In return I can tell you that I find your OP's in your clubs to be absolutely amazing. Just taking a look at that code shows how much time you've put into making it S_S
Well that's a perfectly fine idea. It's all up to the owners whether they want a member list or not, so feel free to do so if you wish to. And yeah, that'll probably reduce the number of generic sign-up posts we have to delete, so a good idea on both parts xD
I'm considering killing the member lists in my clubs, and also remove the sign up form. Why? Too many generic signup posts.
But this doesn't mean that I won't allow new members at all. I'm thinking of something decidedly non-standard.
Just let new members jump into the program - they don't have to bother with a sign up, and let them talk directly, with the membership implied at the time they posted.