Off-Topic Hang out with people and talk about whatever. Feel free to suggest a better description for this forum as everyone seems to have an opinion. :D

TrollandToad.com
Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #1    
Old April 16th, 2010 (3:16 PM). Edited April 16th, 2010 by Prince_of_Light.
Prince_of_Light's Avatar
Prince_of_Light Prince_of_Light is offline
wins.
     
    Join Date: Jul 2009
    Location: Washington
    Age: 26
    Gender: Male
    Nature: Adamant
    Posts: 284
    I've been reading some conflicting information about this, so maybe someone here could help me clear this up. I want to download because I have no way of dumping the ROMs from my own copies of the games (dumping your own ROMs from your own hard copy is DEFINITELY legal in the US).

    If it's not legal, I think it's absolutely ridiculous that you can't download a digital copy of something that you can prove you own physically. That's like saying you can't download MP3's from a CD you own, but you can rip them all you want. The end result is still the same because you still own the game. It makes no sense.

    EDIT: In this case, since my question is solved, let's make this thread a general discussion about the legality and ethical issues pertaining to ROMs. For fun's sake. =P
    Reply With Quote

    Relevant Advertising!

      #2    
    Old April 16th, 2010 (3:21 PM).
    SIN1488's Avatar
    SIN1488 SIN1488 is offline
    Dedicated FluoroCarbons :P
       
      Join Date: Jul 2008
      Location: Orange County, CA
      Age: 25
      Gender: Male
      Nature: Modest
      Posts: 1,148
      I'll just say this, a ROM image is not a highly monitored thing, illegal or not. So the FBI is not going to break down your door for downloading this type of thing.

      I'm not trying to tell you to do something illegal in any way, but I'm just saying if someone did they would not get in trouble for it.
      __________________
      www.zoklet.net/bbs <> www.totse.info
      Freemasonry: Square your actions by the square of virtue.
      Twins Vika and Masha sent out...... What the?? PC Family ./\Little Sis'/\Little Brother/\Lil Sis'/\Uncle/\Long Lost Cousin/\Nephew from the future/\Little Sister/\Queen Aunt/\Reminder: 4 words per post
      Reply With Quote
        #3    
      Old April 16th, 2010 (3:37 PM).
      Prince_of_Light's Avatar
      Prince_of_Light Prince_of_Light is offline
      wins.
         
        Join Date: Jul 2009
        Location: Washington
        Age: 26
        Gender: Male
        Nature: Adamant
        Posts: 284
        Quote:
        Originally Posted by SIN1488 View Post
        I'll just say this, a ROM image is not a highly monitored thing, illegal or not. So the FBI is not going to break down your door for downloading this type of thing.

        I'm not trying to tell you to do something illegal in any way, but I'm just saying if someone did they would not get in trouble for it.
        I just like being on the right side of the law, lol. But if this is illegal I'd definitely lobby against it.
        Reply With Quote
          #4    
        Old April 16th, 2010 (3:40 PM).
        Team Rocket's Raichu Team Rocket's Raichu is offline
        Bye-Bye!
           
          Join Date: Mar 2009
          Age: 22
          Posts: 535
          It is still illegal, because you are playing the game under someone else's license to own and play the game. But if you were to make a ROM of your own game, then it wouldn't be illegal since it would be your license you are playing with.
          __________________

          I'm a supermod of that forum.

          I've left, bye PC.
          Reply With Quote
            #5    
          Old April 16th, 2010 (3:43 PM).
          SIN1488's Avatar
          SIN1488 SIN1488 is offline
          Dedicated FluoroCarbons :P
             
            Join Date: Jul 2008
            Location: Orange County, CA
            Age: 25
            Gender: Male
            Nature: Modest
            Posts: 1,148
            There are many stupid things that are illegal. Like for example, If I owned my own property, I couldn't make whatever obscene artwork I wanted, even if it was tucked away where only me or a guest could see it, just because it would be obscene enough to violate certain laws.
            Reply With Quote
              #6    
            Old April 16th, 2010 (3:53 PM).
            Prince_of_Light's Avatar
            Prince_of_Light Prince_of_Light is offline
            wins.
               
