The PokéCommunity Forums

The PokéCommunity Forums (https://www.pokecommunity.com/index.php)
-   Previous Generations (https://www.pokecommunity.com/forumdisplay.php?f=200)
-   -   4th Gen Heart Gold, Soul Silver, Spirit Crystal? (https://www.pokecommunity.com/showthread.php?t=179598)

TERRA#493 June 2nd, 2009 2:44 PM

when we think logical, it will gives NO crystal-remake.

R/L/Y - Remakes are FR and LG but it gives no Remake of Yellow.
G/S/C - Remakes are HG and SS but it will give no Remake of Crystal.

Mew~ June 3rd, 2009 8:10 AM

i dont think they will make a remake of crystal, it might be lyk how they didnt make a remake 4 yellow

Spinosaurus June 3rd, 2009 9:26 AM

A Crystal remake?

For some reason I dont think there will be any since Kris isnt playlable,Fr/Lg didnt have a Y/B remakes with it and Nintendo didnt even said anything about a Crystal remake.

So doubt it.

Keyaki June 3rd, 2009 1:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cubed (Post 4662065)
So They're in the making of HG/SS. Now allmost every pokemon game has a game which combines both of them together, they combined gold and silver to make crystal, which comes to my conclusion...

What will crystal's remake name be called? I think it might be called spirit crystal.

Leave your thoughts as a reply to this thread

PS: Please feed my Pokemonz in my Signature :D.


Soul and Spirit is the same thing >>


Quote:

R/B/G/Y - Remakes are FR and LG but it gives no Remake of Yellow.

Artemis June 3rd, 2009 1:32 PM

Honestly, there isn't much need for a Crystal or Yellow remake right now. Its already been stated that no new remakes were being planned at the moment either. Everything they would want to add in a Crystal Remake, they can simply put into HeartGold and SoulSilver. I mean yes, Crystal does come with a bit of a different plot than what Gold and Silver had in a way, and they probably won't convert much of these remakes to match that of Crystal's original plot, but it doesn't mean somethings that were added in Crystal can't be included in the new HeartGold and SoulSilver. I think having a Crystal remake would be too much anyway and would just keep back time for us to move on into the next generation. Though, I'm hoping they take their time with the next set of generation games, I think HeartGold and SoulSilver would pretty much keep people busy at the time. Plus, Platinum isn't considered an older third party game of Diamond and Platinum as yet. People are still trying to get the game, even here in the states. So, I consider having a Crystal or even Yellow remake isn't at all necessary. Though, I wouldn't be surprised in the [near] future someone will come up with a ROM Hack of a renewed Crystal like some have said. It is pretty possible for that to come to part, but I doubt GameFreak themselves will spend the money to remake Crystal when we can get everything we need in HeartGold and SoulSilver.

iTzKaizer June 3rd, 2009 1:36 PM

Reasons why there's not going to be a third game of the two remakes:
-It didn't happen in FR/LG.
-Heart Gold/Soul Silver already include improvements of Crystal
-There's not that much to add anyway, since improvements are there, and Crystal basically was made to actualize the games.
-Crystal was a special version, exclusive to the GBC games.

Why it can be made:
-Story is different, since it focuses on suicune.
-Form to obtain Ho-oH is different, and more difficult.
-IN G/S you catch all the three dogs in the wild, in Crystal only Entei and Raikou.
-The introduce of Crystal can bring back Chris, who was excluded from HG/SS.

exteradude June 3rd, 2009 4:16 PM

I'm totally unbiased, but I'll give some information to think about when making your statement:

Gold and Silver had no Female Trainer Option, and Kris was introduced into Crystal.

HeartGold and SoulSilver had the same Male Trainer Option as in G/S[/C], and they created another Female Trainer.

Where did Kris go?

You can assume that this new Female Player is a revamp of Kris.
Or you can assume that this is a new Female Player, and wonder what happened to Kris.
Or you can assume anything else you like, as long as it is logical.

I told you, I'm totally unbiased. I'm just giving some simple facts for you all to keep in mind.

~Exteradude

PS: I'm referring to Kris as the female trainer in Crystal.

titodsik1 June 3rd, 2009 4:39 PM

I dont think they will make a remake of crystal cuz for now Platinum is the main game right now

Shem June 3rd, 2009 5:55 PM

Well, if you haven't noticed, The Main-stream pokemon games have a pattern so far

2 version then a third version for every generation.

Now we've seen one set of remakes, so there's no pattern for those yet, but since there was no yellow remake for FR LG, it's fair to assume there will not be a crystal remake.

exteradude June 3rd, 2009 6:22 PM

Remaining unbiased, just saying:

Patterns can or cannot be broken. Just supposing that Game Freak/Nintendo will keep its pattern on forever is not and cannot be used as an argument. Just because they did not release a remake of the Yellow Version in the past for FireRed/LeafGreen doesn't mean that they will or will not do the same thing with HeartGold/SoulSilver.

