![]() |
Graphic Rating Thread
Here, post your graphics and whatnot, and other people will rate them.
|
Yay! Finally, someone has done this! I hope this can inject some zest into this graphics community!
|
Ok rate my Reborn sig, I just finished it.
|
Quote:
Sig is rather good; as a stand alone work, it is really beautiful. However, I suggest you leave only one image in your sig, because in comparison, it looks like you just used the same mould and filled it in with different stocks and colours. Rate my D-Rex sig down there, suggest improvements. |
I'm assuming it's like The One Above? i really like the effects you used there. the boxes are very pretty. x3
|
2 Attachment(s)
Awesome, a thread like this, here are my 2 first signatures with Photoshop CS2. Rate Away ^_^.
|
^^ I love them, really good for your first try, tonnes better than what I can do ^_^
Okay, can you rate some of my most worked on blinkies pwease http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y252/LonelyPuppet/bbblinkie2.gif http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y252/LonelyPuppet/PJNblinkie.gif http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y252/LonelyPuppet/Syblinkie.gif http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y252/LonelyPuppet/Lpfini.gif |
all i'd say for you, Username, is for the bulbasaur one. the letter part is fine moving fast, but bulbasaur looks like he's got something in his eye and he's trying to get it out by blinking a lot really fast. xD
|
The blinkys are really cool, I so like them xD
|
i know its not that great but i made the pidgeot banner and the second bleach banner plz rate this one:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v510/munna170488/271b1a64.gif and: http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v510/munna170488/shinypidgeot.png |
Bleach banner is very interesting ^^ just work on your cutting.
Pidgeot banner is very smooth; colour suit it well. Good job; just that I can't just used to seeing sprites on banners. |
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/graphics/ichigo.png
What do you think? |
Oh no it's Ichigo! I like it if it was purple but it's okay
Now here's mine http://photobucket.com/albums/a18/LAG119/Project6.png< The black background wasn't my fault! It came like that when it was supposed to be white! I'll post some more later |
...black?
Ouh... it's a .png. Not everyone can read .png- on some computers, png transparency (aka the white thing you were talking about) appears as a random colour instead (aka the blackness). Since on my computer it works (I <3 Firefox), borders appears very fine. However, symmetry and using multi-stock isn't always a good thing in graphics. It gives no focal point to your image if everything's trying to grab the viewer's attention. Text is a bit hard to read... but on a whole, colour flows well. |
yeah, FireFox pwns, cause then you can see all my png's x3
|
heres of mine http://img285.echo.cx/img285/3244/emrayquaza9zi.gif and http://img175.echo.cx/img175/9206/jirachianimation2ip.gif hope you like them
|
dont mean to be mean xD but those are sprites. oh and i recently downloaded a few ps 7 and over brushes so i made a new bleach banner / avatar plz rate em
|
Hmm for once, I actually don't mind seeing more than one stock on the image. It was done well ^^ except that there's a bit of white in Renji's hair. (that's his name, right? The guy with the Baboon's tail sword...)
