Game Development Your number one stop for anything related to creating games (except ROM hacks). You can even make your own!

Draconius GO
View Poll Results: All Regions. All Pokemon. Yes or No
Heck yeah! 29 63.04%
No man, that's stupid! 17 36.96%
Voters: 46. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #1    
Old July 10th, 2013 (9:04 PM).
war rock exe's Avatar
war rock exe war rock exe is offline
Pokemon Colosseum Remaker!!
     
    Join Date: Dec 2009
    Location: wouldn't you like to know?
    Age: 20
    Gender: Male
    Nature: Hardy
    Posts: 817
    Hey guys, it's just as the title says: would you like all that all the games and regions combined into one game? Of course that would take forever but for my intro to computer science class I have to make a game using a game program and I thought, "Hey why not make a Pokemon game using RPG Maker!"
    Would y'all like that? (I wouldn't want to waste my time doing something that everyone hates :/
    __________________
    POKÈMON COLOSSEUM TRILOGY FOR RMXP!! COMING THIS SUMMER!
    STATUS; BETA 1 70%
    Reply With Quote

    Relevant Advertising!

      #2    
    Old July 11th, 2013 (8:31 AM).
    Maruno's Avatar
    Maruno Maruno is offline
    Lead Dev of Pokémon Essentials
       
      Join Date: Jan 2008
      Location: England
      Posts: 5,189
      There are so many maps in each region that it'd take many months to create them all. It would then take even longer to put events into them, and longer still to make it work as some kind of game rather than a Grand Tour (i.e. sight-seeing without a plot).

      The official games work just fine with one region each. Two regions in a game might be all right if you're good and/or the regions are small, but three is pushing it. You certainly couldn't fill more than 3 regions with a single story, and if your solution is to have several different stories (usually one per region), then they might as well be separate games with some recurring characters.

      Consider how many games here have just one region in them, and consider how many of them are actually being worked on rather than abandoned at conception, and then consider how much progress they have. Not much. To say that wanting all regions is ambitious is a gross understatement, and you're practically guaranteed to fail badly (I only say "practically" because it's technically not impossible to succeed, but it might as well be).

      Personally, I wouldn't want to see such a game anyway, even if it existed. I can just go play the official games if I wanted to retread all the regions. Such an idea reeks of unoriginality, and doesn't at all inspire me to play it because it wouldn't add anything new.
      __________________
      Go to the Pokémon Essentials Wiki

      | Downloads | Tutorials | Fangames |
      | All Animations Project |

      Follow me on Twitter: @maruno42


      Reply With Quote
        #3    
      Old July 11th, 2013 (9:11 AM).
      RG8Gaming's Avatar
      RG8Gaming RG8Gaming is offline
         
        Join Date: Jul 2013
        Gender: Male
        Posts: 3
        I think a super long game that is a big accomplishment to complete would be nice.
        For example, we could do what Ash does with every region.
        Store the Pokemon in the Lab and move on to the next region with a fresh start.
        At least that's what I think he does.
        Just my thoughts.
        __________________
        Check out my YouTube Channel if ya want!
        www.youtube.com/RG8Gaming
        Current Series: Minecraft, Legend of Zelda a Link to the Past, and Pokemon Emerald Rainbow Challenge!
        Reply With Quote
          #4    
        Old July 11th, 2013 (12:29 PM).
        Luka S.J.'s Avatar
        Luka S.J. Luka S.J. is offline
        Jealous Croatian
           
          Join Date: Dec 2008
          Location: Croatia
          Age: 24
          Gender: Male
          Nature: Adamant
          Posts: 1,106
          I tried an idea like that, and it is not as pleasant as it sounds. Apart from the heavy work load you get in terms of mapping, eventing, tiling, spriting, thinking (deciding new level caps as they are needed, then the addition of extra movesets past lv100 and such), you have the problem of not being very flexible with such a game. You have to stick to a certain formula, which gets boring after a while. You can't really reinvent the existing towns/routes/misc in terms of mapping (people would look for familiarity in such games). Also, you gotta use existing characters and don't have any freedom with those either. So yeah, as a dewd that tried it, I didn't really have too much fun doing it, hence why I stopped it.
          __________________

          Reply With Quote
            #5    
          Old July 11th, 2013 (3:08 PM).
          Derxwna Kapsyla's Avatar
          Derxwna Kapsyla Derxwna Kapsyla is offline
          [Primal Despair] Derxwna "The Badman" Kapsyla
             
            Join Date: Jun 2011
            Location: Margate, FL
            Age: 24
            Gender: Male
            Nature: Lax
            Posts: 401
            A game with every region is an idea long sought after mostly by two kinds of people:
            • A) Overly Ambitious People, whos projects die before they start
            • B) People developing an MMO, which is rather logical so they can have more of a world to explore.
            Though there have been cases where a person didn't fit either category.

