![]() |
{Tile/Palette Rating Thread}
Introduction: The purpose for this thread is so that hackers can post maps with their tiles/palettes here, and we can rate them, so they can know what we all think of their hack's looks. I thought of making this thread when I wanted an opinion of my tiles/palettes for my hack, and I didn't want to make a thread for my hack yet. Rules: → No stealing palettes/tiles, unless they are public, or the maker gives you permission. → No posting maps with stolen tiles/palettes. → No off-topic posts, or posts without the proper structure. → No posting of tiles/palettes that are part of a ROMBase, unless you make MAJOR changes. → Don't post just tiles. If you post, make sure you post something that is actually inserted into a ROM. Posting Structure: Map Name: The name of your map. Base ROM: The base this map was made on i.e. Fire Red, Ruby, ect. Comments: Any comments you have on your map. Mapshot: The map. Credits: Who made the tiles,palettes, ect. Rating Structure: Map Rated: A quote of the map you are rating. Rating: The rating you give the tiles/palettes. Comments: Any comments you have for the maker. Suggestions: Anything you can suggest for the maker to make the tiles/palettes better. |
This is a great idea.
Map Name: Not really got one... ROM Base: Firered Comments... None really. I made this as a test Mapshot:http://i76.servimg.com/u/f76/13/26/50/72/map_210.png Cresits: Kyledove for the tiles and pallettes, me for inserting, Zeikku for the house. |
So the map itsself (structure, placement, space usage etc) isnt rated, only the tiles and palettes?
thats sweet Map Name: Doesnt have a name, its not even a real map xD Rom Base: Firered Comments: Desert Tiles for my Hack MapShot: http://nareas.na.ohost.de/lof/desert.png Credits: Dshayabusa, Serg!o & PHO for some tiles |
Neti, I really like those tiles :D Especially the mountains ^^
I have to rate it right? Rating: 9/10 |
Quote:
Overall 8/10 |
Quote:
Tiles: 9/10 Palettes: 6/10 Quote:
Palettes: 7/10 Tiles: 10/10 P.S. Fangking Omega made the majority of those tiles. |
Dude, I was actually thinking of making something like this! xD
Quote:
Palettes: 7.5/10~ As for the tiles, to me, they are perfect, because Kyledove and Zeikku tiles are really good mixed together. ;D Tiles: 10/10~ Quote:
The PokéMart's door palette is, as I said before, really ugly, and bright. Palettes: 9.5/10~ The tiles are perfect, I also like that little tower at the middle left of the map. It looks good facing diagonally. :) Though, it's shaped a little weird to me, but... Tiles: 9.5/10~ |
Spoiler:
|
Okay, here is the starting map fro Tensai's Secret. (Map isn't final, but this is the Tile/palette rating thread! xD)
Spoiler:
|
Quote:
Tiles 9/10 It has a beautiful nature theme to it. Quote:
Tiles 8/10 The metal rooms are an eyesore, but still impressive. Quote:
Tiles 9/10 Work very well with the palletes Quote:
Tiles 7/10 the concrete is an eyesore and is also looks like 1st generation. |
Quote:
Honestly look at the shadows under the trees, they are completely messed up. Also those paths are WAY too bright. The stairs are too bright as well, but not as obvious. Anyway... Fix those shadows and make everything darker. Then I will rate you decently. :P |
Spoiler:
|
Well people being giving complaints about the paleltes. so i revised alot and was wondering if it's better or not.
http://img175.imageshack.us/img175/738/aswe34jj5.png |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Zeikku's looks like that except with a little size difference and a bolder color. |
old tiles
1 Attachment(s)
Here's some old tiles I made a while ago(trees only)..
