Off-Topic Hang out with people and talk about whatever. Feel free to suggest a better description for this forum as everyone seems to have an opinion. :D

TrollandToad.com
Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #1    
Old September 12th, 2013 (1:28 PM).
Foxrally's Avatar
Foxrally Foxrally is online now
  • Moderator
  • Crystal Tier
 
Join Date: Mar 2013
Location: On a Torterra
Age: 19
Gender: Male
Nature: Naive
Posts: 2,549
This came up in my YouTube feed today.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tdZ9gKV3ZMw
  • Do you think the mother did the right thing?
  • Do you think the punishment was too light/severe?
  • What do you think of the 11-year-old girl twerking?
__________________
Paired to Ice and gimmepie
3DS Friend Code
0103-9972-1307
I make memes and other carcinogens
Reply With Quote

Relevant Advertising!

  #2    
Old September 12th, 2013 (1:41 PM).
Kyrul's Avatar
Kyrul Kyrul is offline
Long Live The Note
  • Crystal Tier
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: Missouri
Age: 24
Gender: Male
Nature: Hasty
Posts: 833
This is great! She found a good way to punish her kids without beating the loving **** out of them! Nope, not severe at all. If kid's can't remember their punishment then it's not really a punishment, but I'm sure this kid will remember this for a long time. Yes, she did the right thing.
__________________
Reply With Quote
  #3    
Old September 12th, 2013 (4:36 PM).
Melody's Avatar
Melody Melody is offline
A LEGACY → Of Bygone Days and Nights
  • Crystal Tier
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Cuddling those close to me
Gender: Female
Nature: Naughty
Posts: 6,384
It's parenting like this that I have minimal respect for. Sure it's creative; but it's also kind of dangerous. I'm sure the people of the community are all questioning her sanity and competency as a parent right now. Some may agree with her. Some may not. I don't personally believe it's a very harmful parenting move; but I do question it strongly as I don't see any reason to punish an 11 year old this way.

Was what the child did wrong? No. Was it inappropriate? Yes. Children should be taught how to act appropriately; but I believe in my heart of hearts that 11 is too early to expect to understand that something such as twerking is seriously inappropriate even if they know not to do it. If you're going to raise your children conservatively; at least keep in mind that they're going to try things you told them not to. I think that if we stopped hiding simple truths from our children; that these things would not happen as often as they do now. Immaturity is not a real reason to hide something from them and punishment should not be cruel, excessively unusual, or anything that puts them at risk for later problems in life. This kid is going to have a very unfortunate reputation among her peers early on. Her mother is going to have a darkened reputation as well.

I can imagine other ways her mother could have handled this; while achieving similar amounts of punishment-induced and lesson-teaching misery; without potentially worsening the situation like this could.

This is all my personal opinion however. In the end I always say "Parent however you want." There's fewer things more fiery than a parent scorned; and in the end you can't really fault them for trying anything they can to protect their offspring. It's a natural response, and it often delays reasoning a little bit.
__________________
House Doctrina
PAIRS
Astral and Soipe

Reply With Quote
  #4    
Old September 12th, 2013 (6:05 PM).
Kanzler's Avatar
Kanzler Kanzler is offline
naughty biscotti
  • Crystal Tier
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Toronto
Gender: Male
Nature: Relaxed
Posts: 5,911
Parents ashamed of kid twerking. Makes her publically humiliated to be less ashamed. Do not get logic. Also mom, she's just gonna wanna do it more now that you've shown her how to grab and grub for attention. Way to be a role model.
Reply With Quote
  #5    
Old September 12th, 2013 (6:31 PM).
droomph's Avatar
droomph droomph is offline
weeb
  • Crystal Tier
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: nowhere spectacular
Age: 20
Gender: Male
Nature: Impish
Posts: 4,291
ohhhhh boy this can of worms













I think that it isn't cool to do that because believe it or not all tweens and teens are attention *****s. like just look at all the 16 year olds you know.

It's just a stage, they'll stop doing that stuff in time.