For those saying that every two games will have a third, FireRed/LeafGreen proves that wrong, breaking that theory.

For those saying that FireRed/LeafGreen having no third will lead to HeartGold/SoulSilver having no third is still not true evidence.

Patterns, when used in solid evidence, must be used as a reference to something happening over a long, unchangeable period of time. By unchangeable, that means no force can change it. For example, no matter what, Gravity will still exist on this planet. What comes up must come down.

When patterns involving possible human intervention are used as an argument, that argument is false. Unless there is a gigantic force or situation that would lead Game Freak/Nintendo to be ultimately forced to keep the same remake pattern as other games in the past, Nintendo MAY or MAY NOT break the remake pattern, and MAY or MAY NOT release a third remake game.

Using patterns to predict the future depends on the situation. This is not a situation to use patterns as a reference.

Shem June 3rd, 2009 6:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by exteradude (Post 4712126)
Using patterns to predict the future depends on the situation. This is not a situation to use patterns as a reference.

I concur, there haven't been enough remakes to establish a pattern, let alone that game freak can do whatever it wants and doesn't have to make/follow a pattern if it doesn't want to.

But still, I seriously doubt it we will see a Crystal remake.

exteradude June 3rd, 2009 6:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Darkai (Post 4712184)
I concur, there haven't been enough remakes to establish a pattern, let alone that game freak can do whatever it wants and doesn't have to make/follow a pattern if it doesn't want to.

But still, I seriously doubt it we will see a Crystal remake.

That is also a good solid response that can add to mine. You win 1 Internetz. As for your opinion, I'm remaining completely unbiased in situations such as this.

Skymin June 3rd, 2009 8:07 PM

Yee, no crystal remake me thinks. There was no yellow remake, as cool as that would be, so don't expect a Crystal.

For names? Spirit Crystal was pretty cool.

Patatas Fritas June 4th, 2009 9:59 AM

I really doubt there will be a Crystal remake, as much as I would like it, there isnt any need, they didnt remake Yellow, they incoperated features from it into newer games, such as HG/SS, and, they will likley inclue features from Crystal in these remakes.

PokemonLeagueChamp June 4th, 2009 4:40 PM

Not a chance for a remake of Crystal because:
1. No remake of Yellow, why would they remake Crystal?
2. FR/LG had elements of Yellow incorporated, HG/SS will likely be the same.
3. There is very little difference between G/S/C. The only major difference is the subplot with the guy(forgot his name)trying to track down Suicune, which, again, will probably end up in HG/SS.

Ellie June 4th, 2009 4:52 PM

As others have said, the little Crystal extras can just be incorporated into HgSs without really changing much. Plus at this point, the games were already made without a "need" for them (more Pokemon unobtainable or something), so I don't think Nintendo would push their luck in trying for another game without a need for it. It's still possible... just not likely.

Sydian June 4th, 2009 6:06 PM

Crystal will more than likely not get remade. Yellow didn't, so I don't expect Yellow to be getting on.

Alex June 4th, 2009 6:43 PM

I highly doubt Crystal will be remade. Crystal introduced the Battle Tower and Gender feature, which both Heart Gold and Soul Silver will have. So, I doubt they're going to remake Crystal version. After all, they never remade Yellow version.

Artemis June 4th, 2009 6:52 PM

Besides the point of not remaking Yellow back when FireRed and LeafGreen were created, Crystal remake might not be as popular as HeartGold and SoulSilver I would think. I mean for one, everything you had in Crystal [or almost everything] could possibly be mentioned or included in HeartGold and SoulSilver as others have stated. It isn't like Suicune won't be available even if the plot doesn't revolve around it. Also, with Kanto being introduced with a semi-Battle Tower in FireRed and LeafGreen and this taking place three years before Johto, I would expect to see one again. It is already been seen with a new girl that has been added like what Crystal first introduced, and even though it may not be Kris herself, they still gave it a shot for something new. The starter following you, a great feature from Yellow brought back into a [hopefully] a great remake. The game is basically differenciated from others as it included not only a few character designs from previous game characters, but game features too. All old and new, these remakes are serving a good purpose, and even without a Crystal Remake coming [maybe, maybe not] we should still be pretty satisfied with what we're getting now.

Ray Maverick June 4th, 2009 11:22 PM

I don't think Spirit Crystal.Why?Cause Soul & Spirit have the same meaning.

