Roleplay Discussion Thread

[-DeepImpact-]

Originally Posted by Red's Hawt Chibi Pelippers

*bricks Impact* If you make that now, then I throw you out of Arcanum :D bet you could guess that. Have you GM'd before?

Also omg you have Nakuzami's old avatar, I thought Naku was coming back all of a sudden when I saw that.

I hope Mr Cat Dog's RP kicks off and has a good run. The idea is really cool.

Haha I guess I saw that coming xD

Yuup, I co-GM'd a Percy Jackson RP a few months back. Too bad it died though, mainly because I got busy and my co-GM had to leave PC... sigh.

lol I just love the game, and I needed a cool avatar to fit my theme so I picked that 8D Though really I do wonder when Nakuzami is gonna return haha.

[Red's Hawt Chibi Pelippers]

Haha, ;D

Ok, cool. I crave a qualitative, almost-strict journey RP that is not my own creation xD I never get surprised in my own RPs lol. Well, except for VR. It's gonna become epic before you know it.

Mm, I wonder. I don't think he's gone forever. He couldn't.

[PkMnTrainer Yellow]

@RHCP: Well, considering how abusable the leveling system in PTA is, I'd bet on the character development. You can literally gain dozens of levels in one battle via triple battling with only a fair bit more effort than a single battle. Just... nobody cares to do it for one reason or another.

It probably has something to do with the fact that having a level 100 pokemon is pretty godmoddy in and of itself. If Pokemon Special is any indication, even the 70s are a stretch without some special powers to augment their already impressive abilities. The games also seem to support this what with the 70s being champion rematch levels. Of course we never got a level reading on what happened when Red's pikachu was augmented with Yellow's incredibly powerful special abilities... I think that might have actually overshot straight past level 100 completely by anywhere between 20 to 60 levels depending on how exactly that mechanic works (Addition vs Multiplication), if that's even plausible. o_o' Of course, such a thing would come off as incredibly godmoddy if applied to an OC...

Thus, an RPer must know the limits of their characters and limit their levels as such. For instance, my 'average-above average' characters typically have limits in the 50s.

Up until recently, only my evil characters ever went above 70. Dardanette has performance enhancing powers but lacks the sheer skill to rise into the 80s and one of my other characters uses unorthodox, extremely effective (and abusive) training methods to reach the sky high 80s.

The only good aligned character I've ever made that reaches into the 70s only does so because she's both an exceptional trainer with a dramatic specialization in strategy and most of her pokemon were raised individually before being traded to her as gifts on small teams.

I'm rambling though.

[Red's Hawt Chibi Pelippers]

Originally Posted by PkMnTrainer Yellow

@RHCP: Well, considering how abusable the leveling system in PTA is, I'd bet on the character development.

That's probably it. Through all of this, I'm still more of a writer than I am a RPer. That's my theory, at least. But I think it's boring to just write a fic. I want some goals to write against, and the option to actually write together with others once in a while.

Originally Posted by PkMnTrainer Yellow

I'm rambling though.

Nah, I got what you meant. Lv 100 is just... well, not even Arceus was lv 100, right?

[徳清アキオ]

So, another Interest Check.

Who would be willing to join the Team Fortress Roleplay?

And YES, we do have a plot.

[gunnerpow7]

Interest Check!

I decided to postpone the Adventure Time RP till further notice. The plot is a little tricky.

Anyways, I have an idea for a new Pokemon RP so please tell me if you would join it.

Also, if anybody ever heard of Terra Nova and watched it, you will know this storyline.

Originally Posted by gunnerpow7

The plot starts in the year 2042. Professor Bianca starts logging in to her PC. She writes another log entry. The Pokemon World is nearing its end. Smoke and toxic levels are rising to extreme levels. Nature is already extinct. Tress, clean water, rivers, grass, plants, fruits, berries, etc., Most of them, if not all, are dead. Pokemon are rapidly diminishing. In the year 2028, researchers found a fracture in the fabric of time and space. It seems to lead to an alternate dimension on the year 0001. In 2035, they finished a massive teleportation machine on what used to be Aspertia City. If crossed, it would lead to the said dimension. The Pokemon International League passed Law 80, that states all wild Pokemon must be submitted to the League to be shipped at the Teleportation Machine, which they call Operation: New Life. Getting tickets to pass there is very hard. You must be either a Pokemon International League member, any Regional League member, with their families. Professors, Elite Positions, etc. You could buy tickets, but they cost 1 billion Unovian PokeDollars. You could also be recruited from someone from year 0001. You could also win from lotteries. Now, in the year 2042, you, out of billions of people, with you family, got tickets to the teleportation machine. Once you get to New Unova (which is the name of the region), your family is assigned to one of the 17 tribes across the land. Your objective is to gather all 17 Master Symbols (which are equivalent to gym badges) and battle the Supreme Five. But wait, a threat arises in the lovely landscape of New Unova.