            Limiting yourself is the key to a good game, knowing where to draw the line on what to add and what not to add. While the Developer does have total control over what they can do, restraint is a very good skill to learn in development. I speak with minor experience, personal and watching others work.

            The game I'm working on, Touhoumon Faith & Prayer Version, showcases 3 regions from Pokemon proper, and a separate region after that. Overly ambitious, but I have plans to make it work. I'd be working more on it right now if my computer wasn't broken, but I digress.

            There are things you need to keep in mind when even developing a Multi-Region game that encompasses 2+ Regions.
            • A) The number of maps. A traditional region has about 300+ maps if each map was its own map. Exteriors, Routes, Interiors, All of it sums together. If you were to make a 3 or more region game, you'd hit the Engine Imposed 999 Map Limit before you finished. If you need more than 1000 maps, you should perhaps look into either combining maps, or maybe cutting the project into two depending on how the plot works.
            • B) The length of the game. Your game better be more interesting than "Beat the 8 gyms and become a League Champion" for each region, otherwise it's going to get old. Fast. The plot also better not be a complete rehash of the original games plot. A person doesn't want to download a game where all it is is the combination of several non-plot related games when they could download the individual games themselves and play those. You also don't want it to drag on and on. and on.
            • C) Filesize. This is a large issue that gets easily overlooked if you're playing MP3 files for music. Your game's filesize will spike exponentially without you knowing it, and you'll wind up with a 1 region release that's 1 gig because the music is large. If 1 region ends up being 1 gig, imagine how bad 3 regions would be?
            • D) Leveling and Balance Scale. Using Generation II as an example, by the end of Johto, the player was usually around Level 45~55. At the end of Kanto, the player was usually around the level 65~85, sometimes even 100. If you were to add a third region to the mix, you'd be a 100 halfway through it. It'd be illogical to add a Fourth Region, because then everything would be at Level 100 across the region, and that would get really boring really fast. One method to resolve it would be bumping the maximum level up another hundred levels, but why would you honestly do that? You'd have to work to give the Pokemon additional movepools beyond Level 100, otherwise they'd have to work with what they have for the next 100 levels, and considering their movepools were designed to cap at 100, there wouldn't be much else you could do anyways. Another method is to, like Maruno said, split it into two games depending on Plot. Alternatively, find a creative, but good and perhaps "believable", method to lowering the levels of trainers back down to around 5 at the start of a new region. Hell, pull an Anime and make the player put all their Pokemon in the box and challenge the new region fresh.
            I think I covered everything that has been covered in this thread already, with a bit of additional explination, and things that weren't covered yet. Anyone, feel free to correct me on these points if I said something wrong.

            A Multi-Region game can be good IF you do it right, and put forth actual effort to balance it out. You just need to know where to draw the line on certain things. Will you develop a game in RPG Maker that encompasses the current Pokemon Regions? Realistically, no, you won't. It's impossible. Limitations in the RMXP Engine, the sheer number of maps, all sorts of technical issues would prevent it. But if you still want to try it, then go for it. If you succeed, you'll be the first to do so, and you may cause a breakthrough in the RMXP department for Pokemon Fangame Development.
            __________________
            Development Blog:
            For more information future news and updates to any projects, the following blogs are where I post information. You can usually hit me with a message there when it comes to bug reports or feedback, or general conversation about something.
            Game Projects:
            In Progress:
            Reply With Quote
              #6    
            Old July 11th, 2013 (3:10 PM). Edited July 11th, 2013 by war rock exe.
            war rock exe's Avatar
            war rock exe war rock exe is offline
            Pokemon Colosseum Remaker!!
               
              Join Date: Dec 2009
              Location: wouldn't you like to know?
              Age: 20
              Gender: Male
              Nature: Hardy
              Posts: 817
              Quote:
              Originally Posted by Maruno View Post
              There are so many maps in each region that it'd take many months to create them all. It would then take even longer to put events into them, and longer still to make it work as some kind of game rather than a Grand Tour (i.e. sight-seeing without a plot).

              The official games work just fine with one region each. Two regions in a game might be all right if you're good and/or the regions are small, but three is pushing it. You certainly couldn't fill more than 3 regions with a single story, and if your solution is to have several different stories (usually one per region), then they might as well be separate games with some recurring characters.