Though it's not my place to judge. She's not really doing anything to physically or psychologically harm her (I mean, though it's not okay, it's no rape dungeon) so it's all up to the parents to raise the child they want.
__________________
did u no there r 21 letters in the alphabet
o i forgot 5
uraqt


Reply With Quote
  #6    
Old September 12th, 2013 (6:57 PM).
FlamingRage's Avatar
FlamingRage FlamingRage is offline
Can you feel my rage?
     
    Join Date: Aug 2013
    Gender: Male
    Posts: 62
    Ruining you daughter's reputation all across the internet (the number 1. tool employers use to decide whether or not to hire someone)

    Yeah, great job, Mom. Her life will turn out a lot better this way.

    Punishments like these show where the youth of today get their stupidity.
    __________________
    P.s. My name is ironic. I almost never flame or rage.
    Reply With Quote
      #7    
    Old September 12th, 2013 (7:23 PM).
    Sanguine's Avatar
    Sanguine Sanguine is offline
    malignant narcissist
    • Gold Tier
     
    Join Date: May 2013
    Location: in front of my TV
    Gender: Female
    Nature: Relaxed
    Posts: 542
    Not sure why a parent would go for this method of punishment. Sure, the child disobeyed her, but twerking is something she'd have grown out of anyway. It would just be following a "fad".

    The act itself isn't that serious, and she'd have eventually forgotten about it. What she won't forget, is that her mother opted to humiliate her daughter in public, instead of trying to be, I don't know, more understanding of her daughter's age and mindset?

    This is all coming from me being pretty lenient to everyone, so I guess it doesn't mean much xD
    __________________
    [00:18] +oocyst: sang is too pure
    Reply With Quote
      #8    
    Old September 14th, 2013 (9:44 PM).
    cbd98's Avatar
    cbd98 cbd98 is offline
    A bouquet of oopsie dasies
       
      Join Date: Feb 2011
      Location: In your closet :D
      Gender: Male
      Nature: Relaxed
      Posts: 333
      Quote:
      Originally Posted by Pachy View Post
      I think that if we stopped hiding simple truths from our children; that these things would not happen as often as they do now. Immaturity is not a real reason to hide something from them and punishment should not be cruel, excessively unusual, or anything that puts them at risk for later problems in life.
      This.

      Also, we were doing a pre-reading discussion for The Scarlet Letter for English class, and someone brought up a very good point about the difference between shame punishment and guilt punishment, the difference being "You are the bad thing" and "What you did is the bad thing". Supposedly, people who are punished using shame punishment aren't even less likely to do the crime again (I know this isn't a crime really, but it's still a somewhat similar concept), and guilt punishment is more likely to make the criminal want to make amends for what they've done. I mean, I don't think there are any good ideas for a guilt-related twerking punishment, other than like visiting old wrinkly poor strippers who ended up nowhere in life (even though that's drastic to imagine for this girl). However, it does come down to what the parents want to do, and by all means she can punish her child in a way she feels is right.
      __________________
      White FC: 0090-4467-9042

      Strong Pokémon. Weak Pokémon. That is only the selfish perception of people. Truly skilled trainers should try to win with their favorites. -Karen

      We are all books because we have spines and stories to tell.

      Ground Monotype for the Ultimate Pokecommunity League
      Reply With Quote
        #9    
      Old September 14th, 2013 (10:42 PM).
      Livewire's Avatar
      Livewire Livewire is offline
      • Platinum Tier
       
      Join Date: Jul 2009
      Location: Sunnyshore City
      Gender: Male
      Nature: Adamant
      Posts: 14,265
      The mother did more damage in trying to teach 'a lesson'. So now you have a child who has been utterly humiliated, by their own mother no less. If that's not a recipe for disaster one day, I don't know what is. You don't inspire change in someone's behavior or actually teach by stooping this low.
      __________________
      Reply With Quote
        #10    
      Old September 15th, 2013 (1:47 AM).
      «Chuckles»'s Avatar
      «Chuckles» «Chuckles» is offline
      A Man With A Future
         
        Join Date: Jul 2013
        Location: Central Coast, Australia
        Gender: Male
        Posts: 1,547
        This is what happens when you mix the internet with real life it turns out even more messed up then that one server on world or warcraft. you know the roleplay one and everyone is but naked and its okay to run around riding goats and pretend to be doing some wierd ritual trying to summon a tornado.

