Pokémon Gaming Central For topics that aren't necessarily restricted to one game, Pokémon Gaming Central ranges from comparing and contrasting the differences in the gaming generations to discussing the gaming franchise as a whole.
Sort Threads: Spinoff Central | Pokkén

View Poll Results: Who did you choose?
Bulbasaur 12 34.29%
Charmander 12 34.29%
Squirtle 11 31.43%
Voters: 35. You may not vote on this poll

Thread Tools
Old August 28th, 2013 (5:02 AM).
Amore's Avatar
Amore Amore is offline
  • Gold Tier
Join Date: Aug 2009
Age: 23
Posts: 3,881

Bulbasaur, Charmander or Squirtle? A question as old as pokémon itself...literally.

Who did you choose the first time? (Also the poll question)
Who would you choose next time you get this choice?
In which generation did you first encounter this decision? Gen I,III or IV?

Personally I find this to be the hardest out of all the starter choices. There's always clearly a favourite for me in the other generations - Cyndaquil, Mudkip, Piplup, Oshawott. But in Gen I it's always a three-way tie.
The first time I faced the original choice, in LeafGreen, I chose Charmander because, well, it turns into a dragon! I most often choose Bulbasaur though, due to ease of playing through. And when I play LeafGreen again (hopefully very soon) I honestly don't know whom I'll pick - although Squirtle is probably the least likely, due to the abundance of alternative water-types that I like.
"I am Aron Man"
Reply With Quote

Relevant Advertising!

Old August 28th, 2013 (5:27 AM).
ImBlue's Avatar
ImBlue ImBlue is offline
    Join Date: Aug 2013
    Location: Texas
    Gender: Male
    Nature: Quiet
    Posts: 66
    It was rather simple for me, as I had Blue version so felt obliged to get Squirtle. And since that makes it the first Pokemon I ever had, it had a distinct advantage over the other two (although I still love Bulbasaur and Charmander!)
    Reply With Quote
    Old August 28th, 2013 (5:29 AM).
    Telinc1's Avatar
    Telinc1 Telinc1 is offline
    Weirdo Extraordinaire
      Join Date: Jun 2013
      Location: Sofia, Bulgaria
      Gender: Male
      Nature: Bold
      Posts: 167
      Well, the first I time was faced with the decision of picking a starter was in LeafGreen. I picked Charmander, because eh... Fire type seemed the coolest to me. Next time I play the game I will probably pick Bulbasaur, because I like rotating the types when I play. (playthrough 1 - Fire type, playthrough 2 - Water type, playthrough 3 - Grass type, etc.)

      And yeah, I definitely agree with you on Squirtle. There's just so many other good Water-types (Slowbro and Starmie are my personal favourites) that I restrict myself from catching because I already have a Water type, even though both of the Pokémon I mentioned are part Psychic as well.

      Check out my hacks by clicking on the userbar!
      Check out my new website (this link now works!)!
      Reply With Quote
      Old August 28th, 2013 (5:42 AM).
      KingRin's Avatar
      KingRin KingRin is offline
        Join Date: Aug 2013
        Location: Europe
        Gender: Male
        Nature: Jolly
        Posts: 404
        Bulbasaur would be a good choice because it can sweep the first two gyms well and because there arent many other good choices in the grass department. But most likely it will get the least votes because IMO its the least popular among the three. Venusaur is on the cover of Leaf Green, but I think people still bought Fire Red because I mean come on its a Charizard.

        Charmander isn't bad at all. It and its evolutions ( Mainly Charizard) are iconic in the Pokemon franchize thanks to the Anime and because he was on the cover of two Pokemon games. But there are many good fire Pokemon, some even better.

        Squirtle is the 2nd in popularity IMO. He is also famous because his last evolution is on the cover of Pokemon Blue and most people here probably grew up with the Red, Blue and Yellow games. His biggest drawback is that there are many good water Pokemons( Like Lapras and Dewgong and Gyarados).

        I've played with all of them. My first playtrough IIRC was with Bulbasaur and I liked him a lot. My second was with Squirtle and I pretty much swept everything because he was overleveld, but I still felt a dent in my team and if I had a Lapras or at least a Dewgong it would have went easier/faster. But I still loved my Blastoise.
        My playtrough at the moment is with Charmander. The first gym was a PAIN because I only had my Charmeleon and a Pikachu. At least I had Metal Claw. I finished the game, just trying to finish the Pokedex.

        If I started a new playtrough I would go with Bulbasaur for old times sake.

