Advertiser Content

Game Over! A New Challenger Approaches [Game Over] Page 7

Started by Nakuzami March 11th, 2019 8:55 PM
  • 7811 views
  • 243 replies

Filthy Acts at a Reasonable Price

Age 24
Male
Seen 2 Days Ago
Posted 3 Days Ago
3,026 posts
3.9 Years
Excuse my absence but I've been busy with classes/my internship

Anyway I'm gonna get caught up on what happened and make a more detailed post later. I see we have a few role reveals and if that's the route we're taking them I'm down for it.

Corviknight

c h e r r y a l l i g a t o r

Age 28
Male
Corneria
Seen 10 Hours Ago
Posted 21 Hours Ago
6,194 posts
4.4 Years
##Vote EC Haven't seen him talk in a bit.
That's because he left the forum and got replaced.........

Charlie Brown

coolcoolcool

Age 24
Male
Melbourne, Australia
Seen 7 Hours Ago
Posted 9 Hours Ago
4,185 posts
7.2 Years
I meant his posts are a wall for me to read on mobile. Meant to say this but phase change was about to pop.
Ahh my bad. Anyway I made the same mistake as 5qwerty (rip) and didn't read the OP properly, I thought there was a recruiting cult, not a cthulu-type cult (if the cult is even present in the set-up).

##Vote Bardothren - simply, I don’t like that you have another gun and right now alarm bells are ringing saying you’re Maf who just shot an inno and are covering it up; I wouldn’t put it past you to shoot Juno and have her flip Maf for the sake of preservation.
I think you should move your vote off Bard. Ofc we haven't seen him shoot another gun yet so he could be maf who got given a gun and either received another one last night or is bluffing, but I do think that would be a pretty risky and short-term focused strategy for mafia to take which I don't think would make sense when they're 2 people down. And since you're Marth and your vote is the one that counts...

That said I do find it strange that Bard shot 5q, especially since no one else had raised any suspicious of 5qwerty.

Also on the note of the gun I was given N0 and have been hanging on to. Assuming Bard is in fact Bowser Jr, I think the possibilities are either it's a real gun and Aldo was villager/Isabelle and gave me a gun (which would make sense -- he's the type to give out guns N0 and we've been mafia a few times so I guess he'd give it to a familiar face) or it's a fake gun and Lulu was maf-sided villager (though that begs the question of who the real PIkachu is, since she claimed Pikachu). Leaning towards the former but I'm not gonna shoot unless there's a strong enough reason to and there definitely isn't one yet.

Yeah I’m not really feeling scum Juno anymore

Metroid, Syn, EC/Desi (maybe Doof?) This group is where we’ll find scum I think.

Thoughts on this, everyone?

##vote metroid

Also Rabi I think Bard’s claim is believable for now (because who would have visited Del anyway? Makes sense if he’s town Bowser jr getting guns from non-visits, though I am a little surprised if no one targeted Bard after he replaced in)
Can't really comment on Desi, I think I need another phase with him to get a proper feel since he just came in and EC is just naturally scummy imo. But I'd agree with two of Metroid / Syn / Doof (and I'm 50/50 throwing Juno on that list just based on what I said last phase + GP really pushing for a jd vote rather than a Juno vote).

Meta but Doof has been more on the quiet side in a lot of games recently but in those games where he's been mafia, he has made more of an effort rather than pretty much being completely absent. Whereas Syn has posted a fair amount of times but hasn't really offered any individual thinking at all.

With Marth around my vote is just a symbolic one but I'd go with ##vote Syndrome

Bardothren

Muddling along somehow

Age 24
Male
In my room
Seen 16 Hours Ago
Posted 1 Week Ago
8,645 posts
4.6 Years
Ahh my bad. Anyway I made the same mistake as 5qwerty (rip) and didn't read the OP properly, I thought there was a recruiting cult, not a cthulu-type cult (if the cult is even present in the set-up).



I think you should move your vote off Bard. Ofc we haven't seen him shoot another gun yet so he could be maf who got given a gun and either received another one last night or is bluffing, but I do think that would be a pretty risky and short-term focused strategy for mafia to take which I don't think would make sense when they're 2 people down. And since you're Marth and your vote is the one that counts...

That said I do find it strange that Bard shot 5q, especially since no one else had raised any suspicious of 5qwerty.
My suspicion of 5q was based on how chummy he was with gimmepie, and how he had taken a more cautious stance as the Rabi-gimmepie argument heated up. I still suspect Juno, and otherwise, I don't have any solid reads. Considering how my hardest scumread flipped, I'm reluctant to trust my instincts anymore, but maybe I'll redeem myself tomorrow.