Basically,i don't think there will be a crystal remake.

blueblur155 June 5th, 2009 5:40 AM

if i had to guess....since nintendo never came out w/ a remake for yellow, ther will NOT be a remake for crystal

Shiny June 5th, 2009 5:44 AM

I highly doubt it considering the soul & spirit are the same thing, at least in my opinion.

Giraffes? Giraffes! June 5th, 2009 5:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jubilee (Post 4716856)
I highly doubt it considering the soul & spirit are the same thing, at least in my opinion.

They are the same, just with different box art and different pokemon to be caught in game, so i agree with you.

Anyway, i don't believe there will be a spirit crystal. Mostly because they are remakes.

GuruIPB June 5th, 2009 12:39 PM

it can be a chance that it can be spirt to

Sonic2000 June 5th, 2009 12:44 PM

Uh...yeah::disappoin sorry. Pokemon crystal probably won't have- well, it might if everyone requests one. Find people on your side and get them to request that.

There won't be a remake of crystallaugh:face it!

Norcinu June 5th, 2009 4:53 PM

There's sure to be a Crystal version comming out and it's gonna be so awesome and new!



>_> Just wanted to say something different to everyone else.

Infernape June 5th, 2009 6:25 PM

Theres gonna be a remake of crystal because nintendo always comes out with a third version of two already realesed games. Yellow was to Red and Blue, Crystal was t Gold And Silver , and so on and so on. So i think and hope the come out with a crystal remake. If not a crystal remake, then a third version with a differnet title.

Sweet Smoochum June 5th, 2009 6:32 PM

I would love if they came out with a remake of Crystal. :) Especially if Kris was in the game. That would make so many Kris fans happy. Yellow version was called "Special Pikachu Edition." (I have the game.) We can't say for sure that Nintendo's not going to do it. Look at all those people who said that GS wasn't going to be remade and there is no need for it. Even if it doesn't come out in 2010/11, if enough people beg Nintendo to remake all the 3rd versions of the games, they just might do it. I'm trying to be optimistic about this. So please, don't be harsh towards me.

[[[Even if there wasn't one, who's to say that a good hacker can't hack HG/SS to add Kris, Eusine, and Suicune into the game? I'll even help the person if they do it. :) (I'll make the sprites. ^_^ I've made overworlds of Eusine DP styled.)]]]

Artemis June 5th, 2009 6:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Apollo Wildhart (Post 4718658)
Theres gonna be a remake of crystal because nintendo always comes out with a third version of two already realesed games. Yellow was to Red and Blue, Crystal was t Gold And Silver , and so on and so on. So i think and hope the come out with a crystal remake. If not a crystal remake, then a third version with a differnet title.

The third part of a game is when the game is something new on the shelf, as in a new generation game. The thing is HeartGold and SoulSilver aren't new games, they're remakes. This wouldn't need a third counterpart such as Crystal, because anything they'd want in a Crystal Remake can simply be added into the Gold and Silver remakes. Plus, FireRed and LeafGreen came out, but they never got that third party game [meaning, no Yellow Remake was ever made]. It isn't something needed for remakes really. Though, it is kind of a different story I guess when it comes to the newer Generation of a game.

I wouldn't say it is impossible though as GameFreak and Nintendo have the title to do as they please with the games, but this is just my own opinion on what I think. Also, as GymLeaderLily stated, even if GameFreak themselves don't come out with one, who;s to say a ROM Hacker won't take the challenge to make one? I think a lot of people will enjoy it [at least those who play on ROMs]. Some people did say a Gold and Silver remake wasn't possible, but it's coming and I thought it would have eventually seeing FRLG come out a few years ago. It is just that with no Yellow version following it, this just makes me think a Crystal remake wouldn't arrive [Who knows though].

EDIT: Rather than creating another post, I agree with you Kurausu Varuka. I'd like for them to work on Gen. V after this over a Crystal remake as it's usually due for a cameo of a 5th Gen Pokémon in the anime by now. Anyway, a 5th Gen game over the remake would be best, and hopefully they'll take their time with it and come up with mouth watering ideas.

Giraffes? Giraffes! June 5th, 2009 6:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by f l a s h (Post 4718700)
The third part of a game is when the game is something new on the shelf, as in a new generation. The thing is HeartGold and SoulSilver aren't new games, they're remakes. This wouldn't need a third counterpart such as Crystal, because anything they'd want in a Crystal Remake can simply be added into the Gold and Silver remakes. Plus, FireRed and LeafGreen came out, but they never got that third party game. It isn't something needed for remakes really. Though, it is kind of a different story I guess when it comes to the newer Generation of a game.

I'd prefer they get right to work on the 5th generation after they finish the remakes... Not make another port with updated sprites and more to do....

Bigdog June 5th, 2009 7:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurausu Varuka (Post 4718725)
I'd prefer they get right to work on the 5th generation after they finish the remakes... Not make another port with updated sprites and more to do....

