Second Generation Following the success of Red, Blue and Yellow, Pokémon Gold, Silver and Crystal introduced fans to an exciting new world full of new Pokémon to find, catch and train. Reminisce about your favourite moments in the Johto region, share your adventures and argue about the Johto master race.

View Poll Results: Which Rival Is Better?
Blue 27 39.13%
Silver 33 47.83%
Both of them are good! 9 13.04%
Voters: 69. You may not vote on this poll

Thread Tools
Old January 3rd, 2013 (11:04 AM).
pessimisticlyricist pessimisticlyricist is offline
    Join Date: Jan 2013
    Gender: Male
    Posts: 21
    Blue for me because he is the original rival and plus I always played through silver version.
    Reply With Quote

    Relevant Advertising!

    Old January 3rd, 2013 (4:57 PM).
    Skylands's Avatar
    Skylands Skylands is offline
      Join Date: Jul 2009
      Location: Amurica
      Age: 23
      Gender: Female
      Nature: Calm
      Posts: 112
      Blue is my favourite rival, Silver was an arse. Blue sorta was too, but in a good way.
      Reply With Quote
      Old January 3rd, 2013 (7:39 PM).
      MattyJ's Avatar
      MattyJ MattyJ is offline
      Serial Procrastinator
        Join Date: Apr 2012
        Location: Australia
        Gender: Male
        Nature: Brave
        Posts: 40
        It's interesting, I seem to be voting against the trend when I say Blue. I would have thought he'd be a runaway vote getter!

        I guess, for me, Blue seems to be the out-and-out better rival. I remember playing Gold version for the first time (yes, I actually named my rival "???" because that's what he told me his name was!). One restart later Playing through the game and getting to each gym and noticing that my Rival hadn't been there and beaten it first was a bit odd for me. I liked the fact that Blue was always one step ahead, like you were always chasing him, and that, at the end of the Elite Four, it was revealed that he was the Champion. Of course, Blue comes back in the Metal gen as a leader in Viridian too, which is a good final touch.

        To me, he's just more well-rounded, more competitive, and more driven to 'be the best' than Silver. Silver felt like a spoiled brat with no understanding of Pokemon (for the most part, anyway). It was good that they gave his character a bit of development, but I feel that Blue already understood what it meant to be a Pokemon trainer, which is why his character perhaps didn't show as much development.
        Reply With Quote
        Old January 9th, 2013 (11:13 AM).
        XtinaIsMeLuvinWWE's Avatar
        XtinaIsMeLuvinWWE XtinaIsMeLuvinWWE is offline
          Join Date: Jun 2009
          Location: Northern Ireland
          Age: 25
          Gender: Female
          Nature: Quirky
          Posts: 1,544
          I preferred Blue as a character, I liked his team better and "Smell Ya Later!" haha

          Although in terms of the purpose of a rival, Silver was very well created I thought.

          Reply With Quote
          Old January 22nd, 2013 (7:15 AM).
          obiwan362's Avatar
          obiwan362 obiwan362 is offline
            Join Date: Jan 2013
            Gender: Male
            Posts: 48
            See, I'm going to have to go with Blue. The rival that started it all. And the guy that I was afraid was going to try and smell me every time. Ahh...the good old days.
            Reply With Quote
            Old February 4th, 2013 (8:49 AM).
            Halipoke Halipoke is offline
              Join Date: Oct 2012
              Location: Finland
              Gender: Female
              Nature: Rash
              Posts: 16
              I personally can't choose. I prefer Silver as a rival 'cause he's just plain mean and makes me want to win him. Meanwhile, Blue is a little nicer rival and he's a friend at the same time. It makes me smile.
              Reply With Quote
              Old February 16th, 2013 (6:09 PM).
              egiannis's Avatar
              egiannis egiannis is offline
                Join Date: Jan 2011
                Location: Nafpaktos,Greece
                Age: 26
                Gender: Male
                Nature: Timid
                Posts: 12
                Silver because i like his storyline such as son of Giovanni.Also i think is more powerful than blue
                Reply With Quote
                Old February 16th, 2013 (10:33 PM).
                Caelus Caelus is offline
                  Join Date: Oct 2008
                  Posts: 2,701
                  I'm going to have to go with Blue just for the fact that he ends up becoming a gym leader in Generation II. Both were great rivals and I liked how Silver started becoming a better person near the end of the games but I like Blue's design more and I've had more difficulties going against his team than against Silver's team.
                  Reply With Quote
                  Old February 17th, 2013 (1:12 PM).
                  curelixir's Avatar
                  curelixir curelixir is offline
                  the moon
                  • Crystal Tier
                  Join Date: Nov 2012
                  Location: Arizona
                  Age: 21
                  Gender: Male
                  Nature: Lonely
                  Posts: 2,005
                  I liked Blue better because of his personality.
                  Blue was a bit more energetic than Silver.