Also, I'd love to shoot my other guns, but as I said earlier, Naku has me on a strict one gun per day limit as per EM rules. I'd have shot someone yesterday had I had more time to actually read things over and get a scumread.
I really need to change this signature, but I'm too lazy.

Superjolt

The sharpest there is

Age 26
Male
Deep below the PokéCommunity...
Seen 2 Hours Ago
Posted 4 Days Ago
Ahh my bad. Anyway I made the same mistake as 5qwerty (rip) and didn't read the OP properly, I thought there was a recruiting cult, not a cthulu-type cult (if the cult is even present in the set-up).



I think you should move your vote off Bard. Ofc we haven't seen him shoot another gun yet so he could be maf who got given a gun and either received another one last night or is bluffing, but I do think that would be a pretty risky and short-term focused strategy for mafia to take which I don't think would make sense when they're 2 people down. And since you're Marth and your vote is the one that counts...

That said I do find it strange that Bard shot 5q, especially since no one else had raised any suspicious of 5qwerty.

Also on the note of the gun I was given N0 and have been hanging on to. Assuming Bard is in fact Bowser Jr, I think the possibilities are either it's a real gun and Aldo was villager/Isabelle and gave me a gun (which would make sense -- he's the type to give out guns N0 and we've been mafia a few times so I guess he'd give it to a familiar face) or it's a fake gun and Lulu was maf-sided villager (though that begs the question of who the real PIkachu is, since she claimed Pikachu). Leaning towards the former but I'm not gonna shoot unless there's a strong enough reason to and there definitely isn't one yet.



Can't really comment on Desi, I think I need another phase with him to get a proper feel since he just came in and EC is just naturally scummy imo. But I'd agree with two of Metroid / Syn / Doof (and I'm 50/50 throwing Juno on that list just based on what I said last phase + GP really pushing for a jd vote rather than a Juno vote).

Meta but Doof has been more on the quiet side in a lot of games recently but in those games where he's been mafia, he has made more of an effort rather than pretty much being completely absent. Whereas Syn has posted a fair amount of times but hasn't really offered any individual thinking at all.

With Marth around my vote is just a symbolic one but I'd go with ##vote Syndrome
Why Syn over metroid?


"This pitiless Pokémon commands a group of Pawniard to hound prey into immobility. It then moves in to finish the prey off."

Bidoof Island Mafia Age of Demons

Corviknight

c h e r r y a l l i g a t o r

Age 28
Male
Corneria
Seen 10 Hours Ago
Posted 21 Hours Ago
6,194 posts
4.4 Years
Yes I was meant to move off that vote oops, I’m not currently sure who I should swing my sword at next however, I feel this is my last day to live so I want to at least hopefully kill another Maf or at least pave the way to one...

...##Vote Metroid. Iffy non-committal responses at this point BUT more importantly your reveal will confirm my other suspicions.

Filthy Acts at a Reasonable Price

Age 24
Male
Seen 2 Days Ago
Posted 3 Days Ago
3,026 posts
3.9 Years
I know that my posts aren't really that analytical, but I've never been that sort of player and I'm not going to become one overnight.

In any case, right now I'm mostly suspicious of L'Belle for (and this is the pot calling the kettle black, but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯) not contributing much, while only having 2 less posts than me. I'm also a little Iffy on Josh because of that. He conveniently didn't list L'Belle at all when I really don't think his posts could be considered any better than what I've thrown out so far.

So for now, I'm gonna ##Vote L'Belle

Bidoof FTW

→ Bidoof is Pretty Rad

Age 20
Male
the States
Seen 21 Hours Ago
Posted 21 Hours Ago
3,544 posts
5.6 Years
I'm pretty confident syn is town, just based off of what has been said already, and I haven't really liked what Metroid has said earlier in the game, so this vote is fine with me.
##Vote Metroid

Juno

w i n t e r

Age 24
Female
Canadia
Seen 1 Hour Ago
Posted 2 Days Ago
4,156 posts
5.6 Years
I think it's more likely that Bard just had a bad read, and no, I am not just saying this to appeal to the madman because he wants to shoot me tomorrow - 5qwerty read really town to me, so on that alone I find Bard's suspicion iffy, however on a more meta note I agree with Jolt's assessment that it would have been unlikely anyone visited Del, so it would make sense for Bard to step into this role with all these guns. If he is not bluffing and he has more than one (which lbr it's Bard so who knows) then it's most likely Del was Bowser Jr.

