Quote:
Originally Posted by Fairy
I think you need to grow up a little more and learn to empathize and articulate. To me, it sounds like they care about you a lot and you take every amount of discipline as abuse. If your dad says you’ve been on the Xbox all day, it’s probably hyperbole, but he sets these limitations because he wants you to succeed. And if he knows you’re on your phone during class, maybe you do need to spend some extra time studying and not online, yeah? This may come as a surprise but well functioning and mindful parents don’t do things completely arbitrarily (yes, there are exceptions).
No, it’s not okay for him to threaten you. It’s not okay for him to hit you. But it’s not okay for you to be an indignant little smart ass either. This is just an awkward phase for both of you - where you're becoming a young adult with the priorities of a child and he’s trying to parent someone who he perceives should be more self sufficient. When the time comes and you have a more worldly view, you’ll realize what actual abuse is versus what what you’re going through, which seems to me like pretty fair and reasonable parenting highlighted by moments of intense frustration and near physicality because both sides think they’re right. Which isn’t okay, of course, but it takes two, know what I mean?
If you want advice, I’d say talk to him like a damn human being with honesty and respect. Ask him if it’s a good time, preferably not during conflict, and just outright tell him that you feel scared to tell him anything because your afraid he’ll overreact or get violent. Have a proper father-son sit down and work your muk out like adults. If you start to behave like you’re not a petulant child, he might stop treating you like one.
I don't mean this to come off as insulting and I really don’t want to pretend like I know anything in detail about your family dynamic. But from everything you’ve said here I think you’re just *young* in mind and spirit. Let your parents do their job.
|
See, I agree with your general message. He's choosing many of the wrong things to focus on because he hasn't grown enough to reflect on what's really psyducked up and what is down to being an imperfect parent. I think that's a fine thing to get across.
it's not unwarranted. Flame, your focus on the minutiae of Xbox/gaming/etc restrictions is rather immature and betrays the overall message you want people to understand. It comes off like you are more concerned about the restrictions placed on you than trying to understand why they're there in the first place, and you seem unwilling to adapt. It's not the thing to be hung up on here, despite your relative youth.
However: while I think Flame has a lot of growing up to do, I think a point that has been missed is that he has said that his
mother is looking for a new residence in order to escape the attitudes and physical reactions of his father. The point of being threatened with physical retribution cannot be lost when we explain why it's immature to solely be focused on getting back on one's various consoles.
Quote:
Since October of last year, my mom has been looking at places to move to, so we can get away from him but she hasnt actually found a good place yet.
|
Now, while I think Flame is somewhat of an unreliable narrator, that point backs up that there's a direr situation that we might think. There's something to be said when the mother has decided that she needs to find a new location because the father's style of parenting, style of cohabiting with his supposedly cherished family, is dangerous on some level. Evidently there's an abusive atmosphere of some level that the other primary parent recognises, and I think the idea of sitting down and talking to the father, trying to reason with him, doesn't work if he's seemingly past the point of rationality.
And I completely understand Flame's inability to work with/relate to the guy if this is the situation. Darling, what might be better is taking this advice as... a method of coping. I seriously doubt you will be able to build a bridge and if the abusive atmosphere is real, which I believe, I don't think it's the right thing to do. However, Fairy has a point: if you are currently stuck in this situation, it's basic safety and pragmatism to learn how to deal with abusive behaviour for your own safety until you can free yourself. Learning how to understand your father doesn't mean you have to agree with him on anything, it means you're emotionally growing and learning how to reject abusive behaviour without setting it off - until you and your mother are able to stand on your own.
Edit: I should say that as someone who grew up in an extremely abusive household, I totally understand the apprehension inherent in this discussion. Just be sure to not direct your anger on those trying to help you.