Main problem is that I didn't realise you actually had font until I stared really closely at the "pixel art" in the corner XD |
yea that just my way of saying tis mine f off, anyway i altered the banner slightly
|
I read the first volume of bleach, but never got the second, and i'll tell you why. i can't read Chinese, and volume 7 in english hasn't come out yet. i promised not to get anything else until Naruto vol. 7 comes out. that's how much i want it. xD whatever, that's off-topic. i really like your banner, but perhaps give us more looking time at each part of the animation. i'd like to see the detail on it. ^^ your avatar i can see part of what was on the banner, except it looks harder on the darkness and light, which is a good effect if you're trying to take part of the banner off and make it an avatar. good job is all else i can say. ^^
LatiosLover - this is a graphics thread, not a sprite thread. try Home of the Sprites if you want to be commented upon. ^^ EDIT: i've been asked this constantly... if this is for rating graphics, why do Nic and I and everyone make new threads? i'll tell you why. this thread was intented for aspiring artists who wanted to know how good they can get. for example, poke munna probably could make threads for his graphics now; he/she is very good. i forgot your gender, munna. *rubs chin* anyway, if you think you're ready, go ahead and make threads instead of posting here. we're trusting your judgement, but not if you're worse than you say you are. *cough* |
Well I would like the one in my sig to be rated and criticized please XD
Stevo-Kun |
9/10...I don't like the red but the rst is awesome! I like how the black border fades out into the picture. Also the pixel text is great. :)
|
well mine are avatars for here
|
|
i dont like the text sorry but i like the pattern overlay thingy 7/10 & ll was talking about :
Quote:
|
Well, it was a request :P
|
Quote:
|
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/fanfic%20banners/frontierelite.png
Not as good as my last few pieces, but I'm still proud of it. Any comments. |
Quote:
As far as your latest piece is concerned, I like it a lot too! Only, I'm wondering, where's the "a la mode"? =3 Me no see no ice cream! XD Biiii. :P I've got a new banner too... but it's not that detailed. Mine is just a simple banner I made for the Singing Contest, lol. But the picture is prettyful, ne? |
I just made the image in my sigrate?
|
do you still have the .psd file becuase the text moving too, should be on a different layer
|
It is on a different layer =/
I just placed it under the rain layer which was set to screen EDIT: k made the words stop moving and moved them to above the rain |
oh it looks good, especially seeing that the bad guysmaking thunder, its clever hehe, maybe add the border round the sides and turn the rain layers the other direction, that way you could make it look like it bounces off his left hand, *realises links a lefty hurrah*
|
Ganon making the thunder is a good idea, but you could use an eraser to make the part that's coming off his hand come to a point, so it looks more like the thunder gets bigger and bigger. x3
|
Meh, as bland as it is, here's my new banner, XD
http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a160/Daiaki711b/rock1.png |
I like it a lot, Yukito. it reminds me of a giant battery or something... especially with the line of light on the thing next to Megaman.
|
http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y252/LonelyPuppet/pinnyblinkie.gif
My latest blinkie, Im really glad of how it came out, it took me ages...what do you think? |
Amelia, i really like that one. best part is how the squirtle chao walks across it and as it's walking, makes the blinking part go off. x3 i'm awful at that kind of stuff, but do it when i have to. (really badly, of course xD)
|
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/fanfic%20banners/sidneyava.pnghttp://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/fanfic%20banners/phoebeava.pnghttp://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/fanfic%20banners/glaciaava.pnghttp://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/fanfic%20banners/drakeava.png
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/fanfic%20banners/nolandava.pnghttp://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/fanfic%20banners/gretaava.pnghttp://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/fanfic%20banners/anabelava.pnghttp://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/fanfic%20banners/tuckerava.pnghttp://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/fanfic%20banners/brandonava.pnghttp://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/fanfic%20banners/spenserava.pnghttp://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/fanfic%20banners/lucyava.png Some more avas I made with Soara's pics. Enjoy! |
Thanks so much AC <3
Nekomajo Asunya there okay nice backround affect, but Im not keen on the font, its very mess, perhaps download some diffrent more exciting fonts, also try your hand at signatures :) |
There wicked well done. The background colours go good with the pic. i rate it 7/10
|
Original T I love the one in your signature! VERY WELL MADE! 10/10 even thought you didn't ask for it to be rated. :P
|
Thomas-san is right, the one in your signature is pretty good.
|
Rate my banner...I redid it so now it is an animation...
