An awesome thread that died because of a Stunfisk.
Anyways, to play one person just posts a WHAT IF question, and the next person has to answer, then give their own WHAT IF.

Example:
Poster 1: What if...Pokemon shut down after 2nd gen.

Poster 2: Then I wouldn't know what the heck a pokemon is.
What if...Munchlax ate so much, he exploded?

(etc.)

So, I'll start:
What if...
Nintendo held a make your own pokemon contest, and the winner was a Digimon.

Then I would 1) Kill the hoster, and 2) bludgeon to death the winning artist.
Oh and btw Game Freak owns Pokémon

Q: What if Pokémon were actually animals?

Then I imagine it would be immensely less interesting, and the animal rights activists would make a very large fuss indeed.

What if animals were actually Pokémon? (throwing you all for a loop with how original and inspired I clearly am)

I would hide behind cement walls as they took over the Earth. :0

What if team rocket took over Kanto?

Then we would start off as rocket grunts instead of gold in GSC.

What if a Joltik appears suddenly in real life and jumps on top of your head?

I would probably die from electrocution.

What if you woke up at Spear Pillar and Cyrus was awakening Arceus?

i would scream

what if pokemon made a remake of hoenn region?

I would buy both remakes of Ruby and Sapphire, and then beat both of them...then buy 2 more copies of the game...beat both of them, buy 2 MORE copies of the game...etc.

What would happen if Giovanni and Red had an epic battle with each person having opposite legendaries (so if Giovanni had Mewtwo, Red would have Mew. If Giovanni had Palkia, Red would have Dialga. If Giovanni had Kyogre, Red would have Groudon...etc.)

then it would be a disaster

what if zubats disappeared?

Woobats would take their place...Game Freak was soooo creative with the WOobat concept.

WHAT IF...Legendary Pokemon were impossible to obtain in any game unless you used hacks.

then everyone would have a hacked game and pokmon would discontinue their games

what if you could join team rocket and other evil organizations in the game?

I would like the games even more
what if arceus was real and was the one who created pokemon?

Then Red would win, and Ash's destiny to become a pokemon master would end right there.

What if...all the gen v pokemon were gen I pokemon and vice versa.

Nothing. Genwunners will Genwun no matter what.

What if you could battle Kcalb in BW2?

I have no idea who Kcalb is o.o; So...um...then, Mew would appear...and then...um...the game would explode.

What if...Pikachu did not go "Pika Pika" and instead went "AUGH! MY KNEE! THAT'S MY * KNEE!" in pokemon battles.

Then no one would be an adventurer anymore...dang arrows.

What if MissingNo was a legendary?

Then I would catch it

What if there was an Individual Arceus for all Types

Then there would be 17x more Arceus.

What if...the pokemon anime did an episode where a musical pokemon of some sort curses Ash and his friends so that they can't stop singing? (Musical episode fdw!)

Then it would be derpicly awesome.

What if the battle at Spear Pillar was interrupted by a certain large black dog? HP fans you know what I mean...

Then those of us who don't know what you mean(me xD) would all turn into zombies because the large black dog was cursed.

What if....Pikachu learned how to play spanish guitar

Then names like Black 2 or White 2 would be placeholder names.

What if Pokemon had a game based on one of its movies?

Then I wouldn't buy it....face it, nobody wants to play as le nooby Ash.

WHAT IF....Ash was a robot, and every time that an Ash-droid malfunctioned, they replaced it with a new one....

Then the anime would show Ash getting changed every time, because the robot was badly manufactured.

What if...Mew was everywhere where we walked?