        #Enough of life for today
        #Enough of the internet for today
        #Enough of interlife for today
        Reply With Quote
          #11    
        Old September 15th, 2013 (4:10 AM).
        Trev's Avatar
        Trev Trev is offline
        starting my comeback tour
           
          Join Date: May 2012
          Location: anywhere as long as I have dogs
          Age: 20
          Gender: Male
          Nature: Sassy
          Posts: 1,234
          I would be against this punishment if the girl wasn't 11. 11 year old children should not be twerking. Ever.
          __________________
          Projects





          Reply With Quote
            #12    
          Old September 15th, 2013 (4:54 AM).
          Mana's Avatar
          Mana Mana is offline
          • Platinum Tier
           
          Join Date: Jan 2009
          Location: UK
          Gender: Female
          Posts: 10,015
          To those saying that the mother humiliated her across the internet - actually, that was the media.

          Whilst this may not be the perfect example, I am sure this is going to be a much more effective punishment than being grounded for a week. She broke the rules, she got punished.

          To those saying it will effect her future jobs... she's 11. That's like saying the old lie that your permanent record will be seen by every employer in your life - utter rubbish.

          Quote:
          Originally Posted by Pachy
          I think that if we stopped hiding simple truths from our children; that these things would not happen as often as they do now.
          I don't understand how this relates to the OP. The mother says that the girl has done the dance previously, and was told it was inappropriate and sexual, yet she continued. How is that hiding any truths? The girl new exactly what she was doing.

          Surprised Miley Cirus hasn't been mentioned.
          Reply With Quote
            #13    
          Old September 15th, 2013 (8:11 AM).
          Kanzler's Avatar
          Kanzler Kanzler is offline
          naughty biscotti
          • Crystal Tier
           
          Join Date: Jul 2008
          Location: Toronto
          Gender: Male
          Nature: Relaxed
          Posts: 5,911
          Quote:
          Originally Posted by Magic Fox View Post
          To those saying that the mother humiliated her across the internet - actually, that was the media.
          If the mother was more responsible, she'd know that the media would pick up on this. But hey, I guess it's not a big deal for her and perhaps she's got a different idea of what shame and humiliation is if twerking is too much and this is.

          Quote:
          Originally Posted by Magic Fox View Post
          I don't understand how this relates to the OP. The mother says that the girl has done the dance previously, and was told it was inappropriate and sexual, yet she continued. How is that hiding any truths? The girl new exactly what she was doing.
          There are many different ways of getting someone not to do something. If her kid was just told that it was "inappropriate" and "sexual" - unless she's one of those obedient-type kids who listen at the drop of a hat, it's not going to work. And she's clearly not that type of kid. At that age - even for me, I'm a dude too - there is a big dissociation between hearing what "sexual" means and understanding what "sexual" is. And there's also a similar dissociation between what she did and her punishment, she'll know that her mom would punish the crap out of her, but she still doesn't understand what twerking means for her mom - this isn't teaching her any empathy.

          To me, this is an example of fighting a battle to win the battle, instead of trying to win the war. I guess mom promised a punishment, so she feels like she has go on with the deterrence - well A) it wasn't much of a deterrence, and B) it wasn't much of a constructive punishment either. Maybe it's okay to do this just once (not the ridiculous attention-seaking seeking fashion she did it) to maintain her parental authority, but again her battle plan is not working and should be changed, and now she has to deal with the fallout from this punishment which she may or may not have prepared for. One does not punish simply to punish, but to teach. It's not about outlining a set of artificial (compared to the real world) conditions and consequences for the child to follow but, as parent, to continually adapt and communicate to get the message across.