                  "WHAT? Unbelievable! I picked the wrong Pokemon!" and "Bonjour! ! Imagine seeing you here! were you really invited?"

                  and Silver was pretty depressing and quite mean.

                  "I hate the weak. Pokemon, Trainers. It doesn't matter who or what. I hate to see them hanging around."

                  Blue's rudeness was much better than Silver's hatred for everything. Even though Silver eventually lightened up, I still preferred Blue.
                  Reply With Quote
                  Old February 17th, 2013 (1:56 PM).
                  YamaskUnchained's Avatar
                  YamaskUnchained YamaskUnchained is offline
                    Join Date: Feb 2013
                    Gender: Male
                    Posts: 16
                    Blue just had that.....rival feel to him. In 96 this was one of the first games most of us completed (If you early 20's like me) and what a twist to go to. You have the pride of not only beating on your smug neighbour rival who was always a step ahead when you head towards victory road right after beating the mob boss Giovanni, but right after you go through the hardest battle against Lance he tells you that your joy of winning this battle is stripped away because you rival is the first Champion....Its just heart sinking and makes that battle better because you thought you were done with him, you beat the Elite Four, and became the best only to find out you're second fiddle to him AGAIN. It was just a better story I find for a rival itself.

                    Silver had more character yes, but it wasn't a real "rival" feel like Blue was. Also have to keep in check that Blue/Red will always have a nostalgia factor for a lot of people as it was the first pokemon game
                    Reply With Quote
                    Old February 18th, 2013 (12:35 PM).
                    Isseubnida's Avatar
                    Isseubnida Isseubnida is offline
                      Join Date: Feb 2013
                      Location: Where I'm meant to be
                      Gender: Male
                      Nature: Jolly
                      Posts: 87
                      Silver actually progressed to being friendlier... unlike snotty Blue, who kept belittling you, even after you kicked his sorry behind countless times.
                      Reply With Quote
                      Old February 24th, 2013 (7:07 AM).
                      Fernando Torres's Avatar
                      Fernando Torres Fernando Torres is offline
                      Class on grass
                      • Crystal Tier
                      Join Date: Feb 2013
                      Gender: Male
                      Nature: Jolly
                      Posts: 162
                      Nostalgia blinding makes blue my favourite rival.
                      Reply With Quote
                      Old February 26th, 2013 (7:54 PM).
                      Yoshistar64's Avatar
                      Yoshistar64 Yoshistar64 is offline
                        Join Date: Mar 2007
                        Location: Kelina Village
                        Nature: Relaxed
                        Posts: 360
                        Originally Posted by metal64meli View Post
                        Silver is just what we call pure hate, he hates you, he hates tam rocket, he hates gym leaders, he just wants to beat everyone's a**es and conquer the world.
                        I really agree, and although I didn't think it was this extreme back then, this kind of attitude is what has always endeared him to me this whole time. His standoffish, cool and composed attitude resembled how I viewed my "older brother" that I always used to chill with, the guy I always wanted to be as cool as. Not only was Silver the rival of my favourite game in the series (I mean, it was my first game and I played it during the best times of my life) which makes it very biased, but he also reinforced an ideal that I strove for.

                        Originally Posted by pikakitten View Post
                        I like Silver better. One BIG reason is he doesn't want to 'smell you later' that's creepy.
                        Originally Posted by Gary Muzza Fuzzin Oak View Post
                        Nostalgia blinding...
                        Reply With Quote
                        Old February 26th, 2013 (8:09 PM).
                        Necrum's Avatar
                        Necrum Necrum is offline
                        I AM THE REAL SONIC
                        • Crystal Tier
                        Join Date: Jul 2012
                        Location: Portland, OR
                        Gender: Male
                        Nature: Adamant
                        Posts: 5,207
                        I have warmed up to Blue in recent years, as I finally managed to separate him from is Anime counterpart, who was a total jerk early in the series. Even so, Silver has always been my favorite rival, because he is the ideal antihero. He is the most interesting rival from a character development standpoint, and actually grows as much as the player theoretically does throughout the story. Plus he's got red hair. :D Of course, I'm sure you can all tell by my avatar and sig that I like villains and such, so maybe I'm just different...
                        Reply With Quote
                        Old February 27th, 2013 (9:41 AM). Edited February 27th, 2013 by pallando.
                        pallando's Avatar
                        pallando pallando is offline
                          Join Date: Feb 2013
                          Location: Germany
                          Age: 24
                          Gender: Male
                          Posts: 19
                          Blue's my favorite rival, I like the personality he has in R/B/Y as well as him having all the badges (before you). Silver apparantly wasn't that interested in the gym battles and therefore it felt quite odd to always be one step ahead. And of course the fact that Blue became a gym leader in the second Generation gives him a significant role in both games.

