The Starter League! (Round 4!) SEMI-FINAL

Totodile for me

Go my boy Snivy

Totodile.. Bulbasaur... ugh this is hard :(

I think I've gotta go with Totodile still. I just love the nugget so much. ;;

Still going with Treecko here- glad it made it to the final 4. Also find it interesting that all of the Fire starters have been eliminated, and 3 of the last 4 are Grass types!

Had to go with Treeko! ^-^

very sad about the lack of piplup!!!!!!
i voted totodile though because water starters

Best boy toto gets my vote

Wait, question: why did Fennekin get left off when it had the same vote total as Bulbasaur and Totodile in the last thread?

That said, of these 4, Bulba all the way.

I mean come on now

torchic was robbed

voted bulbasaur

donavannj said:

Wait, question: why did Fennekin get left off when it had the same vote total as Bulbasaur and Totodile in the last thread?

Click to expand...

I wonder that as well especially because the same happened to Chamander and Piplup in round 3. Transparency is important in these cases because otherwise the poll looks rigged.

donavannj said:

Wait, question: why did Fennekin get left off when it had the same vote total as Bulbasaur and Totodile in the last thread?

Click to expand...

It's because in it's previous round, Bulbasaur and Totodile had more Votes than Fennekin, So they were chosen.

Braze said:

It's because in it's previous round, Bulbasaur and Totodile had more Votes than Fennekin

Click to expand...

Totodile had more votes than Fennekin in Round 2 but Bulbasaur hadn't, there was a tie between Fennekin and Bulbasaur.

Yes, I know that you may have used the results of round 1 as a tie-breaker but that logic don't work in the case of Piplup, Piplup won the round 1 with Snivy and Rowlet but it was still left out from round 3.

In round 2, Mudkip, Treecko, Totodile and Snivy took the first four places but after them there was tie between Piplup, Bulbasaur, Chikorita, Fennekin, Litten, Charmander and Torchic. The results of round one is used as tie-breaker and they're following.

Piplup - 33.33%
Bulbasaur - 28.57%
Chikorita - 28.57%
Fennekin - 23.81%
Litten - 23.81%
Charmander - 19.05%
Torchic - 19.05%

There's still tie between Fennekin and Litten so they could both be in round 3:

Mudkip
Treecko
Totodile
Snivy
Piplup
Bulbasaur
Chikorita
Fennekin
Litten

ok so someone help me on who should and shouldn't be in the semifinals? it was probably an oversight and if so, it's an easy fix of just either re-doing the round over or just including the missing Pokemon in the poll.

colours said:

ok so someone help me on who should and shouldn't be in the semifinals?

Click to expand...

It's impossible to say without re-doing round 3 with Mudkip, Treecko, Totodile, Snivy, Piplup, Bulbasaur, Chikorita, Fennekin and Litten because Piplup was so strong in round 1 that the results of round 3 would be different if it were in.

Mistakes happen- we're all human. If everyone wants a fair vote though, then re-doing one of the rounds would be the best idea.

Either that, or I'd personally be fine even if we did a seperate round with the four Pokemon from this poll plus Piplup (who should've been included in round 3) and Fennekin (who was tied with Bulbasaur and Totodile the last 2 rounds). Then maybe have a final three instead of final 2?

Why don't we just re-do the whole thing?

I agree. Re-do the whole thing. I recently got a Oshawott in my Omega Ruby game (yes, you can get a gen 5 starter in ORAS legally), and my heart MELTED! Also, gen 5 flashbacks. Let us bow our heads in respect for Ella the Samurott. ;-;

If I HAD to choose between the four remaining though, it'd be uhhhhh Totodile I guess. My user name in the 3DS ehop is Totodile with a bunch of numbers in front of it. Also, he's a hyper boi like me!

Mewtwolover said:

.

Click to expand...

FeraligatrMaster said:

Why don't we just re-do the whole thing?

Click to expand...

RedBalloon said:

I agree. Re-do the whole thing.

Click to expand...

as well as anyone else who may have had concerns...

To be clear: by "the whole thing" would you rather:

a) redo every round/this entire competition
b) do what Brendino suggested and re-do this particular round, with Piplup and Fennekin, then having a final three?
c) other.. ?