The first graphic isn't exactly well-made. You've placed Kakashi too far to the right, making the whole thing look too empty. Also, the colour scheme doesn't work, and the effects on Kakashi make him stick out like brick, especially the stroke and the lightness. 6.5/10
The second graphic fails on the same basis. The animation isn't of the best quality, and the banner's too empty. The text, placement and colours need to be revised, although this one has an atmosphere. Remember to blend keep things balanced. 7/10
Third graphic: your best attempt. A fitting colour scheme for the render, effects are fine, placement is profficient. The animation's quality and placement earns your extra marks. One of your greatest downfalls is still your text. Choice of font and placement need to be fixed up. 8/10
The fourth and final banner is alright, but could be improved on several aspects. The colour scheme and motion effects are fine, but you placed the render in an awkward position, again, too far to the right. Lastly, the right side doesn't blend into the animation too well. A nice border though, and overall it's neat and organized. 7.5/10
Your overall mark for this set is: 7/10
Keep trying!