Fifth Generation Are Pokémon slaves to humans? Team Plasma thinks so. Travel the Unova region and prove them wrong in Black & White, and then return two years later in Black 2 & White 2.

View Poll Results: What do you think of Ghetsis trying to freeze you alive instead of killing you?
Good that they did it, it makes it safer for kids 3 5.45%
I like it, it makes the scene a bit scarier (intentionally or unintentionally) 14 25.45%
Indifferent 16 29.09%
They should have censored it but in a different way, or not to the same extent 1 1.82%
They should have just left it the same as in Japanese 21 38.18%
Voters: 55. You may not vote on this poll

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools
  #1    
Old October 8th, 2012 (9:05 AM). Edited October 8th, 2012 by Darthrai.
Darthrai's Avatar
Darthrai Darthrai is offline
Dragon Tamer
     
    Join Date: Feb 2011
    Age: 25
    Gender: Male
    Nature: Lonely
    Posts: 65
    So Ghetsis doesn't try to murder Nate/Rosa after all in the English version. He simply tries to freeze them solid. But not only that, he does it so that they can "watch his glorious ascent".



    What do you guys think?

    Personally, I think this was kind of a stupid move. Lots of kids' shows and movies use "kill" and "die" without hesitation. It makes Ghetsis sound a lot more cartoonish and less of a monster, and the fact that they made a point of the protagonist still being alive isn't a good sign either (even "I'll freeze you solid right here and let you be" would have been way better while still being safe for little kids).

    It reminds me a lot of "Han shot first" in Star Wars, where a change to a tiny little scene to make it more politically correct kinda ruins the characterization of a major character. I can see this becoming the "Han shot first" of the Pokemon fandom ("Ghetsis tried to kill you" T-shirts, anyone?)

    And just for fun, here's a Dolan comic about it (warning: some (albeit misspelled) language):
    http://knowyourmeme.com/photos/414357-dolan
    __________________
    Instagram | Facebook | deviantART

    Relevant Advertising!

      #2    
    Old October 8th, 2012 (9:12 AM).
    Sydian's Avatar
    Sydian Sydian is offline
    case CLOSED.
    • Crystal Tier
     
    Join Date: Feb 2008
    Location: Alabama
    Age: 25
    Nature: Timid
    Posts: 32,104
    Can you fix the link on the comic? lol Can't watch the vid cause I'm in class...anyway, I didn't even know he tried to kill you in the Jap versions. But hey, censorship is nothing new. Nothing new at all. If you're not Japanese, you're automatically in a super-sensitive country so there you go!
    __________________
    ≫ they took a little look at my heart
    they found a prince living behind bars ≪

    challenges | klippy
      #3    
    Old October 8th, 2012 (9:12 AM).
    Killjoy's Avatar
    Killjoy Killjoy is offline
    "He was a laser fish."
       
      Join Date: Oct 2011
      Location: Brandon, MB. Canada
      Gender: Male
      Nature: Quiet
      Posts: 584
      Whatever. Generally freezing someone solid would kill that someone.... So I wouldn't read into it that much.


      That being said, a lot of parent groups have it out for Pokémon. I think GF would just like to avoid giving them anymore ammo than they already have
      __________________
        #4    
      Old October 8th, 2012 (9:17 AM).
      shengar's Avatar
      shengar shengar is offline
      ♥ Mikan Enthusiast ♥
         
        Join Date: May 2010
        Age: 23
        Gender: Male
        Nature: Lonely
        Posts: 667
        This is suck really
        Their effort to maturized the series still hindered by needless censorship.
        Like you said, there are A LOT of show where the character threaten another character with "kill" or "die". Why should they censor it at all? There are worse thing out there and it not even censored.

