Game Development Your number one stop for anything related to creating games (except ROM hacks). You can even make your own!

Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #1    
Old August 11th, 2012 (8:11 AM).
Dragonite Ernston's Avatar
Dragonite Ernston Dragonite Ernston is offline
I rival Lance's.
     
    Join Date: May 2010
    Gender: Male
    Posts: 149
    One of the things I did while starting to create Four Star Mon was to propose revamps of almost every single formula in the Pokémon games.

    I've actually implemented a few of them in the engine itself, and they seem to work just fine. But I know from seeing many posts on here that some people are averse to such developments, because they like to stick to what already works. What are you guys' stance on doing new, unexpected things with the game mechanics?
    Reply With Quote

    Relevant Advertising!

      #2    
    Old August 11th, 2012 (9:11 AM).
    Yamiidenryuu's Avatar
    Yamiidenryuu Yamiidenryuu is offline
       
      Join Date: Oct 2011
      Posts: 185
      Why not? As long as the end result is workable for the player, it shouldn't matter too much exactly what formulas you used to get there, right? And the main games changed the EXP yield formula in Gen 5, so it's not entirely unprecedented. Changing things for the sake of changing them instead of because you've found something you think works better seems like a bad idea, though.
      __________________

      Cheren Comic is a comic about Cheren! Go read it.
      Reply With Quote
        #3    
      Old August 11th, 2012 (11:11 AM).
      DaSpirit's Avatar
      DaSpirit DaSpirit is offline
      Mad Programmer
         
        Join Date: Jul 2007
        Location: New York City
        Gender: Male
        Nature: Quiet
        Posts: 240
        "Ain't" is improper grammar.

        Anyway, sure, I think it's a good idea. You just have to be careful to make sure that everything still stays balanced. Then again, some people argue that the official people games are unbalanced.
        Reply With Quote
          #4    
        Old August 11th, 2012 (12:03 PM).
        RaulCortez's Avatar
        RaulCortez RaulCortez is offline
        Maybe active...sometimes?
           
          Join Date: Sep 2011
          Location: Panamá, Panamá
          Age: 27
          Gender: Male
          Nature: Sassy
          Posts: 95
          If you're making a fan game, and you want to do something creative and different, why not change stuff?

          It's your game, and like Yami said, as long as it works for the player it shouldn't matter what you tweaked, it's like in performing arts - The public doesn't know what you're doing or how you did it, they just see the result and judge if they like it or not based on that. If you think those changes work and make the game a better experience and you enjoy them, then by all means you should do it!

          (By the way, i'm very interested about your Four Star Mon game. Where can i see it? Looks like an interesting idea!:D)
          __________________

          Name: Bellefleur
          Adopt one yourself! @Pokémon Orphanage
          Reply With Quote
            #5    
          Old August 11th, 2012 (1:42 PM). Edited August 27th, 2012 by DarkDoom3000.
          DarkDoom3000's Avatar
          DarkDoom3000 DarkDoom3000 is offline
          Super Pokemon Eevee Edition
             
            Join Date: Jul 2004
            Location: New Zealand
            Age: 25
            Gender: Male
            Nature: Calm
            Posts: 1,694
            Don't fix what ain't broke is the reason official pokemon games have stagnated.

            theres thousands of hacks out there for people who want a 1:1 pokemon experience.

            we have cool engines, instead of copying features exactly, we should try to impove on the standard pokemon formular.
            __________________
            Version 0.753 is out
            Thread | Website | Blog
            Reply With Quote
              #6    
            Old August 11th, 2012 (6:11 PM).
            Dragonite Ernston's Avatar
            Dragonite Ernston Dragonite Ernston is offline
            I rival Lance's.
               
              Join Date: May 2010
              Gender: Male
              Posts: 149
              Thanks for all your replies.

              Quote:
              Originally Posted by Yamiidenryuu View Post
              Changing things for the sake of changing them instead of because you've found something you think works better seems like a bad idea, though.
              Often changing things requires the thought of wanting to change them first, and that will always be for the sake of changing them because you're unsatisfied with simply "sticking to what works".

              Sometimes the change isn't for the better, in which case you always have the old way to revert to. But it's never a waste of time to try something new when designing games, in my opinion.

              Quote:
              Originally Posted by DaSpirit View Post
              "Ain't" is improper grammar.
              I'm quoting Bert Lance who said, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it."

              "Broke" is also improper grammar in this case, but I didn't see you correct that

              Quote:
              Anyway, sure, I think it's a good idea. You just have to be careful to make sure that everything still stays balanced. Then again, some people argue that the official people games are unbalanced.
              Well, balancing is an independent concern, relevant more to game design itself than staying faithful to or straying from the Pokémon games.

