature: Liquid Crystal

Top Three: Genesis, Liquid Crystal, Rijon Adventures

Best Mapping:pokemon Distant
Best Scripting: pokemon Rescue Rangers
Best Storyline: pokemon Genesis
Best Newcomer: pokemon Liquid Crystal
Most Graphically Appealing: pokemon Thunder Emblem
Most Interesting Feature: pokemon Reign of Legends

Best mapping: Genesis
Best scripting:rijon adventures
Best storyline: Genesis
best newcomer: Ruby dagger murders
Most graphically appealing:Thunder emblem
most interesting feature(s):rijon adventures

Best Mapping: Distant
Best Scripting: rijonAdventures
Best Storyline: Genesis
Best Newcomer: Congbu
Most Graphically Appealing: Battle Fire
Most Interesting Feature: rijonAdventures

Hack Of The Year 2008 Round 2 - Voting

Best Scripting
Pokemon Liquid Crystal
Best Storyline
Pokemon Liquid Crystal
Most Graphically Appealing
Pokemon Genesis
Most Interesting Feature
Pokemon Liquid Crystal
Best Newcomer
Pokemon Shiny Gold

I vote for Pokemon Liquid Crystal :D

(Good Luck Everyone) :)

Best Mapping: Genesis
Best Scripting: Liquid Crystal
Best Storyline: Liquid Crystal
Best Newcomer: Liquid Crystal
Most Graphically Appealing: Liquid Crystal
Most Interesting Feature:Liquid Crystal

best mapping rijon adventures
best scripting rescue rangeres
best storyline thunder embelm
best newcomer genesis
best graphiclly amazing reign of legends
most intresting features reign of legends
my vote
regin of legends

Best Mapping: Genesis
Best Scripting: Rescue Rangers
Best Storyline: Genesis
Best Newcomer: Distant
Most Graphically Appealing: Thunder Emblem
Most Interesting Feature: rijonAdventures

Best Mapping:Thunder Emblem
Best Scripting:Ruby Destiny: Rescue Rangers
Best Storyline:Congbu
Best Newcomer:Distant
Most Graphically Appealing:Pokemon Battle Fire
Most Interesting Feature:Ruby Destiny: Rescue Rangers

EarthsVisitor said:

There really should have been a "Your Top 3" choice, to determine the Top 3 Hacks, because there are only a few categories in this 2nd round, and some hacks excel in things not even listed on this round, or hacks are great overall, but they don't focus on one aspect like some of these hacks do. Also, you encourage people to vote for the same hack for things they might not even deserve so they can get to the 3rd Round.
Just questioning your methods.
i.e; I think Genesis is a great hack, and should go to the Top 3, but when split into categories, it does not win any from me.
Nevertheless, I'll put my top 3.

Click to expand...

First of all if you (or anyone else for that matter) has a problem with anything to do with HotY PM me, don't post it in this thread. Do not reply to this, if you want to discuss further you can reach me via PM or on MSN. I'm only posting here so everyone else knows not to do this.

What other categories are you referring to? I chose those particular categories because they were easy to understand for people. People were meant to base their nominations in Round 1 on the hack they thought were "great overall". This round is meant to reward hacks that excel in particular areas above all others. Whether a hack that excels in only one aspect gets into the Top 10 was a decision made by the members of PC.

What people base their votes on for the various categories is not something we can affect. Unfortunately in a large community like this you will get people who take competitions like this far too seriously. Also, your opinion on which hack "deserves" a particular award does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the rest of the community.

The "Top 3" hacks were decided in Round 1, I made this very clear. If you didn't agree then you should have complained about it earlier. I appreciate that your idea would be a good one in more ideal circumstances. There are time constraints this year and limiting the time the judges have to review the Top 3 hacks even further is not a good idea.

Best Mapping: Congbu
Best Scripting: Rescue Rangers
Best Storyline: Rescue Rangers
Best Newcomer: Congbu
Most Graphically Appealing: Congbu
Most Interesting Feature:Rescue Rangers

My votes ^^.

Best Mapping: Pokémon Congbu
Best Scripting: Pokémon Genesis
Best Storyline: Pokémon Genesis
Best Newcomer: Pokémon Congbu
Most Graphically Appealing: Pokémon Congbu
Most Interesting Feature: Pokémon Genesis

SAw Congbu(I think that's it's name) recently and I love the maps and the graphics look quite good(Altho I can't find the thread in Hacks Showcase ATM), I've been a fan of Genesis ever since I saw it and Like all there is about it :)

Genesis: Best mapping
Rijon Adventures: Best Scripting
Rijon Adventures: Best Storyline
Poea: Best Newcomer
Genesis: Most Graphically appealing
Rijon Adventures: Most interesting Feature

Best mapping: Distant
Best scripting: rijonAdventures
Best storyline: Genesis
Best newcomer: Genesis
Most graphically appealing: Distant
Most interesting features: rijonAdventures

Editted. Ahh, sorry bout that.

Best mapping: Distant
Best scripting: Rijon Adventures
Best storyline: Genesis
Best newcomer: Congbu
Most graphically appealing: Genesis
Most interesting features: Ruby Destiny: Rescue Rangers

* Best Mapping
Liquid Crystal
* Best Scripting
Rescue rangers
* Best Storyline
Genesis
* Most Graphically Appealing
Congbu
* Most Interesting Feature
Rescue Rangers
* Best Newcomer
King of Sea

Best Mapping: Genesis
Best Scripting: rijonAdventures
Best Storyline: Genesis
Best Newcomer: Congbu
Most Graphically Appealing: rijonAdventures
Most Interesting Feature: rijonAdventures