          What her mom should have done is sit her down and have a talk about it, get her to think about it herself, get her to question her motives. I don't know if that'll be getting her kid to grow up too quickly since a lot of kids do whatever they do without thinking about it, but if she's looking for maturity that's a way she'll get maturity. This has to be built around institutionalizing proper rapport and frequent communication and confidence building exercises (I'm taking this from international relations, but it's been an apt analogy so far), it's better for her kid to feel confident that her mom isn't going to shame her in any way if she happens to be influenced by peer pressure that day or whatever. If obedience is an issue, then it's better to tie that down with trust, so you both know what's going on on the ground as quickly as you can as well as to promote common interests and the feeling of being on the same page.

          Overall, I see humiliation punishments as a failure. Mom is evoking the shame in the punishment in hopes that the child will associate this with whatever behaviour she's doing, but mom hasn't demonstrated why the behaviour shouldn't occur and in extension hasn't taken away her motivation for doing it in the first place (peer pressure, hypersexualization, having people think she's easy). Furthermore, in the off-chance that she has successfully associated twerking with punishment and will stfu and lay her head down like a good little girl, she will still have successfully associated unnecessary punishment with mom. And when you put your parent-child relationship at stake to get one point across, that's what I would call a very imprudent decision. She's missing the forest for a tree. Not the trees, one tree. A tactical decision should not compromise strategy - but perhaps there wasn't much of a coherent strategy to compromise in the first place. And now I'm done judging her.
          Reply With Quote
            #14    
          Old September 15th, 2013 (10:07 AM).
          Ivysaur's Avatar
          Ivysaur Ivysaur is offline
          You found a heart!
          • Crystal Tier
           
          Join Date: Mar 2007
          Location: Madrid
          Age: 26
          Gender: Male
          Posts: 20,647
          As BlahISuck said, punishments should make the kid reflect about what they did and whi it's wrong. Punishing someone for the sake of punishment will only make the kid resent you or make them afraid of you. And you should want your kid to respect you, not to fear you. They are very different things.

          I'm a very self-conscious person so a public embarrassment would have hurt me very deeply. Specially if my mother didn't bother telling me why what I did was wrong- just that it was.
          __________________
          Y hubo tanto amor que no queda nada,
          Y ahora mírate, no, no, no, no,
          No puedes ver bien la luz.
          Cuando todas las historias se acaban
          Y ya solo quedas tú.



          Yes kids, once upon a time I was an admin
          Reply With Quote
            #15    
          Old September 15th, 2013 (10:17 AM).
          charizard is best charizard is best is offline
             
            Join Date: Jul 2013
            Gender: Male
            Posts: 16
            First, off a few questions of my own:
            1. What's with twerking exactly? Read the Bible!
            2. What's with parents making their daughters hold signs at busy streets as punishment?
            3. Was the girl ever told by her mom not to twerk? Our generation's messed up because the last generation apparently doesn't feel the need to teach us anything! You can't just bring a new life into the world and expect it to know everything. If the mom actually told the girl, not to twerk, why she shouldn't twerk, and didn't overreact over stupid things like twerking, this wouldn't happen.
            Reply With Quote
              #16    
            Old September 15th, 2013 (11:02 AM).
            Mana's Avatar
            Mana Mana is offline
            • Platinum Tier
             
            Join Date: Jan 2009
            Location: UK
            Gender: Female
            Posts: 10,015
            A lot of the "this mother is awful" argument seems to rely on her not telling her daughter why she did something wrong - we don't know what happened there, it's a big what if.

            Also, how many of you can honestly say you reflected on doing something bad whilst being grounded, and never did it again? Anyone? Now I bet, whilst this girl was standing in the street feeling very sorry for herself, that she decided to listen to her mother more.

            Kids are not perfect and for repeat offenders, ones that just won't listen, perhaps shock tactics are the best way to go.
            Reply With Quote
              #17    
            Old September 15th, 2013 (11:17 AM).
            Aeroblast's Avatar
            Aeroblast Aeroblast is offline
            • Platinum Tier
             
            Join Date: Jul 2013
            Location: Basement
            Gender: Male
            Nature: Relaxed
            Posts: 4,211
            While this punishment is effective in the way she probably won't go around twerking anymore, she will probably be subject to being bullied in school.
            Reply With Quote
              #18    
            Old September 15th, 2013 (5:11 PM).
            OmegaTL's Avatar
            OmegaTL OmegaTL is offline
            Time Lord
               