EDIT: Nevermind I switched it...you can rate my current avatar (didn't make it but it was too awesome to pass up) and my animation. |
Well, here's my latest creation, I got a little bored this afternoon, XD
http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a160/Daiaki711b/negi.png |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
i really like that banner, Yukito. it's very themed and it looks quite smooth. as for the little pic, if you had put it a little further to the left, it would have looked better, but as far as i can tell, it certainly ridded it of its partial boringness x3
|
http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a160/Daiaki711b/sessh.png
http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a160/Daiaki711b/poochy.png Just some stuff I threw together on PSP8 while brush testing. I wasn't at all serious while making them, so lets not go too hard on how bad they are okay? XD |
i love the brushing on the Sesshomaru one, but i suggest making the white part a little bit bluer, but not too much. as for the second one, very nice grunge border, it matches the chess table grid brush. the text under Poochyena is hard to read.. just the second word, which i still can't tell what it says. very, very nice x3 i think you should try doing some smaller sized banners; judging by your brushing, it looks like you have great potential x3
|
Quote:
I'll try to do a few smaller ones to see how they turn out. |
k, good luck with that. btw... my favorite size is 380x85. generally, that works pretty well; it shows a good amount of brushing and is still small. x3
|
I tried something smaller, and again used a black and white colour scheme.
http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a160/Daiaki711b/naraku.png |
the black and white color scheme is good, but for the the blast-ish thing under the text... it should be colored, even if still very desaturated. :/
|
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v250/Ida-chan/graphics/rainbowmeowth.png
A banner feature my favorite Pokemon, rainbow edition! |
Quote:
Its very cute, but the font isn't very nice, and the stock clashes with the backround. Anyone care to rate my 2 newest types of blinkies. http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a150/ChemicalTrip/pinblinkie.gif ^^ Text blinkie, in a box, just trying it out, letters took me ages >.> http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a150/ChemicalTrip/derekxlindsayblinkie2.gif New block style.. |
this thread won't go away, cause it's a sticky, but... it's really lost activity. >_>
|
Quote:
|
No? I've seen this style of blinkies before and just gave it a shot.
|
Poor you... I know a tutorial that learns you how to do the same effect in ps in max 3 min, lol
|
someone rate my pimp sig and avatar
|
Looks cool to me ^_^
Anyway this is my first attemp at making sig in PS: http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v520/DarkPegasus/firstsig.png I know it's a bit dark, but it's ment to be that way(yes I know about the hue/saturation and duplicate layer and make it overlay). |
Quote:
|
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v192/blitzballchamp/Signiture.png
This one is abit big, So I made a smaller version for my sig |
I've got some stuff for rating! My avatar, my sig, this icon and banner:
http://*.com/ajphm0.jpg http://*.com/ajp8au.jpg and this wallpaper I made: http://img219.imageshack.us/my.php?image=air39xz.jpg All due to my Misuzu mode XD |
The avatar is good, But it probibly needs some wrighting on it, 9.5/10
THe banner is great, Good compasition, Great use of patterns, 10/10 The wallpaper is good, But the pattern on that one kinda anoot's me, I give it 9/10 If i was to rate them all as one it would be a 9.5/10 Now rate mine, COz Mine didn't get rated :( http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v192/blitzballchamp/Signiture.png |
OK, I'll rate yours, then you have to rate the avatar and sig image I'm using (they're all part of the set :))
I don't know much about Naruto :) The banner is pretty cute though. The image you used is nice and cartoonish, nice font, but I don't like the way the circles blend into the background. 8/10 |
These were quick experiments with masking in PS, any good? http://www.ian559.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/Tom/Signature/Signature 5.gif http://www.ian559.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/Tom/Signature/Signature 4.gif If you look closely, the line overlapping the "EH" in the first one shines slightly, as does Auron's Sword. |
peoplel shouldn't have to put text in their avatars. in fact, almost nobody does. Tommeh Smiff, your text and picture effects aren't too bad, but... the bg on the second one is really repetitive. and make the line and the sword's animation a little more noticeable.
|
Quote:
Oh in that case, (i have rated the rest) Your sig deserves a 9/10 and avatar a 10/10 :D |
Thanks for your ratings XD. Was my rating of yours OK?
|
Yeah, Its your opinion not mine XD
Well keep up the good art :D |
Nice JA! Misuzu~ <3 9/10 - Something seems off about the banner, but I can't identify it.