              Consider how many games here have just one region in them, and consider how many of them are actually being worked on rather than abandoned at conception, and then consider how much progress they have. Not much. To say that wanting all regions is ambitious is a gross understatement, and you're practically guaranteed to fail badly (I only say "practically" because it's technically not impossible to succeed, but it might as well be).

              Personally, I wouldn't want to see such a game anyway, even if it existed. I can just go play the official games if I wanted to retread all the regions. Such an idea reeks of unoriginality, and doesn't at all inspire me to play it because it wouldn't add anything new.
              I respect your opinion sir! I was thinking about that same thing as I went to bed! I also think that a difficulty would be very challenging because that's a lot of gyms, a lot of trainers, and a lot of battles... Maybe the player could just start over after every region

              Quote:
              Originally Posted by Derxwna Kapsyla View Post
              A game with every region is an idea long sought after mostly by two kinds of people:
              • A) Overly Ambitious People, whos projects die before they start
              • B) People developing an MMO, which is rather logical so they can have more of a world to explore.
              Though there have been cases where a person didn't fit either category.

              Limiting yourself is the key to a good game, knowing where to draw the line on what to add and what not to add. While the Developer does have total control over what they can do, restraint is a very good skill to learn in development. I speak with minor experience, personal and watching others work.

              The game I'm working on, Touhoumon Faith & Prayer Version, showcases 3 regions from Pokemon proper, and a separate region after that. Overly ambitious, but I have plans to make it work. I'd be working more on it right now if my computer wasn't broken, but I digress.

              There are things you need to keep in mind when even developing a Multi-Region game that encompasses 2+ Regions.
              • A) The number of maps. A traditional region has about 300+ maps if each map was its own map. Exteriors, Routes, Interiors, All of it sums together. If you were to make a 3 or more region game, you'd hit the Engine Imposed 999 Map Limit before you finished. If you need more than 1000 maps, you should perhaps look into either combining maps, or maybe cutting the project into two depending on how the plot works.
              • B) The length of the game. Your game better be more interesting than "Beat the 8 gyms and become a League Champion" for each region, otherwise it's going to get old. Fast. The plot also better not be a complete rehash of the original games plot. A person doesn't want to download a game where all it is is the combination of several non-plot related games when they could download the individual games themselves and play those. You also don't want it to drag on and on. and on.
              • C) Filesize. This is a large issue that gets easily overlooked if you're playing MP3 files for music. Your game's filesize will spike exponentially without you knowing it, and you'll wind up with a 1 region release that's 1 gig because the music is large. If 1 region ends up being 1 gig, imagine how bad 3 regions would be?
              • D) Leveling and Balance Scale. Using Generation II as an example, by the end of Johto, the player was usually around Level 45~55. At the end of Kanto, the player was usually around the level 65~85, sometimes even 100. If you were to add a third region to the mix, you'd be a 100 halfway through it. It'd be illogical to add a Fourth Region, because then everything would be at Level 100 across the region, and that would get really boring really fast. One method to resolve it would be bumping the maximum level up another hundred levels, but why would you honestly do that? You'd have to work to give the Pokemon additional movepools beyond Level 100, otherwise they'd have to work with what they have for the next 100 levels, and considering their movepools were designed to cap at 100, there wouldn't be much else you could do anyways. Another method is to, like Maruno said, split it into two games depending on Plot. Alternatively, find a creative, but good and perhaps "believable", method to lowering the levels of trainers back down to around 5 at the start of a new region. Hell, pull an Anime and make the player put all their Pokemon in the box and challenge the new region fresh.
              I think I covered everything that has been covered in this thread already, with a bit of additional explination, and things that weren't covered yet. Anyone, feel free to correct me on these points if I said something wrong.

              A Multi-Region game can be good IF you do it right, and put forth actual effort to balance it out. You just need to know where to draw the line on certain things. Will you develop a game in RPG Maker that encompasses the current Pokemon Regions? Realistically, no, you won't. It's impossible. Limitations in the RMXP Engine, the sheer number of maps, all sorts of technical issues would prevent it. But if you still want to try it, then go for it. If you succeed, you'll be the first to do so, and you may cause a breakthrough in the RMXP department for Pokemon Fangame Development.
              Thank you! Now I know that I must be aware/careful of certain things and situations! But you know, there's always hope!

              Quote:
              Originally Posted by RG8Gaming View Post
              I think a super long game that is a big accomplishment to complete would be nice.
              For example, we could do what Ash does with every region.
              Store the Pokemon in the Lab and move on to the next region with a fresh start.
              At least that's what I think he does.
              Just my thoughts.
              That could work bro! That way I could not have to worry about the difficulty every new region if the player starts over!