        EDIT: Actually, in my opinion freezes someone alive while they still conscious considere as fate worse than dead
        Just imagine being frozen for Arceus-know-when while you still have your mind.
        Seriously this kind of censorship would get us to nowhere as it only make things even worse than before
        __________________


        Pokemon is a Japanese RPG Made By a Japanese Developer With Japanese Audience in Mind I tell You
          #5    
        Old October 8th, 2012 (9:18 AM).
        Darthrai's Avatar
        Darthrai Darthrai is offline
        Dragon Tamer
           
          Join Date: Feb 2011
          Age: 25
          Gender: Male
          Nature: Lonely
          Posts: 65
          Quote:
          Originally Posted by Killjoy View Post
          Whatever. Generally freezing someone solid would kill that someone.... So I wouldn't read into it that much.


          That being said, a lot of parent groups have it out for Pokémon. I think GF would just like to avoid giving them anymore ammo than they already have
          Well... at least to me, it looks like Ghetsis is making a point of keeping the protagonist alive.

          As for parent groups, I do remember that they complained about Pokémon a lot in the '90s. Maybe that's why they're so prudish about censorship (this and censoring "Afro Break" and the word "afro" too, though that might have had more to do with the Jynx controversy too). Still, it's been 15 years, and I'm sure that they can safely stop doing that kind of thing...

          Quote:
          Originally Posted by shengar View Post
          This is suck really
          Their effort to maturized the series still hindered by needless censorship.
          Like you said, there are A LOT of show where the character threaten another character with "kill" or "die". Why should they censor it at all? There are worse thing out there and it not even censored.
          Exactly - suddenly, BW1 seem like the darker games than BW2. I know it was only one line, but still, "Han shot first".

          And the comic link has been fixed
          __________________
          Instagram | Facebook | deviantART
            #6    
          Old October 8th, 2012 (9:26 AM).
          shengar's Avatar
          shengar shengar is offline
          ♥ Mikan Enthusiast ♥
             
            Join Date: May 2010
            Age: 23
            Gender: Male
            Nature: Lonely
            Posts: 667
            Quote:
            Originally Posted by Darthrai View Post
            Well... at least to me, it looks like Ghetsis is making a point of keeping the protagonist alive.

            As for parent groups, I do remember that they complained about Pokémon a lot in the '90s. Maybe that's why they're so prudish about censorship (this and censoring "Afro Break" and the word "afro" too, though that might have had more to do with the Jynx controversy too). Still, it's been 15 years, and I'm sure that they can safely stop doing that kind of thing...



            Exactly - suddenly, BW1 seem like the darker games than BW2. I know it was only one line, but still, "Han shot first".

            And the comic link has been fixed
            Yeah, Pokemon past experience with controversy in US make Nintendo take really conservative approach when handling this franchise. Just look at the needless redesign of Lenora.

            Also you can check my edited comment
            __________________


            Pokemon is a Japanese RPG Made By a Japanese Developer With Japanese Audience in Mind I tell You
              #7    
            Old October 8th, 2012 (11:39 AM). Edited October 8th, 2012 by Darthrai.
            Darthrai's Avatar
            Darthrai Darthrai is offline
            Dragon Tamer
               
              Join Date: Feb 2011
              Age: 25
              Gender: Male
              Nature: Lonely
              Posts: 65
              Quote:
              Originally Posted by shengar View Post
              Yeah, Pokemon past experience with controversy in US make Nintendo take really conservative approach when handling this franchise. Just look at the needless redesign of Lenora.

              Also you can check my edited comment
              Actually, the Lenora redesign made sense in my opinion - from what I read, they even recursively applied it to Japan too. She seemed like less of a racist stereotype and more of a positive character in the English version, and IMO it's one of the few good censorship changes they've made (along with Jynx).

              Being frozen alive being a "fate worse than death" is probably unintentional Fridge Horror rather than an honest attempt on their part to keep Ghetsis scary while censoring. They're probably trying to give the impression that Nate/Rosa are just frozen in the same (relatively minor) way that Pokemon are frozen during battles. >.<

              You know things are bad when the ANIME is the incarnation of the franchise that uses "kill" and "die" the most often.