              Quote:
              Originally Posted by RaulCortez View Post
              (By the way, i'm very interested about your Four Star Mon game. Where can i see it? Looks like an interesting idea! :D)
              It's not a game, it's an engine. http://fourstarmon.com/
              Reply With Quote
                #7    
              Old August 12th, 2012 (11:28 PM).
              audinowho's Avatar
              audinowho audinowho is offline
              我是谁?
                 
                Join Date: Jul 2012
                Gender: Male
                Posts: 67
                It's really up to you. What's there in Pokemon games already works. If you want to try something new, it might be better, it might be worse. Since you're working on an engine, it might just be up to the user of that engine to pick whether or not they want to use a formula.
                Reply With Quote
                  #8    
                Old August 22nd, 2012 (11:38 AM).
                Laurenellis's Avatar
                Laurenellis Laurenellis is offline
                   
                  Join Date: Jun 2012
                  Location: Austin, TX
                  Gender: Female
                  Nature: Quirky
                  Posts: 17
                  Quote:
                  Originally Posted by DarkDoom3000 View Post
                  Don't fix what ain't broke is the reason official pokemon games have stagnated.

                  theres thousands of hacks out there for people who want a 1:1 pokemon experience.
                  Totally agree. 16 years of the same formula. But it works and it sells.
                  __________________


                  I'm working on the newest monster catching game for Andriod and iOS: Deozoa! So excited!

                  Reply With Quote
                    #9    
                  Old August 23rd, 2012 (10:40 AM). Edited August 23rd, 2012 by KingCharizard.
                  KingCharizard's Avatar
                  KingCharizard KingCharizard is offline
                  C++ Developer Extraordinaire
                     
                    Join Date: Dec 2009
                    Location: Pennsylvania
                    Age: 28
                    Gender: Male
                    Nature: Bold
                    Posts: 1,250
                    To answer the OP's question as a developer its good to experiment test things see what works and what doesn't. Feedback should help you develop the best product but it shouldn't dictate the final product
                    __________________
                    Reply With Quote
                      #10    
                    Old August 25th, 2012 (12:46 AM).
                    Darkroman Darkroman is offline
                       
                      Join Date: Oct 2011
                      Gender: Male
                      Nature: Adamant
                      Posts: 181
                      I'm conflicted by this to be honest. In one way, it's great because it's very familiar and it's what I've been used to for the past 14 years. In another way, I'd love something a little fresh, and I don't mean a new region, or new pokemon. I mean set in a completely different era of pokemon (past or future). Same RPG, but much different story flow so to speak.
                      Reply With Quote
                        #11    
                      Old August 27th, 2012 (11:59 AM).
                      KingCharizard's Avatar
                      KingCharizard KingCharizard is offline
                      C++ Developer Extraordinaire
                         
                        Join Date: Dec 2009
                        Location: Pennsylvania
                        Age: 28
                        Gender: Male
                        Nature: Bold
                        Posts: 1,250
                        Quote:
                        Originally Posted by Darkroman View Post
                        I'm conflicted by this to be honest. In one way, it's great because it's very familiar and it's what I've been used to for the past 14 years. In another way, I'd love something a little fresh, and I don't mean a new region, or new pokemon. I mean set in a completely different era of pokemon (past or future). Same RPG, but much different story flow so to speak.
                        Then go for it. Try something new. Its what good developers do all the time..
                        __________________
                        Reply With Quote
                          #12    
                        Old September 19th, 2012 (7:03 AM).
                        TheMrQuit's Avatar
                        TheMrQuit TheMrQuit is offline
                        Egg: It's going to hatch soon!
                           
                          Join Date: Aug 2012
                          Location: Italy
                          Gender: Male
                          Nature: Lax
                          Posts: 18
                          I absolutely agree with that. If you don't change the formula to a game, it's just the same game with different graphics and some additional features and we have plenty of examples of these kind of games. Be free to change it: experimenting is the key to improve.
                          __________________
                          This is my signature!

                          Reply With Quote
                          Reply
                          Quick Reply

                          Sponsored Links
                          Thread Tools

                          Posting Rules
                          You may not post new threads
                          You may not post replies
                          You may not post attachments
                          You may not edit your posts

                          BB code is On
                          Smilies are On
                          [IMG] code is On
                          HTML code is Off

                          Forum Jump


                          All times are GMT -8. The time now is 6:01 PM.