Quote:
Originally Posted by Maruno
Regarding your screenshots, your mapping skills could do with a little improvement. The "hi there Phuj" ground should be raised so that it looks higher than the lava, and you should merge it into the cave wall so that there aren't slivers of red between the two. The floor texture of "choose one of these 5" doesn't look particularly like a cave - they look like old floorboards. And the trees at the side of "Professor Robus' Lab" are too widely spaced - players would expect to be able to squeeze between them. And swathes of red flowers like that doesn't look that great.
While we haven't seen much of your outdoor mapping skills, I fear they may be a little too square and sparse. Still, we'll have to see whether that concern is justified or not.
|
I definitely agree with these concerns. Like I said, my creative skills are quite lacking.
I've been toying around, and I have since improved the caves and the lava. As for the trees, I wouldn't worry too much about it. Players will learn quickly that they cannot squeeze through them.
In addition, the way I choose to lay out my maps is unique and special to me. I understand that concerns about look, but I'm not concerned about minor flaws.
Hopefully the release of the 1st Beta will give me some more input for improvement. I greatly appreciate the feedback.
Let me just get this out of the way before I get anymore emails and messages:
I understand that my maps and other visuals aren't perfect. I understand this, and no I'm not finding someone to map for me.
I don't consider my maps and such bad or even horrible. In my opinion, they are pretty good.
So if you aren't going to try my game because of the maps, then I think you're missing the entire point of a fan-made game. They are supposed to be made because the creator has a vision for a fun Pokemon game. Be focused on the content and enjoyment value of the game. You don't play Pokemon because it looks pretty and colorful. You play it because it's fun and exciting. That's what I hope my game brings.
Sorry for the rant, but I've had too many emails from people who like to give "suggestions."