View Single Post
Old April 12th, 2009 (7:38 PM).
Rabbit Rabbit is offline
where is my mind?
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: BC, Canada
Age: 24
Gender: Female
Nature: Adamant
Posts: 488
Send a message via AIM to Rabbit Send a message via Windows Live Messenger to Rabbit
Originally Posted by rednano12 View Post
I was thinking of a plot based off of pokemon cruelty. You are a young kid in a town, and your mom leaves her purse by the lake. You go back and get it for her, but on the other side of the lake, you see some men and a few pokemon crying out in pain. You approach the men and see they have blood dripping down their faces. A wouned pokemon is by them. You rescue a pokemon from a cage near them and attack them. Outraged, someone(probly a mayor) sends a group of people to investigate.

I have a lot more, but its all spoilerified. Is this too dark and gory for a pokemon game?
I think Pokemon could stand being made 'darker and edgier' - I mean, Pokemon battling is essentialy similar to dog fights. But you have to be careful in how you do it, or you enter cliche land.

First, everyone knows that ANIMAL CRUELTY IS BAD. That shouldn't be your story's main focus. It's almost redundant. If your plotline involves the protagonist chasing after villains who mindlessly torture innocent fluffy creatures, there's no value in it. The trick is in finding something ambiguous in it, something with two sides. For instance, the fine line between 'Pokemon cruelty' and 'Pokemon as working animals'. You could show the transition in stages: dog-type Pokemon being used for hunting, dairy Miltank being kept in crowded conditions, Rapidash being whipped, Ursaring at the carnivals, Torchic in rooster-fights.

Second, there's the issue of Pokemon battling as being rather cruel. If you leave it out, the gameplay collapses, but if you don't explain it in some way, the player is sure to notice the double standard - so it's wrong for the villains to keep Pokemon in small cages, but alright for the hero to keep them in small balls? And isn't it wrong to make Pokemon fight each other for sport?

Third, there's the cliche around abused Pokemon that they will form an immediate, super-strong bond with their rescuer. In fact, the most logical thing for it to do when released is high-tail it into the forest. Why should it expect anything good from you?An abused Pokemon should have a fear of people and take a long time to get used to being handled by an owner.

So...I don't really know. I'd like to hear the rest of the storyline, though.

dreaming again
of a train track ending at the edge of the sea