So what do you guys think?

[PkMnTrainer Yellow]

@gunnerpower7: Just a thought, but pokedollars = yen. 1 billion pokedollars is the equivalent of only about 12 million actual dollars.

[gunnerpow7]

Originally Posted by PkMnTrainer Yellow

@gunnerpower7: Just a thought, but pokedollars = yen. 1 billion pokedollars is the equivalent of only about 12 million actual dollars.

Well, for the sake of the RP, Unovian PokeDollars cost as much as Euros. Don't ask why. I'm just saying that buying tickets are really expensive. Also, it's per head. So, if your buying 4 tickets, it would cost 4 billion Unovian PokeDollars.

[Red's Hawt Chibi Pelippers]

Originally Posted by 徳清アキオ

So, another Interest Check.

Who would be willing to join the Team Fortress Roleplay?

And YES, we do have a plot.

Not me, I've never played it and doubt I'll like it :3 doesn't mean it would be a bad RP though!

Originally Posted by gunnerpow7

Interest Check!

I decided to postpone the Adventure Time RP till further notice. The plot is a little tricky.

Anyways, I have an idea for a new Pokemon RP so please tell me if you would join it.

Also, if anybody ever heard of Terra Nova and watched it, you will know this storyline.

So what do you guys think?

Whooaa that sounds so cool. I heard of that, if it's where they go back to the dinosaur's time or something. I think it would be a bit weird setting to have something resembling a pokémon league though, since the most important thing for everyone there would be to, well, survive and build a new society rather than start battling immediately just for fun. Maybe the RP can take place some years after a new society - however primal - has been built up? Or maybe the RP can be about the dimension travelers exploring and uncovering things about their new home, rather than go around beating gyms?

[ShinyDiamond]

>.< Gah! I don't know what to reply to! Uh, I would join that Pokemon RP gunnerpow7.

[雷影 イチロ]

Originally Posted by 徳清アキオ

So, another Interest Check.

Who would be willing to join the Team Fortress Roleplay?

And YES, we do have a plot.

No interest from here, I like the game, but would rather it not be butchered in an RP.

@Gunnerpow7: Seems interesting, if you can elaborate more on it, it could come off quite well, although I'm not too sure about the whole "league/17 tribes". Perhaps, you could use the Terra Nova idea, one colony, and have both 'bad' and 'good' guys, much like Terra Nova.

[-DeepImpact-]

@Akio: tbh, I kind of agree with Ichiro. Some things are just better off being video games. I won't join, but I'm still interested in seeing how exactly you manage such a RP.

The plot starts in the year 2042. Professor Bianca starts logging in to her PC. She writes another log entry. The Pokemon World is nearing its end. Smoke and toxic levels are rising to extreme levels. Nature is already extinct. Tress, clean water, rivers, grass, plants, fruits, berries, etc., Most of them, if not all, are dead. Pokemon are rapidly diminishing. In the year 2028, researchers found a fracture in the fabric of time and space. It seems to lead to an alternate dimension on the year 0001. In 2035, they finished a massive teleportation machine on what used to be Aspertia City. If crossed, it would lead to the said dimension. The Pokemon International League passed Law 80, that states all wild Pokemon must be submitted to the League to be shipped at the Teleportation Machine, which they call Operation: New Life. Getting tickets to pass there is very hard. You must be either a Pokemon International League member, any Regional League member, with their families. Professors, Elite Positions, etc. You could buy tickets, but they cost 1 billion Unovian PokeDollars. You could also be recruited from someone from year 0001. You could also win from lotteries. Now, in the year 2042, you, out of billions of people, with you family, got tickets to the teleportation machine. Once you get to New Unova (which is the name of the region), your family is assigned to one of the 17 tribes across the land. Your objective is to gather all 17 Master Symbols (which are equivalent to gym badges) and battle the Supreme Five. But wait, a threat arises in the lovely landscape of New Unova.

Eh... the whole Pokemon League concept kind of put me off. When I read a "Pokemon-Terra Nova" crossover, I expected something like people going back and trying to rebuild society, like in the show. I thought it would be cool if you brought like limited Pokemon back in time, and actually survived in a harsh land along with primitive version of current gen Pokemon, which imo would be cool. Then, there would be internal conflicts within the society, like the show.

tl;dr my point is that the league concept makes it seem like a League RP in a different setting. It would be cool if it featured older versions of Pokemon, that would interest me.

