Game Development Your number one stop for anything related to creating games (except ROM hacks). You can even make your own!

View Poll Results: Is having new Pokémon in a remake bad? (Ex. Wingull in Kanto)
Yes, it is bad! 3 12.50%
I am fine, either way. 10 41.67%
No, it makes the game better! 10 41.67%
Other? (Comment) 1 4.17%
Voters: 24. You may not vote on this poll

Thread Tools
Old August 20th, 2013 (6:49 AM).
tImE's Avatar
tImE tImE is offline
It's still me, 44tim44 ;)
    Join Date: Mar 2007
    Location: Somewhere in Scandinavia...
    Nature: Relaxed
    Posts: 689
    Hello, I am currently developing a remake/retelling of RBGY/FRLG, and I'm wondering what the general consensus is on how much liberty the developer can take when making a game, and still being able to call it a remake.

    The biggest point/problem is the fact that I am considering adding Pokémon from outside the 151 first.
    This is mostly due to the fact that it'd be weird to "ban" some pre-/evolutions, such as Glaceon and Pichu, just because they are from the wrong generation. At the same time, it feels like I could make the world itself so much better, by adding Wingulls in the ocean to compliment the Tentacools, and so on.

    My question is, do people, in general, think, doing things like this is good or bad for the game?
    Does it make it better, or does it ruin it?
    Reply With Quote

    Relevant Advertising!

    Old August 20th, 2013 (7:39 AM).
    Rayquaza.'s Avatar
    Rayquaza. Rayquaza. is offline
    Lead Dev in Pokémon Chaos
      Join Date: Sep 2011
      Location: United Kingdom
      Age: 21
      Gender: Male
      Nature: Adamant
      Posts: 690
      In my opinion I don't think that remakes need to be that strict. But what matters is how true to the original games you make it. For instance; HGSS was a remake of GS but was set two years after.

      From what I've seen of this game your mapping is amazing and the idea of adding up to Gen V Pokémon is not a bad idea if you want the game to be a little "up-to-date".
      If you don't end up adding Pokémon up to Gen V at least add Gen V evolutions of the Gen I Pokémon like GF did for HGSS.
      Reply With Quote
      Old August 20th, 2013 (7:55 AM).
      Fernando Torres's Avatar
      Fernando Torres Fernando Torres is offline
      Class on grass
      • Crystal Tier
      Join Date: Feb 2013
      Gender: Male
      Nature: Jolly
      Posts: 162
      I believe that having other Pokémon in remakes isn't a bad idea. It brings out variety in the game bringing new team combinations to the table every play through.
      Reply With Quote
      Old August 20th, 2013 (7:56 AM).
      Corvus of the Black Night's Avatar
      Corvus of the Black Night Corvus of the Black Night is offline
      Wild Duck Pokémon
      • Gold Tier
      • Gold Tier
      Join Date: Feb 2009
      Location: With the Birds
      Age: 24
      Gender: Other
      Nature: Impish
      Posts: 3,429
      It's really all up to you. I'm also recreating R/B/Y and I'm using things from all the generations. It really depends on what your final plan is - I plan to extend the game across all generations, so having it utilize certain calculations now saves me the trouble later. If you want to make a loyal port, go ahead, but R/B/Y is broken as all hell.

      I mean, FR/LG added 7 new islands, all sorts of changes, and things like that, and HG/SS actually had a safari zone and several areas that didn't exist in the previous games, as well as a hecka lot of new functions, so do what you think is a good idea.
      Reply With Quote
      Old August 20th, 2013 (9:03 AM).
      Wootius's Avatar
      Wootius Wootius is offline
        Join Date: Mar 2013
        Gender: Male
        Posts: 306
        More pokemon is cool, as long as they don't "take over". I keep about 50-70% of the pokemon Gen I/II in my game and sprinkle in other pokemon that fit around them. I've also added pokemon to towns and given each one a "mascot", like Dwebble for Pewter City.

        Some things I've cycled pretty quickly, like starting birds, just to give everyone a chance at their favorite one right at the start.
        Pokemon Rebalanced: Red
        Where every Pokemon is useful.
        Reply With Quote
        Old August 20th, 2013 (10:02 AM).
        Maruno's Avatar
        Maruno Maruno is offline
        Lead Dev of Pokémon Essentials
          Join Date: Jan 2008
          Location: England
          Posts: 5,189
          You shouldn't feel restricted by the original games when you make your remake, nor should you feel restricted by what later games have added (i.e. new evolutions, moves, etc.). For example, you can completely exclude Magmortar from your game if you want to, or add Wingull or change where other Pokémon are encountered.

          I think the ultimate point is that you want to make a remake, which involves the same location/progression/story as the original. You can tweak these things, sure (such as the Kimono Girls doing something in HGSS), but overall you're trying to recreate the original game as a whole, not just make a new game set in an existing region, so you probably shouldn't make drastic changes to the formula.

          You should definitely not overdo the extra stuff, though, because that'll change the focus of the game by shifting attention away from the main plot. Keep much of it for the "postgame" (as stupid an idea as that is for fangames), and make the rest more subtle and/or try to incorporate it into the main game.