I don't want my banner and avy rated, since I threw them togther in 5 minutes on PSP8, XD |
I'd love to rate them anyway XD. SHUFFLE! is win, we showed some of it at our last club marathon.
|
JA, <3! It's Misuzu-chan~! <333 And it ish blue, too! :3 I wish I could read what was written though. :o Your avvy ish very nice too. I like how the piccies overlay. ;3
Davey-chan, yours ish awesome~! ;o |
i can't rate it?! it's amazing, Yukito! perfect color scheme for grunginess, and brown and blue go well together x3
|
I would like someone to rate my current sig and avy, I made them XD *points to avy and sig* XD
|
They're OK, but a bit dark, and I have no idea what they say XD. The background in the sig is kind of boring.
|
Thanks for the comment ^^. Well I have an alternate version, plus I am kinda new to grunging XD
With coloured face http://img130.imageshack.us/img130/3631/nbanner016ux.png Blue face XD http://img40.imageshack.us/img40/7964/nbannero11iq.png There it is, tell me what ya think |
okay, what you need to do is... duplicate the image layer on the first of those, then change the Sasuke face to blue, and then lower the duplicate layer's opacity. x3
|
Well I cant now ^^:. I forgot to save the psd lol. Thanks alot for the help, I will remember it next time, and try to improve my grunging XD
|
oh, okay... x3 no problem. remember, grunges are all about the desaturation and darkness x3
|
|
Hmm, I'd recommend working on your cropping. I find it easiest to remove most of it with the Selection tool, and then get the rest with the wand.
|
Just a random banner I made in paint:
http://*.com/anbfvq.png And yes I know it sucks =( and better banners can be made with paint... ~DL~ |
THAT is the BEST paint banner I have ever seen, I don't care what anyone say's, That benner deserves a 10/10
|
I agree, thats a wonderful banner Dragon Lover, most my graphics are made with Paint, I have no idea why people dislike it so much.
I have a little animation for somone to rate, it has a few glitches, but it took me ages and is a hell of alotta frames. http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a150/ChemicalTrip/marioani.gif |
Thomas- ewww~;; when you're doing repetitions, change the opacitiy on the ones behind it ;.;
|
Quote:
Quote:
~DL~ |
Paint Shop Pro is PSP, DL. did you mean photoshop?
|
ehho, can u guys rate my banner and avvy please, i made em.
|
i really like your avatar, but the banner doesn't really match it; it's a bit shotty too, just the cropping problems, tho.
|
Ok I just made this banner and avy, please rate and tell me how it can be improved ^^
http://img394.imageshack.us/img394/7752/nbanner24zf.png http://img391.imageshack.us/img391/2948/navatar26sz.png |
Quote:
|
|
It's nice, reminds me of Freelancer.
|
thats beautiful, amazing, what program do you use?
|
He uses photoshop, I think.
|
it's okay... you took two planets, put them on a starfield.. it would have been nicer if you had put a sort of haze over the planets to make them look like they were already on the starfield.
|
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 2:13 AM. |
![]()
© 2002 - 2018 The PokéCommunity™, pokecommunity.com.
Pokémon characters and images belong to The Pokémon Company International and Nintendo. This website is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Nintendo, Creatures, GAMEFREAK, The Pokémon Company or The Pokémon Company International. We just love Pokémon.
All forum styles, their images (unless noted otherwise) and site designs are © 2002 - 2016 The PokéCommunity / PokéCommunity.com.
PokéCommunity™ is a trademark of The PokéCommunity. All rights reserved. Sponsor advertisements do not imply our endorsement of that product or service. User generated content remains the property of its creator.
Acknowledgements
Use of PokéCommunity Assets
vB Optimise by DragonByte Technologies Ltd © 2023.