![]() |
Some of my siggiesss~! *Experienced GIMP user*
'Bout time I showed you all some of my work. ^^
http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/5179/smgsigv5.png http://img41.imageshack.us/img41/4061/inuyashasig.png http://img7.imageshack.us/img7/3028/bwgmsig.png http://img3.imageshack.us/img3/5453/roxassig.png Need to make some more pokemon sigs. =/ Anyway, like? Good enough to open my own shop? Not been making sigs for ages. These ones are only recent and are kinda simple looking. A little rusty but I'll get back into my stride soon. Hopefully. =P |
did you say experienced ?
|
Ermm, yes. =/ Are they not good enough to be 'experienced'?
|
can i see some from when you weren't rusty?
|
I'll just have to dig into my documents to find them. >.<
Are those posted really that bad? D= |
better than average but nothing special really. It's really just your composition that bugs me, for instance in the roxas signature, he is stood there, off centre and out of position, and he's absolutely tiny, also the text is faded and hard to read. I think you need to experiment with composure and composition because whilst you've got the idea about it, you're really awful at it.
A tiny wee man dead centre isn't that great for a sig. I'm guessing your very young though so props for learning the ropes this fast. You also need to learn how to use textures. |
i thought they were really good
|
Hehe, not that young. ^^ Thanks for the constructive criticism though, greatly appreciated. I admit, those sigs aren't my best. I've been lacking ideas lately. Also, for some reason, I'm against using textures. =/ Weird, I know. I rather make sigs from scratch. Occasionally, I use a stock, but not very often.
Anyway, here are a few more recent ones. http://i48.*.com/10sdr2c.png http://i49.*.com/23h6ds4.png Stupid links aren't working. =( Most of my siggies are lost somewhere. x_x |
i don't believe those two are yours if they're from the same person who posted the first ones.
|
Haha. Are you serious? =P How can I prove it to you?
I told you that the first ones are my most recent and are the really crap ones. I am Shoeb on another forum. =P |
Never mind iPochama, never even see him in here before, and the tag in his signature isn't exactly outstanding.
Anyways, http://i48.*.com/10sdr2c.png Love this one, the colors etc are all really good on it, use more effect C4D's in your work it'll definately help. |
Quote:
|
okay first, yes, i won't post like that again, but second:
um, excuse me, don't drag me into this okay? you have no right to insult my sig or even so much as discuss it, as i didn't ask for that. I was giving constructive criticism, so you can just bite your tongue babe, and for the record, your 3 coloured 100x100 icons aren't that great either. |
Thanks for the comment, Ramen! I should definitely look into using C4Ds. Not too good with C4D work.
Here was one of my attempts: http://i48.*.com/n6q9u0.png It's ok Baromega. I guess the signatures in the first post were pretty poor. >.< EDIT: Don't fight please. =/ And just to make it clear, I don't steal other peoples work, iPochama. Everything I say is mine is actually mine. |
I don't understand your need to constantly make grungey signatures, have you ever thought about making a cleaner or clearer one? I hate that one you've just made, I think it's really awful, but still, the quality is a lot better and I see that you've used quite a big image (even if said image is ugly) so it's still good use of space. I still stand by what I said earlier - you should look at some textures, they don't have to be glaringly obvious.
|
I said that was my first attempt at a proper C4D sig. =/ I don't really like the way you're criticising me but I guess it's far. >.<
|
right okay, i'm sorry if you don't feel the way im criticizing you. i'll try to stop being harsh? or did you want asspatting like most of the users will give you? either way, the good points is that a) i've said good use of space and b) nice colour scheme c) great first attempt. The negative points are a) the render is ridiculous, but if it's what you wanted then i suppose there's not much else i can say and b) it's still quite grungey/messy and unproffesional looking.
|
Quote:
This style is barely considered grungy aswell, just because of the smudging doesn't make it grungy. And if your going to comment on my icons, for a start they aren't made by me they were made by someone on LJ, of whom I have credited in my signature, and I can guarrantee the whole graphics section would agree that they're leagues ahead of whatever you're making. Don't go saying the things you're saying, when by the looks of it you're no better yourself. |
Alright. I won't say anything further.
Thanks for the comments, I guess. |
Quote:
and are you even insinuating that i can't critique anything that i am not possible of producing myself? if so that's ridiculous, my critique is as valuable as the next persons, regardless of whether or not i use tacky ichigo renders. ty babe. i'm not hating on anything, the best form of critique is attack. fgs, are you stupid? fight or flight, if they take my advice really badly and run away, okay, they were never cut out for graphic design, if they react by improving(fighting) they'll come out better. running around saying that everything a person does is fantastic will only make that person become cocky and arrogant. i'm not a villain, please, i'm trying to help. |
Kay then, just a tip here and please don't take this the wrong way, if you are going to post constructive critiscm like you say, can you atleast be saying in which ways they can improve it.
And you probably should find a way to credit your friend for it xD |
I've been on alot of GFX forums and even the harshest of members don't critique like you do. There is a difference between something contructive and something rude. Although I understand where you're coming from, you aren't really helping either. Criticism can be friendly and helpful at the same time. You're doing neither.
You didn't really help me in anyway. Just made fun of my render choice. Yes, it was an odd render but it was more experimental than anything. I just showed an example of a C4D attempt. Just think about that next time you try to 'help' somebody. |
Quote:
and i did give you compliments, you're butthurt and feeling strong with everyone on your side, this is what i mean. If you give them loads of compliments they become cocky and arrogant, like yourself. I'm off, clearly i've ruptured the happiness in this little village. good riddance. (oh and, i critique my friend anya like this, and she's been great with it, and it has helped her.) i'll let you take the last word now, i know how much you love it. |
But you don't properly give criticism. Honestly, if you can't make a decent sig yourself, you shouldn't be so harsh on others.
and personally I don't think the sigs made by Solo_kid are that great, they have very plain and simple backrounds which kind of bother me. If they had just a pit more in them these would be great. But the first one with Mario is just TOO simple. I can tell that must of been an early one. Just too plain. |
yay another gimp user (:
they're amazing. |
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 8:06 PM. |
![]()
© 2002 - 2018 The PokéCommunity™, pokecommunity.com.
Pokémon characters and images belong to The Pokémon Company International and Nintendo. This website is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Nintendo, Creatures, GAMEFREAK, The Pokémon Company or The Pokémon Company International. We just love Pokémon.
All forum styles, their images (unless noted otherwise) and site designs are © 2002 - 2016 The PokéCommunity / PokéCommunity.com.
PokéCommunity™ is a trademark of The PokéCommunity. All rights reserved. Sponsor advertisements do not imply our endorsement of that product or service. User generated content remains the property of its creator.
Acknowledgements
Use of PokéCommunity Assets
vB Optimise by DragonByte Technologies Ltd © 2023.