|
Quote:
rate my tiles though http://i197.photobucket.com/albums/aa92/badman10_2007/lol-13.png |
Quote:
Tiles: 8/10 - The trees look great(except for the short one)! The grasses look nice as well. The signposts look pretty good(ONE IS MINE #@$%(lol(joke))) besides the big blocky one. The buildings look good, especially the gym. The mountains are great! The boulder-ish platina rip is kinda...bad-ish. The water is great(I WAS GONNA DO THAT @#$^(Lool))! The paths are wonderful as well. Palettes: 9/10 - I like the palettes on everything except the house. It looks a bit dark to me, Idk. |
Quote:
10/10 Quote:
7-8/10 |
Quote:
The tree tiles are amazing. :3 A bit small, bit very unique. Tiles: 10/10~ The palettes on the trees suit them perfectly as well. The mountain palettes are pretty good, but resemble as Alistair's palettes. But they are okay. Never cared for those palettes much. Palettes: 9/10~ |
Quote:
The trees' pallets aren't like the real Pokemon games', and they have good shading, I like them. Also the house wood is lovely, so is the big iron rock thing and the paths. Good job. Tiles 8/10 I don't like the tree tiles, some of them are too...fat. The Gym, house and grass are OK. |
Map name: not important
http://www.shrani.si/f/2R/xW/2tJNvMzS/surprise.png Please rate the palletes! |
Quote:
Palettes: 9/10 Tiles: 6/10(mainly because of the tree and that building/structure needs shading) |
Hello Thread!!
Map Name: MOUNTIDE TOWN Base ROM: Fire Red Comments: I know there is no town sign, however i added that and i have a updated map right open now! And I changed the map, however this never made a difference to the pallet! Mapshot: http://i438.photobucket.com/albums/qq105/N3xtone/MOUNTIDETOWN.jpg |
Quote:
i love them accept the mountains + water, i don't think they go well together. 7/10 tiles: there good but the rocks look horrible, i think you should insert new ones and even a new house. 8/10 |
My new rombase, in the resources...
I need opinions on it ^^ http://i244.photobucket.com/albums/gg19/Mecharatchet/disturbedsforest.png |
@Disturbed:Tiles: 9/10 - {Good}, The tiles are fine, except for the trees on the right. They seem funky to me. Palettes: 10/10 - {Excellent}, I've always loved soft palettes. :3 |
1 Attachment(s)
I don't want the actual tiles rated, more the mixture and the palettes I made.
See attachment please. |
Quote:
So's here are the ratings: Tiles 10/10: It cannot be better in can only be more perfect. Palletes 9.8: The tiles are perfect, but I don't like the brown flowers. And the house wood seems too dark in my opinion.. |
I need an opinion on tiles so far. I know that the grass is pretty much ruined, so I'm gonna recolour that at some point... Anyway, these are the tiles in a map:
http://i39.*.com/14y6d0o.png |
Spoiler:
heres a mapshot form my first hack.. please rate the pallets and the map as well |
Map Name: Diego Town
Base ROM: Fire Red Comments: A small farming town after you venture through Almat Cave, this town actually hosts Battle tournament #1, that is what the building to the right leads to ;) http://i224.photobucket.com/albums/dd251/hockeypanda32/Picture20-2.png |
Quote:
Holy crap thats amazing, goes together well. However, use the little rocks and medium rock made for mountain tiles over the mountains. They look a little plain ;) Quote:
both on trees. barely noticable block error though. |
Here
|
Quote:
|
|
Quote:
Tiles: 8/10 Palettes: 6/10 Comments: I really like the trees, they are amazing, and the palettes flow with them well. The only issue I have is the tiles and palettes of the mountains, they seem a little odd. The ground and wild grass pals are kinda...suckish. They don't mix very well at all. Suggestions: Make the ground pals flow more with the trees and mountains, and make the grass the same pal as the trees, or close to the same. |
Quote:
Everything seems to clash together, and it sways from light to dark throughout the whole entire map. The things that were inserted look poorly inserted too. Also, use you're own palettes, if you don't, give credit >_> Tiles - 6/10 Palettes- 4/10 EDIT: Heres mine! It's kinda unfinished, but I need to know how it looks so far :) http://i244.photobucket.com/albums/gg19/Mecharatchet/testmap.png |
@Disturbed:
Tiles: 9/10, loving the Alistair trees and paths Pal's: 7/10, The beach pal is a lil weirdish. Overall though great job! ------------------- Here is an update on the palettes and some new tile entries! The new tiles for Underground http://img296.imageshack.us/img296/5434/omgfantastoctz0.png |
Quote:
Loving the mountain, but whats up with the rock. Im like Ugh.. Nicely done. Tiles: Loving the nice way you did this. Nicely inserted. Pal's: They are Great to. But the grass tile. The plain grass, not the Wild battle one.. its ugh.. the black thing is Ugh. |
Fina update! Latimar Isle home to pokeschool owner Oak. You start here in the new Underground
http://img401.imageshack.us/img401/4992/awesomezl3.png |
Quote:
Maybe use the one from Oblivion? The other tiles are great (and well-inserted, too) Keep it up! EDIT: Can somebody rate my tiles, too? http://www.shrani.si/f/47/B0/lbJq0o8/1/grand-valley-10.png |
@Tropical Sunlight,
your tiles are very nice except the mountain pal's could be a teensy bit darker. Tiles, 9/10: Rhevarhe Dugh (However you spell his name) has great tiles that you inserted great. Palettes, 8/10: Great pal's on trees and grass. You just need to darken up the mountains |
im just going to post a link to my game page....no one saw it yet..http://www.pokecommunity.com/showthread.php?t=166205
but ill post my best map/ palate http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk142/amassenburg/Route1.jpg |
@amassenburg:
Tiles: 0/10 - no new tiles Palletes: 2/10 - The palletes are really not good. It doesn't flow together well. Try having a little changed palletes. |
http://img187.imageshack.us/img187/4350/route1xk2.png
Someone rate these. Credits; iPro; Pal's [Edited by me] Ozumas; Tree |
@пзо:
The new tree tiles are not well inserted. Otherwise, you should change Pal 5. |
Fine.
Fine, I get many complaints about my tree.
So i Changed it all up; http://www.freeimagehosting.net/uploads/4a2197b1d0.png |
Those aren't your trees, give credit.
|
Okaz this is my first post here so i might as well make it last
http://i40.photobucket.com/albums/e206/hackimon13/Map.jpg I think that the grass need to be darkend but I just don't know Any ideas? Credit to Alistar for the small tree and Wesly FG for the other tiles |
hey,can anyone rate mine?dont mind about the map:
http://i397.photobucket.com/albums/pp52/trebuh12345/map.jpg |
@Mac_Mini: Sorry, but the thouses are not inserted well. You use project Marnian, right? Look at my hack, I have the same houses and they're inserted well.
Tiles: 8/10 Palletes: 5/10 @Rigel_101: Nice tiles! Everything is... soo perfect! Tiles: 9.99/10 Palletes: 9.99/10 |
Thanks,btw i made another one,for the resources pls rate it
http://i397.photobucket.com/albums/pp52/trebuh12345/hey.jpg I Think it is not good.. |
Quote:
But anyway, it's nice. Nice and simple. And that's what I like. |
This is all the tiles i've ripped and inserted so far. They're all from Platinum, it's not 100% but I think it's a good start. (The small houses are there because this isn't a big town).
And yes, I made the shadows actual shadows, not just grey :> http://img228.imageshack.us/img228/5757/startingtownbl1.png |
Quote:
Tiles: 10/10 inserted, 7/10 good (because Nintendo made them, I can't blame you for that Palletes: It's a Platinum rombase... |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Please tell me what you guys think about the transition from mountain to grass tiles :) There wasn't any premade my kyledove (that I know) so I attempted to make some of my own...
