Advertiser Content

Game Over! Old School Mafia Page 4

Started by gimmepie September 17th, 2019 2:27 AM
  • 3415 views
  • 95 replies

Charlie Brown

coolcoolcool

Age 24
Male
Melbourne, Australia
Seen 2 Weeks Ago
Posted 2 Weeks Ago
4,231 posts
7.5 Years
Whoops went back to old habits and forgot to check PC
  • On D1 alone I would've been surprised at Fletch's flip but reading over his D2 play it was very towny
  • Honestly partially inclined to give Midnight Umbreon the benefit of the doubt because he has had a tendency in past games to just throw around votes based on a hunch. Definitely don't think it's a good play by him to not really back it up but at the same time I'm hesitant to vote him purely because of that when I know that's just (unfortunately) how he often plays. Thought if he can't explain the 'hunch'... @Midnight Umbreon what's your hunch on Rainbow?
  • Still townreading Isa mostly based on their D1 plays and proactiveness, though Isa why the townread on Umbreon?
  • I'd say I've moved back to a nullread on Corviknight (rather than the scumread I mentioned on D1) just based on the explanation for the SJ vote which I think is a fair explanation.
  • Would really like some reads from Sheep, Rainbow and Bidoof ofc...
  • atm though discounting the above three inactive players I'm quite iffy on Ty, your posts on this day phase have been pretty much skating by, you haven't really said anything that could cause confrontation which imo would be a good way to fly under the radar as mafia -- by casting the vote on Midnight Umbreon for a pretty standard reason and your comments on other players just parroting what's already been said (i.e. that players have been inactive, that Corviknight's vote on SJ was a bit odd considering the circumstances, and that I argued with Fletch). Would be keen to see a bit more... idk proactiveness or lead from Ty -- Ty, what do you think about Isa?

I should be able to get online before the phase changes again but in case I don't, casting a vote on Ty bc most iffy on him atm (out of the active players) and would rather spread votes a bit more when there's a lack of consensus, and to give Midnight Umbreon one last chance to explain himself (and if I don't vote I'll be modkilled). But will hopefully be back to read some more responses and adjust my vote accordingly. [vote] Ty

TY

Age 23
Male
Netherlandia
Online now
Posted 2 Hours Ago
2,642 posts
227 Days
I'm not 100% sure what to think of Isa, shes very determined to vote off Corviknight from D1 onwards, which makes me think she has something onto Corvi. I started to be a tad suspicious of her when she mentioned that the early cop kill was a good thing in D2. As it stands though I believe her to be town for now.

My vote on Umbreon was poorly worded perhaps, I just am curious what made him believe that Rainbow is mafia. Predictability can also be deceiving when he can just throw down a 180 at any given time. Untill he explains his reasoning my vote for him stands.

Midnight Umbreon

Life is a conundrum of esoterica

Age 14
Male
Not Delaware
Seen 19 Hours Ago
Posted 2 Weeks Ago
887 posts
1.4 Years
They started with a grudge vote. It was entirely unrelated to the game, and yet voted anyway. The only kind of person that could vote that recklessly is either an idiot (Sorry if the first one is true lol) and the second is that Their mafia and knew that if they voted for that person, it was a win-win.

TY

Age 23
Male
Netherlandia
Online now
Posted 2 Hours Ago
2,642 posts
227 Days
So what about SJ who also had started with a grudge vote but turned out to be town in the end?

Midnight Umbreon

Life is a conundrum of esoterica

Age 14
Male
Not Delaware
Seen 19 Hours Ago
Posted 2 Weeks Ago
887 posts
1.4 Years
...

Huh ok.

I'm not retracting my vote yet, we have proof that the last post i made was stupid, but still none that proves that rainbow is in fact not guilty. If rainbow themself could voice their thoughts on the matter, it might sway me in another direction.