                          Also, Silver is way too weak level-wise in (almost) every fight. I mean, it was rare when my levels were actually lower than his levels, and I played the game a lot. And no, I didn't train my pokemon a lot vs. wild pokemon, I just beat trainers. The first battle vs Silver is no big challenge as your level usually is higher. The second fight in Azalea Town is in my opinion the hardest fight vs Silver. But the only one that's actually difficult to win..

                          Also, I think Blue is more like a Rival than Silver, because he has the same goal like you have - become the best trainer by winning 8 badges and the E4. Silver however, even though he states that it is his dream to become the best trainer, I also think that another goal of himself is to find his way. That's why Silver's story has more depth, but my favorite rival is Blue. While the levels of Blue's pokemon have raised significantly, which makes him a really tough enemy, the levels of Silver's pokemon in the last two fights are just pathetic. Blue, the last gym leader, has pokemon above level 50, while your rival's pokemon are not higher than 50, and I don't like it. Also the battle at Mt. Moon must be the best example. All Gym Leaders you beat till that point (except for Janine) have higher levels than your rival.. that's what I think is pretty dumb. My last point is that I like how Blue's team varies depending on the starter you/he take(s), which makes his team more interesting. I don't like that the team of Silver always stays the same.
                          Reply With Quote
                          Old March 3rd, 2013 (10:36 AM).
                          TouchemonLearner's Avatar
                          TouchemonLearner TouchemonLearner is offline
                          Bad Egg
                            Join Date: Feb 2013
                            Location: Sacramento
                            Age: 22
                            Gender: Male
                            Nature: Docile
                            Posts: 19
                            Blue's better because he actually acts like a rival whereas Silver is kind of up to his own agenda and doesn't really care about you as much. Also you crush Blue's dreams every time you meet him so he deserves to win something.
                            Reply With Quote
                            Old March 14th, 2013 (1:38 PM).
                            Zorogami's Avatar
                            Zorogami Zorogami is offline
                            WUB WUB
                            • Gold Tier
                            Join Date: Mar 2013
                            Location: Madrid/Spain
                            Age: 25
                            Gender: Male
                            Nature: Relaxed
                            Posts: 2,169
                            I think Blue was the better rival in every aspect. He would tease you all the time, say he was sooo much better than you and just in general would make you want to beat him as often as possible. But at the same time, he is a very talented Pokemon trainer, he loves his Pokemon and treats them well, and even managed to become Champion of the Pokemon League himself, technically even before you did.

                            Silver was so full of himself, he stole his starter, which makes him a thief and a bad pokemon trainer. He treats his pokemon like weapons, not friends, and gets mad at them when they lose against you. Plus he never made it to the Pokemon League...

                            I think now it's pretty obvious who the better rival is

                            ~ Anything for my Nakama ~
                            Reply With Quote
                            Old March 24th, 2013 (7:44 AM).
                            Aethestode's Avatar
                            Aethestode Aethestode is offline
                              Join Date: Jan 2008
                              Location: Australia
                              Gender: Male
                              Nature: Serious
                              Posts: 1,691
                              Silver for me. This is because he's more evil evil and have backstory (HG/SS). Blue is just obnoxious.

                              Name: Sinep
                              Adopt one yourself! @Pokémon Orphanage
                              Reply With Quote
                              Old April 9th, 2013 (7:45 AM).
                              ABGamer ABGamer is offline
                                Join Date: Apr 2013
                                Gender: Male
                                Nature: Calm
                                Posts: 18
                                Blue or Silver, in my opinion Silver's the better rival, although this is mainly based on the pokemon he has (Sneasel, Gengar, Alakazam and Magneton) I love Dark, Ghost, Psychic and Steel types so yeah Silver wins on quick pick but comparing is different I think that Blue would win just because he has a team that could destroy Silvers, just listing what pokemon he would use.

                                Sneasel - Charizard, Flareon or Arcanine (based on game and choice)
                                Gengar - Alakazam
                                Magneton - same as Sneasel and Rhydon
                                Starter - Opposite starter, Gyarados, Arcanine or Exeggutor
                                Crobat - Rhydon

                                That's all I can think but, obviously there are advantages Silver can take but I think Blue has more.
                                Reply With Quote
                                Old April 9th, 2013 (2:50 PM).
                                Kiriyuuki Kasuna's Avatar
                                Kiriyuuki Kasuna Kiriyuuki Kasuna is offline
                                <b><i><font color="#979C1F">Insert Purpose of Meaning</font></i></b>
                                • Gold Tier
                                • Crystal Tier
                                Join Date: Nov 2012
                                Location: Toronto, Canada
                                Age: 23
                                Gender: Male
                                Nature: Adamant
                                Posts: 393
                                I did in fact liked Blue as a Rival, but Silver is just more appealing as a Character and Rival.
                                He had Character Development unlike Blue, where he just turns out to be jerk obsessed with being the Kanto Champion and being the world's strongest trainer. Silver had a journey of finding out what he lacked and found it, again unlike Blue.

