Pokémon Gaming Central For topics that aren't necessarily restricted to one game, Pokémon Gaming Central ranges from comparing and contrasting the differences in the gaming generations to discussing the gaming franchise as a whole.
Sort Threads: Spinoff Central | Pokkén

View Poll Results:

Is cloning cheating?

Yes, it is cheap in my opinion!

20 60.61%

No, it is a fully legitimate method!

13 39.39%
Voters: 33. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #1    
Old April 17th, 2013 (4:23 PM).
Frost Mage's Avatar
Frost Mage Frost Mage is offline
     
    Join Date: Jan 2013
    Gender: Male
    Posts: 17

    So I've recently obtained a few cloned shinies through trading, and while they were clearly not hacked, I started to wonder about the legitimacy of this practice. Sure it's just an exact copy for someone else to have, but cloning is putting far more shinies out there, and making the need to soft-reset/RNG far smaller. What do you think, is it cheating/cheap?

    Reply With Quote

    Relevant Advertising!

      #2    
    Old April 17th, 2013 (4:47 PM).
    Cyclone's Avatar
    Cyclone Cyclone is offline
    Eye of the Storm
       
      Join Date: Jul 2012
      Gender: Male
      Posts: 3,392

      This is a debatable question. If it's an Event, many do not see it as cheating, but even in those cases some still think it is. Some will meanwhile clone Events but nothing else, because Events are Events (meant for everyone) and not everyone can get them (geographical region), so clones are a common practice. This is also the case with legendaries, even in-game ones that are game-exclusive.

      Whether it's considered cheating is really a matter for an individual to decide.

      Cyclone

      __________________

      "Y'know...my Emolga really wants to shock your Dedenne."

      Cyclone. FC: 2079-8536-2160. Safari on X (5327-1949-9511): Lampent, Pumpkaboo, and Golurk (Ghost). Champion of the GC11 Pokémon Challenge!
      Breeder extraordinaire. Semi-competent battler.

      Building an event collection. If you want to help my sickness, ask what I have to trade!

      Reply With Quote
        #3    
      Old April 17th, 2013 (5:00 PM).
      Forever's Avatar
      Forever Forever is offline

      SACRED FIRE

      • Moderator
      • Crystal Tier
      • EOEvent Organizer
       
      Join Date: Nov 2005
      Location: Queensland
      Age: 25
      Gender: Female
      Nature: Bold
      Posts: 35,412

      Just throwing this over to Pokemon Gaming Central because Fifth Generation pertains to questions which are specific to those games. This is a broad question, thus fits here! n_n

      __________________


      Celebrating Gold and Silver's Upcoming Virtual Console Release!
      moderator of the following games
      [ ]

      Reply With Quote
        #4    
      Old April 17th, 2013 (5:12 PM).
      Yusshin's Avatar
      Yusshin Yusshin is offline
      ♪ Yggdrasil ♪
         
        Join Date: Jul 2009
        Location: Quebec, Canada
        Age: 24
        Nature: Brave
        Posts: 2,424

        I think it's cheating. You're duping the system into thinking that that Pokemon should exist more than once, when it shouldn't. It also dumbs down the rarity of certain event Pokemon, shiny Pokemon, high-IV Pokemon, etc. and if you will, it hurts the game's "economy."

        It's like doubling an item in an MMORPG. Normally that's a ban-able offense for understandable reasons.

        __________________



        Polaret | Fourette | Ecuret | Axew | Zorua | Nanette [Shiny]
        "My scar makes me sassy, child!"
        The Big Bang Theory Fan Club - Click To Join!
        The French Club

        Reply With Quote
          #5    
        Old April 17th, 2013 (5:38 PM).
        ~RNC~'s Avatar
        ~RNC~ ~RNC~ is offline
        Mother Of All Pokemon!!
           
          Join Date: Dec 2006
          Location: Surfing With Blastoise!!
          Gender: Female
          Nature: Quirky
          Posts: 8,727

          In my opinion it is not cheating, cloning only makes an Exactduplicate of the poke you are trading, so how does that make it cheating? You are not changing any thing about the pokemon itself, I mean if some one changed the moves or nature or any thing like that I would consider that cheating but not cloning ever.