        I always had problems choosing my Hoenn and Kanto starters.

        In the end my vote goes for Squirtle.
        Reply With Quote
        Old August 28th, 2013 (5:49 AM).
        Tsutarja's Avatar
        Tsutarja Tsutarja is online now
        • Moderator
        • Platinum Tier
        • PokéCommunity Daily
        Join Date: Mar 2010
        Location: Florida
        Age: 22
        Gender: Male
        Nature: Jolly
        Posts: 23,034
        I decided to go with Squirtle simply for it to get past Brock, and because back then I had a love of water Pokémon.

        "I see that you raise Pokémon with utmost care.
        A child like you would never understand what I hope to achieve.
        I shall step aside this time! I hope we meet again..."

        Moderator of Science & TechnologyTrainer Tournament
        Reply With Quote
        Old August 28th, 2013 (6:08 AM).
        Blue's Avatar
        Blue Blue is online now
        Mine Badge
        • Moderator
        • Platinum Tier
        Join Date: Jan 2008
        Location: United Kingdom
        Gender: Male
        Nature: Relaxed
        Posts: 20,467
        Squritle because at the time, out of those three it was my favorite appearance wise.

        "Hmm! My sturdy Pokémon, defeated!"
        sun + moonultra sun + moon
        trainer tournament
        Reply With Quote
        Old August 28th, 2013 (6:36 AM).
        PlatinumDude's Avatar
        PlatinumDude PlatinumDude is offline
        • Gold Tier
        Join Date: Aug 2010
        Location: Canada
        Age: 23
        Gender: Male
        Nature: Hasty
        Posts: 12,937
        I went with Squirtle the first time I played FireRed. It didn't disappoint me.

        Reply With Quote
        Old August 28th, 2013 (8:36 AM).
        atomtanned's Avatar
        atomtanned atomtanned is offline
          Join Date: Feb 2013
          Gender: Female
          Posts: 152
          For me, playing Pokemon Blue, I picked Charmander. I nicknamed him Matches! I have no idea why I picked him, it was so long ago... I guess I thought he looked the coolest? Since then I've always liked Fire Pokemon as a type as well.

          That is one nostalgic thing I will always hold on to... in every game, I obtain a Charmander and name it Matches.

          Friend Code

          Currently Playing:
          Alpha Sapphire

          tumblr || backlog

          Reply With Quote
          Old August 28th, 2013 (9:02 AM).
          Choice Specs's Avatar
          Choice Specs Choice Specs is online now
          Fortune doesn't favor fools!
          • Super Moderator
          • Battle Server Staff
          • Platinum Tier
          Join Date: Aug 2012
          Location: Weather Institute in Hoenn
          Age: 23
          Gender: Male
          Nature: Modest
          Posts: 20,278
          When I got my Pokemon Blue Version, I picked Squirtle because I though that I had to because Blastiose was on the cover, haha. I didn't regret it though because he was amazing throughout the game. I believe I picked Charmander the second time and then Bulbasaur the third. All 3 were really fun to use!
          Reply With Quote
          Old August 28th, 2013 (11:23 AM).
          Altair's Avatar
          Altair Altair is offline
            Join Date: Feb 2013
            Location: Sydney
            Age: 22
            Gender: Male
            Nature: Quiet
            Posts: 579
            I chose Charmander because it looked cool and was a fire type, in my young mind that meant it was tough! I played with Charmander in Yellow Version, then I chose it in FireRed. I like Squirtle as well, not too fond of Bulbasaur though.
            Reply With Quote
            Old August 28th, 2013 (1:53 PM).
            Sweets Witch's Avatar
            Sweets Witch Sweets Witch is offline
            I just love ham jerky.
              Join Date: Jan 2013
              Location: Old People Community, USA
              Age: 25
              Gender: Male
              Nature: Adamant
              Posts: 1,420
              When I first got Blue I picked Bulbasaur every time because I absolutely loved its official art. Hell, I still do. Looking at it makes me really nostalgic. I can almost feel myself thinking that the old man in Viridian City was a Pokemon.