          For example, obtaining a Porygon can be seen as a side-quest (part of the "complete the Dex" thing, which I still believe should be a thing), yet the process of obtaining it is completely below the radar (get enough coins in the slot machines). The Safari Zone is a more blatant side-quest, but the plot itself forces you all the way through it to obtain an HM and a key item (for another HM), which mostly disguises the fact that the side-quest exists at all by treating it as a dungeon with a goal which you've accomplished.

          I'm reminded of what was probably the Shiny Gold hack which I briefly played. Two things in that stand out to me: more rivals and more gifts of Pokémon (usually the starters from other games). The rivals thing should have actually been called "more recurring characters", and they were quite random and felt pretty forced. The gifted Pokémon thing made a big deal out of gaining whichever Pokémon they were handing out, which also felt bad. Both of these features were too blatant for their own good.

          Feel free to redesign dungeon maps, though. It'll be boring if we already know exactly how to get through the various caves (and Safari Zone).
          Go to the Pokémon Essentials Wiki

          | Downloads | Tutorials | Fangames |
          | All Animations Project |

          Follow me on Twitter: @maruno42

          Reply With Quote
          Old August 20th, 2013 (11:08 AM).
          tImE's Avatar
          tImE tImE is offline
          It's still me, 44tim44 ;)
            Join Date: Mar 2007
            Location: Somewhere in Scandinavia...
            Nature: Relaxed
            Posts: 689
            Thanks for the great comments, guys!

            I feel a lot more confident in moving forward now.
            I'll do my best to stay true to the originals while still having fresh content and adding my own twist to things.

            My game will probably show up in one of the showcases soon, and if you notice I've strayed too far from the path by then, be sure to give me a shout!

            And, I've actually planned on redesigning most of the gyms and the dungeons I feel are outdated or don't make sense! Some of them will stay true to the originals though.

            Thanks for the help! :D
            Reply With Quote
            Old August 20th, 2013 (12:38 PM).
            joeyhugg's Avatar
            joeyhugg joeyhugg is offline
              Join Date: Apr 2013
              Gender: Male
              Posts: 384
              If you stay to true to the original, people would rather play the original than play your game. I say, go for it!
              This signature has been disabled.
              Signature exceeds height limit.
              Please review and fix the issues by reading the signature rules.

              You must edit it to meet the limits set by the rules before you may remove the [sig-reason] code from your signature. Removing this tag will re-enable it.

              Do not remove the tag until you fix the issues in your signature. You may be infracted for removing this tag if you do not fix the specified issues. Do not use this tag for decoration purposes.
              Reply With Quote
              Old August 20th, 2013 (3:49 PM).
              FL's Avatar
              FL FL is offline
              Pokémon Island Creator
                Join Date: Sep 2010
                Gender: Male
                Posts: 1,722
                I prefer the ones with new content (like Sevii Islands in FrLg and some evolutions in HgSs). I really prefer to have all these evolutions. Maybe some few other pokémon like Wingull (I suggest the Pokégear sound and swarm ones). This will be even better if these pokémon can be caught, but aren't in the regional dexes.

                Only limit to very few or none trainer use these "new pokémon".
                Reply With Quote
                Old August 20th, 2013 (4:39 PM).
                ImBlue's Avatar
                ImBlue ImBlue is offline
                  Join Date: Aug 2013
                  Location: Texas
                  Gender: Male
                  Nature: Quiet
                  Posts: 66
                  One of the biggest complaints about old games is the lack of variety of Pokemon in some areas (see Eastern Hoenn Region with pretty much just Wingull and Tentacool). Adding a few more Pokemon, but not too many, in my opinion makes it feel much more like an interesting, modern game and less like just the same game with new graphics.
                  Reply With Quote
                  Old August 22nd, 2013 (3:07 AM).
                  UnderMybrella's Avatar
                  UnderMybrella UnderMybrella is offline
                  Some Programmer
                    Join Date: Jan 2011
                    Location: Australia
                    Gender: Other
                    Nature: Calm
                    Posts: 280
                    As ImBlue said, use the new Pokemon and content to spruce up the game, give it something just a little different, while keeping the old game we all know and love
                    Reply With Quote
                    Old August 26th, 2013 (3:11 PM).
                    Ben.'s Avatar
                    Ben. Ben. is offline
                    Orange I s l a n d s~
                    • Silver Tier
                    Join Date: Jun 2009
                    Location: England
                    Age: 21
                    Gender: Male
                    Nature: Quirky
                    Posts: 626
                    There is a balance which is quite hard to get when remaking a game but I'll give my opinion on how a game should be remade. It needs to have a balance of what made the game great in the first place & making and improving the game to make it feel you're having the experience of playing a new game. HGSS In my opinion did a fantastic job with this, basing your game and how they've improved and remade things is not a bad idea in the slightest.
                    What I like to see from remakes is more of a fresh new game where you can still get the same feelings as playing the original, like you're playing and reliving the experience but not just replaying them game.
                    In the end of the day it's your game, if you make a great remake people will play it.

                    Reply With Quote

                    Quick Reply

                    Join the conversation!

                    Create an account to post a reply in this thread, participate in other discussions, and more!

                    Create a PokéCommunity Account

                    Sponsored Links
                    Thread Tools

                    Posting Rules
                    You may not post new threads
                    You may not post replies
                    You may not post attachments
                    You may not edit your posts

                    BB code is On
                    Smilies are On
                    [IMG] code is On
                    HTML code is Off

                    Forum Jump

                    All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:12 PM.