At least you're not Wes... he hears a lot more of my horrible ideas then you do. He's learned to tune them out, but I don't stop it anyway. Helps me develop them more.
I have learned that having the lives of horrible people extinguished because of the only person who gave a crap about them stopped believing in them is actually a lot cooler then it should be.
Hmm... Vita ut Nex, if that one was the one with disease... Great Nightmare Fuel opportunities in there... but then again, The Cult has a guy and a thing who do unholy acts against God/Arceus...
Hmm... I'd have to say... Vita ut Nex. The premise is generally more terrifying, tbh, and I can see more things scary to the players.