              Quote:
              Originally Posted by RG8Gaming View Post
              I think a super long game that is a big accomplishment to complete would be nice.
              For example, we could do what Ash does with every region.
              Store the Pokemon in the Lab and move on to the next region with a fresh start.
              At least that's what I think he does.
              Just my thoughts.
              Quote:
              Originally Posted by Luka S.J. View Post
              I tried an idea like that, and it is not as pleasant as it sounds. Apart from the heavy work load you get in terms of mapping, eventing, tiling, spriting, thinking (deciding new level caps as they are needed, then the addition of extra movesets past lv100 and such), you have the problem of not being very flexible with such a game. You have to stick to a certain formula, which gets boring after a while. You can't really reinvent the existing towns/routes/misc in terms of mapping (people would look for familiarity in such games). Also, you gotta use existing characters and don't have any freedom with those either. So yeah, as a dewd that tried it, I didn't really have too much fun doing it, hence why I stopped it.
              I do agree, it's not a pleasant job, but I do know that I have the opinion of creating and entirely different story that involved all of the current regions.
              __________________
              POKÈMON COLOSSEUM TRILOGY FOR RMXP!! COMING THIS SUMMER!
              STATUS; BETA 1 70%
              Reply With Quote
                #7    
              Old July 12th, 2013 (6:35 AM).
              Wootius's Avatar
              Wootius Wootius is offline
              Glah
                 
                Join Date: Mar 2013
                Gender: Male
                Posts: 306
                It's keeping the "momentum" of the game up for more then two regions that's the main problem. Changing leveling speed is easy or keeping the levelcap for the first few regions low like G/S/C is easy, but motivating the player to keep going would be the hardest part.

                I'd rather have two huge regions that are greatly fleshed out, with a side trip to somewhere else as a special event(like the Orange islands). Like what I plan to do with my game.
                __________________
                Pokemon Rebalanced: Red
                Where every Pokemon is useful.
                Reply With Quote
                  #8    
                Old July 12th, 2013 (7:42 AM).
                war rock exe's Avatar
                war rock exe war rock exe is offline
                Pokemon Colosseum Remaker!!
                   
                  Join Date: Dec 2009
                  Location: wouldn't you like to know?
                  Age: 20
                  Gender: Male
                  Nature: Hardy
                  Posts: 817
                  Quote:
                  Originally Posted by lauerolus View Post
                  It's keeping the "momentum" of the game up for more then two regions that's the main problem. Changing leveling speed is easy or keeping the levelcap for the first few regions low like G/S/C is easy, but motivating the player to keep going would be the hardest part.

                  I'd rather have two huge regions that are greatly fleshed out, with a side trip to somewhere else as a special event(like the Orange islands). Like what I plan to do with my game.
                  Yes that would be increasingly difficult! But maybe someone (or I) could get rid if that level 100 level cap that way you could keep leveling up your Pokemon!
                  __________________
                  POKÈMON COLOSSEUM TRILOGY FOR RMXP!! COMING THIS SUMMER!
                  STATUS; BETA 1 70%
                  Reply With Quote
                    #9    
                  Old July 12th, 2013 (9:08 AM).
                  Wootius's Avatar
                  Wootius Wootius is offline
                  Glah
                     
                    Join Date: Mar 2013
                    Gender: Male
                    Posts: 306
                    Quote:
                    Originally Posted by war rock exe View Post
                    Yes that would be increasingly difficult!
                    What's difficult? Changing leveling rates? That'd be elbow grease work and possibly a bit of it but it shouldn't be that hard. Expanding the total number of levels... that just invites more work then most people would like in everything you can think of. that's why it's not done.

                    Making an "expanded" two region game? I'd think if you have the ability to make a three plus region game, cutting it down to two and expanding those two or two plus a sidetrip regions would about the same amount of work.