Sheep

Female
Seen 1 Hour Ago
Posted 3 Hours Ago
Would really like some reads from Sheep, Rainbow and Bidoof ofc...
As a brand new player I'm not quite confident enough yet to provide any interesting reads ):

Meanwhile from the thinking I've done today (been busy) and as someone who has no past experience seeing how others in this game have played Mafia before, Midnight Umbreon's votes strike me as a little odd because I couldn't understand the reasoning behind them. With that said...

[Vote] Midnight Umbreon

sheep x bobandbill 5ever

Isa_theDT

Dragon Tamer

Female
Ecuador
Seen 2 Hours Ago
Posted 3 Days Ago
76 posts
5.3 Years
1. Why the townread on Umbreon?
Honestly it's not a solid read, but this is my thought process:
  • He's been doing his own things without following others. On D1 he thought maybe SD's vote was not just a random vote.
  • Then he voted on SD but said it was a free vote.
  • He answered my comment about how experienced JD was with a comment about how based on the kill maybe mafia was not all new players.
  • On day two him and Fletch voted Omicron first thing with a similar comment.
  • At first I thought (conspiracy theory) maybe Fletch and Umbreon planned to kill who they thought may be the cop, then vote on the target, and when the target flipped mafia they would be more or less confirmed town.
  • This theory proved to be false from Fletch's flip and anyway, I wasn't sure Fletch was mafia anyway.
  • Umbreon had a similar thought-peocess to a now known Townie, so he may be a townie too.
  • Umbreon made the first move on D3.
Like I said, not a solid read but I'm more inclined to think he's town than before.

2. Comment about killing the cop being a good play
On hindsight I see how that comment could be taken the wrong way. What I meant was that killing a cop, in and on itself, is a good strategy, because a cop can confirm who is town and who isn't. So really when is leaving the cop alive a good play?? And it's more difficult to lynch them during the day because they can just prove who they are. But taking into account that mafia wasn't sure that SD was cop, then there were better plays, like someone who was more active than him. I'm still not sure because no one explained...? But anyway, someone can explain it to me after the game.

3. My votes on Corviknight
He went for the easy kill and with a target that was being cooperative. He could have gone for any of the other random/grudge voters or for anyone else with another reason. He went inactive for a day and never gave an explanation (until now). Which I'm still not fully convinced about but ok.

A couple of my own questions:
Umbreon. You keep saying that you think mafia members are mostly new players with maybe one good player helping. Do you have someone in mind that fits either criteria? And what's your opinion on Omicron?

Sheep and Ty if you had to say someone you think is more likely to be town who would you say and why?

Also
[Unvote] Corviknight

TY

Age 23
Male
Netherlandia
Online now
Posted 2 Hours Ago
2,642 posts
227 Days
I get what your intention is with your comment, i think it was just worded a bit poorly. Happens.

As for your question, I think CB is more likely to be town than Umbreon right now. Even though he voted me to be lynched it has much more motives behind it than Umbreons.

Isa_theDT

Dragon Tamer

Female
Ecuador
Seen 2 Hours Ago
Posted 3 Days Ago
76 posts
5.3 Years
Oh! I see... Gah. Facepalm. What I meant was with Fletch's comment that mafia was made entirely of new players I thought he was saying that going for the cop was a bad play for the mafia. So guess I misinterpreted and didn't make myself clear. I never meant that it was a good thing for us. Of course it's not.

Midnight Umbreon

Life is a conundrum of esoterica

Age 14
Male
Not Delaware
Seen 19 Hours Ago
Posted 2 Weeks Ago
887 posts
1.4 Years
Tsk....

I'm the drunk. I used my n1 action on rainbow and n2 on Charlie brown. This will probably get me killed tonight if y'all dont today. Don't say I didn't warn you.

gimmepie

Age 24
Male
Australia
Seen 31 Minutes Ago
Posted 13 Hours Ago
20,358 posts
7.5 Years
Time's Up

Apologies for the late change, I got caught up doing a million things at once.

gimmepie

Age 24
Male
Australia
Seen 31 Minutes Ago
Posted 13 Hours Ago
20,358 posts
7.5 Years
Old School Mafia
No fancy custom roles. No flavour or thematics. Nothing but pure mafia.