It would be nice if Gamefreak made another TCG game because they were awesome and challenging in my opinion and I just wished that they came out with more.

OokamiShipper June 6th, 2009 6:35 AM

Maayybee not...because for FRLG, they never remade Yellow, did they?
So, not to be pessimistic or anything, but I doubt it. ^^;

scotland950 June 6th, 2009 11:38 AM

they wont be making a crystle remake

they didnt make a yellow remake to go with leaf green and fire red

Serene Grace June 6th, 2009 11:49 AM

I think that the Crystal remake will get released because I know Heart Gold and Soul Silver is going to be a huge success. Nintendo would want to continue that by making a remake and getting even more money.

It's all about the benjamins baby.

Artemis June 6th, 2009 11:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Unbreakable (Post 4721671)
I think that the Crystal remake will get released because I know Heart Gold and Soul Silver is going to be a huge success. Nintendo would want to continue that by making a remake and getting even more money.

It's all about the benjamins baby.

This is true that if HeartGold and SoulSilver brings in a lot money, they'll want to continue on. Except, it wouldn't have to a Crystal remake to be a big hit. Simply the next generation of games will have a large number on sales, possible more than a Crystal remake as well. The reason why I say this, is because people will have HeartGold and SoulSilver for their fun in Johto, and yes, Crystal would be great too, but a new generation game seems probably when it comes to brining in more money for the company. This is personally what I think, and to me it seems very probable too.

Plus, if you look at it, DPPt had a higher raise on sales than FireRed and LeafGreen, even though so many people at that time wanted the remake for the original Kanto games. Then, came Platinum, another Sinnoh game, but still the newer 4th Generation which had a raise on sales as well. I think they are simply doing this to follow the new pattern they began and to keep the old and new players interested. Knowing Gold and Silver was popular and wanted by so many fans as a remake, this may be successful enough while they begin their next generation project.

Poliwhirl#1 June 6th, 2009 11:55 AM

I would love for there to be a new Crystal but it is obvious there wont be one.
If they made a Crystal remake I bet some people would love it but others might think it is a thing just to make more money and complain

Dr. James June 6th, 2009 12:46 PM

I don' think they will make a remake of Crystal, but I think they would put Crystal's events in HG/SS, like the better-run off of the Legendary Beasts.

exteradude June 6th, 2009 1:43 PM

[Still Unbiased]

If they release a remake of the Crystal Version, I hope that they add more features than the usual, since HG/SS will have a lot of features as well. Perhaps they could add subplots that have nothing to do with the main plot, or add some information on the Legendary Beasts.

If they don't release a remake of the Crystal Version, I hope that they'll at least add the Suicune Subplot, the features introduced in Crystal, and perhaps some new, unheard of features.

I'm not saying that these will happen, I just hope. Also, everyone keep in mind that just because there was no remake of Yellow, that doesn't mean that Nintendo won't release a remake of the Crystal Version. They might, they might not.

Pingouin_7 June 6th, 2009 2:03 PM

I would personnaly like to see a Crystal remake come in. But I'll do without if they decide not to remake it.

Blaziquaza June 7th, 2009 5:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LishaKara (Post 4663439)
Well, I doubt there will be a remake of Crystal, seeing as there wasn't a remake of Yellow.

Really, I think that rather than going by JUST G/S, they will most likely include elements of Crystal into both remakes. It would make more sense. I mean, this IS a deluxe version after all, so they will probably go in that direction anyways.

Why Yellow wasn't made as a remake,is because basically look at what was in it.You get a Pikachu,it follows you around.Duh!

Haza June 7th, 2009 7:01 PM

Spirt or Mind both do not fit in. U guys are thinking of Mind, Body & Soul

Norcinu June 8th, 2009 12:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bigdog (Post 4719058)
It would be nice if Gamefreak made another TCG game because they were awesome

D: Man, would that be a dream come true!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Unbreakable (Post 4721671)
It's all about the benjamins baby.

Quote:

Originally Posted by f l a s h (Post 4721691)
Plus, if you look at it, DPPt had a higher raise on sales than FireRed and LeafGreen, even though so many people at that time wanted the remake for the original Kanto games.

You two bring up good points 'cause all this comes down to the money and profits. Making a Crystal remake won't have that much higher sales, if at all but a brand new generation *shrudder* would.

/: There goes my hopes and dreams.

