The PokéCommunity Forums Pokémon Gaming Previous Generations
3rd Gen What did you think of the I Gen remakes?

Thread Tools
Old February 24th, 2013 (1:49 AM).
gold/silverFTW's Avatar
gold/silverFTW gold/silverFTW is offline
Ecruteak Champion
    Join Date: Feb 2013
    Location: Ecruteak City
    Gender: Male
    Nature: Bold
    Posts: 24
    I personally think they were really good, but I wish the game had weather effects like RSE. What are your opinions on them?
    Reply With Quote
    Old March 6th, 2013 (11:32 AM).
    ShinyBidoof ShinyBidoof is offline
      Join Date: Sep 2012
      Gender: Male
      Posts: 17
      I thoroughly enjoyed them, even though I think HG and SS were WAY better
      Reply With Quote
      Old March 6th, 2013 (11:59 AM).
      Isseubnida's Avatar
      Isseubnida Isseubnida is offline
        Join Date: Feb 2013
        Location: Where I'm meant to be
        Gender: Male
        Nature: Jolly
        Posts: 87
        I enjoyed them, but I don't think they added enough to the material, other than the Sevii Islands. I played LeafGreen, and I felt like I was playing the EXACT same game, with updated mechanics and remastered graphics. They also didn't add enough additional legendaries, with the only ones being The Dog Trio of Johto. They could have at least added a big island reminiscent of Mt. Silver, with a massive legendary Pokemon, probably Ho-Oh and Lugia, for FireRed and LeafGreen, respectively.

        Speaking of those rascals, you could never complete your Pokedex unless you went to a wretched event where you could DOWNLOAD the on your game. DOWNLOAD. This necessarily means that unless you went to one of those damned events, or you cheated (which is never condoned by Nintendo), you had absolutely no hope in completing your Pokedex. A minor personal complaint is the lack of animated sprites in these and RS. Crystal had this all set up, but they took until Emerald to redo this.

        I'm not all complaints, though. It was great to replay the games that kept me captivated as a child, and I somewhat liked the new key items, like the Fame Checker, which I could never complete, but oh, well. The addition of abilities was a blessing and a curse for certain Pokemon, like Koffing, which could now evade Ground moves. The music was not stellar, but it was pretty acceptable.

        Overall, I enjoyed this game, but I feel that it could have been reinforced more by Gamefreak.

        Have you ever seen a chicken strip?
        Reply With Quote
        Old March 6th, 2013 (1:05 PM).
        Yiazmat's Avatar
        Yiazmat Yiazmat is offline
        going ham since 93'
          Join Date: Jan 2013
          Age: 24
          Gender: Male
          Nature: Lax
          Posts: 12
          They were good, but are now hard to enjoy because of HGSS being better. :(
          Original Yiazmat. ▲

          I remix songs and whatnot. :3
          Reply With Quote
          Old March 6th, 2013 (1:46 PM).
          Kikaito plush's Avatar
          Kikaito plush Kikaito plush is offline
          Angeline plushxKikaito plush
            Join Date: Dec 2009
            Location: plushies resort
            Age: 26
            Gender: Male
            Nature: Naughty
            Posts: 5,598
            They were okay but after main story is over it got a bit boring.
            Reply With Quote
            Old March 6th, 2013 (3:03 PM).
            vovillia vovillia is offline
            CEO & Owner of VoVillia Corp.
              Join Date: Mar 2013
              Location: Saint Petersburg, Florida, USA
              Age: 28
              Gender: Male
              Nature: Relaxed
              Posts: 25
              I thought they were pretty good, but could have been more stuff in it, but when they did the Gen II remakes, it was perfect! :D
              "There were many, and now there are none. With only you stand, and to stand alone. Only you can choose to go on with strength, and continue to write your story of life."
              Reply With Quote
              Old March 6th, 2013 (8:55 PM).
              Brendino's Avatar
              Brendino Brendino is offline
              It's Showtime!
              Join Date: Dec 2009
              Location: Chiefs Kingdom
              Posts: 7,829
              I thought that FireRed and LeafGreen were really well done, staying true to the originals, yet adding new things like the Sevii Islands. Like a few others have said, though, there isn't very much to do once you've completed the story, which was a problem that Ruby and Sapphire had as well (Emerald added the Battle Frontier).

              Overall, they aren't quite as good as HG/SS, but for the lesser technology at the time, they did a pretty good job.
              Reply With Quote
              Old March 6th, 2013 (11:49 PM).
              Tackle's Avatar
              Tackle Tackle is offline
                Join Date: Dec 2012
                Location: Forest
                Age: 19
                Gender: Male
                Nature: Timid
                Posts: 140
                I think it isn't needed, Fire Red and Leaf Green are remakes already. They won't make 3rd remake of Kanto, I think. Plus, in HGSS there's Kanto.