              Join Date: Jul 2009
              Location: Washington
              Age: 26
              Gender: Male
              Nature: Adamant
              Posts: 284
              Quote:
              Originally Posted by Team Rocket's Raichu View Post
              It is still illegal, because you are playing the game under someone else's license to own and play the game. But if you were to make a ROM of your own game, then it wouldn't be illegal since it would be your license you are playing with.
              Thank you, that helps things. Guess I'll have to clear out my ROMs now. =(

              Quote:
              Originally Posted by SIN1488 View Post
              There are many stupid things that are illegal. Like for example, If I owned my own property, I couldn't make whatever obscene artwork I wanted, even if it was tucked away where only me or a guest could see it, just because it would be obscene enough to violate certain laws.
              LET'S LOBBY! lolz.

              In this case, since my question is solved, let's make this thread a general discussion about the legality and ethical issues pertaining to ROMs. For fun's sake. =P
              Reply With Quote
                #7    
              Old April 16th, 2010 (7:15 PM).
              NarutoActor's Avatar
              NarutoActor NarutoActor is offline
              The rocks cry out to me
              • Silver Tier
               
              Join Date: Jan 2009
              Location: Brooklyn/Marlboro
              Age: 23
              Gender: Female
              Nature: Bashful
              Posts: 1,979
              In some states you can't have ice cream in your back pocket.

              But seriously it's like downloading music on Limewire. You can have it on a cd, but you still downloaded it.
              If it is illegal, who cares? xD
              __________________
              ~There are those people who understand hex, F the rest
              Reply With Quote
                #8    
              Old April 16th, 2010 (7:15 PM).
              Melody's Avatar
              Melody Melody is offline
              A LEGACY → Of Bygone Days and Nights
              • Crystal Tier
               
              Join Date: Oct 2004
              Location: Cuddling those close to me
              Gender: Female
              Nature: Naughty
              Posts: 6,384
              Quote:
              Originally Posted by Team Rocket's Raichu View Post
              It is still illegal, because you are playing the game under someone else's license to own and play the game. But if you were to make a ROM of your own game, then it wouldn't be illegal since it would be your license you are playing with.
              You are incorrect. It is perfectly legal to download a ROM of a game you physically own. Your license applies to the digital copy of the game as well.

              However it IS ILLEGAL to SHARE your digital copy. It's not the downloader who is punished, it's the one sharing the ROM file.
              __________________
              House Doctrina
              PAIRS
              Astral and Soipe

              Reply With Quote
                #9    
              Old April 16th, 2010 (7:38 PM).
              Prince_of_Light's Avatar
              Prince_of_Light Prince_of_Light is offline
              wins.
                 
                Join Date: Jul 2009
                Location: Washington
                Age: 26
                Gender: Male
                Nature: Adamant
                Posts: 284
                Quote:
                Originally Posted by Pachy View Post


                You are incorrect. It is perfectly legal to download a ROM of a game you physically own. Your license applies to the digital copy of the game as well.

                However it IS ILLEGAL to SHARE your digital copy. It's not the downloader who is punished, it's the one sharing the ROM file.
                That's not what Nintendo says. lol.

