[Wi-Fi] PC WiFi Tournament

[johnny18]

Originally Posted by wonjoon0330

These Pokemon were banned before the tournament started(officially banned on 13th and tournament started on 15th).

Yeah, that's what I'm about to say

[ShinySalamence888]

Still no reply from _Prince_, really want to get this tournament going!

[Snorelacks]

Originally Posted by cartercr

Ooh, making me a bit nervous :D. I'm gonna guess Cloyster on a whim, but that may just be because I've 6-0'd several people with it. :D

You're WRONG.
Stop guessing though... don't want you to actually guess it. :D

[ShinySalamence888]

Still haven't heard from Prince, when's the deadline date?

[wonjoon0330]

Originally Posted by ShinySalamence888

Still haven't heard from Prince, when's the deadline date?

October 29 and you'll just have to wait till that day.
Who knows, maybe you'll get a lucky default win.

P.S. Also VM/PM'd you, so hopefully, you won't forget the deadline anymore.

[greg0915]

Just beat ShadowExcadrill 4-0

[ShadowExcadrill]

Lost from greg...
Back to the drawing table...

[cartercr]

I guess the Excadrill and Thundrus ban depends on the date we used. The registration started on November 27th, the first round began on October 15th. Since Excadrill and Thundrus were banned on October 9th, I believe that they would still be allowed, as the Tournament truly began on the 27th.

[wonjoon0330]

Originally Posted by cartercr

I guess the Excadrill and Thundrus ban depends on the date we used. The registration started on November 27th, the first round began on October 15th. Since Excadrill and Thundrus were banned on October 9th, I believe that they would still be allowed, as the Tournament truly began on the 27th.

From the past experience, Pokemon remains banned in tournament if it's been banned before the tournament has began(before the match up is announced), but you're the one who's hosting the tourney now, not Alakazam17, so it's up to you to decide whether to allow the banned Pokemon or not.

[johnny18]

Originally Posted by cartercr

I guess the Excadrill and Thundrus ban depends on the date we used. The registration started on November 27th, the first round began on October 15th. Since Excadrill and Thundrus were banned on October 9th, I believe that they would still be allowed, as the Tournament truly began on the 27th.

Well, I guess it is up to you then.
Snorelacks and Assassinjay battled with each other already and Snorelacks is the winner. I think you should add that.

[cartercr]

As for the battles, they are updated. (I will be moving them to the OP.)

As for the ban rule, I think there is only one fair way to do this, and that is a vote. Voting will end Friday the 28th, and will be deciding if the bans should be before the Registration Date, or before Round 1.

Let the voting commence!

[wonjoon0330]

I honestly think it's kinda late for voting considering people already have battled, but I'll vote anyway.

My vote goes to... These Pokemon should remain banned or I'll have to make new team ;w;

[cartercr]

Forgot to post that I beat LegendaryPokemon 6-0.

[greg0915]

I agree with wonjoon0330

My vote goes to... These Pokemon should remain banned or I'll have to make new team ;w;

[johnny18]

Originally Posted by greg0915

My vote goes to... These Pokemon should remain banned or I'll have to make new team ;w;

I agree with both of them.

[giorgos]

My vote is that these pokemon should remain banned.
Also my opponent haven't been on since 14 of October.Is this giving me a free win?

[ShinySalamence888]

I vote same as everyone elseee.

[Dusknoirs]

Yes. Have them remain banned

[ShadowExcadrill]

Yep they must still be banned.
Even though it was my powerhouse...

[cartercr]

Remember, the question is not should they be banned, the question is what date are we going to use. This will prevent further conflict. Can I assume by your answers that the ban should take effect even if the registration has begun?

[wonjoon0330]

Originally Posted by cartercr

Remember, the question is not should they be banned, the question is what date are we going to use. This will prevent further conflict. Can I assume by your answers that the ban should take effect even if the registration has begun?

Yes, we understand it perfectly and yes, ban should take the effect, because tournament haven't actually began till October 15.
Not only that, I think most of participants registered after these Pokemon were banned, so it perfectly make sense to have these Pokemon remain banned(since that's what most of people want anyway).

[cartercr]

Originally Posted by wonjoon0330

Yes, we understand it perfectly and yes, ban should take the effect, because tournament haven't actually began till October 15.
Not only that, I think most of participants registered after these Pokemon were banned, so it perfectly make sense to have these Pokemon remain banned(since that's what most of people want anyway).

I agree, I just wanted to make sure the issue was perfectly clear. From here on out. Pokemon will be banned if they are banned prior to Round 1, not the registration day.

[wonjoon0330]

Originally Posted by cartercr

I agree, I just wanted to make sure the issue was perfectly clear. From here on out. Pokemon will be banned if they are banned prior to Round 1, not the registration day.

Thank You!

[cartercr]

29th is deadline and we still have three battles remaining, should these battles not be finished, I will assign winners based on activity. (Don't sweat Salamence, you're through if it doesn't happen :D)

[wonjoon0330]

Originally Posted by cartercr

29th is deadline and we still have three battles remaining, should these battles not be finished, I will assign winners based on activity. (Don't sweat Salamence, you're through if it doesn't happen :D)

Me and aragornbird will battle today(hopefully)!

Update: Lost to aragornbird by 5-2. This must be the longest battle I ever had in my life, GG!