Artemis June 8th, 2009 5:47 AM

I wouldn't give up on the chances of a Spirit Crystal, or something of that nature. If you enjoy playing the ROMs that Hackers create, then I'm sure one of them may end up making a Crystal update with it. Except, yes, the comapny is about bringing in the highest money income they can get, while still keeping their fans hooked. It is likely a Crystal Remake won't sell as much as HeartGold and SoulSilver at this time. Though, with the new release of a new generation, then I'd say it is pretty probable over a Crystal revamp and Nintendo and GameFreak knows they'll get a higher raise in sales. Not to mention, even though some may not want a 5th Gen as yet, it is very predicatable they may still end up buying it. Why? Because like Nintendo and GameFreak wants to do is keep their fans attached to the franchise and surprisingly, with all our complaints we may have, it actually works.

Not to mention, I would rather keep Crystal and Yellow a priceless original as I wouldn't want anything to be messed or tampered with too much. They are good as is, and older gamers would still enjoy playing them now as Yellow and Crystal without a remake messing a few things up.

uhhh6677 June 8th, 2009 1:34 PM

I don't think it will happen because they didn't remake Yellow, but it's possible.

Radial TIA June 8th, 2009 2:24 PM

Most likely not a Crystal.I would LOVE it if they were going to make a Crystal remake with the Gold and Silver remakes but they probably won't make it.I mean, if they were going to make it then they probably woud have put the remake name with the Heart Gold and Soul Silver names when the announcement came up.

But I do hope they will make a remake of it.

Chibaymega12 June 8th, 2009 2:30 PM

Usually, when Nintendo makes remakes of these games, they leave out the third installment. I would see no point in making a Crystal remake. They aren't going to throw any new pokemon in there, which is usually the point that the third installments hold.

Pan!ko June 10th, 2009 12:16 AM

I don't c whats the purpose. they could just include most of the features from Crystal into HGSS anyway. Unless they plan on making something even more new for Crystal.

Tinhead Bruce June 10th, 2009 10:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Norcinu (Post 4666201)
Liver Crystal? What on Earth are you on? I think naming it Kidney Crystal is better.

Hmm, kidney stone anyone?

Oh Em Gee! ThEy DiDn'T mAkE a YeLlOw ReMaKe, WhY wOuLd ThEy MaKe CrYsTaL???!!!! [/sarcasm]

Seriously, doesn't anyone read the posts in the thread? I swear, the reasons have been recycled soo many times it's not even funny. Nah, I dun think there will be a remake. Costs more munny, and seeing as HG/SS is spposed to have a crap load of new stuff, they'd have to add even more stuff to Crystal (i.e. 4th Gen pokes). Doing so would cause them to alienate even more people who liked the old games for their simpleness.

Yuoaman June 10th, 2009 10:30 AM

I find it strange that this thread still has a discussion going on... There may be a Crystal remake, though it is unlikely because I, for one, would prefer a fifth generation to another remake, as I believe most people would.

Keyaki June 10th, 2009 10:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Yuoaman (Post 4735876)
I find it strange that this thread still has a discussion going on... There may be a Crystal remake, though it is unlikely because I, for one, would prefer a fifth generation to another remake, as I believe most people would.

There wont be one

If they were gonna make a remake of Crystal they would've done that instead of remaking Gold and Silver

Leafeon1201 June 10th, 2009 7:25 PM

Well if you think about it whenever they made fire red and leaf green they didn't make a remake of yellow

pikalax June 11th, 2009 12:52 PM

If they do make it, it would be more like MindCrystal.

bubblewrap June 11th, 2009 12:55 PM

Ahaha, I don't think there will be a Spirit Crystal in the near future, but if there is one in like ten years or something, that would be cool. : D

Mōnštȝr¿ June 11th, 2009 12:57 PM

I really don't see a remake for Crystal happening...
There was never a Yellow remake for GBA when FR/LG came out.
So why should there be for Crystal?

Tatortotts June 11th, 2009 1:11 PM

I vote on Lung Crystal.
/facepalm

There's not going to be a remake as far as I'm concerned.
Fire Red and Leaf Green didn't have a Lightning Yellow, soo. :/

-Tator

Dr. James June 11th, 2009 6:08 PM

I sure hope that the advanced-story of Ho-Oh heard in Crystal remains in HG/SS. So we don't need a remake of Crystal.

p!kablu June 12th, 2009 5:06 AM

I don't see a Crystal coming.

Everything seems to be completed (dex wise) in just the two.

Just good idea about the Spirit.

I still personally would have prefered Dusk Gold and Dawn Silver, but you cant win em all.

Johto's Best June 13th, 2009 8:09 AM

I really don't WANT a remake for crystal. All of the remakes I bought (all 3) haven't really been all that great, so I don't want to waste 30 dollars for just an extra quest.

Down with the darkness June 13th, 2009 6:55 PM

I WANT MIND CRYSTAL!