If I need to respond to the whole "Juno is suspicious because gp defended Juno" line of logic, I may be biased here but could it be that I made some good and reasonable points that are easy to defend, therefore gp and several others came to my defense? It's not exactly unheard of for mafia to side with town to appear town and I'm pretty confident I wouldn't have been lynched last day regardless of whether gp came to my defense or not, because several players seemed to realize the logic behind voting for me was shaky.

I'm ok with the metroid vote - like I said last day, he does read as an inexperienced player but that could go either way, I can't tell if he's inexperienced town or inexperienced maf but currently leaning towards the latter.

##Vote metroid

Charlie Brown

coolcoolcool

Age 24
Male
Melbourne, Australia
Seen 7 Hours Ago
Posted 9 Hours Ago
4,185 posts
7.2 Years
Why Syn over metroid?
I’m tbh not sure what the case is against metroid, apart from a jumpy vote last day phase which is generally how he plays so I’m not reading much into it

@Syn - L’Belle was one of the few people critical of both bandwagons yesterday so their unwillingness to jump on either one was why i townread him yesterday and he hasn’t done anything today to make me lose faith in him

Superjolt

The sharpest there is

Age 26
Male
Deep below the PokéCommunity...
Seen 2 Hours Ago
Posted 4 Days Ago
That's because he left the forum and got replaced.........
Whaaat?? Wait why did he leave??
I know that my posts aren't really that analytical, but I've never been that sort of player and I'm not going to become one overnight.
I think you need to go read your own posts in older games because I’m not sure why you think this o_O
(unless my memory of older games is just really bad)

Anyway i think L’Belle is town so I don’t really get that vote, why is L’Belle a better vote than others?

I’m tbh not sure what the case is against metroid, apart from a jumpy vote last day phase which is generally how he plays so I’m not reading much into it
For me, it’s mostly POE as I think he’s the most likely scum in that group right now, but also didn’t like his vote on jd

Though now that I’m looking back a little, it does kind of feel like Syn was looking for an excuse to join Lulu wagon... so maybe I’m wrong on this? idk

Also looking at your previous post again I think I agree about Desi but I really want to hear why he’s thinking about lynching Pecilia

Desinishon

Banned

Age 20
Male
East Blue
Seen 5 Days Ago
Posted April 28th, 2019
5,030 posts
3.8 Years
Pecillia hadn't given anything of substance yet beside that the way GP was gunning for JD and me assuming that JD is inno. Pecillia being part of jdwagon last phase didn't sit right with me. That's my reason for voting them even if I didn't voted them at all just stated a potential player who I'll go for if we didn't get any other info or come to any agreement about who to lynch and you're losing your marbles just for that. That being said

##VotePecillia


I'm ok with meteoroid/syn vote too but I still think meteoroid is just new player. It's been a while since I played but I've not seen them in any of games. As for syn like I stated in previous post I see them same as Pecillia just trying to blend in.

Pecilia

Best Witch

Male
'Murica
Seen 4 Hours Ago
Posted 1 Week Ago
1,827 posts
8.9 Years
I wouldn't call Metroid a new player though I can see where this is coming from his posts.Oh, and if I was trying to blend in don't you think I would've jumped onto the Metrowagon rather than not? Also:
I may be reading too much into this, but is it possible Kirby may have also had a play in it last night? Pointing this out from the "fruitful" bit. Since Kirby is usually associated with food.
This post gives me more of a town vibe, yes it may be a bit far-fetched but putting the effort and thinking outside the box to me is much more of something a town would do.

Guess while I'm at it in the middle of the night when I'm not working or playing Sekiro I'll take some time to read through and give some reads on a few players.

Syndrome- Reluctance to vote Lulu day 1 pre-claim is noteworthy. Though his lack of posts being due to real world reasons, his vote on L'belle kinda rubs me weirdly. Slight Scumread.

Charlie Brown- Has a gun, honestly I think it's real. I feel like mafia would fab a gun to someone a little more chaotic or new as they have an increased risk of shooting it without taking it into full consideration. Also Bard claimed Bowser Jr. and has guns so it's a good chance to say it's not sabo'd.

Superjolt- Super inquisitive, as always. Haven't bothered looking in past games to see if you change any bit as scum, but from what I can tell you're most likely town.

Desinishon- Previously as EC, who always acted scummy regardless of alignment. Not much to go on though, since EC didn't really say anything. Also I feel like I'm getting a bit of Deja Vu, is this the first time you've gunned for me out of everyone? It's not actually, you went for me in High School Sweethearts mafia apparently. Not sure why, guess I just always look scummy in your eyes. Though I change my posting style every so often, I mostly keep short posts at the start with more jokes than reads. Regardless of your conviction against me, I have a null read on you.