              EDIT: And meanwhile, the game has this in it too... inconsistent standards anyone?
              __________________
              Instagram | Facebook | deviantART
                #8    
              Old October 8th, 2012 (11:46 AM).
              Superjub's Avatar
              Superjub Superjub is offline
              Pokémon Aureolin
              • Crystal Tier
               
              Join Date: Sep 2007
              Location: Hoenn
              Age: 22
              Gender: Male
              Nature: Timid
              Posts: 2,286
              'eh, I'm not too fussed. As long as they're not removing content *cough* Game Corner *cough* or changing the storyline massively (such as getting rid of a character, completely changing the plot or whatever) then I don't really mind.
              __________________
                #9    
              Old October 8th, 2012 (12:03 PM).
              Darthrai's Avatar
              Darthrai Darthrai is offline
              Dragon Tamer
                 
                Join Date: Feb 2011
                Age: 25
                Gender: Male
                Nature: Lonely
                Posts: 65
                Added a poll so you guys can express your opinions
                __________________
                Instagram | Facebook | deviantART
                  #10    
                Old October 8th, 2012 (11:41 PM).
                shengar's Avatar
                shengar shengar is offline
                ♥ Mikan Enthusiast ♥
                   
                  Join Date: May 2010
                  Age: 23
                  Gender: Male
                  Nature: Lonely
                  Posts: 667
                  Quote:
                  Originally Posted by Darthrai View Post
                  Actually, the Lenora redesign made sense in my opinion - from what I read, they even recursively applied it to Japan too. She seemed like less of a racist stereotype and more of a positive character in the English version, and IMO it's one of the few good censorship changes they've made (along with Jynx).

                  Being frozen alive being a "fate worse than death" is probably unintentional Fridge Horror rather than an honest attempt on their part to keep Ghetsis scary while censoring. They're probably trying to give the impression that Nate/Rosa are just frozen in the same (relatively minor) way that Pokemon are frozen during battles. >.<

                  You know things are bad when the ANIME is the incarnation of the franchise that uses "kill" and "die" the most often.

                  EDIT: And meanwhile, the game has this in it too... inconsistent standards anyone?
                  Woa, that was something new to me
                  I always though that Lenora's "apron" supposed to keep the dust away from her clothes while see cleaning up relics and stuff.
                  Well, it just me but I never saw Lenora as racist stereotype whatsoever. Because yeah, her character

                  Unintentional Fridge Horror, yeah so damned true >__>
                  Does Nintendo give a further thought about this when censoring? It already gave me the chill how Ghetsis keeps you alive while he doing his evil deeds. Its the same when Bane keeps Batman alive just toa make sure he witness the destruction of Gotham. Even Batman ask someone to kill him outright.


                  I even vote poll number 2 for the sake of sarcasm

                  EDIT: uhh, what that picture supposed to mean? Is the biker getting......
                  __________________


                  Pokemon is a Japanese RPG Made By a Japanese Developer With Japanese Audience in Mind I tell You
                    #11    
                  Old October 9th, 2012 (4:56 AM).
                  Satoshi Ookami's Avatar
                  Satoshi Ookami Satoshi Ookami is offline
                  Memento Mori
                  • Gold Tier
                   
                  Join Date: Jul 2008
                  Location: Abyss of Time, Great Seal
                  Age: 25
                  Gender: Male
                  Nature: Calm
                  Posts: 14,494
                  Well... American versions... I'm always saying that censorship destroys American versions... and that's why I hate them...
                  __________________
                  ROM hacking FAQ - Read before asking how to play a hack.

                  Anime List | PSN Trophy List
                    #12    
                  Old October 9th, 2012 (5:28 AM).
                  Rodriguezjames55's Avatar
                  Rodriguezjames55 Rodriguezjames55 is offline
                  No Jokes #MegaCharizard
                     
                    Join Date: Jan 2012
                    Location: United states, New York, New York City, Bronx
                    Age: 21
                    Gender: Male
                    Nature: Adamant
                    Posts: 391
                    damn soccer moms ruining america i think its stupid
                    __________________
                      #13    
                    Old October 9th, 2012 (5:38 AM).
                    BZW Golem's Avatar
                    BZW Golem BZW Golem is offline
                    Conspirator~
                    • Crystal Tier
                     
                    Join Date: Feb 2012
                    Location: Poland
                    Age: 22
                    Gender: Female
                    Posts: 142
                    Well, freezing means dying in most cases anyway.