                Quote:
                Originally Posted by Nintendo Legal Information
                Can I Download a Nintendo ROM from the Internet if I Already Own the Authentic Game? There is a good deal of misinformation on the Internet regarding the backup/archival copy exception. It is not a "second copy" rule and is often mistakenly cited for the proposition that if you have one lawful copy of a copyrighted work, you are entitled to have a second copy of the copyrighted work even if that second copy is an infringing copy. The backup/archival copy exception is a very narrow limitation relating to a copy being made by the rightful owner of an authentic game to ensure he or she has one in the event of damage or destruction of the authentic. Therefore, whether you have an authentic game or not, or whether you have possession of a Nintendo ROM for a limited amount of time, i.e. 24 hours, it is illegal to download and play a Nintendo ROM from the Internet.

                source: http://www.nintendo.com/corp/legal.jsp#download_rom
                Reply With Quote
                  #10    
                Old April 16th, 2010 (8:23 PM).
                Chibi-chan's Avatar
                Chibi-chan Chibi-chan is offline
                The Freshmaker!
                • Crystal Tier
                 
                Join Date: Apr 2005
                Location: Over the Rainbow
                Nature: Mild
                Posts: 10,033
                All roms are illegal. Just buy the game again.
                __________________


                / / ////
                Reply With Quote
                  #11    
                Old April 16th, 2010 (8:49 PM).
                Prince_of_Light's Avatar
                Prince_of_Light Prince_of_Light is offline
                wins.
                   
                  Join Date: Jul 2009
                  Location: Washington
                  Age: 26
                  Gender: Male
                  Nature: Adamant
                  Posts: 284
                  Quote:
                  Originally Posted by Chibi-chan View Post
                  All roms are illegal. Just buy the game again.
                  My games work for the most part, thankfully. I took good care of my SNES. It's just irritating that you can't have multiple self-created copies of property you've paid for to be used for your own personal use. It's common sense. It's like telling people they can't make photocopies of a book and that you have to use the original book, and then when the book gets ruined since you can't make photocopies you have to go buy another one.
                  Reply With Quote
                    #12    
                  Old April 16th, 2010 (8:52 PM).
                  donavannj's Avatar
                  donavannj donavannj is offline
                  • Moderator
                  • Crystal Tier
                   
                  Join Date: Mar 2005
                  Location: 'cause it get cold like Minnesota
                  Age: 26
                  Gender: Male
                  Posts: 21,110
                  Quote:
                  Originally Posted by Prince_of_Light View Post
                  It's like telling people they can't make photocopies of a book and that you have to use the original book, and then when the book gets ruined you have to go buy another one.
                  Technically, you can't do this. :\
                  __________________
                  idol trash and game nerd
                  Reply With Quote
                    #13    
                  Old April 16th, 2010 (8:53 PM). Edited April 16th, 2010 by Prince_of_Light.
                  Prince_of_Light's Avatar
                  Prince_of_Light Prince_of_Light is offline
                  wins.
                     
                    Join Date: Jul 2009
                    Location: Washington
                    Age: 26
                    Gender: Male
                    Nature: Adamant
                    Posts: 284
                    Quote:
                    Originally Posted by donavannj View Post
                    Technically, you can't do this. :\
                    The world doesn't make sense. DX

                    What I find strange though is how none of this holds true for music. It's probably because of the nature of digital media though; making copies is necessary for MP3 players to be functional. I found out you can even have a spare burned copy on another CD and an unlimited amount of MP3 copies as long as they're for your own personal use and provided all the copies were made off of the CD/MP3s you own.

                    However, downloading in all cases is illegal, even if you own the music already. This means if your CD busted and you have no MP3 copies that are made from that CD then you're stuck buying a new CD.

                    Kinda destroys the spirit of the law if you ask me.
                    Reply With Quote
                      #14    
                    Old April 16th, 2010 (10:01 PM).
                    Zet's Avatar
                    Zet Zet is offline
                    • Platinum Tier
                     
                    Join Date: Sep 2007
                    Location: Brisbane, Australia
                    Age: 27
                    Gender: Male
                    Nature: Jolly
                    Posts: 7,755
                    Quote:
                    Originally Posted by Pachy View Post


                    You are incorrect. It is perfectly legal to download a ROM of a game you physically own. Your license applies to the digital copy of the game as well.

                    However it IS ILLEGAL to SHARE your digital copy. It's not the downloader who is punished, it's the one sharing the ROM file.
                    I'm afraid you're wrong Mr. Pachy, it is illegal to do anything with roms... even making roms is illegal.