                    Momentum? I'm cheating and reusing Gamefreak's work as a base, so I can't comment.
                    Reply With Quote
                      #10    
                    Old July 12th, 2013 (9:11 AM).
                    Derxwna Kapsyla's Avatar
                    Derxwna Kapsyla Derxwna Kapsyla is offline
                    [Primal Despair] Derxwna "The Badman" Kapsyla
                       
                      Join Date: Jun 2011
                      Location: Margate, FL
                      Age: 24
                      Gender: Male
                      Nature: Lax
                      Posts: 401
                      Getting rid of the level cap isn't the issue, it's keeping the players interested. You could bump the level cap to 999 and it wouldn't make a lick of difference if the players get bored of your game halfway through the second region. You need to keep things fresh and make them good. Removing the Level Cap isn't the best motivator, it just says "I changed this because I made my game needlessly long and you would have topped by 100".
                      __________________
                      Development Blog:
                      For more information future news and updates to any projects, the following blogs are where I post information. You can usually hit me with a message there when it comes to bug reports or feedback, or general conversation about something.
                      Game Projects:
                      In Progress:
                      Reply With Quote
                        #11    
                      Old July 12th, 2013 (9:16 AM).
                      Zylas's Avatar
                      Zylas Zylas is offline
                      Dat Trains Kid
                         
                        Join Date: Jun 2013
                        Location: Chuggington
                        Gender: Male
                        Nature: Docile
                        Posts: 84
                        I think a game like this would be amazing if you followed the plot line sort of like Ash. Ash adventures to ALL of the regions does he not? Plus the plot is quite interesting. So maybe relating it to the anime would make it a lot easier to develop a game such as this. Heck, Skyrim (if any of you have heard of this game) has way more content than if a Pokemon game with all the regions would be created. So why can't Nintendo do the same?
                        __________________

                        |Black 2 FC| Best Song EVER|
                        |Platinum FC| Mah KI:U Neoseeker|
                        |Old Profile|VM|PM|Credit|


                        For an innovative, innocent, young boy once said, "I like trains."
                        Reply With Quote
                          #12    
                        Old July 12th, 2013 (11:54 AM).
                        Nickalooose Nickalooose is offline
                        --------------------
                           
                          Join Date: Mar 2008
                          Gender: Female
                          Posts: 1,309
                          My older game had 3.5 regions fully created events, encounters, trainer battles, item balls, story etc etc... It's not hard, but long... If you have consistency, creativity and the will power, you can do it.

                          Personally, if you have the ideas and motivation to pull off these ideas, why not try... You can only have a go after-all.

                          Not trying = negativity and negativity = failure.

                          Imagine if Usain Bolt thought he couldn't break a record because it's impractical or he thinks he's too tall or whatever... (off topic but the same concept).

                          I say go for it, fail if needed, but in any weather, if you fail to make Johto, but have finished Kanto, guess what... You can build a smaller game with your Kanto region already been made, dadaaa.

                          I think a game with all regions would be fantastic... I would ask you these questions however; and with these answers:

                          Have you been in production long... Yes
                          Do you have school/college or any other education... No
                          Are you in full time employment be it 25 hours or more... No
                          Are you consistant (don't give up at the first bump in the road)... Yes
                          Do you get jobs done or do you prefer to divide your time between other bits and bobs... I get the job done
                          Are you serious... Yes

                          If your answers are not the same or are slight variations, I wouldn't try creating a game this big. (obviously there's more to the questions but you get the general idea)
                          Reply With Quote
                            #13    
                          Old July 13th, 2013 (1:50 AM).
                          BlackWaltz3's Avatar
                          BlackWaltz3 BlackWaltz3 is offline
                             
                            Join Date: Jul 2009
                            Gender: Male
                            Posts: 188
                            Quote:
                            Originally Posted by Zylas View Post
                            Heck, Skyrim (if any of you have heard of this game) has way more content than if a Pokemon game with all the regions would be created. So why can't Nintendo do the same?
                            I think the vast majority of players, myself included, would much prefer a game of quality rather than quantity. Yes, Skyrim may have a lot of content. But what is the point if there are one thousand of exactly the same quest with a few verbs and nouns changed? You may as well name the quests "Generic Fetch Quest 1", "Generic Fetch Quest 2" and so on.

                            This goes for regions. I would much rather one incredibly detailed, fleshed out region than several that, no matter how much work will be put into them, will inevitably become decreasingly fresh and original as you traverse them. It is for this reason that I do not understand the seemingly widespread desire for such a game. But, I guess kids will be kids, and fantasies will remain fantasies.
                            Reply With Quote
                              #14    
                            Old July 13th, 2013 (3:39 AM). Edited July 13th, 2013 by Mugendai.
                            Mugendai's Avatar
                            Mugendai Mugendai is offline
                            Glitchologist
                               
                              Join Date: Jun 2010
                              Posts: 11
                              Ignoring the fact that it would be considerably harder for Bethesda to do so, there is a reason they wouldn't make a single-player Elder Scrolls game encompassing all of Tamriel. There's already enough to do and explore in a TES game that a lot of players would probably just get tired of playing after exploring a couple of regions.