              Nowadays I pick Squirtle though.
              Reply With Quote
              Old August 28th, 2013 (3:10 PM).
              pokemasta92's Avatar
              pokemasta92 pokemasta92 is offline
              3rd Gen. Enthusiast
                Join Date: Aug 2013
                Location: Bolingbrook, IL, USA
                Age: 25
                Gender: Male
                Nature: Naughty
                Posts: 323
                I chose Charmander because I'm a huge fan of fire types, but even if you're not it's kind of hard to deny how awesome he/she is. Charizard, it's final evolve form, CAN FLY. I don't care what type it is, what its stats are, or what moves it can learn, the fact that it has wings and the power of flight automatically takes the WIN!
                I don't use "uber" Pokémon, I don't calculate stat values, I don't use cheating devices, I don't breed my way to perfection, and I don't care about natures. I catch my Pokemon the way they are, and treat them like individuals instead of brainless drones. If you use this philosophy, copy & paste this into your signature.
                Reply With Quote
                Old August 28th, 2013 (4:54 PM).
                Sydian's Avatar
                Sydian Sydian is offline
                i'm a shapeshifter
                • Crystal Tier
                Join Date: Feb 2008
                Location: Alabama
                Age: 25
                Nature: Timid
                Posts: 32,192
                I chose Charmander in Red and FireRed the first time I played them (which I played them before their brother games, excluding Yellow since you don't choose anyway). In SoulSilver, I'm pretty sure I took Charmander, but I rarely play that far into HGSS to even get my Kanto starter.

                It's safe to say I like playing with fire.

                challenges | klippy
                Reply With Quote
                Old August 28th, 2013 (6:52 PM).
                I've Come to Bargain's Avatar
                I've Come to Bargain I've Come to Bargain is online now
                • Moderator
                • Silver Tier
                Join Date: Jul 2012
                Posts: 12,107
                In Pokémon Blue, I chose Squirtle. I found it to be a very cute Pokémon, especially the way it made its noise and smiled at you. It just made want me want to give it a great, big hug and not let go of it, haha. In Pokémon FireRed, I ended up choosing Bulbasaur. Its sprite was just too adorable. I would've chosen Charmander, but since most of my friends chose this Pokémon, I decided to treat myself with something different~
                Reply With Quote
                Old August 28th, 2013 (8:23 PM).
                Oshamaru's Avatar
                Oshamaru Oshamaru is offline
                Legs go, Megaman!
                  Join Date: Dec 2012
                  Location: Mexico
                  Age: 19
                  Gender: Male
                  Nature: Timid
                  Posts: 245
                  In LeafGreen I choosed Bulbasaur. It wasn't even because Venusaur was the mascot, but I liked Bulbasaur when I first saw it.
                  I usually choose Squirtle other times.
                  <img src=http://i41.tinypic.com/30sa8gz.png border=0 alt= />
                  Farmers are scary...
                  Reply With Quote
                  Old August 28th, 2013 (9:52 PM).
                  KnockFan KnockFan is offline
                  Just a Beginner ...
                    Join Date: Aug 2013
                    Gender: Male
                    Posts: 15
                    When I played Red, I chose Bulbasaur. In fact, throughout playing Pokemon, I've always have chosen the Grass starters.
                    Reply With Quote
                    Old August 28th, 2013 (9:54 PM).
                    Cerberus87's Avatar
                    Cerberus87 Cerberus87 is offline
                    Mega Houndoom, baby!
                      Join Date: Jul 2012
                      Location: Dream World
                      Age: 30
                      Gender: Male
                      Nature: Lonely
                      Posts: 1,671
                      Who did you choose the first time? Bulbasaur.
                      Who would you choose next time you get this choice? Charmander.
                      In which generation did you first encounter this decision? Gen I,III or IV? Gen I.