          __________________

          My Trading Thread ---> HERE
          I Clone 6th & 7th Gen.
          Name: ~RNC~ 3DS FC: 4012 5688 9276 Safari Pokes: Psychic: Espurr, Giraffic and Grumpig
          My Thread Review ---> HERE

          Reply With Quote
            #6    
          Old April 17th, 2013 (5:44 PM).
          Captain Gizmo's Avatar
          Captain Gizmo Captain Gizmo is offline
          Legit Boss
          • Gold Tier
           
          Join Date: Sep 2012
          Location: Canada
          Age: 23
          Gender: Male
          Nature: Quiet
          Posts: 4,824

          I would say yes, since you're doing an exact replica of a Pokemon that you already have instead of using the game's legit system to try and get the same Pokemon you're just cloning the Pokemon. The game itself doesn't talk about teaching you or even mention cloning at all, so it's basically cheating. It also make rare Pokemon less rare since no one is losing anything out of cloning.

          __________________

          ♥Plusle bro of Synerjee♥ | ♥Pink Mommy♥
          |3DS FC|

          Reply With Quote
            #7    
          Old April 17th, 2013 (5:53 PM).
          Sydian's Avatar
          Sydian Sydian is offline

          case CLOSED.

          • Crystal Tier
           
          Join Date: Feb 2008
          Location: Alabama
          Age: 25
          Nature: Timid
          Posts: 32,105

          As long as the Pokemon you're cloning was obtained legitimately, then it's fine. I don't care. I ain't about to RNG the same Pokemon over and over just to trade them to other people for them to use. I ain't about that life. If you don't like clones and don't think it's a good practice, don't go to the Trade Corner.

          __________________

          ≫ they took a little look at my heart
          they found a prince living behind bars ≪

          challenges | klippy

          Reply With Quote
            #8    
          Old April 17th, 2013 (5:55 PM).
          Pinta77's Avatar
          Pinta77 Pinta77 is offline
          Swadloon Trainer
          • Silver Tier
           
          Join Date: Nov 2008
          Location: San Jose
          Age: 22
          Gender: Male
          Posts: 703

          I think it's ok if you do it using a glitch, and not a gameshark or an action replay. Ya, I understand lots of people don't like it and I understand why, but I consider it cheating only if you use an external device.

          When I learned about the duplicating glitch in emerald, I cloned my shiny azumarril a bunch. So if anyone happens to have an orange azumarril with the OT Max, well now you know where it came from

          Reply With Quote
            #9    
          Old April 17th, 2013 (6:19 PM).
          Shadowraze's Avatar
          Shadowraze Shadowraze is offline
          ur mum
             
            Join Date: Apr 2013
            Location: ur mum
            Age: 18
            Gender: Other
            Nature: Lonely
            Posts: 798

            Yes, I do think cloning is cheating instead of raising it you have to clone it to others. :/

            Reply With Quote
              #10    
            Old April 17th, 2013 (6:27 PM).
            ~RNC~'s Avatar
            ~RNC~ ~RNC~ is offline
            Mother Of All Pokemon!!
               
              Join Date: Dec 2006
              Location: Surfing With Blastoise!!
              Gender: Female
              Nature: Quirky
              Posts: 8,727

              Every one is going to have their own opinion on this, some think it's cheating and others do not, this will be a never ending discussion about this question.

              __________________

              My Trading Thread ---> HERE
              I Clone 6th & 7th Gen.
              Name: ~RNC~ 3DS FC: 4012 5688 9276 Safari Pokes: Psychic: Espurr, Giraffic and Grumpig
              My Thread Review ---> HERE

              Reply With Quote
                #11    
              Old April 17th, 2013 (6:47 PM).
              tabor62's Avatar
              tabor62 tabor62 is offline

              Who?