              Join Date: Sep 2013
              Gender: Male
              Nature: Timid
              Posts: 59
              The fact that she was twerking is ridiculous and she shouldn't have done it, but kids will be kids. I strongly disagree with this kind of punishment and chances are she's going to have a lot of problems in life due to this.
              __________________

              Planned X/Y team so far: Fennekin evo, Charizard, Blaziken, ???, ???, ???
              Like Doctor Who? Come join us at Peladon!
              Reply With Quote
                #19    
              Old September 15th, 2013 (6:56 PM).
              Foxrally's Avatar
              Foxrally Foxrally is online now
              • Moderator
              • Crystal Tier
               
              Join Date: Mar 2013
              Location: On a Torterra
              Age: 19
              Gender: Male
              Nature: Naive
              Posts: 2,549
              Quote:
              Originally Posted by charizard is best View Post
              First, off a few questions of my own:
              1. What's with twerking exactly? Read the Bible!
              2. What's with parents making their daughters hold signs at busy streets as punishment?
              3. Was the girl ever told by her mom not to twerk?
              I just wanted to answer the first and third questions. Twerking, as explained by the reporter, is "moving one's behind in a sexually suggestive manner." This overall behaviour is inappropriate, especially for a 7th-grader.

              Also, if you listened well to the reporter, the mom did tell her daughter not to twerk, yet the girl disobeyed her.
              Reply With Quote
                #20    
              Old September 15th, 2013 (7:02 PM).
              Danny0317's Avatar
              Danny0317 Danny0317 is offline
              Fluorite's back, brah
              • Gold Tier
               
              Join Date: Jun 2013
              Location: Miami, FL
              Age: 17
              Gender: Male
              Nature: Hasty
              Posts: 1,075
              I'm in 8th grade and totally agree with the mom. I don't wanna hear any of the "oh she's young she doesn't know what she's doing" bs. She knew what she was doing very well. Twerking is disgusting and that girl knew exactly what she was doing so I don't feel bad for her. If I did something really stupid like that and my mom forced me to do that I would accept the punishment.

              GO MOM!
              __________________
              Reply With Quote
                #21    
              Old October 14th, 2013 (8:10 PM).
              annwal annwal is offline
                 
                Join Date: Oct 2013
                Gender: Female
                Posts: 1
                There used to be such a thing as public shaming, a type of legal punishment where individuals would be embarrassed in public for their mistakes. It's been getting some traction, as petty thieves and other criminals have been getting shamed for minor wrongdoings.
                Reply With Quote
                  #22    
                Old October 14th, 2013 (8:36 PM).
                Rezilia's Avatar
                Rezilia Rezilia is offline
                   
                  Join Date: Sep 2013
                  Gender: Female
                  Nature: Sassy
                  Posts: 322
                  Quote:
                  Originally Posted by Rezilia View Post
                  I fully believe that children age 5 and over are fully capable of coming up with their own conclusions and sense of ethics. This is due to a study that shows children are first able to ACTUALLY QUESTION the universe around them starting around the age of 4. Parents exist to nurture a child AKA take care of them until their bodies and brains have gotten to the point where they can function on their own - even better if the children have attained a level of expertise in something by that time.

                  The Ten Commandments - I'm not religious but they have some wisdom in them - say that you should respect your father and your mother. My mother did the best she could but she never respected ME. My father is a constant criminal. You are an individual. If you respect someone and they respect you, that's great! But if they don't respect you, why should you respect them? This is esp. the case if you have TRIED to respect them only for them to never return that respect.

                  I appreciate everything my mother did for me. I don't hate her. But when I have a child, I'll nurture them yet let them decide for themselves what is right and wrong, truth and lie. I don't think parents should be slaves to their children - still, children should not be slaves to their parents. We're all EQUAL, no matter our age, and we should ALL treat each other as such.
                  ^ Just going to post that here...

                  The parent is appalled, not because she thinks twerking is wrong, but because her spawn - which she thinks is a part of herself - did something she doesn't like, personally.