                    Quote:
                    Originally Posted by Chibi-chan View Post
                    All roms are illegal. Just buy the game again.
                    Thank you for telling the truth, you shall be rewarded in the afterlife!
                    Reply With Quote
                      #15    
                    Old April 16th, 2010 (10:38 PM).
                    twocows's Avatar
                    twocows twocows is offline
                    Mostly Benign
                    • Gold Tier
                     
                    Join Date: Mar 2009
                    Location: Michigan
                    Age: 27
                    Gender: Male
                    Nature: Lax
                    Posts: 4,172
                    It's more or less a legal gray area right now; for the most part, though, it's illegal. Doesn't mean it's wrong, though.
                    __________________
                    8values
                    Political Simulator
                    Reply With Quote
                      #16    
                    Old April 18th, 2010 (5:33 PM).
                    Team Rocket's Raichu Team Rocket's Raichu is offline
                    Bye-Bye!
                       
                      Join Date: Mar 2009
                      Age: 22
                      Posts: 535
                      Quote:
                      Originally Posted by Zet View Post
                      I'm afraid you're wrong Mr. Pachy, it is illegal to do anything with roms... even making roms is illegal.
                      This is such a weird area. They area is such a grey one. In some states it is legal if you make your own. In others they are outright illegal.

                      The Supreme Court said it is illegal to make a ROM of a game if you put it on another cartridge. Though whether a computer, flash drive, or USB card would be considered is a cartridge is also grey.

                      They should make this black and white, not gray.
                      Reply With Quote
                        #17    
                      Old April 18th, 2010 (5:39 PM).
                      Zet's Avatar
                      Zet Zet is offline
                      • Platinum Tier
                       
                      Join Date: Sep 2007
                      Location: Brisbane, Australia
                      Age: 27
                      Gender: Male
                      Nature: Jolly
                      Posts: 7,755
                      Quote:
                      Originally Posted by Team Rocket's Raichu View Post


                      This is such a weird area. They area is such a grey one. In some states it is legal if you make your own. In others they are outright illegal.

                      The Supreme Court said it is illegal to make a ROM of a game if you put it on another cartridge. Though whether a computer, flash drive, or USB card would be considered is a cartridge is also grey.

                      They should make this black and white, not gray.
                      For America maybe, but it is illegal completely outside of the US iirc
                      Reply With Quote
                        #18    
                      Old April 18th, 2010 (7:09 PM).
                      Alistair Alistair is offline
                      • Silver Tier
                       
                      Join Date: Mar 2005
                      Age: 26
                      Nature: Quirky
                      Posts: 2,243
                      Quote:
                      Originally Posted by Zet View Post
                      For America maybe, but it is illegal completely outside of the US iirc
                      Not necessarily. Copyright laws are different in every country. That's why The Pirate Bay was trying to buy an island.

                      But I would just assume it's illegal, to be honest. It's too up-in-the-air for a definitive answer.
                      __________________
                      No signature to be found here...
                      Reply With Quote
                        #19    
                      Old April 19th, 2010 (9:08 AM).
                      Heart's Soul's Avatar
                      Heart's Soul Heart's Soul is offline
                      Hey, look, I was gone.
                         
                        Join Date: Nov 2007
                        Age: 22
                        Gender: Male
                        Posts: 2,536
                        Well, it depends if you own a prototype game, but nobody will break into your house for downloading ROMs. I only download prototypes and betas and demos. Those are legal.
                        __________________
                        I've been on this forum for about 10 years now. You guys wanna see a rare badge? I got some rare badges.
                        Reply With Quote
                          #20    
                        Old April 19th, 2010 (3:17 PM).
                        TheAppleFreak's Avatar
                        TheAppleFreak TheAppleFreak is offline
                        If it ain't broke, break it until it's fixed.
                           