              • Crystal Tier
               
              Join Date: Nov 2008
              Location: In the Sun
              Gender: Male
              Nature: Lax
              Posts: 1,632

              I have to agree with Sydian about cloning, I'm definitely not going keep RNGing the same Pokemon over and over again to offer in my shop. As for events, it really helps for people who can't get certain events. It would be near impossible to build up a substantial collection AND have events to trade to other people. As for making rare Pokemon less rare, yes, it does put more into circulation. However, unlike online MMOs, they have no virtual currency value. In addition, it helps out the people who cannot obtain the Pokemon themselves. A much better alternative to hacking and importing wondercards no?

              __________________

              Trade Corner
              PM me | VM me

              3DS Friend Code
              0946 2243 9665

              Trade Reviews
              Click Here

              Reply With Quote
                #12    
              Old April 17th, 2013 (6:54 PM).
              Pichu2Pikachu2Raichu's Avatar
              Pichu2Pikachu2Raichu Pichu2Pikachu2Raichu is offline
              Yep, that's me
              • Silver Tier
               
              Join Date: Mar 2013
              Location: Hastings, New Zealand
              Age: 27
              Nature: Naughty
              Posts: 309

              Hi tabor62 ^-^

              IMO YES!! and YES it is and forever will be!

              __________________


              Pichu2Pikachu2Raichu
              My favorite evolution series

              Kiwi Land|Thunder Bolt Forums|ProBoards After Dark|New Zealand

              Reply With Quote
                #13    
              Old April 17th, 2013 (6:59 PM).
              ~RNC~'s Avatar
              ~RNC~ ~RNC~ is offline
              Mother Of All Pokemon!!
                 
                Join Date: Dec 2006
                Location: Surfing With Blastoise!!
                Gender: Female
                Nature: Quirky
                Posts: 8,727

                I am like I got it and can offer it weather it be a clone or not I am helping out a some one who needs what I have but still keeping it for myself.

                __________________

                My Trading Thread ---> HERE
                I Clone 6th & 7th Gen.
                Name: ~RNC~ 3DS FC: 4012 5688 9276 Safari Pokes: Psychic: Espurr, Giraffic and Grumpig
                My Thread Review ---> HERE

                Reply With Quote
                  #14    
                Old April 17th, 2013 (9:53 PM).
                Kitori's Avatar
                Kitori Kitori is offline

                [ ICE QUEEN ]

                • Crystal Tier
                 
                Join Date: Mar 2013
                Location: Madison, WI
                Gender: Female
                Nature: Sassy
                Posts: 141

                Ehhh... it's hard to say, I guess. I think if you're an avid collector pretty much the only way you're going to be able to get a large collection of rare pokemon is if you're open to clones. I can see why people would think it's cheap or cheating, though, but I don't mind clones myself.

                __________________


                Let the storm rage on....
                The cold never bothered me anyway.

                [ TRADE THREAD | FRIEND CODE | TWITTER | CHALLENGE | PAIR♥]


                Reply With Quote
                  #15    
                Old April 17th, 2013 (11:01 PM).
                Brendino's Avatar
                Brendino Brendino is offline

                Third time's the charm... right?

                • Moderator
                • Crystal Tier
                • Social Media
                 
                Join Date: Dec 2009
                Location: Studiopolis
                Nature: Quiet
                Posts: 7,344

                The only time I really clone is if I'm transferring a Pokemon from one generation to the next (III to IV, IV to V), just so I don't have to get rid of it from my original game. I don't see it as cheating, though, since clones are likely just of legitimate Pokemon, which I'd much rather have than a hacked individual.

                __________________

                Reply With Quote
                  #16    
                Old April 18th, 2013 (12:51 AM).
                Elaitenstile's Avatar
                Elaitenstile Elaitenstile is offline
                I am legend
                   
                  Join Date: Feb 2013
                  Posts: 1,909

                  Yes, and I strongly believe so. Don't you think duplicating the hard work catching and raising Pokémon in an instant is bad? It is the path used by people who want to conserve their Pokémon for trade. How can you call it a 'trade' if you practically are not exchanging? Yes, cloning shouldn't be done.