Game Over


Midnight Umbreon is dead. He was the Drunk.

Bidoof FTW is dead. He was a Villager.

The mafia of Corviknght, TY, Sheep and Omicron wins!

The Rules


1. All UG and PC rules apply.
2. The Night Phase lasts 24 hours, the Day Phase 48. Do not post in the thread during the Night Phase.
3. Do not share information from your role PM/DM or discuss the details of the game outside of the thread or Mafia team chat.
4. If you die, you're dead. Don't continue to haunt the thread with your posts. The exception to this is a single "death post" that cannot contain any game related information.
5. Post twice per Day Phase.
6. Format lynch votes as [vote] username
7. Failing to vote during two consecutive Day Phases may result in a GM kill.

The Players


gimmepie as the Game Master
Fletch as the Doctor
Sheep as the Scout
TY as the Godfather
Corviknight as the Mafioso
Rainbow as a Villager
Simply Dunsparce as the Cop
Bidoof FTW as a Villager
Isa_theDT as a Villager
jdthebud as a Villager
Omicron as the Hooker
Nakuzami as a Villager
Midnight Umbreon as the Drunk
Charlie Brown a Villager
Superjolt as the Vigilante



Spoiler:
I’ll play
joininggg
I'll give this a shot why not
Let’s hope this gets past signups! Count me in (:
sure
Signing up
yes
How busy are these games in this forum usually? I'm interested but not sure about my free time.
I'll join!
[Lynch] Fletch

(I'm in)
I'll slide in
i want in please


in
i probably shouldn’t

but i will!


Keep your eyes peeled because I'll have a follow-up game posted either tonight or tomorrow.

Fletch

Age 23
Male
Seen 2 Hours Ago
Posted 3 Days Ago
6,387 posts
5.7 Years
Surprising plays from the mafia for sure. But definitely did well and I can see how that would work now, judging how slow and scrambled town were. GG

Sheep

Female
Seen 1 Hour Ago
Posted 3 Hours Ago
oooh what a thing to wake up to

for my first time experiencing a mafia game from beginning to end, I had fun despite being so confused at first!!!

sheep x bobandbill 5ever

TY

Age 23
Male
Netherlandia
Online now
Posted 2 Hours Ago
2,642 posts
227 Days
Hah. See I wasn't completely wrong... Good game people.
close but no cigar :P

Midnight Umbreon

Life is a conundrum of esoterica

Age 14
Male
Not Delaware
Seen 19 Hours Ago
Posted 2 Weeks Ago
887 posts
1.4 Years
Hey i was wrong. At least the mafia was largely inactive, so it wasnt even possible so suspect anyone




also legit i almost turned my vote to TY, but it would have looked like a grudge vote. And it partially would have been, but yesterday i thought "you know what would be funny? If TY was mafia." Obviously it would still have been grasping at straws but i mean...

TY

Age 23
Male
Netherlandia
Online now
Posted 2 Hours Ago
2,642 posts
227 Days
was my very first game so I just tend to watch from the sidelines, even if i was town :s

Nakuzami

Age 21
Female
The Forgotten Crossroads
Seen 3 Days Ago
Posted 5 Days Ago
6,885 posts
9.1 Years
I should feel bad that my first thought was to lynch Corviknight when I read day one and then I didn't even post lmao
"Sure, there're probably infinite dimensions, but I'm with you in this one, so why would I try to find them?"
~Neil Hilborn


gimmepie

Age 24
Male
Australia
Seen 31 Minutes Ago
Posted 13 Hours Ago
20,358 posts
7.5 Years
I should feel bad that my first thought was to lynch Corviknight when I read day one and then I didn't even post lmao
Yes

Charlie Brown

coolcoolcool

Age 24
Male
Melbourne, Australia
Seen 2 Weeks Ago
Posted 2 Weeks Ago
4,231 posts
7.5 Years
damn, gg. at least isa and i pinpointed most of the mafia team, just couldn't string together an effective lynch lel
Advertiser Content