[PkMnTrainer Yellow]

@DeepImpact: To be fair, pokemon mythology seems to suggest that humans were created around the same time as pokemon (who were created near the beginning of the world.), and that they somehow had access to /magic/ at some point. The concept of an ancient league might not be that far off. Perhaps it's less about having fun though and more like a hierarchy of sorts. Perhaps the league is the government and the strongest is effectively the ruler.

I'm just musing though.

[-DeepImpact-]

Originally Posted by PkMnTrainer Yellow

@DeepImpact: To be fair, pokemon mythology seems to suggest that humans were created around the same time as pokemon (who were created near the beginning of the world.), and that they somehow had access to /magic/ at some point. The concept of an ancient league might not be that far off. Perhaps it's less about having fun though and more like a hierarchy of sorts. Perhaps the league is the government and the strongest is effectively the ruler.

I'm just musing though.

According to the GM here the portal actually opened into an alternate dimension so I guess we can freely play around with the very concept of Pokemon here lol.

I'm just saying that it would be cool if Pokemon were shown as dinosaurs, bigger, violent, not really well-developed, etc. It would just be a rather different concept than "have a league in the old times", which has already been done in Miss Doronjo's Ye Pokebeast's Journeye, btw.

[ShinyDiamond]

The plot starts in the year 2042. Professor Bianca starts logging in to her PC. She writes another log entry. The Pokemon World is nearing its end. Smoke and toxic levels are rising to extreme levels. Nature is already extinct. Tress, clean water, rivers, grass, plants, fruits, berries, etc., Most of them, if not all, are dead. Pokemon are rapidly diminishing. In the year 2028, researchers found a fracture in the fabric of time and space. It seems to lead to an alternate dimension on the year 0001. In 2035, they finished a massive teleportation machine on what used to be Aspertia City. If crossed, it would lead to the said dimension. The Pokemon International League passed Law 80, that states all wild Pokemon must be submitted to the League to be shipped at the Teleportation Machine, which they call Operation: New Life. Getting tickets to pass there is very hard. You must be either a Pokemon International League member, any Regional League member, with their families. Professors, Elite Positions, etc. You could buy tickets, but they cost 1 billion Unovian PokeDollars. You could also be recruited from someone from year 0001. You could also win from lotteries. Now, in the year 2042, you, out of billions of people, with you family, got tickets to the teleportation machine. Once you get to New Unova (which is the name of the region), your family is assigned to one of the 17 tribes across the land. Your objective is to gather all 17 Master Symbols (which are equivalent to gym badges) and battle the Supreme Five. But wait, a threat arises in the lovely landscape of New Unova.

I'm guessing the Supreme Five is like the Elite Four & the Champion. :\ I might be a little uneasy joining this, but I would definitely try it out.

[徳清アキオ]

Originally Posted by 雷影　イチロ

No interest from here, I like the game, but would rather it not be butchered in an RP.

Wow. I mean, that's pretty damn rude, you know? The least you could do is re-word it, or, I don't know, give it a chance? Trust me, from how much Jaffersin and I have been chatting, he knows his stuff, and so do I, to an extent. I think we have something great in the works. We have a full plot (believe it or not, Team Fortress DOES have a story) and we will follow the main plot of the canon. However, we've made it much more intricate, given legitimate reasons for death and respawn, and given actual purposes to the gametypes, such as payload, attack/defense, and capture the intel.

Most people wouldn't be so ignorant to knock something before they have the first clue about it.

Originally Posted by -DeepImpact-

@Akio: tbh, I kind of agree with Ichiro. Some things are just better off being video games. I won't join, but I'm still interested in seeing how exactly you manage such a RP.

Read above.

[XLegionxX]

I'm going to say this as polite as I can...

Please don't make TF2 into a RP.

[徳清アキオ]

Originally Posted by XLegionxX

I'm going to say this as polite as I can...

Please don't make TF2 into a RP.

And why exactly would it be such a bad thing to create a roleplay out of such a wonderful game? People neglect to realize that there really was a story behind the multiplayer game.

Storyline from the Official TF2 Wiki

And, while this is satirical, I thought I should include it.

[雷影 イチロ]

Originally Posted by 徳清アキオ

Wow. I mean, that's pretty damn rude, you know? The least you could do is re-word it, or, I don't know, give it a chance? Trust me, from how much Jaffersin and I have been chatting, he knows his stuff, and so do I, to an extent. I think we have something great in the works. We have a full plot (believe it or not, Team Fortress DOES have a story) and we will follow the main plot of the canon. However, we've made it much more intricate, given legitimate reasons for death and respawn, and given actual purposes to the gametypes, such as payload, attack/defense, and capture the intel.

Most people wouldn't be so ignorant to knock something before they have the first clue about it.



