-Villains. Magical girls/boys are like superheroes, and every superhero has at least a villain, or a villainous species. There doesn't have to be one kind of villain; there could be two. Madoka, for example, has two villains. I was thinking that the magical boys/girls would have to compete to live, kind of like in Madoka. That would make them villainous to each other, no?
I would assume it would make them villainous to each other. For some reason when I think about competing to live, I think about the Hunger Games.
-Powers/abilities. Despite being called a "magical" girl/boy, said characters do not have to have magical powers. Homura Akemi in Madoka mainly uses weapons she stole from various mafias (using her time manipulating ability) rather than magic. However, the characters do usually have some type of magical defense, so they aren't powerless against the villains/their own kind. If anything, I'd let the player choose whether or not they want their character to have magical powers or just be skilled with something non-magical.
I would think that's a good choice there. The reason is that some people might rather be a swordsman than a magician, or a sharpshooter instead of a sorcerer or sorceress.
-How the characters get their powers/abilities. In Madoka, they make a contract with Kyubey. In Tokyo Mew Mew, they are infected (I guess that's the right term?) with genes of endangered species. In Mermaid Melody, their pearls give them their powers so long as they keep them nearby. So how do you think a magical girl/boy should get her/his powers/abilities?
Well, this is a hard one. You could always have the characters come from a long line of magicians, though that may be to common in other things, or have them receive their power from their weapon, which is also a bit overrated but eh.
-Type of RP. As in, Chapter versus Do-What-You-Want. I'm leaning toward the latter only because it isn't as controlled, you know? I mean, there'll be plots thrown in from time to time, but at least you don't have to wait for the GM to announce what you're supposed to do next, right?
I agree.
-Any other suggestions? Besides not making one altogether. I want to make a magical girl RP enjoyable for both males and females, ya know? :3
None from me. :P