                              The same issue would apply to a Pokemon game encompassing most or all of the regions. You would have to figure out how to make exploring enjoyable. I had the over-ambitious idea of an "open-world" sandbox-style Pokemon fangame, but I'm not entirely sure how one would make it worth visiting all 7 regions.
                              Reply With Quote
                                #15    
                              Old July 13th, 2013 (12:41 PM).
                              ChaosLord's Avatar
                              ChaosLord ChaosLord is offline
                              Game Dev Wanderer
                                 
                                Join Date: Nov 2010
                                Gender: Male
                                Nature: Bold
                                Posts: 58
                                Yeah, I really think you should just pick another project if you want to pass that class of yours. Obviously, from all of these comments, making a Pokemon game takes lots of time and work. So, unless you're actually able to work with a few people you know in your area rather than depending on people online and the recruitment thread, might as well work on something else for that grade.
                                Reply With Quote
                                  #16    
                                Old July 17th, 2013 (6:04 AM).
                                BlueMudkipz's Avatar
                                BlueMudkipz BlueMudkipz is offline
                                Blu
                                   
                                  Join Date: Jul 2013
                                  Location: Texas
                                  Gender: Male
                                  Nature: Rash
                                  Posts: 36
                                  It can be done over a long time, most likely a few months.

                                  But yes I think it would be really interesting, having all the regions would make for a really fun and long adventure. I have seen some ROM hacks that have had more than their regions pokemon, and i find it really interesting to see it on a Gameboy Advance or Gameboy game!

                                  ~blu
                                  __________________
                                  Find a place inside where there is joy, and the joy will burn out the pain.

                                  ~Robert Louis Stevenson
                                  Reply With Quote
                                    #17    
                                  Old July 17th, 2013 (9:38 AM).
                                  Derxwna Kapsyla's Avatar
                                  Derxwna Kapsyla Derxwna Kapsyla is offline
                                  [Primal Despair] Derxwna "The Badman" Kapsyla
                                     
                                    Join Date: Jun 2011
                                    Location: Margate, FL
                                    Age: 24
                                    Gender: Male
                                    Nature: Lax
                                    Posts: 401
                                    Quote:
                                    Originally Posted by BlueMudkipz View Post
                                    It can be done over a long time, most likely a few months.

                                    But yes I think it would be really interesting, having all the regions would make for a really fun and long adventure. I have seen some ROM hacks that have had more than their regions pokemon, and i find it really interesting to see it on a Gameboy Advance or Gameboy game!

                                    ~blu
                                    I think you severely underestimate exactly how much work it is that needs to be put into a project. You're saying a few months for every region - that could be true, if you had a large team with multiple people working on different regions at the same time. If you have one developer working on it, it'll take that time and expand on it massively. Even my project has taken almost a full year to get where it is today, and that's not even halfway through the first region (Granted, things will pick back up when I get my new computer, but that's besides the point). To make a game with all the regions, looking way beyond the Limitations of Pokemon Essentials, would take you a year, maybe 3, maybe even more, to do, if you do it right and don't rush it.
                                    __________________
                                    Development Blog:
                                    For more information future news and updates to any projects, the following blogs are where I post information. You can usually hit me with a message there when it comes to bug reports or feedback, or general conversation about something.
                                    Game Projects:
                                    In Progress:
                                    Reply With Quote
                                      #18    
                                    Old July 19th, 2013 (7:06 PM).
                                    th3shark's Avatar
                                    th3shark th3shark is offline
                                    Develops in AS3/C++
                                       
                                      Join Date: Jul 2013
                                      Location: Connecticut
                                      Gender: Male
                                      Nature: Calm
                                      Posts: 79
                                      I've tried my hand at developing games for a year or two now, and all I can say is that projects will take at least 10x longer to complete than you think. Having aspirations is great, but if you don't set realistic goals your game will never be finished. Trust me, I've had so many projects wither away because of lofty expectations.
                                      __________________
                                      Reply With Quote
                                        #19    
                                      Old July 20th, 2013 (11:36 PM).
                                      Arma's Avatar
                                      Arma Arma is offline
                                      The Hyena
                                      • Silver Tier
                                       
                                      Join Date: Dec 2009
                                      Location: The Hague
                                      Age: 24
                                      Gender: Male
                                      Nature: Jolly
                                      Posts: 1,459
                                      I voted no some time ago, don't know why I haven't replied yet.