Read above.

I don't doubt that you have a reason for everything and a storyline, neither do I doubt Jaffersin's knowledge of Team Fortress 2 either. However like DeepImpact and XLegion, I believe TF2 is a really good game, and some things just shouldn't be made into a Roleplay because then it ends up 'butchering' the idea/vision of the game.

Again, I'm not really a fan of game-based Roleplays, so my idea is slightly skewed and biased, but there are some games like TF2, that I believe should not be made into RPs.

Also, if your asking for comments, be prepared for both positive and negative comments, not everyone is going to respond: "OMFG dis is sum c00l stuffs!!!11!!!1!!11!!!!"

[徳清アキオ]

Originally Posted by 雷影　イチロ

I don't doubt that you have a reason for everything and a storyline, neither do I doubt Jaffersin's knowledge of Team Fortress 2 either. However like DeepImpact and XLegion, I believe TF2 is a really good game, and some things just shouldn't be made into a Roleplay because then it ends up 'butchering' the idea/vision of the game.

Again, I'm not really a fan of game-based Roleplays, so my idea is slightly skewed and biased, but there are some games like TF2, that I believe should not be made into RPs.

Also, if your asking for comments, be prepared for both positive and negative comments, not everyone is going to respond: "OMFG dis is sum c00l stuffs!!!11!!!1!!11!!!!"

Of course I don't expect strictly positive comments. I just think that you could have showed a little more courtesy and respect with your negative comment.

[gunnerpow7]

Okay, how about one colony situated in where would Castelia City soon stand and the colony will be divided into 17 sectors, one for each type. Still thinking of another plotline besides the league thing... It's a WIP... But I will consider the rebuilding civilization part. Common Pokemon are the Fossil Pokemon, And some other Pokemon. But I will tell you that the strongest Pokemon in New Unova will be the Prehistoric Magikarp. Yes, Magikarp.

[ShinyDiamond]

Originally Posted by gunnerpow7

Okay, how about one colony situated in where would Castelia City soon stand and the colony will be divided into 17 sectors, one for each type. Still thinking of another plotline besides the league thing... It's a WIP... But I will consider the rebuilding civilization part. Common Pokemon are the Fossil Pokemon, And some other Pokemon. But I will tell you that the strongest Pokemon in New Unova will be the Prehistoric Magikarp. Yes, Magikarp.

I'll probably follow along with it as I go. :3 I'm definitely joining the electric sector!

[雷影 イチロ]

Originally Posted by gunnerpow7

Okay, how about one colony situated in where would Castelia City soon stand and the colony will be divided into 17 sectors, one for each type. Still thinking of another plotline besides the league thing... It's a WIP... But I will consider the rebuilding civilization part. Common Pokemon are the Fossil Pokemon, And some other Pokemon. But I will tell you that the strongest Pokemon in New Unova will be the Prehistoric Magikarp. Yes, Magikarp.

Hmm, it doesn't always have to be a league, there could be some sort of catastrophic event that the RPers need to stop, maybe there are dissenters (akin to the sixers) that have opposing ideals? Or maybe there are prehistoric people there too, and they don't want the invaders there?

Just a few idea's off the top of my head. The one colony, seventeen sectors sounds fine. And a prehistoric Magicarp? Interesting, will be looking forward to seeing it's power.

[Red's Hawt Chibi Pelippers]

@ Zerin / Akio - We replied because it seemed like you wanted replies. That he happened to use the word "butchered" doesn't mean that he hates you.

@ Ichiro - I think it's ok to try and make RPs out of anything. With a good enough idea and the will to set up an intricate enough plot or setting and game mechanics, nothing is impossible, just maybe less simple than some other settings. At least this is the view that I'd like to have but perhaps I just haven't tried making too strange RPs yet x3

[-DeepImpact-]

Originally Posted by Red's Hawt Chibi Pelippers

@ Zerin / Akio - We replied because it seemed like you wanted replies. That he happened to use the word "butchered" doesn't mean that he hates you.

@ Ichiro - I think it's ok to try and make RPs out of anything. With a good enough idea and the will to set up an intricate enough plot or setting and game mechanics, nothing is impossible, just maybe less simple than some other settings. At least this is the view that I'd like to have but perhaps I just haven't tried making too strange RPs yet x3

Well, I agree with you, it's ok to try and make RPs about whatever you feel like. But it's just that sometimes there are some things that are better off staying just like they are. Like TF2.

@Ichiro: I actually like the prehistoric people idea. Maybe they could be like rebels? But the only problem with that is that it would seem like that idea was ripped off the Sixers.

@Gunnerpow: But if Magikarp is the most powerful... what about Gyarados, it's evolution? xD