Graphic Rating Thread

[Sawyer]

Here, post your graphics and whatnot, and other people will rate them.

[Composer of Requiems]

Yay! Finally, someone has done this! I hope this can inject some zest into this graphics community!

[MystiKal]

Ok rate my Reborn sig, I just finished it.

[Composer of Requiems]

Originally Posted by Anubis

Ok rate my Reborn sig, I just finished it.

You know I hate number ratings so...

Sig is rather good; as a stand alone work, it is really beautiful. However, I suggest you leave only one image in your sig, because in comparison, it looks like you just used the same mould and filled it in with different stocks and colours.

Rate my D-Rex sig down there, suggest improvements.

[Sawyer]

I'm assuming it's like The One Above? i really like the effects you used there. the boxes are very pretty. x3

[Aaron5367]

Awesome, a thread like this, here are my 2 first signatures with Photoshop CS2. Rate Away .

[Pincushion]

I love them, really good for your first try, tonnes better than what I can do

Okay, can you rate some of my most worked on blinkies pwease

http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y25...bbblinkie2.gif
http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y25...PJNblinkie.gif
http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y25.../Syblinkie.gif
http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y25...pet/Lpfini.gif

[Sawyer]

all i'd say for you, Username, is for the bulbasaur one. the letter part is fine moving fast, but bulbasaur looks like he's got something in his eye and he's trying to get it out by blinking a lot really fast. xD

[Kira]

The blinkys are really cool, I so like them xD

[THIRTY-SIX]

i know its not that great but i made the pidgeot banner and the second bleach banner plz rate this one:

and:

[Composer of Requiems]

Bleach banner is very interesting just work on your cutting.
Pidgeot banner is very smooth; colour suit it well. Good job; just that I can't just used to seeing sprites on banners.

[Strawberry Delcatty]

What do you think?

[LegendaryPokemonTamer]

Oh no it's Ichigo! I like it if it was purple but it's okay

Now here's mine

< The black background wasn't my fault! It came like that when it was supposed to be white!

I'll post some more later

[Composer of Requiems]

...black?

Ouh... it's a .png. Not everyone can read .png- on some computers, png transparency (aka the white thing you were talking about) appears as a random colour instead (aka the blackness).

Since on my computer it works (I <3 Firefox), borders appears very fine. However, symmetry and using multi-stock isn't always a good thing in graphics. It gives no focal point to your image if everything's trying to grab the viewer's attention. Text is a bit hard to read... but on a whole, colour flows well.

[Sawyer]

yeah, FireFox pwns, cause then you can see all my png's x3

[Arcanine Fan 101]

heres of mine and hope you like them

[THIRTY-SIX]

dont mean to be mean xD but those are sprites. oh and i recently downloaded a few ps 7 and over brushes so i made a new bleach banner / avatar plz rate em

[Composer of Requiems]

Hmm for once, I actually don't mind seeing more than one stock on the image. It was done well except that there's a bit of white in Renji's hair. (that's his name, right? The guy with the Baboon's tail sword...)
Main problem is that I didn't realise you actually had font until I stared really closely at the "pixel art" in the corner XD

[THIRTY-SIX]

yea that just my way of saying tis mine f off, anyway i altered the banner slightly

[Sawyer]

I read the first volume of bleach, but never got the second, and i'll tell you why. i can't read Chinese, and volume 7 in english hasn't come out yet. i promised not to get anything else until Naruto vol. 7 comes out. that's how much i want it. xD whatever, that's off-topic. i really like your banner, but perhaps give us more looking time at each part of the animation. i'd like to see the detail on it. your avatar i can see part of what was on the banner, except it looks harder on the darkness and light, which is a good effect if you're trying to take part of the banner off and make it an avatar. good job is all else i can say.

LatiosLover - this is a graphics thread, not a sprite thread. try Home of the Sprites if you want to be commented upon.

EDIT: i've been asked this constantly... if this is for rating graphics, why do Nic and I and everyone make new threads? i'll tell you why. this thread was intented for aspiring artists who wanted to know how good they can get. for example, poke munna probably could make threads for his graphics now; he/she is very good. i forgot your gender, munna. *rubs chin* anyway, if you think you're ready, go ahead and make threads instead of posting here. we're trusting your judgement, but not if you're worse than you say you are. *cough*

[Stevo-kun]

Well I would like the one in my sig to be rated and criticized please XD

Stevo-Kun

[Thomas]

9/10...I don't like the red but the rst is awesome! I like how the black border fades out into the picture. Also the pixel text is great.

[Arcanine Fan 101]

well mine are avatars for here

[Kira]

I did not get that really O.o

[THIRTY-SIX]

i dont like the text sorry but i like the pattern overlay thingy 7/10 & ll was talking about :

Originally Posted by Latios Lover

heres of mine and hope you like them