                                      Anyway, I don't like fan games using the official regions, let alone all of them. You'll never be able to finish it (and actually end with a decent game, that is) let's say that a region has around 20 towns, that would mean a game with all regions would have over 100 towns... how would you fit all that in a story? What story and which features can you come up with to not make any place not just a place where you can recover your team and battle the gym leader? Most games, including the original ones, even have trouble with just one region...

                                      Before you start out working on it, rry to write a proper design document (This goes for all game developers! )

                                      I would just create a game with a new region, which contains my favorite pokemon from all the other regions...
                                      __________________
                                      Reply With Quote
                                        #20    
                                      Old July 22nd, 2013 (11:28 AM).
                                      Worldslayer608's Avatar
                                      Worldslayer608 Worldslayer608 is offline
                                      ಥдಥ
                                      • Silver Tier
                                       
                                      Join Date: Mar 2008
                                      Location: San Diego
                                      Age: 28
                                      Gender: Male
                                      Nature: Calm
                                      Posts: 892
                                      I like the idea of all regions, however I do not like them blending into a single plot and I do not like them all having the same repetitive Gym scenario.

                                      Instead, I like them to add their own plot to the overall game. It is a **** ton of work though.
                                      __________________



                                      SMEARGLE SOLO CHALLENGE
                                      HARDCORE EDITION
                                      To vanquish without peril is to triumph without glory...
                                      Voted Best Game Designer 2011 on PC
                                      Reply With Quote
                                        #21    
                                      Old July 23rd, 2013 (12:55 AM).
                                      Catcher6's Avatar
                                      Catcher6 Catcher6 is offline
                                      Forio's Finest
                                         
                                        Join Date: Jun 2013
                                        Location: Island of Ischia
                                        Gender: Male
                                        Posts: 6
                                        Why not? I like the idea ,but I think it will take too much time!
                                        Reply With Quote
                                          #22    
                                        Old July 28th, 2013 (11:28 AM).
                                        FL's Avatar
                                        FL FL is offline
                                        Pokémon Island Creator
                                           
                                          Join Date: Sep 2010
                                          Gender: Male
                                          Posts: 1,719
                                          I believe that is possible to make a good game with 10 regions, but only an exceptional dev team may succeed this. Read more in my older post. I've seen playable games with 4 regions.

                                          Quote:
                                          Originally Posted by Derxwna Kapsyla View Post
                                          Spoiler:
                                          A game with every region is an idea long sought after mostly by two kinds of people:
                                          • A) Overly Ambitious People, whos projects die before they start
                                          • B) People developing an MMO, which is rather logical so they can have more of a world to explore.
                                          Though there have been cases where a person didn't fit either category.

                                          Limiting yourself is the key to a good game, knowing where to draw the line on what to add and what not to add. While the Developer does have total control over what they can do, restraint is a very good skill to learn in development. I speak with minor experience, personal and watching others work.

                                          The game I'm working on, Touhoumon Faith & Prayer Version, showcases 3 regions from Pokemon proper, and a separate region after that. Overly ambitious, but I have plans to make it work. I'd be working more on it right now if my computer wasn't broken, but I digress.

                                          There are things you need to keep in mind when even developing a Multi-Region game that encompasses 2+ Regions.
                                          • A) The number of maps. A traditional region has about 300+ maps if each map was its own map. Exteriors, Routes, Interiors, All of it sums together. If you were to make a 3 or more region game, you'd hit the Engine Imposed 999 Map Limit before you finished. If you need more than 1000 maps, you should perhaps look into either combining maps, or maybe cutting the project into two depending on how the plot works.
                                          • B) The length of the game. Your game better be more interesting than "Beat the 8 gyms and become a League Champion" for each region, otherwise it's going to get old. Fast. The plot also better not be a complete rehash of the original games plot. A person doesn't want to download a game where all it is is the combination of several non-plot related games when they could download the individual games themselves and play those. You also don't want it to drag on and on. and on.
                                          • C) Filesize. This is a large issue that gets easily overlooked if you're playing MP3 files for music. Your game's filesize will spike exponentially without you knowing it, and you'll wind up with a 1 region release that's 1 gig because the music is large. If 1 region ends up being 1 gig, imagine how bad 3 regions would be?
                                          • D) Leveling and Balance Scale. Using Generation II as an example, by the end of Johto, the player was usually around Level 45~55. At the end of Kanto, the player was usually around the level 65~85, sometimes even 100. If you were to add a third region to the mix, you'd be a 100 halfway through it. It'd be illogical to add a Fourth Region, because then everything would be at Level 100 across the region, and that would get really boring really fast. One method to resolve it would be bumping the maximum level up another hundred levels, but why would you honestly do that? You'd have to work to give the Pokemon additional movepools beyond Level 100, otherwise they'd have to work with what they have for the next 100 levels, and considering their movepools were designed to cap at 100, there wouldn't be much else you could do anyways. Another method is to, like Maruno said, split it into two games depending on Plot. Alternatively, find a creative, but good and perhaps "believable", method to lowering the levels of trainers back down to around 5 at the start of a new region. Hell, pull an Anime and make the player put all their Pokemon in the box and challenge the new region fresh.
                                          I think I covered everything that has been covered in this thread already, with a bit of additional explination, and things that weren't covered yet. Anyone, feel free to correct me on these points if I said something wrong.