                  __________________

                  ~

                  Reply With Quote
                    #17    
                  Old April 19th, 2013 (12:12 AM).
                  Yankas Yankas is offline
                     
                    Join Date: Mar 2013
                    Gender: Male
                    Posts: 55

                    Most definitely, there is no way to clone without using either a cheating device or abusing an exploit/glitch within the game.

                    Reply With Quote
                      #18    
                    Old April 19th, 2013 (5:47 PM).
                    Boilurn's Avatar
                    Boilurn Boilurn is offline
                    Scald Pokémon
                       
                      Join Date: Nov 2012
                      Location: Route 49
                      Nature: Mild
                      Posts: 612

                      Good question. I think that Cloning shinies is perfectly acceptable and not cheating because there isn't much different in terms of the Pokemon's battling capabilities, as long as its moves and abilities remain the same. However, if we were cloning event Pokemon (Like for example, a Pikachu with the move Fly) then I think it would be cheating if we were cloning things like that.

                      __________________

                      Quote:
                      Boilurn, the Scald Pokemon and the evolved form of Hottle. It can burn the holder by the lightest of touches when it boils. It can boil 3 gallons of water in one minute.

                      Reply With Quote
                        #19    
                      Old April 19th, 2013 (5:55 PM).
                      tabor62's Avatar
                      tabor62 tabor62 is offline

                      Who?

                      • Crystal Tier
                       
                      Join Date: Nov 2008
                      Location: In the Sun
                      Gender: Male
                      Nature: Lax
                      Posts: 1,632

                      I fail to see any difference between cloning shinies and event Pokemon. You might say it's because of special event moves that they may have. But let's consider Pokemon like these. (Ignore the random Flying Pikachu mixed in with them ) Completely normal other than being an event no?

                      __________________

                      Trade Corner
                      PM me | VM me

                      3DS Friend Code
                      0946 2243 9665

                      Trade Reviews
                      Click Here

                      Reply With Quote
                        #20    
                      Old April 19th, 2013 (6:10 PM).
                      Tyrael's Avatar
                      Tyrael Tyrael is offline
                      This is a Sailor's Prayer
                      • Crystal Tier
                       
                      Join Date: Mar 2013
                      Location: Deep in the Heart of Texas
                      Age: 24
                      Gender: Male
                      Nature: Adamant
                      Posts: 407

                      As far as i'm concerned, there is nothing wrong with cloning. It allows someone to be able to offer a great pokemon of theirs for anything that they might possibly need and not have to worry about having to get rid of that pokemon.

                      __________________

                      As long as these struggles are aimless, we will all be standing still.
                      Trade Thread3DS FCPair

                      Reply With Quote
                        #21    
                      Old April 20th, 2013 (4:16 PM).
                      Cassiopeiia's Avatar
                      Cassiopeiia Cassiopeiia is offline
                      Floating
                         
                        Join Date: Apr 2013
                        Location: Norvegia
                        Age: 22
                        Gender: Female
                        Nature: Bashful
                        Posts: 79

                        If you are using cloned Pokémon with perfectly legitimate stats and moves to battle with, would you, in the context of the battle, be cheating?
                        No you wouldn't, you would however be cheating if your Pokémon sported a move it should not be able to learn, for example.

                        In the context of in-game Pokémon collecting however, cloning is cheating because you are collecting your Pokémon by a use of methods not intended by Game Freak to be possible. They created the game and the rules, and by cloning, you are breaking them. Obviously it's cheating.

                        Whether it's an issue or not is a totally different question. Personally I don't think it's a problem more than using cheat codes in, say, the Sims is a problem. As long as those you trade with are aware it's a clone, and as long as you're not using your perfect IV clones to gain an upper hand in battle over honest breeders, there really is no problem at all. You're entitled to play the game the way you enjoy it the most as long as you don't interfere with others' experience. There's the GTS though, but oh well.

