The PokéCommunity Forums Pokémon: Main Series Games Second Generation
Gold or Heartgold continuity

Second Generation Following the success of Red, Blue and Yellow, Pokémon Gold, Silver and Crystal introduced fans to an exciting new world full of new Pokémon to find, catch and train. Reminisce about your favourite moments in the Johto region, share your adventures and argue about the Johto master race.

Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #1    
Old March 9th, 2013 (11:49 AM).
LeftNut's Avatar
LeftNut LeftNut is offline
     
    Join Date: Mar 2013
    Gender: Male
    Posts: 60
    Around the internet, tons of people have gotten mad at me for saying that the main character's name is Gold instead of Ethan, usually scream something along the lines of "BULBAPEDIA SAYS IT'S ETHAN SO IT'S ETHAN!!!" at me through their computer. Do you guys consider the main character's name to be Gold or Ethan?

    Personally, like I already said, I consider the character's name to be Gold. I'm not saying this because of the Mangas calling him that, but because of evidence in the games points to it. For example, the rival's name is officially Silver in both gens, and the second gen's female protagonist is called Kris, which is obviously a variation of Crystal. Also, when translating the original Japanese versions, the first choice for your name translates directly to Gold. As far as I'm concerned, Ethan is never the protagonist's name. It's just the name of the kid with a Marill who happens to look like him.
    Reply With Quote

    Relevant Advertising!

      #2    
    Old March 9th, 2013 (2:55 PM).
    Lord Varion's Avatar
    Lord Varion Lord Varion is offline
    Guess who's back?
       
      Join Date: Feb 2009
      Age: 22
      Gender: Other
      Nature: Naughty
      Posts: 2,644
      Pokémon Gold and Silver and Crystal: It's Gold.
      Pokémon HeartGold and Soul Silver: It's Ethan.

      I do believe myself that HGSS is a sequel or a new game based in an old region more than a remake, so new characters need be.
      __________________
      gone.
      Reply With Quote
        #3    
      Old March 10th, 2013 (1:10 AM).
      Rivvon's Avatar
      Rivvon Rivvon is offline
      Shrewd Strategist
      • PokéCommunity Daily
      • Crystal Tier
       
      Join Date: Apr 2007
      Location: USA
      Age: 24
      Gender: Female
      Nature: Jolly
      Posts: 2,383
      I have a pretty...unique way of viewing Ethan and Lyra, I think.

      I like to think of protagonists as not being canon because every player plays them differently (I think Bulbapedia takes a similar approach, too). The only thing that makes the protagonists canon is when and how they appear as an NPC. For example, Red is an NPC in GSC, HGSS, and B2W2. Lucas or Dawn in DPP, Brendan or May in RSE, etc.

      But in GSC, Gold (and Kris) never appear as NPCs, so they themselves are not canon in the way that the others are.
      HGSS changed this by having Ethan and Lyra as NPCs.

      So to me, Ethan and Lyra are the canon counterparts of Gold and Kris. As such, I'd probably use the name Gold when referring to the protagonist and Ethan when referring to the NPC.
      __________________
      SOREN

      "My only wish was to see you again."
      Daily
      Staff Fire Emblem Collab
      Reply With Quote
      Reply
      Quick Reply

      Sponsored Links
      Thread Tools

      Posting Rules
      You may not post new threads
      You may not post replies
      You may not post attachments
      You may not edit your posts

      BB code is On
      Smilies are On
      [IMG] code is On
      HTML code is Off

      Forum Jump


      All times are GMT -8. The time now is 3:58 AM.