                Feel free to VM / PM me, I'll be sure to reply your messages!

                Paired with ForeverDash, MidnightShine, Shadowraze, Daniel Evans and Hoenn.

                Also known as Clown of Hearts.

                Join Castelia City Forums now!

                Reply With Quote
                Old March 7th, 2013 (12:37 AM).
                Crunch Punch's Avatar
                Crunch Punch Crunch Punch is offline
                fire > ice
                Join Date: Feb 2013
                Location: England
                Age: 21
                Gender: Male
                Posts: 1,375
                I thoroughly enjoyed FRLG but like everyone else said there could have been a lot more stuff done to it, like animated sprites for the Pokemon and updated the Kanto region with things in RS like different types of weather but overall it was enjoyable.
                >> paired to gimmepie ·
                Reply With Quote
                Old March 8th, 2013 (7:52 AM).
                Sorbet's Avatar
                Sorbet Sorbet is offline
                  Join Date: Mar 2013
                  Location: The Netherlands
                  Age: 23
                  Gender: Male
                  Posts: 21
                  They were really good games at the time. For me there was enough to do after the Elite 4, like exploring all the Sevii Islands, which were a great addition to the game.

                  I find it hard to enjoy the games now though, it's just very dated and we have also have Kanto in HG/SS. The only reason to play them now are because of the Sevii Islands and just nostalgia.
                  Reply With Quote
                  Old March 10th, 2013 (6:40 AM).
                  JokerBen's Avatar
                  JokerBen JokerBen is offline
                  Director of Pokémon Nobelium
                    Join Date: Nov 2012
                    Location: Indiana, United States
                    Gender: Male
                    Posts: 236
                    I wish they would have waited for a while and remake it on DS
                    Reply With Quote
                    Old March 11th, 2013 (11:02 PM). Edited March 11th, 2013 by Sonikkts.
                    Sonikkts's Avatar
                    Sonikkts Sonikkts is offline
                      Join Date: Feb 2013
                      Gender: Male
                      Posts: 139
                      I think they were very well done, but could have added in Ho-Oh and Lugia for a different version each. They're not needed to complete the Dex but if you're a perfectionist like me they are.
                      Reply With Quote
                      Old March 12th, 2013 (4:34 AM). Edited March 13th, 2013 by ZetaZaku.
                      ZetaZaku's Avatar
                      ZetaZaku ZetaZaku is offline
                      AEUG Pilot
                        Join Date: Jul 2012
                        Location: Argama
                        Age: 26
                        Gender: Male
                        Posts: 581
                        It's a thing that I actually really dislike. A literal copy of the first games. They should have taken a bit liberty in some parts, like allowing trade with Hoenn from the beginning, or at least when you reach Bill. Having to play the whole game without any Johto or Hoenn Pokemon was boring. I have RedBlueYellow for that. HGSS handled this issue way better. In FRLG you can't even evolve Pokemon who's evolution wasn't in the original games. I had to carry Golbat until Elite Four which it trying to evolve after each level, only to say it stopped.

                        Basically it's the same thing all over again and it was extremely boring. I'd rather replay my RBY games than play FRLG. Thankfully they learned their lesson in HGSS.

                        EDIT: Now that I've beaten the E4 and went to Sevii Island, I have to say that the islands are quite boring. It's just visiting some random locations with the same encounters. I hoped for some new Pokemon, and not Pidgey/Meowth/Spearow combination on ALL seven. This is easily my least favorite game in the series. I'll play it just for the sake of Pokedex and trade with RSE.
                        "Your sight, my delight
                        will you marry me?"
                        Reply With Quote
                        Old March 12th, 2013 (9:07 AM).
                        Zorogami's Avatar
                        Zorogami Zorogami is offline
                        WUB WUB
                        Join Date: Mar 2013
                        Location: Madrid/Spain
                        Age: 26
                        Gender: Male
                        Nature: Relaxed
                        Posts: 2,169
                        I actually had a lot of fun with FR/LF. I loved the fact i could replay the classic games with improved graphics and gameplay. And i thought the addition of the islands was pretty cool. AND the fact you could have wireless battle with that thingy that came with the games :D

                        ~ Anything for my Nakama ~
                        Reply With Quote
                        Old March 13th, 2013 (2:15 PM).
                        Bounsweet's Avatar
                        Bounsweet Bounsweet is offline
                        Fruit Pokémon
                          Join Date: Oct 2007
                          Posts: 2,105
                          I love FRLG. They stand out among the others to me, but seem pretty underrated. The only part I disliked was how hard they made it to connect to the other games in Gen III, what with getting the Ruby and Sapphire for that guy in Sevii Islands.
                          Reply With Quote
                          Old March 14th, 2013 (5:08 PM).
                          B-L-A-Z-E's Avatar
                          B-L-A-Z-E B-L-A-Z-E is offline
                          Join Date: Mar 2013
                          Location: 2nd Largest City in the US
                          Age: 25
                          Gender: Male
                          Nature: Impish
                          Posts: 55
                          While they are my least favorite main series games, I still think they are ok. They're not games I would want to play over and over again but they can be fun every once in a while.