                        Reply With Quote
                          #22    
                        Old April 20th, 2013 (6:43 PM).
                        Treecko's Avatar
                        Treecko Treecko is offline
                        im back
                        • Gold Tier
                         
                        Join Date: Feb 2012
                        Location: St.Louis,Missouri
                        Age: 25
                        Gender: Male
                        Nature: Modest
                        Posts: 5,769

                        My friends and I would to clone Pokemon in Gold and Silver all the time, and we saw nothing wrong with it. If your cloning a Pokemon is for a event like the ones that happen in the Trade Corner in PC and they have legit stats,moves, etc , then I'd say no, it isn't cheating. It makes distribution of the Pokemon that are hard to get easier. As long as the Pokemon has legit stats and moves it can actually learn, I'm find with it.

                        __________________

                        im back

                        Reply With Quote
                          #23    
                        Old April 22nd, 2013 (12:36 AM).
                        Aslan's Avatar
                        Aslan Aslan is offline
                        the pretender
                        • Gold Tier
                         
                        Join Date: Mar 2013
                        Location: Sydney
                        Gender: Female
                        Nature: Modest
                        Posts: 2,242

                        I guess you could argue both sides to this question. In a way it is technically cheating. Game Freak, like mentioned before never wanted you to use this sort of method while playing the game. Also, what about if you threw on a Master Ball on the Pokemon you were going to clone? Not only would you get a duplicate copy, but you'd get another Master Ball, which is not supposed to happen as a Master Ball is crowned as the ultimate Pokeball and was intended for one time use. But I'm not sure, from videos I've seen it's possible to clone items that are on the Pokemon.

                        However in another way it isn't cheating. I mean as long as you're not tacking on items like Master Balls, it's perfectly fine. They're still legitimate Pokemon as long as they have moves that can be learnt by them etc. And even though I don't RNG and am not a person who is a frequent trader, I would certainly clone than RNG over and over for the same Pokemon. I mean it saves time and effort and in a way it shouldn't be classified as 'cheating'. But that's my opinion on this. XD

                        Reply With Quote
                          #24    
                        Old May 3rd, 2013 (3:26 PM).
                        Anszkz.DkLt Anszkz.DkLt is offline
                        The Semi-Newb
                           
                          Join Date: Apr 2013
                          Location: Hoenn
                          Age: 20
                          Gender: Male
                          Nature: Brave
                          Posts: 21

                          Even if it isn't done by using external devices to interfere with the games normal execution (e.g. AR, GS) it's still considered an exploitation of a bug and therefore by cloning, you're not only cheating the game and the developers but you're also cheating YOURSELF...

                          Meh, that's just my 2cents...

                          But i'm not saying that I'm against cloning (though I deem it more ethical if done without external devices).. Heck i've already got a bunch of Shiny legendaries that I trade for other shiny legendaries that I level up to 100 if they aren't already then trade them for other shinies. Lather, rinse, repeat.

                          __________________


                          Current Challenges

                          • Hunger Games Challenge - District 12 - Emerald (0/8)

                          Reply With Quote
                            #25    
                          Old May 3rd, 2013 (4:22 PM).
                          Sheep's Avatar
                          Sheep Sheep is offline
                          Puwa Puwa
                          • Administrator
                          • Silver Tier
                           
                          Join Date: Sep 2011
                          Age: 26
                          Gender: Female
                          Nature: Bashful
                          Posts: 21,641

                          Well, cloning wasn't intended to be a method for players to use in their games, so in a way it is cheating. But I don't consider it cheating as much as using an Action Replay is, especially if you're closing Pokemon you got legitimately. It's a bit of both so I can't word my answer without it being confusing, haha. :[

                          __________________


                          . pair family twin mal lv llsif .

                          Reply With Quote
                          Reply
                          Quick Reply

                          Sponsored Links
                          Thread Tools

                          Posting Rules
                          You may not post new threads
                          You may not post replies
                          You may not post attachments
                          You may not edit your posts

                          BB code is On
                          Smilies are On
                          [IMG] code is On
                          HTML code is Off

                          Forum Jump


                          All times are GMT -8. The time now is 1:10 AM.