Bardothren- So Bard has guns and he was revealed upon shooting them so obviously not a sniper, which means their Bowser Jr. claim is likely true. Join more games though, if you're in and I can give you guns, I 120% will. fufu

BidoofFTW- Not really giving much and I feel he does moreso as scum. So between everyone, I'm going to lean scum.

Juno- Town lean, they gave a pretty in-depth analysis which shows me they're putting in a good effort to scum hunt. While they did last minute change to Juno Day 1 I honestly feel at the time it was justified. While I don't agree with the metroid vote, I feel good about their posts.

Rabinov- Judging by the results of yesterday I would guess Marth, no? Town read.

jdthebud- I joke about the whole GP/JD thing, but honestly I feel like Aldo (Lucas) froze LuluRina, who very well may have been Pikachu as well as been the one to go for the kill. I don't have any real deep reads on JD himself but I'm going with my gut and leaning town.

L'Belle- Meta read: probably Ike, and since my read on Rabi and that GP was the one lynched, town assuming Ike.

##Vote BidoofFTW I scum read doof the hardest but wouldn't mind voting Syn either, just getting my vote there now.

Nakuzami

Age 21
Female
The Forgotten Crossroads
Seen 1 Day Ago
Posted 1 Week Ago
6,879 posts
8.8 Years
hi sorry for not ending the phase on time i kinda went to a movie and then didn't go home and then i did a sleep

so i'll be doing that in a little bit
"Sure, there're probably infinite dimensions, but I'm with you in this one, so why would I try to find them?"
~Neil Hilborn


Nakuzami

Age 21
Female
The Forgotten Crossroads
Seen 1 Day Ago
Posted 1 Week Ago
6,879 posts
8.8 Years

Night Three

The combatants seemed more torn than usual, changing their minds a few times over the course of the day and ending in a split decision, but the majority still ruled.

They decided to kill the one who had been their greatest guardian, allowing darkness to seep in in even greater amounts than ever before.


Brawl!
Combatants line up in the arena, ganging up on particular players like all good fighters do!

Syndrome
Pecilia
Charlie Brown
Superjolt
Desinishon
Bardothren
Bidoof FTW
Juno
Rabinov
jdthebud
L'Belle
metroid711
L'Belle
Bidoof FTW
Syndrome
metroid711
Juno
Pecilia
metroid711
metroid711
metroid711
did not vote
metroid711
did not vote

metroid711 is dead! He was a Hero of the Light!


Cast List
Nakuzami as the Game Master

Syndrome
Pecilia
Charlie Brown
Superjolt
Desinishon
Bardothren
Bidoof FTW
Juno
Rabinov
jdthebud
L'Belle
LuluRina
Aldo
gimmepie
5qwerty
metroid711
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
"Sure, there're probably infinite dimensions, but I'm with you in this one, so why would I try to find them?"
~Neil Hilborn


Nakuzami

Age 21
Female
The Forgotten Crossroads
Seen 1 Day Ago
Posted 1 Week Ago
6,879 posts
8.8 Years

Day Four

"Finally, now that that one's gone, the bloodshed goes on uninterrupted!"

And that it did. Someone infiltrated Bardothren's personal space during the night and caused whatever he was messing with to explode, running away with a handy reward.


Bardothren is dead! He was a Hero of the Light!


Cast List
Nakuzami as the Game Master

Syndrome
Pecilia
Charlie Brown
Superjolt
Desinishon
Bidoof FTW
Juno
Rabinov
jdthebud
L'Belle
LuluRina
Aldo
gimmepie
5qwerty
metroid711
Bardothren
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
boop!
"Sure, there're probably infinite dimensions, but I'm with you in this one, so why would I try to find them?"
~Neil Hilborn


Corviknight

c h e r r y a l l i g a t o r

Age 28
Male
Corneria
Seen 10 Hours Ago
Posted 21 Hours Ago
6,194 posts
4.4 Years
........is this some psyduckery to do with roles Naku or did you forget to edit the CSS.

Nakuzami

Age 21
Female
The Forgotten Crossroads
Seen 1 Day Ago
Posted 1 Week Ago
6,879 posts
8.8 Years
you saw nothing :eyes:
"Sure, there're probably infinite dimensions, but I'm with you in this one, so why would I try to find them?"
~Neil Hilborn


Advertiser Content