                    But that sharp icicles don't make it look like trying to "freeze", but to pierce o.0

                    Oh well, I HOPE that my european version will not have this change.. but that may be only my hope >..>"
                    __________________

                    None at the moment, but Mac rules, just saying.
                      #14    
                    Old October 9th, 2012 (6:05 AM).
                    RedJ's Avatar
                    RedJ RedJ is offline
                       
                      Join Date: Dec 2008
                      Location: Over thar
                      Gender: Male
                      Nature: Quiet
                      Posts: 1,423
                      Quote:
                      Originally Posted by shengar View Post
                      Does Nintendo give a further thought about this when censoring? It already gave me the chill how Ghetsis keeps you alive
                      BAHAHAHA pun *smacked*

                      Anyway, I'm not too upset over it. I figured they would do something like this- in fact, I was under the impression that when Ghetsis said 'kill' he was just going to have Kyurem freeze the protagonist anyway...although that doesn't exactly guarantee death, but meh.
                      __________________

                        #15    
                      Old October 9th, 2012 (7:52 AM).
                      Blade_of_darkness Blade_of_darkness is offline
                      Banned
                         
                        Join Date: Oct 2011
                        Gender: Male
                        Nature: Rash
                        Posts: 595
                        Here's the way I see it: Being frozen alive is a slower & more horrible way to die, so I'm not seeing what all the fuss is about with this regard.

                        Think about it, you've got hypothermia & frostbite mixed together, & if left that way, your going to die. Also, if Ghetsis threatens to kill the MC, we won't know how he's going to kill him/her - It might be some quick & painless method, or the worst thing anyone can imagine. We'll never know.
                          #16    
                        Old October 9th, 2012 (7:58 AM).
                        droomph's Avatar
                        droomph droomph is offline
                        weeb
                        • Crystal Tier
                         
                        Join Date: Sep 2011
                        Location: nowhere spectacular
                        Age: 20
                        Gender: Male
                        Nature: Impish
                        Posts: 4,291
                        I mean, English has a much bigger vocabulary by default - and in Japanese, how they say it is a lot different, though they use the same word.

                        I don't really care but I'm kinda disappointed that that would happen?
                        __________________
                        did u no there r 21 letters in the alphabet
                        o i forgot 5
                        uraqt


                          #17    
                        Old October 9th, 2012 (8:50 AM).
                        Lord Varion's Avatar
                        Lord Varion Lord Varion is offline
                        Guess who's back?
                           
                          Join Date: Feb 2009
                          Age: 23
                          Gender: Other
                          Nature: Naughty
                          Posts: 2,644
                          To be fair, The general rule in gaming, is you can't harm the children. Which makes every single pokémon trainer main character invincible.

                          And in my eyes, Freezing em alive and killing them would have the same outcome.
                          EDIT: Also, unless you speak and read fluent japanese, do you really know what ghetsis said, and if he was trying to kill you, or still freeze?
                          __________________
                          gone.
                            #18    
                          Old October 9th, 2012 (9:13 AM).
                          droomph's Avatar
                          droomph droomph is offline
                          weeb
                          • Crystal Tier
                           
                          Join Date: Sep 2011
                          Location: nowhere spectacular
                          Age: 20
                          Gender: Male
                          Nature: Impish
                          Posts: 4,291
                          I never said they were, I just said that it cld be a possibility.
                          __________________
                          did u no there r 21 letters in the alphabet
                          o i forgot 5
                          uraqt


                            #19    
                          Old October 9th, 2012 (9:32 AM).
                          Lord Varion's Avatar
                          Lord Varion Lord Varion is offline
                          Guess who's back?
                             
                            Join Date: Feb 2009
                            Age: 23
                            Gender: Other
                            Nature: Naughty
                            Posts: 2,644
                            I never said the post was directed at you. xD
                            And i didn't see your post.
                            __________________
                            gone.
                              #20    
                            Old October 9th, 2012 (2:16 PM).
                            Darthrai's Avatar
                            Darthrai Darthrai is offline
                            Dragon Tamer
                               
                              Join Date: Feb 2011
                              Age: 25
                              Gender: Male
                              Nature: Lonely
                              Posts: 65
                              Quote:
                              Originally Posted by Nintendork15 View Post
                              To be fair, The general rule in gaming, is you can't harm the children. Which makes every single pokémon trainer main character invincible.