Crystal was my first game and it rocked! I say they call it "Mind Crystal"

Kumata June 13th, 2009 10:58 PM

There's no need for a Crystal remake, and I'm sure the sales would be noticably worse compared to HG/SS... notwithstanding I don't want them to focus on that, can't they move on to Gen 5 yet? ^^;

Norcinu June 13th, 2009 11:08 PM

Heart and Soul, if there was a Crystal I think it'd be named Mind. At first I thought Spirit was a cool name but another S starter is ish, and it sort of follows "Mind, Body and Soul" with Heart being Body.

joshual2153 June 16th, 2009 9:16 AM

acually i think there may be a crystal remake. yeh, they didnt do a yellow remake, so what? the third games are always the best. yellow, crystal, emerald, platinum.
im not sure why they didnt do a yellow remake but, they did third games for all the other gens sooo yeh.... Spirit crystal - Mind crystal...

Samme! June 16th, 2009 9:40 AM

I really don't see the need to remake it...

Zenite June 17th, 2009 12:07 AM

Spirit and Soul sound too similar and I agree with everyone there will most likely not be a Crystal remake. R/S remake anyone? :P

derozio June 17th, 2009 12:50 AM

There was no yellow remake and so I really can't help but think that there will not be any Mind/Spirit Crystal game. But IF maybe they just bother to remake crystal I say that I will definitely try to play it.

Neutrino June 17th, 2009 10:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jαcκςση (Post 4662457)
I guarantee you that there will be no crystal remake in the near future. It's utterly pointless.

there's no point guaranteeing what you don't know ¬¬

I personally don't think that they'll make a crystal remake, because anything that was special about Crystal will ahve been added and expanded into Hg/SS. they've already added in bits of Yellow to make up for it not being remade - the following pokemon and that.

Artemis June 17th, 2009 10:59 AM

It is very unlikely for a Crystal remake, as said many times before. For one, if there might have been one, then at least a quarter of all the new features added now might not have been implemented into HeartGold and SoulSilver, but rather left for the Crystal remake. Not to mention, new hidden areas, like the possible Battle Frontier or Tower could have waited for the Crystal remake as well. Seeing as Yellow never had a remade version for the GameBoy Advance is what makes this Crystal remake idea unlikely.

However it is never impossible, and you never know that maybe in the next ten years, rather than remaking FireRed and LeafGreen for the latest system at that time, they could remake Yellow instead. The same could happen for Crystal as well, but for now HeartGold and SoulSilver seems to have it all. Not to forget, having a Crystal version isn't something needed, seeing as what HeartGold and SoulSilver is bringing in seems very satisfying. Plus, a remake of Crystal would only delay the waited fifth generation to come in like a year or two at some point.

JohnBoy617 June 17th, 2009 11:02 AM

I hate how everyone assumes that there will be a Crystal remake. For the millionth time, was there a Yellow remake???

holaboy June 27th, 2009 11:22 AM

Pokemon Crystal 2?
 
Well this is my first time being on here in 2 years so please dont flame if theres already a topic like this but do you guys think there will be a crystal remake too? If so what do you think they will call it.

ZestyCactus June 27th, 2009 11:28 AM

I think a Crystal remake would be overkill, personally. Also, they didn't do a SparkYellow or anything like that, so I'm hard-pressed to believe they'd do a Crystal remake. Plus, if they planned to bring back Crystal, I think they would have used Kris instead of the (ugly) new girl character. ;P

HeartGoldnSoulSilver June 27th, 2009 11:28 AM

Nah, I don't think there will be a remake of Crystal just yet, seeing how they haven't made a yellow remake. But if there was a Crystal remake it would be called.................. Mind Crystal , Heart Gold, and Soul Silver.

holaboy June 27th, 2009 11:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZestyCactus (Post 4794774)
I think a Crystal remake would be overkill, personally. Also, they didn't do a SparkYellow or anything like that, so I'm hard-pressed to believe they'd do a Crystal remake. Plus, if they planned to bring back Crystal, I think they would have used Kris instead of the (ugly) new girl character. ;P

Lmfao true i just thought of them not bringing back yellow lol.

The Roshi June 27th, 2009 12:03 PM

Yeah, I think this is in the speculation thread... Someone said that crystal wasn't viable because there wasn't a need to expand on the series or anything. These games incorporate all pokemon updates and probably will have their own special features as well. So a crystal wouldn't really be necessary.

beckystarr~ June 27th, 2009 3:52 PM

Probably not because when they remade the first generation, they didn't remake yellow version :)

Greene1516 June 27th, 2009 4:20 PM

There won't be............................

bobandbill June 27th, 2009 5:16 PM

Merged thread with this pre-existing one.

Personally, I do doubt there being a Crystal remake as well... and it'll be even more unlikely if we see Crystal features in HG/SS. Given that there is now a pic of another NPC in front of the Burnt Tower who looks similar (but isn't necessarily the same, mind) as another who only appeared in Crystal, it's rather possible, IMO.

