Pick Your Starter!

I'm trying to get settled in here, as I'm new. So I'm proposing a small forum game idea.

How it works:
Person A says 3 Pokemon. (From any generation, from best to worst! You can include levels or moves if you want to get really technical, but not needed.)
Person B must choose one with a small explanation why, then Person B gets to propose 3 new starters.

Simple right? I'll start.
1. Metapod
2. Magikarp
3. Bidoof.

All with tackle only.

Fun idea! Gonna move this over to Pokemon Trivia - that's the Pokemon-specific forum games. :)

Anyway, realistically that Magikarp is going to be pretty useful one day but I gotta go with Bidoof, it's just so goofy

I know it's not required, buuut I'm gonna make them the three starter Types too:
1. Cherubi
2. Vulpix
3. Psyduck

Is this a question? :t037:

Let?s see...

Mankey
Spearow
Onix

That's actually tough because they're so different... I think Onix because Mega Steelix.

Raikou
Entei
Suicune

Raikou

Skarmory
Mantine
Delibird

I'd pick Skarmory.

Mankey
Kabuto
Hoothoot

Kabuto because i like that double typing ^^.

Let's see, hmm...

Beldum
Larvitar
Poipole

Poipole would make an interesting choice! Plus it's actually pretty cute. :D

Skiddo
Numel
Skrelp

Skiddo

Inkay
Pumpkaboo
Honedge

Honedge.

Dodrio
Dugtrio
Magneton

Dugtrio

Snover
Swinub
Spheal

Swinub

Cyndaquil
Torchic
Chimchar

Torchic! Hoenn starters are always hard to resist

Dratini
Larvitar
Larvesta

Larvesta! Because Volcarona is so beautiful and majestic and easily one of my favourite Pokémon. :D

Clauncher
Corphish
Dwebble

Corphish. It's evolution isn't half bad.

Espeon
Umbreon
Sylveon

I'll take Espeon here.

Mr. Mime
Jynx
Aromatisse

I'll take Jynx then since it has a good move pool.

Quilfish
Ledian
Simisage
__________________

Simisage does not have good defense but I do like its design.

Rotom
Tapu Koko
Alolan Golem

Tapu Koko, its a great Pokemon though, sure its OP but I won't leave it.

Sandile, Digett, Mudbray

Mudbray. I used all three and I loved Mudbray the most.

Remoraid
Pumpkaboo
Minccino