http://i48.photobucket.com/albums/f246/1918293456/transtiles.png |
Quote:
These are almost perfect, However some edges in my eyes look wierd. Palettes; .. This is a Rombase I think. So I cant rate these. Carry on you are getting better. - My Map. Please Rate; I had to jpeg.. Tinypic wouldent have it.. Im trying to make a alistiar tile hack. http://i44.*.com/343ndr6.jpg Edit; Credit to Alistiar. |
Quote:
|
Hey,i made this a little while ago..i used kyledoves'
all tile are on tileset 1. http://i397.photobucket.com/albums/pp52/trebuh12345/qwg3g.jpg i rushed it,so i think its not really good.pls rate it thanks. |
I bring you a map:
http://i224.photobucket.com/albums/dd251/hockeypanda32/Awesome.png?t=1233711727 All inserted by me. Thanks TB Pro and Alistair for tiles and pals |
Quote:
Why? I really love the lab and the house. They are wonderful sprites. The two trees, however, do not fit well together. They just look really awkward with each other. Palettes: 9/10 Why? I really like soft palettes and the grass is just a great color in my opinion. The colors of the buildings are great as well, I really like it. The trees are a wonderful shade of green too. |
Quote:
Because those are the exact tiles from Michel1's rombase and pallettes Anyway I'll rate it anyway 10\10 tiles Why: Kyledove has an incredible style. Backde up by peyi and Alistars tiles there perfect. 10\10 Palletes I can't really comment on the palletes. They just fit it too perfectly |
Ok I inserted a bunch of new stuff!
http://i224.photobucket.com/albums/dd251/hockeypanda32/2Town-1.png |
Yeah
Map name; Route one [old]
Map of; Fire Red Comments; Please tell me what to darken and lighten. fankoo. http://i42.*.com/1zwky21.jpg |
new
These are my new palettes in "Pokemon Guardian of the Sky"
Rate plz. kthx. http://i42.*.com/wl6e8l.jpg |
Quote:
|
Rom Base: Pokemon Firered
Comments: Don't bother saying the roofpallettes don't fit with the other pallettes, I simply haven't changed them yet, xD. Map Shot: http://img201.imageshack.us/img201/703/eastshorevillagedb5.png |
Quote:
Anyways on to my rating. Palettes: I love the brightness and trees which look professionally inserted. I would give you a 9/10 Tiles: Well I cant see much new but the trees and wildlife stuff. But if that is all I am rating I give it a 9/10 ;) |
Well, I fully finished my first tileset yesterday, the desert tileset.
http://i183.photobucket.com/albums/x33/heimdallinc/001-28.png http://i183.photobucket.com/albums/x33/heimdallinc/002-23.png Note: The crappy waterfalls of sand actually have a completely different animation - I just haven't loaded the tiles into the tileset, because it would be useless to do that anyhow with the exception of these map pictures =P What are your opinions? |
http://www.shrani.si/f/19/ZI/2XCPyfl2/dracoville-10.png
Please rate the newly inserted tiles... The well and the houses and the cave door |
Please rate this:
http://i237.photobucket.com/albums/ff272/legolunatic99/Platinum_Tree.png Platinum tree with Kyledove's palette. |
http://www.shrani.si/f/2s/tI/1MUBltfL/53-pure-forest.png
My tileset for Pure Forest, credits to iPro, Zeikku and rhevarhe_duh. |
Tiles by me:
http://i309.photobucket.com/albums/kk368/Gary_hack93/NuevaLaminadeGary-1.png credits if use |
Very good tiles gary 8.5/10 overall, some pals are a bit weird.
My inside tiles ^^, I inserted them today :D http://i224.photobucket.com/albums/dd251/hockeypanda32/InsidesLabdone.png |
just a few fr/lg tiles that i revamped in kyledove style
http://i105.photobucket.com/albums/m225/bitrzo/FRLGDPTILES.jpg |
Palletes: 5/10
I don't like the colors that much, they burn my eyes (not litterally), and they kind of hurt. Tiles: 10/10 I LOVE THE TILES! They are amazing, I think they are very beautiful and will look useful in games. |
more tiles
the bridge and dirt to grass tiles are new http://i105.photobucket.com/albums/m225/bitrzo/tiletestmap1copy.jpg and heres another load of new tiles some millitary based ones and some trees based around some of kyles but dont worry they are different http://i105.photobucket.com/albums/m225/bitrzo/militarytiletestcopy.jpg and please remember dont use these tiles |
Credits: Wesley FG for the tiles and palettes.
