I received your email. I already told you, you can't make a club based on a game and your post was more like a guide than a fan club. In future, please check the approval updates thread to see if you club has been revoked and the reasons for it.
I've checked the new thread, I'm sorry but I still can't accept it. D: 'Legendary Pokemon' can't include things such as Charizard etc, it can only include the Pokemon that are classed as legendary in game. You need to keep your list just to those Pokemon if your club is about Legendaries :)
Ok, I saved everything as a document. I'm going to repost (sorry, I had to make tweaks, like adding the Pokemon list (which is know not all legends)). As for your question, I'll change it to make it that after no Pokèmon are left, then the rest of the Pokèmon are added. Once all are out, and you join, you can join, but you don't get a Pokemon. I doubt I would ever get that many members, but it's nice to dream.
Hi there! Before I can approve your Legendary Pokemon group, I do ask that you make a change to it. You currently have it so that each member can choose only one of the remaining Pokemon, but what happens when there aren't any Pokemon left? No more members could join D: If you'll change this, I'll approve the group. :)