                          You wish it was this easy...
                          Reply With Quote
                          Old March 14th, 2013 (6:12 PM).
                          Munchlax11's Avatar
                          Munchlax11 Munchlax11 is offline
                            Join Date: Jul 2012
                            Location: USA
                            Age: 20
                            Gender: Male
                            Nature: Serious
                            Posts: 198
                            I really liked FRLG... but I liked RSE a lot better, I feel like that FRLG are a step back from RSE.

                            |Ever Grande City Forums|My Profile|PM|Pokemoon Chatbox

                            Pokemon X
                            3DS FC: 2852-7439-1811
                            (VM if you add) :)
                            Reply With Quote
                            Old March 14th, 2013 (6:45 PM).
                            Guy Guy is offline
                            just a guy
                            Join Date: Sep 2008
                            Location: Florida
                            Age: 26
                            Gender: Male
                            Posts: 7,133
                            At the time, they were good for what they were. They certainly learned a thing or two by the time HG/SS came around though. Compared to RSE, however, FRLG did lack a few things that could have made it better: lack of weather effect, no new Pokémon included during the main play-through, and very little graphic improvement are some that come to mind.

                            I never got to play the original Red or Blue versions ─ Ruby was the first Pokémon game I ever got ─ so I couldn't compare the original with the remakes. I do know that the remakes were very much like a carbon copy of the originals though. Not much was changed to make the game play feel somewhat new or refreshing other than what they added post-game. This is something they learned from when making HG/SS I thought.

                            Overall, like I said, they were good for what they were at the time. I certainly had my share of fun playing them.
                            Reply With Quote
                            Old March 15th, 2013 (6:49 PM).
                            Necrum's Avatar
                            Necrum Necrum is offline
                            I AM THE REAL SONIC
                            Join Date: Jul 2012
                            Location: Portland, OR
                            Gender: Male
                            Nature: Adamant
                            Posts: 5,082
                            I thought that FRLG were flawed masterpieces. They certainly do a great job of recreating the region and presenting it in a way that feels very nostalgic. However, it does seem like they could have done more to bring it up to modern standards. I personally think that the absence of the ability to evolve national mons without the national dex was rather silly, but I am glad that it wasn't implemented in HGSS. It does seem like they could have done more to flesh out the story more, maybe explain more of why Giovanni is doing what he's doing, and even include more involvement in the story by Prof Oak. The strictness of which they adhered to the originals makes it feel even more aged than it is. But, even with all that strictness, they changed things in the game that made little sense to me. Primarily the Pokemon distribution throughout the region. Some of it makes sense, yes, but Things like Manky on Route 22 from Yellow are maintained, while Nidoran is removed from the very same route, despite being available on that route in all the gen 1 games! Overall, though, I do thoroughly enjoy my copy of LeafGreen, even if it does have its flaws.
                            Reply With Quote
                            Old March 16th, 2013 (5:33 PM).
                            pokem0nprincess's Avatar
                            pokem0nprincess pokem0nprincess is offline
                              Join Date: Feb 2013
                              Location: USA
                              Age: 24
                              Gender: Female
                              Nature: Quirky
                              Posts: 107
                              I loved it. But I think they could have implemented a few things more that they had introduced in GSC and RSE, like berries and animated sprites. I understand they wished to keep it as authentic to the originals as possible, but I still think they could have at least had berry planting areas in the Sevii Islands and ways to make Pokeblocks and Contests. All in all, though, I think the game is excellent and I love that there were added second gen pokemon catchable. I just wish that there was a prize of a Johto starter once the Kanto dex was complete.
                              Gotta collect 'em all! (seriously, I'm trying.)
                              Reply With Quote

                              Quick Reply

                              Join the conversation!

                              Create an account to post a reply in this thread, participate in other discussions, and more!

                              Create a PokéCommunity Account
                              Thread Tools

                              Posting Rules
                              You may not post new threads
                              You may not post replies
                              You may not post attachments
                              You may not edit your posts

                              BB code is On
                              Smilies are On
                              [IMG] code is On
                              HTML code is Off

                              Forum Jump

                              All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:07 PM.