Mika555 June 27th, 2009 7:03 PM

Some people are forgetting that Pokemon Blue was originally the third version in Japan and Pokemon Red and Green were the released together in Japan. Pokemon Yellow was a fourth special edition version based on the anime, but was dubbed a third version in other countries because Pokemon Green was not release outside of Japan. The game was because the game was said have so much abnormalities within it so those countries paired Pokemon Red with Pokemon Blue. Though this does not change the fact that Pokemon Red and Green are the paired version and Pokemon Blue is the third version because that is how they were released in Japan. So the reason of why I think it is unlikely that they will make Pokemon Crystal is because there was not a Pokmeon Blue remake. Also I thought that it was say that the Battle Tower and Sunicune Ledge were some features that were suppose to be included in the remakes meaning that some Crystal elements will be included while others will be left out.

Shiny Buizel June 28th, 2009 2:17 AM

I doubt it, but I hope so. I hadn't really thought about it to be honest lol

kinu June 28th, 2009 4:00 AM

acutaly i think crystal has a higher chance of a remake becuase its like the third top rpg game or something like after silver gold and emerald

laxen June 28th, 2009 5:50 AM

alright maybe not a crystal remake anytime soon. but noone can say that they didn't do a remake for yellow so the could do a remake later in like 5-10 years or something

Luigi12895 June 28th, 2009 12:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by digibeast (Post 4662982)
firered = yellow + red
leafgreen = yellow + leafgreen

heartgold = crystal + gold
soulsilver = crystal + silver

so, actually, there are remaking crystal INSIDE of heartgold and soulsilver.

that's what I think.

Did you mean to say Leafgreen = Yellow + Blue? :S

Ellie June 28th, 2009 12:47 PM

Yeah, they can easily just throw Crystal elements into HgSs, especially since there wasn't even much that changed in Crystal, just some extra features and a couple of changed places. Plus remaking Crystal might take away from the sales of HgSs, which I'm sure GF doesn't want :P

Circuit June 28th, 2009 12:55 PM

Yellow was a special edition so they wouldn't remake that, but the chance that a Crystal remake will be done is really very slim. Almost all of Crystals attributes have been put into the remakes plus some little extras. I don't see why, but people basing that they wont because they didn't with Yellow is total rubbish. Yellow was a special edition. Green wasn't released over here, only in Japan.

Anxiety. June 28th, 2009 1:03 PM

I doubt they'll make one.
If they did, it wouldn't be a huge thing, it wouldn't get as much money as HG or SS.
Just my opinion though. It just doesn't seem very likely. But if they do make one it probably would be called Spirit Crystal.

Pikaluvr June 28th, 2009 4:30 PM

There wasnt a new yellow so i say there wont be a new chrystal.

Dragonzord June 28th, 2009 4:53 PM

a better name would be mind crystal.

spirit is kinda like soul, because, for lack of a better term, nintendo is kinda goin for a "spiritual body parts" theme, heart and soul, so the mind would fall into that.

also

Quote:

Originally Posted by cheesymitten (Post 4663018)
My guess on the Crystal remake name?
Blood Crystal mbe?

.... really? thats really close to blood diamond. Not very politicol correcto!

Blue Nocturne June 30th, 2009 9:09 AM

*agrees with Dragonzord*

Mind crystal would be more appropriate name. But i doubt a third remake will be produced.
Features from crystal would most likely be in HGSS (eg, the battle tower which is visible in the new Johto art).
Also they didnt release a SeaBlue/OceanBlue/WaterBlue version so why bother with a mind crystal?

silvanarrow June 30th, 2009 1:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blue Nocturne (Post 4806800)
*agrees with Dragonzord*

Mind crystal would be more appropriate name. But i doubt a third remake will be produced.
Features from crystal would most likely be in HGSS (eg, the battle tower which is visible in the new Johto art).
Also they didnt release a SeaBlue/OceanBlue/WaterBlue version so why bother with a mind crystal?

I'm gonna have to agree with this. When they remade Red and Green as FireRed and LeafGreen, they never did a third remake for Blue. I can't see why this would be any different. Correct me if I'm wrong, but the only times they have done a third game in a series is when it's a new generation and not a remake (ie. R/B/Y, G/S/C, R/S/E, D/P/Pt).

Of course, I would love to see a Crystal remake, but I doubt it'll happen.