                                So all in all, I picked Silver.
                                " I Want You to Need me, could you do that for me? "

                                ~Mei Aihara, CITRUS BY SABURO UTA

                                Partner N'Crime
                                BATTLE SERVER!
                                PC Family
                                THE UNDERGROUND
                                Reply With Quote
                                Old April 20th, 2013 (8:23 AM).
                                razor8771's Avatar
                                razor8771 razor8771 is offline
                                  Join Date: Nov 2011
                                  Gender: Male
                                  Posts: 40
                                  Silver is amazing.Blue is a loudmouthed idiot who wants to smell you later.Silver has the more rivaly and hateful personality.Silver looks awesome.Blue is a useless jerk.Im voting for silver!!!!(duh)
                                  Reply With Quote
                                  Old May 8th, 2013 (2:09 AM).
                                    Posts: n/a
                                    Silver because:

                                    He's a criminal who stole a starter & you tell his name to the police so they arrest him, while Gary is a noob who legally owns a starter that he doesn't deserve & you can do nothing to him.
                                    Silver is less of a douchebag than Gary; When defeated he doubts himself & his way of treatment for his Pokemon & goes back to train more, that's why he's always behind, not like Gary who keeps blaming his Pokemon for his losses then claims that he's better & moves on ahead of you.
                                    Silver never became a champion because he still mistreats his Pokemon, while Gary becomes champion & stays in the Plateau for eternity even after you beat him, which doesn't make sense.

                                    So I guess Silver is reasonably a better rival, he gives a moral that if you're a bad person you'll never succeed in life...
                                    Reply With Quote
                                    Old May 17th, 2013 (11:51 PM).
                                    ruine87's Avatar
                                    ruine87 ruine87 is offline
                                      Join Date: May 2013
                                      Location: 209
                                      Gender: Male
                                      Posts: 8
                                      they were both good rivals but silver has the edge cuz he was more of a douche and that made you want to put a beatdown on him.
                                      Reply With Quote
                                      Old May 18th, 2013 (12:37 PM).
                                      Shaturu711's Avatar
                                      Shaturu711 Shaturu711 is offline
                                        Join Date: Feb 2013
                                        Gender: Male
                                        Nature: Gentle
                                        Posts: 62
                                        Silver for me. His personality is badass and he is more or less always calm and collected, but Blue is like that too. That being said, I think both rivals have equally good Pokemon, though Blue went on to become the Champion but Silver didn't, but overall it's still Silver for me.

                                        Eeveextreme Club Profile:

                                        Username: Shaturu711
                                        Partner Pokemon: Umberon

                                        Titles: [None]
                                        Reply With Quote
                                        Old May 18th, 2013 (1:35 PM). Edited May 18th, 2013 by Seth Rollins.
                                        Seth Rollins's Avatar
                                        Seth Rollins Seth Rollins is offline
                                        Holding on to You |-/
                                        • Silver Tier
                                        Join Date: Dec 2012
                                        Location: Nah
                                        Age: 16
                                        Gender: Male
                                        Nature: Brave
                                        Posts: 2,493
                                        Silver was kind of cool, and had a better backstory than Blue, but Blue is just stronger. Silver was a weakling, easy to beat, while Blue raised his PKMNs quickly :o and he beat the Kanto/Johto champion (Lance) which is very much better than what Silver did in his PKMN Trainer career. Also Silver sucks. He thinks hes the best, Blue was like that too, but Silver was more like that and somethign that I don't like about Silver is that he keeps insulting his PKMNs for being weak while he is weak

                                        EDIT: OK you guys must be saying "WTF SILVER HAS A BETTER TEAM THAN BLUE" but not in my opinion. Deal with it.

                                        The Underground
                                        Come and play mafia with us! You are always welcome.
                                        Reply With Quote

                                        Quick Reply

                                        Join the conversation!

                                        Create an account to post a reply in this thread, participate in other discussions, and more!

                                        Create a PokéCommunity Account

                                        Sponsored Links
                                        Thread Tools

                                        Posting Rules
                                        You may not post new threads
                                        You may not post replies
                                        You may not post attachments
                                        You may not edit your posts

                                        BB code is On
                                        Smilies are On
                                        [IMG] code is On
                                        HTML code is Off

                                        Forum Jump

                                        All times are GMT -8. The time now is 3:26 AM.