                          Join Date: Oct 2009
                          Age: 23
                          Gender: Male
                          Nature: Modest
                          Posts: 791
                          I think it's perfectly legal; that's why I back up all of my DVDs to my computer for safekeeping.
                          Reply With Quote
                            #21    
                          Old April 19th, 2010 (4:04 PM).
                          Zet's Avatar
                          Zet Zet is offline
                          • Platinum Tier
                           
                          Join Date: Sep 2007
                          Location: Brisbane, Australia
                          Age: 27
                          Gender: Male
                          Nature: Jolly
                          Posts: 7,755
                          Quote:
                          Originally Posted by Heart's Soul View Post
                          Well, it depends if you own a prototype game, but nobody will break into your house for downloading ROMs. I only download prototypes and betas and demos. Those are legal.
                          Wouldn't they only be disclosed to a certain group of people and not given away to everyone?
                          Reply With Quote
                            #22    
                          Old April 19th, 2010 (4:47 PM).
                          Alistair Alistair is offline
                          • Silver Tier
                           
                          Join Date: Mar 2005
                          Age: 26
                          Nature: Quirky
                          Posts: 2,243
                          Fair use on the grounds of preservation purposes would like to say "Hi." But even then, it's still not clearly defined and could go either way.
                          Reply With Quote
                            #23    
                          Old April 21st, 2010 (6:47 PM).
                          Heart's Soul's Avatar
                          Heart's Soul Heart's Soul is offline
                          Hey, look, I was gone.
                             
                            Join Date: Nov 2007
                            Age: 22
                            Gender: Male
                            Posts: 2,536
                            Quote:
                            Originally Posted by Zet View Post
                            Wouldn't they only be disclosed to a certain group of people and not given away to everyone?
                            I could go into the case of STARFOX2 for Japan which was released as a ROM online, it was legal to download, and we got an English patch.
                            Reply With Quote
                              #24    
                            Old April 22nd, 2010 (11:19 AM).
                            Yusshin's Avatar
                            Yusshin Yusshin is offline
                            ♪ Yggdrasil ♪
                               
                              Join Date: Jul 2009
                              Location: Quebec, Canada
                              Age: 25
                              Nature: Brave
                              Posts: 2,424
                              You can make copies of your game for yourself only as long as you've bought the product already. You can't give the copies to friends, though, and you certainly can't sell'em. If you don't own the product, it's illegal to download it.

                              Some companies don't even permit back-ups, like Nintendo ($.$); Sony and Microsoft don't really care, as long as you buy the game once.

                              All Nintendo game handbooks state specifically that back-ups "are not needed". That message is not on Sony or Microsoft games.
                              __________________


                              Polaret | Fourette | Ecuret | Axew | Zorua | Nanette [Shiny]
                              "My scar makes me sassy, child!"
                              The Big Bang Theory Fan Club - Click To Join!
                              The French Club
                              Reply With Quote
                                #25    
                              Old April 22nd, 2010 (11:32 AM).
                              JakeyBoy's Avatar
                              JakeyBoy JakeyBoy is offline
                              Riddle me this
                                 
                                Join Date: Jan 2009
                                Location: Scotland
                                Age: 24
                                Gender: Female
                                Nature: Naughty
                                Posts: 394
                                For all saying you can make your own backups, I've read elsewhere that that isn't even true either. I'll have to find that quote.
                                Anyway, not encouraging you or anything, but I can't say I've heard of a case where the downloader was prosecuted.
                                Reply With Quote
                                Reply

                                Quick Reply

                                Join the conversation!

                                Create an account to post a reply in this thread, participate in other discussions, and more!

                                Create a PokéCommunity Account

                                Sponsored Links
                                Thread Tools

                                Posting Rules
                                You may not post new threads
                                You may not post replies
                                You may not post attachments
                                You may not edit your posts

                                BB code is On
                                Smilies are On
                                [IMG] code is On
                                HTML code is Off

                                Forum Jump


                                All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:59 PM.