                  In other words, it has nothing to do with the ethical nature of twerking, or how it made the child look. The parent took it personally, feeling that it made her (the parent) look bad. When it DIDN'T - she just had that in her head and outright made her child pay for the parent's own insecurities.

                  --

                  The child should have been allowed to do what she wanted and not been punished - since she didn't actually do anything "wrong".
                  __________________


                  Reply With Quote
                    #23    
                  Old October 16th, 2013 (10:52 AM).
                  Eevee's Avatar
                  Eevee Eevee is offline
                  ╰( ´・ω・)つ━☆゚.* ・。゚
                     
                    Join Date: Sep 2013
                    Location: Canada
                    Age: 23
                    Gender: Female
                    Nature: Jolly
                    Posts: 681
                    I think that the girl being 11 made this punishment happen. She's far too young to be behaving like that but I think that this punishment isn't appropriate either. It's like those jokes that are funny to say but when you actually go out and do it, it's not as funny.

                    I think a punishment was needed but not this way. It's easy to punish a child nowadays. Take away a phone or a laptop or something. Children nowadays are glued to the stuff. It would be a much better punishment than this.
                    __________________


                    Reply With Quote
                      #24    
                    Old October 16th, 2013 (11:40 AM).
                    Rezilia's Avatar
                    Rezilia Rezilia is offline
                       
                      Join Date: Sep 2013
                      Gender: Female
                      Nature: Sassy
                      Posts: 322
                      Quote:
                      Originally Posted by Shimmer Mint View Post
                      I think that the girl being 11 made this punishment happen. She's far too young to be behaving like that
                      According to YOU. Not to the girl, who herself felt it was appropriate for her age. Thus, it was her decision. This wasn't an issue of peer pressure. Her mother told her to NOT do it. This means she came to her own decision, using her own reasoning. She felt it was appropriate for her age, so she did it. Period. She shouldn't be punished just because other people can't handle looking at twerking without blowing a fuse.
                      Reply With Quote
                        #25    
                      Old October 16th, 2013 (4:35 PM).
                      Silais's Avatar
                      Silais Silais is offline
                      That useless reptile
                         
                        Join Date: Jul 2013
                        Gender: Female
                        Nature: Quiet
                        Posts: 297
                        Quote:
                        Originally Posted by Rezilia View Post
                        According to YOU. Not to the girl, who herself felt it was appropriate for her age. Thus, it was her decision. This wasn't an issue of peer pressure. Her mother told her to NOT do it. This means she came to her own decision, using her own reasoning. She felt it was appropriate for her age, so she did it. Period. She shouldn't be punished just because other people can't handle looking at twerking without blowing a fuse.
                        I think you have forgotten that human beings are not cognitively mature until they are around 25 years old. She may have made her own decision, but it was not a mature decision and she should not be given the freedom to act in a sexualized way at such a young age. Twerking is inappropriate for children because it construes a sexual innuendo, and we know what happens to those who find children sexually attractive and appealing. The mother, in my opinion, did the right thing by punishing her for engaging in an act that might sexualize her to others, especially adults. We need to teach our children that our bodies are not objects that we should use to exploit ourselves and others.

                        As I said above, she is not NEARLY mature enough to make decisions that construe sexual themes or innuendos. There is a reason her mother "blew a fuse" so to speak; she does not want her daughter to be overly sexual at her age, and she does not want others to see her daughter as a sexual object at such a young age.

                        The reasoning standard only goes so far. We cannot give the freedom of all choice to young children and teenagers and expect good, solid results to come from it. Sometimes we need to regulate how our offspring act so as to remind them what being a decent human being means.
                        __________________
                        Reply With Quote
                        Reply

                        Quick Reply

                        Join the conversation!

                        Create an account to post a reply in this thread, participate in other discussions, and more!

                        Create a PokéCommunity Account

                        Sponsored Links
                        Thread Tools

                        Posting Rules
                        You may not post new threads
                        You may not post replies
                        You may not post attachments
                        You may not edit your posts

                        BB code is On
                        Smilies are On
                        [IMG] code is On
                        HTML code is Off

                        Forum Jump


                        All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:45 AM.