Comments: There will be more tiles later on. http://i428.photobucket.com/albums/qq3/Hiche_Tamer/Snowtiles.png |
Quote:
But that's not the point. Are you going to release a rombase with it? Good luck! |
Nope. This set is a part of a hack I am doing. I am including all the tiles I can find in it xD
Thanks btw. |
http://www.shrani.si/f/3X/uo/1fM6f2nx/ruby-english.png
This is made in Ruby, but if you think it's good enough I can insert it to Turquoise. |
http://i428.photobucket.com/albums/qq3/Hiche_Tamer/4.png
P.S: This may seem like the tiles >Dante< inserted, but actually they are different. Only the same palette. |
Quote:
maybe... but you can't use my palette. please remove it. |
Sorry >Dante<. I will change them. Btw I only used the same tree palettes. The PC, and mart are mine. xD But anyways, I will change the tree palettes.
Changed the palettes. http://i428.photobucket.com/albums/qq3/Hiche_Tamer/5-2.png |
2 Attachment(s)
My first tiles, a tree. Made 32x32 because I prefer them smaller.
EDIT: Added mapshot. |
The pallet is open source, because it is exactly the same as the one on the WAH tilesheet.
|
Please rate the tiles they're all inserted by me ;]
Credits: Alistair, WAH Spoiler:
|
Well hello,Todays a happy day for me.
http://i40.photobucket.com/albums/e206/hackimon13/maps.jpg Credit to Kyledove for the tiles |
Quote:
They look fabulous! 9.999999/10 |
Quote:
I have some more stuff http://i40.photobucket.com/albums/e206/hackimon13/map-2.jpg and http://i40.photobucket.com/albums/e206/hackimon13/map-3.jpg |
Very good work surf! ill give you a 9.5/10
very impressive as always. Heres mine:pls rate these Spoiler:
Note:If anybody wants to help me with my hack then Pm me.showing some proofs will be good |
post of ~Trebuh~
Well Nice Titlescreen and Nice Intro but i can't be rate =/ So i'll rate your map! Tiles: 10/10 Palettes: 10/10 The Tiles and Palettes fit to each other,.! |
Could someone rate my tree please?? :pirate:
Quote:
|
Okay I know this is against the rules, but why should I submit a new thread when this one will work just fine? If you close this, I'll make a new one, but really, this would be much simpler.
Map Name: N/A Base ROM: FireRed Comments: Well I've been gone for a while, and I decided to try hacking again. Worked on tiles first, and I think it turned out pretty good. Mapshot: Spoiler:
Creds: Kyledove - Tiles, Alistair - Tiles, Rhevarhe_Duh - Tiles, Me - Pals |
this thread should be stickeyed it gained so much popularity in such a short time the only thing I dont like is asking for a rating when you using a rom base or partial rom base there your tiles and it defeats the purpose
|
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:23 AM. |
![]()
© 2002 - 2018 The PokéCommunity™, pokecommunity.com.
Pokémon characters and images belong to The Pokémon Company International and Nintendo. This website is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Nintendo, Creatures, GAMEFREAK, The Pokémon Company or The Pokémon Company International. We just love Pokémon.
All forum styles, their images (unless noted otherwise) and site designs are © 2002 - 2016 The PokéCommunity / PokéCommunity.com.
PokéCommunity™ is a trademark of The PokéCommunity. All rights reserved. Sponsor advertisements do not imply our endorsement of that product or service. User generated content remains the property of its creator.
Acknowledgements
Use of PokéCommunity Assets
vB Optimise by DragonByte Technologies Ltd © 2023.