Challenge Ideas & Discussion

Noooo, but Sydian is the best mod. ever created D:

Why couldn't Erik mod D/P/Pt, don't you have a say in this? I mean, I assume that your happy modering here, so why can't you continue doing what you love?

I think Syd requested someone else to take over because of how many threads keep getting made over and over with challenge ideas when people clearly didn't read the rules for making chalenges or something. Syd made the rules thing as sort of a last resort thing, and it didn't really work. I think Eric might have more patience, maybe? Idk.

I did some pretty cool stuff in DPPt, once upon a time. I did, however, get bored of it after a while.

How about some N challenge?

-You must liberate your Pokemon after every gym badge.
-After doing so you must capture, 6 new party members, those members must be used to beat the next gym
-If any of your Pokemon faint it is dead, and must be liberated.
-No re-battling trainers, unless the story requires it.
-No fighting wild pokemon, they are your friends.
-You must catch the legendary pokemon of the game, and challenge the elite four with it. It cannot die, and it must be in your party at all times. Kanto = Mewtwo if your were wondering....

Yes exactly, you would have to re-fight the Elite Four, or I can make the Legendary Pokemon be Articuno, Zapdos or Moltes, and you would have to use one of them.



@Alt: It is the City to City challenge fused with the Nuzlocke challenge. But with more difficulty like no grinding (because you can't fight Wild Pokemon nor re-battle trainers) and after you liberate the Pokemon, you must capture 6 more team members, and some how use them in battle, without training them before hand. That sounds pretty difficult, even more so in B/W since that Level Jump after the E4 and you must catch 6 more members, plus the chance of dying.

I get the idea, except the "If a pokemon faints, its dead" with i don't see fitting N (I beat the E4 for the 1. time today, and he doesn't strike me as a person who would release a pokemon because it loses a battle)

jespoke said:

I get the idea, except the "If a pokemon faints, its dead" with i don't see fitting N (I beat the E4 for the 1. time today, and he doesn't strike me as a person who would release a pokemon because it loses a battle)

Click to expand...

Well, N uses completely different teams each time you fight him (except for Klink -> Klinklang), so that might actually fit. So switching the teams after each gym is good, and the releasing when fainting is more of a standard rule for this kind of challenge I think, although I see your point. Maybe N would see it as if it faints, it wants to be free?

jdthebud said:

Well, N uses completely different teams each time you fight him (except for Klink -> Klinklang), so that might actually fit. So switching the teams after each gym is good, and the releasing when fainting is more of a standard rule for this kind of challenge I think, although I see your point. Maybe N would see it as if it faints, it wants to be free?

Click to expand...

Exactly, N is't the person to see a Pokemon suffer, so he releases it.

Oh, well, you've got a good argument there, fine with me too now.

Since my last idea wasn't kinda approved, I came up with another idea, same hardness, and maybe a bit more annoying, but you can have POWERFUL Pokèmon for your games, if you're used to play challenges on originals :D

The EVs challenge.

1. Every member of your team MUST have at least a stat (the one you prefer) at Max EVs.
2. You can have every Pokèmon you want, not Legendaries.
3. You can hack if you need, but in the 1st Route.
4. You can also hack the Power items.
5. Breeding and Egg Moves are allowed.

What do you think?

After Finally getting back to my UMC Normal, I defeated Red with a team of Level 55s. That Snorlax was a pain the kiester. But I finally got lucky with Dynamic Punch.

I kinda like the sound of the N challenge, but maybe take out the no fighting wild pokemon rule. That would just make it a bit too challenging.

I personally like the idea of challenges having optional rules. The 'No Wild Battles' rule for the N challenge would make a great optional rule.

And I agree with Syd... EV challenge sounds almost.. easier than normal? Because you would focus on EV training Pokemon in stats that they would be better with.

I'm actually considering a Hall of Fame challenge on Emerald. But I want to see if Syd says it's worth doing first?

I recently started a nuzlocke challenge. Its going to be in comic form. And its going to be awesome.