                              And in my eyes, Freezing em alive and killing them would have the same outcome.
                              EDIT: Also, unless you speak and read fluent japanese, do you really know what ghetsis said, and if he was trying to kill you, or still freeze?
                              It's possible that they might have been trying to give the impression that it's "temporary freezing that can be undone by the tears of poor Pokémon to bring you back". You know, just like in the Pokémon movies! *facepalm*

                              Or, they might have translated it so that little kids interpret it that way, while older players take it more seriously and know how lethal it is. I wish we had an interview of some kind where we could find out what they intended when they translated it...

                              It's also possible that they bowdlerized it just to prevent the games from getting an E10+ rating, anyone think of that?
                              __________________
                              Instagram | Facebook | deviantART
                                #21    
                              Old October 9th, 2012 (2:35 PM).
                              DenCabe's Avatar
                              DenCabe DenCabe is offline
                              Striaton Gym Leader
                                 
                                Join Date: Oct 2012
                                Location: Striaton City
                                Age: 21
                                Gender: Female
                                Nature: Quiet
                                Posts: 1
                                Cutting stuff out/Censoring when Translated is messed up.:cer_shifty:
                                __________________
                                  #22    
                                Old October 9th, 2012 (5:56 PM).
                                Wobbachomp's Avatar
                                Wobbachomp Wobbachomp is offline
                                • Silver Tier
                                 
                                Join Date: Sep 2012
                                Location: If a mudkip could kip mud
                                Gender: Male
                                Nature: Adamant
                                Posts: 106
                                Well, I can't really say I care about this much.
                                  #23    
                                Old October 10th, 2012 (3:52 AM).
                                DarkWolf13's Avatar
                                DarkWolf13 DarkWolf13 is offline
                                Battle Subway Editor
                                   
                                  Join Date: Dec 2011
                                  Location: RF HQ
                                  Gender: Male
                                  Nature: Careful
                                  Posts: 250
                                  Eh... don't care of the change. This is like a localization thing. I was expecting something like this from the start. It's obvious the Japanese are more tolerant to violent actions such as Ghetsis trying to actually kill the protagonist. This may seem a little off topic but in the US version of Final Fight 1 & 2 for the SNES, there were NO female enemies because the issue of "domestic violence".
                                  __________________
                                  All forum members BEWARE OF THE DARK WOLF..!
                                    #24    
                                  Old October 10th, 2012 (12:33 PM).
                                  Palkia's Avatar
                                  Palkia Palkia is offline
                                  the thread killer™
                                  • Crystal Tier
                                   
                                  Join Date: Apr 2010
                                  Gender: Male
                                  Posts: 2,311
                                  What's the difference, and why are we making such a deal over it.

                                  In short Death = Frozen Alive. It's just another way of killing someone. No actual censorship here.
                                    #25    
                                  Old October 10th, 2012 (12:48 PM).
                                  Yuzuru Otonashi's Avatar
                                  Yuzuru Otonashi Yuzuru Otonashi is offline
                                  A new start...
                                     
                                    Join Date: Oct 2012
                                    Age: 24
                                    Gender: Male
                                    Nature: Lonely
                                    Posts: 23
                                    ... I don't get it, what's the issue?

                                    Honestly, if Japanese DOES say kill, then the localized version does it better. Freezing to death, especially to watch as they die, is a lot more fitting than just killing them, and I honestly cant see the issue.
                                    Closed Thread
                                    Quick Reply

                                    Sponsored Links
                                    Thread Tools

                                    Posting Rules
                                    You may not post new threads
                                    You may not post replies
                                    You may not post attachments
                                    You may not edit your posts

                                    BB code is On
                                    Smilies are On
                                    [IMG] code is On
                                    HTML code is Off

                                    Forum Jump


                                    All times are GMT -8. The time now is 7:20 PM.