Tristin1991 June 30th, 2009 1:40 PM

silver narrow have you been around in japan!?!?! it is red blue yellow GREEN =firered leaf green and OCEANBLUE crystal gold and silver you are all right it is heart gold soul silver ans spirit crystal and there is a 40 percent chance about firey ruby misty sapphire and shimmering emerald the 3 ruby saphire and emerald games for hoenn

GreyShadow June 30th, 2009 1:52 PM

I highly doubt there will be one because there would have been a Yellow remake already if there was a Crystal remake. And I also think that anything that they had in Crystal that wasn't in Gold/Silver (like Battle Tower) will probobly be in HG/SS. But anyway Spirit Crystal would be the perfect name for the game!!

silvanarrow June 30th, 2009 3:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tristin1991 (Post 4807966)
silver narrow have you been around in japan!?!?! it is red blue yellow GREEN =firered leaf green and OCEANBLUE crystal gold and silver you are all right it is heart gold soul silver ans spirit crystal and there is a 40 percent chance about firey ruby misty sapphire and shimmering emerald the 3 ruby saphire and emerald games for hoenn

When I listed the games, I was only speaking about the ones released in North America, since I live in the USA. I'm fully aware of Green in Japan. My apologies for the confusion. Also, I have never heard of OceanBlue, Firey Ruby, Misty Sapphire, or Shimmering Emerald, on Serebii or any other credible site.

Neko June 30th, 2009 3:39 PM

Honestly, I can't see them making a remake of Crystal. What would be the difference, anyway? You can already chose the gender you want, and the sprites are animated. Plus they never remade Pokemon Yellow either.

FreakyLocz14 July 1st, 2009 1:24 PM

No Yellow remake = No Crystal remake = No Emerald remake (when R/S comes up for remake time)

Guy July 1st, 2009 1:29 PM

Here is more evidential proof on why a Crystal remake may not come to past. For one, like so many have said before, when FRLG came out, a Yellow or even Blue remake never came to follow. To add onto this idea, HeartGold and SoulSilver has been confirmed to see the Battle Tower in the exact route where it was located in Crystal. So, with this being said, if there were to be a Crystal remake then more than likely the Battle Tower would have at least been kept for Crystal like before instead of probably being placed in the main GSDS games.

Now, even if the possibilities of a Crystal remake are low, I wouldn't count out seeing some Crystal references placed within the game. For instance, besides the Battle Tower we have also seen from the Johto Map the same lodge where Suicune was in Cianwood City I believe it was. Not to mention, if we had Shiny Gold as a ROM, then at least one person out there will take the chance at a Crystal ROM hack.

JustinDestruction July 1st, 2009 1:44 PM

There was no third remake of Yellow for GBA, so I highly doubt they will remake Crystal. There would seriously be no point, especially when they can simply combine elements of the 'new' stuff in Crystal with HG and SS, therefore eliminating the possibility of a third remake.

Luke92 July 2nd, 2009 8:00 AM

i'm pretty sure that there will be NO crystal remake.. because , IMO the 3rd series remake will only be implemented for the new generation's'.

but it sure will be great IF they really make the remake of crystal.

heart gold , soul silver.
mind crystal maybe? =p

Wobbuffet July 2nd, 2009 8:18 AM

i wouldnt get either...yet
 
We all know how nintendo does this, they did the same with emerald, platinium and myster dungeon sky. in one or 2 months they'll anounce a crystel remake with some epic addition that the other 2 dont have like some exclusive legendary or something like that. Si im going to wait until they bring out that game rather then letting myself be fooled again into buying 2 copies of the nearby exact same game

Verguil13 July 2nd, 2009 8:23 AM

i doubt that they'll remake crystal... they didnt remake yellow. and besides if they make a new game it'll probably be a 5th gen which who knows if they're even goin to make a fifth gen. this is al coming from past experiences. but who knows.... can't wait for the new games to come out.

JustinDestruction July 2nd, 2009 8:24 AM

Yeah, I highly doubt a Crystal remake is in the making. They can simply incorporate Crystal's features into HG/SS. And there was no Yellow remake. So there really is no evidence.

Melodyfree July 2nd, 2009 8:41 AM

They only make third versions for main games, not remakes.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 5:25 AM.


Like our Facebook Page Follow us on Twitter © 2002 - 2018 The PokéCommunity™, pokecommunity.com.
Pokémon characters and images belong to The Pokémon Company International and Nintendo. This website is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Nintendo, Creatures, GAMEFREAK, The Pokémon Company or The Pokémon Company International. We just love Pokémon.
All forum styles, their images (unless noted otherwise) and site designs are © 2002 - 2016 The PokéCommunity / PokéCommunity.com.
PokéCommunity™ is a trademark of The PokéCommunity. All rights reserved. Sponsor advertisements do not imply our endorsement of that product or service. User generated content remains the property of its creator.

Acknowledgements
Use of PokéCommunity Assets
vB Optimise by DragonByte Technologies Ltd © 2023.