                      Omega Ruby & Alpha Sapphire, the day Pokémon pulled a Dallas and jumped the shark.
                      Reply With Quote
                      Old August 29th, 2013 (5:21 AM).
                      mucus's Avatar
                      mucus mucus is offline
                      Moémon Master
                        Join Date: Aug 2008
                        Location: The Usa
                        Age: 33
                        Gender: Male
                        Nature: Quirky
                        Posts: 333
                        I overslept and got an unruly pikachu.
                        Reply With Quote
                        Old August 29th, 2013 (7:17 AM).
                        Ash's Avatar
                        Ash Ash is offline
                        • Crystal Tier
                        Join Date: Jul 2008
                        Nature: Gentle
                        Posts: 10,938
                        The first time I played Kanto games (both Blue and Leaf Green) I had picked Bulbasaur. Sadly, I never got too far when I had Bulbasaur in those playthroughs but I do remember that in Blue I picked him because I loved his sprite. Ended up with Squirtle the next time I played though because water type I guess?? I don't know. I've never picked Charmander though. I mean ... I do like Charmander but I suppose it's just not for me?? And if I have picked Charmander then I don't really remember very much about it. Perhaps that is who I would choose if I played a Kanto game again (after my current playthrough in which I chose Bulbasaur because Red).
                        at night i rule
                        Reply With Quote
                        Old August 30th, 2013 (6:50 AM).
                        Sableye~'s Avatar
                        Sableye~ Sableye~ is offline
                        Back to PC~
                        • Silver Tier
                        Join Date: Nov 2012
                        Gender: Male
                        Posts: 4,056
                        I only began playing Pokemon a couple of years ago, so that would be on Gen IV.
                        I chose Bulbasaur and went through several soft resets until I got a female that I liked. I still have her now, as a level 70-something Venusaur.
                        I can't think of a good signature.
                        Reply With Quote
                        Old August 30th, 2013 (10:14 AM).
                        Sabrewulf238's Avatar
                        Sabrewulf238 Sabrewulf238 is offline
                          Join Date: May 2008
                          Age: 26
                          Gender: Male
                          Nature: Jolly
                          Posts: 2,289
                          Gen one was the first time I made the choice, I choose Squirtle and I would choose him again if given the chance.

                          Interesting how it's a tie now, 9 votes each.
                          Looking for X & Y friends, friend code is: 2964-8571-0102
                          Send me a pm if you add me.
                          Reply With Quote
                          Old August 30th, 2013 (11:20 AM).
                          Sonatron's Avatar
                          Sonatron Sonatron is offline
                          Face of Rubber
                            Join Date: Aug 2013
                            Location: Albion
                            Age: 22
                            Gender: Female
                            Nature: Quiet
                            Posts: 66
                            I was really young when I played Pokémon (I think I had Red first) but I remember not picking Bulbasaur XD I'm pretty sure I picked Squirtle, but these days I prefer Charmander because Charizard is one of my favourites XD

                            Oh, and yeah, Gen 1 was when I first chose one of these Pokémon.

                            Pet Shop "Let's make it another great day!" RPGuild

                            For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. - John 3:16

                            Reply With Quote
                            Old August 30th, 2013 (3:03 PM).
                            T!M T!M is offline
                            Four Category MoTY (VG) Winner
                            • Silver Tier
                            Join Date: Jan 2009
                            Location: Georgia, United States
                            Age: 25
                            Gender: Male
                            Nature: Serious
                            Posts: 1,422


                            Who did you choose the first time?
                            Tim: Squirtle. I was very young when I made the decision but when I saw that Bubble halved Geodude and Onix's HP at level 8, I forever fell in love with Squirtle and is always my choice in whatever version I play the Kanto adventure.

                            Who would you choose next time you get this choice?
                            Tim: Squirtle.

                            In which generation did you first encounter this decision? Gen I,III or IV?
                            Tim: Generation I in 1999.
                            Reply With Quote
                            Old August 30th, 2013 (6:00 PM).
                            Bobith's Avatar
                            Bobith Bobith is offline
                            Tossin' balls since '99
                              Join Date: Jun 2013
                              Location: Murica
                              Gender: Male
                              Nature: Impish
                              Posts: 57
                              Bulbasaur, all my friends had either Squirtle or Charmander. As I was a hipster back in the second grade, I picked the unused one.

                              Pokemon Clan Site/Strategy Guide/Other Thingies
                              Shuckle is love, Shuckle is life.
                              Reply With Quote
                              Old August 31st, 2013 (10:02 AM).
                              EJ Nero's Avatar
                              EJ Nero EJ Nero is offline
                                Join Date: Jul 2013
                                Location: Sootopolis City
                                Age: 23
                                Gender: Male
                                Nature: Bold
                                Posts: 66
                                Bulbasaur was my choice in LeafGreen, Squirtle in FireRed, and I can't remember who I chose when I played Blue for a short while. The first generation though was the only gen where I originally preferred the grass over water starter.
                                Life without water would be no fun
                                Reply With Quote

                                Quick Reply

                                Join the conversation!

                                Create an account to post a reply in this thread, participate in other discussions, and more!

                                Create a PokéCommunity Account

                                Sponsored Links
                                Thread Tools

                                Posting Rules
                                You may not post new threads
                                You may not post replies
                                You may not post attachments
                                You may not edit your posts

                                BB code is On
                                Smilies are On
                                [IMG] code is On
                                HTML code is Off

                                Forum Jump

                                All times are GMT -8. The time now is 8:16 AM.