                                          A Multi-Region game can be good IF you do it right, and put forth actual effort to balance it out. You just need to know where to draw the line on certain things. Will you develop a game in RPG Maker that encompasses the current Pokemon Regions? Realistically, no, you won't. It's impossible. Limitations in the RMXP Engine, the sheer number of maps, all sorts of technical issues would prevent it. But if you still want to try it, then go for it. If you succeed, you'll be the first to do so, and you may cause a breakthrough in the RMXP department for Pokemon Fangame Development.
                                          • A) Combination of maps solve around of 80% of this problem. Remembers that GSC Kanto have around of 35% the size of RBY Kanto.
                                          • B) A good developer can think in something to make the plot more interesting, probably without following the GYM formula in every region.
                                          • C) Animated battlers and MP3 that make the filesize large. Without these things, every region probably adds to the filesize less that 10 MB.
                                          • D) You can put less trainers or even cut the exp gain by half.

                                          Quote:
                                          Originally Posted by th3shark View Post
                                          I've tried my hand at developing games for a year or two now, and all I can say is that projects will take at least 10x longer to complete than you think. Having aspirations is great, but if you don't set realistic goals your game will never be finished. Trust me, I've had so many projects wither away because of lofty expectations.
                                          The first game that I completed in RPG Maker I spent 4x the time that I first thought that I will spend. A game with Essentials is even more complex! To new devs: start slowly like I said in my guide.
                                          __________________
                                          Reply With Quote
                                            #23    
                                          Old August 1st, 2013 (9:52 PM).
                                          Sundragon's Avatar
                                          Sundragon Sundragon is offline
                                             
                                            Join Date: Jun 2011
                                            Gender: Male
                                            Posts: 33
                                            It would become pretty boring after playing the same game. And I think it might be tough to create such a story plus the game wont keep players that intrested.
                                            __________________
                                            This signature has been disabled.
                                            Exceeds signature width limit.
                                            Please review and fix the issues by reading the signature rules.

                                            You must edit it to meet the limits set by the rules before you may remove the [sig-reason] code from your signature. Removing this tag will re-enable it.

                                            Do not remove the tag until you fix the issues in your signature. You may be infracted for removing this tag if you do not fix the specified issues. Do not use this tag for decoration purposes.
                                            Reply With Quote
                                              #24    
                                            Old August 2nd, 2013 (3:47 PM).
                                            Crimson Hunter's Avatar
                                            Crimson Hunter Crimson Hunter is offline
                                            Pichu lover <3
                                               
                                              Join Date: Aug 2013
                                              Location: Pallet town
                                              Gender: Male
                                              Nature: Adamant
                                              Posts: 5
                                              Sounds Epic to me if u have the skillz why not?
                                              Reply With Quote
                                                #25    
                                              Old August 2nd, 2013 (6:49 PM).
                                              oxysoft's Avatar
                                              oxysoft oxysoft is offline
                                                 
                                                Join Date: Sep 2009
                                                Posts: 99
                                                If you add more than one region, make it so you travel from one region to another more multiple times in your adventure, don't make it like "Ok, Kanto's done, now we move on to Hoenn." That's just boring and stupid, make it so you travel back and forth and access new locations depending on the plot and storyline.
                                                __________________
                                                PokeSharp Engine
                                                Reply With Quote
                                                Reply

                                                Quick Reply

                                                Join the conversation!

                                                Create an account to post a reply in this thread, participate in other discussions, and more!

                                                Create a PokéCommunity Account

                                                Sponsored Links
                                                Thread Tools

                                                Posting Rules
                                                You may not post new threads
                                                You may not post replies
                                                You may not post attachments
                                                You may not edit your posts

                                                BB code is On
                                                Smilies are On
                                                [IMG] code is On
                                                HTML code is Off

                                                Forum Jump


                                                All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:47 PM.