A lot of your Kanto/Johto theories and ideas make me wretch (Not all of them, though!), to be honest, and I really don't like being told how to interpret certain characters that I probably know and understand better than you.
Like which ones? The only ones I've mentioned have been Blue and Silver and that was based on alternate interpretations other Gen I-II fans have had. Well I guess there was Lance's name...but the guy is still a hero regardless plus all his names are either weapons, or things like being brave and magnificent.
But, don't worry, because I'm pretty much the same in regards to Hoenn and Sinnoh, and that's okay. (As much as I gripe about Cynthia's popularity, which must annoy you, LOL.) When I talk about Hoenn and Sinnoh, I try to think about what fans of those regions would want rather than what I would want, but in the end, I'm not a fan of them, so my opinions and ideas don't count as much. It's amazing how divided this fandom can be sometimes...
It's getting worse as time goes on is all I'll say. I find it interesting how those I've talked to who don't like all the Gens tend to like their own and the one after it,but hate the one two Gen's after the starting Gen (Ex: You love Gen I and II (and hate III), I love Gen III and IV (and hate V), and my younger sister loves Gen IV and V (and she hates VI))