Charlie and the Ice Cream Factory - Froyo wins!
- Thread starter Charlie Brown
- Start date
Aha, so Abby was the Lemon Sorbet, which means Abby was tailored. Notice how only N0 had a role revealed?
This is going to be a good read when I wake up...I'm tired now, so I'm heading to bed. I think we just about have found the Froyos as well, so I feel tonight a lot has been accomplished.
This is going to be a good read when I wake up...I'm tired now, so I'm heading to bed. I think we just about have found the Froyos as well, so I feel tonight a lot has been accomplished.
Last edited:
Ho-Oh
used Sacred Fire!
- 35,992
- Posts
- 18
- Years
- Age 31
- Seen Jul 1, 2023
OK.
Tonight we lynch Bidoof.
JD - kill EMS as he's trying to push me as CL REALLY heavily.
If EMS is indeed cult leader that means that the above is right... that Abby was tailored n0 which means Nakazumi wasn't tailored n0 which means he is mafia.
Tonight we lynch Bidoof.
JD - kill EMS as he's trying to push me as CL REALLY heavily.
If EMS is indeed cult leader that means that the above is right... that Abby was tailored n0 which means Nakazumi wasn't tailored n0 which means he is mafia.
Miah
╮( ^ ∇ ^")╭
- 4,380
- Posts
- 10
- Years
- Route 38, Johto
- Seen Aug 16, 2023
Cast List, compiled with the claims I believe
These may be the potentional
5 mafia
1. Kitty
2. Nakuzami
3. L'Belle
4. BidoofFTW
5. Nick Wilde
and 4 cult
1. Kitty
2. L'Belle
3. Nakuzami
4. Lycanthropy
Since Naku claimed Rum and Raisinand no one's counterclaimed yet, and he was not a good cream in my report, he was probably culted N0? Neon Sword's new and probably doesn't know a lot of people, I thought he wouldn't be the cult leader and that would be Lycan. Though it's possible for Neon to be the actual cult leader, idrk I'm using metadata
I'm honestly not sure about who are in the cult
Spoiler:
These may be the potentional
5 mafia
1. Kitty
2. Nakuzami
3. L'Belle
4. BidoofFTW
5. Nick Wilde
and 4 cult
1. Kitty
2. L'Belle
3. Nakuzami
4. Lycanthropy
Since Naku claimed Rum and Raisin
I'm honestly not sure about who are in the cult
Last edited:
Lycanthropy
[cd=font-family:Special Elite;font-size:16px;color
- 11,037
- Posts
- 10
- Years
- Age 27
- Clan of Fools, Waterdeep
- Seen Aug 20, 2023
Hi, quick post from mobile. (Will share more after I gave everything a good read.)
Anyways, hi I'm Pistachio/granny. Well granny-ish, I kill whoever visits me but I don't think I'm immune to night kills.
Anyways, hi I'm Pistachio/granny. Well granny-ish, I kill whoever visits me but I don't think I'm immune to night kills.
L'Belle
I am beauty!
- 2,175
- Posts
- 8
- Years
- Age 22
- The Netherlands
- Seen Dec 30, 2022
Nice list, Miah. Unfortunatly, it is wrong.
Wouldn't that make it a not nice list?
Also I apparently missed a lot. Cult should be a good priority, but I think going after Doof today is our best course of action right now.
L'Belle
I am beauty!
- 2,175
- Posts
- 8
- Years
- Age 22
- The Netherlands
- Seen Dec 30, 2022
I guess so huh!
Vragon2.0
Say it with me (Vray-gun)
- 420
- Posts
- 6
- Years
- Age 29
- As if I'd be one to say
- Seen Feb 19, 2024
care to share, why it's wrong?
Lycanthropy
[cd=font-family:Special Elite;font-size:16px;color
- 11,037
- Posts
- 10
- Years
- Age 27
- Clan of Fools, Waterdeep
- Seen Aug 20, 2023
Okay, so after a thorough read, I think Ho-Oh could likely be the cult leader. Syn has claimed Lemon Sorbet without counterclaim. It's impossible for the Oracle to be dead and tailored, or we would all have received some information from him. We didn't, so the claim is pretty much sound.
From this logic, Vragon is a cultist. That clears Kitty and L'Belle as Cream and Cookies.
As for the two cop claims, why are we even assuming either one is a real cop? All we know is that GP/Choc Mint 1 died, so either Doof or Miah is lying, yes. But that doesn't mean the other is telling the truth. Both are very quick to jump to the conclusion that they are.
Personally, I believe both Tails's and Naku's claims. Both have been giving me town vibes for a while. A lack of counterclaims on either of their roles pretty much confirms them as inno at this point.
Therefore, I think Doof is maf and Miah is either the false cop or the a culted cop that's trying to set the game to their hand. Though it might as well be the other way around.
Also, obviously Miah is mistaken in her list. Had I been culted, I would have killed the cult leader and we wouldn't have this whole cult problem right now.
From this logic, Vragon is a cultist. That clears Kitty and L'Belle as Cream and Cookies.
As for the two cop claims, why are we even assuming either one is a real cop? All we know is that GP/Choc Mint 1 died, so either Doof or Miah is lying, yes. But that doesn't mean the other is telling the truth. Both are very quick to jump to the conclusion that they are.
Personally, I believe both Tails's and Naku's claims. Both have been giving me town vibes for a while. A lack of counterclaims on either of their roles pretty much confirms them as inno at this point.
Therefore, I think Doof is maf and Miah is either the false cop or the a culted cop that's trying to set the game to their hand. Though it might as well be the other way around.
Also, obviously Miah is mistaken in her list. Had I been culted, I would have killed the cult leader and we wouldn't have this whole cult problem right now.
L'Belle
I am beauty!
- 2,175
- Posts
- 8
- Years
- Age 22
- The Netherlands
- Seen Dec 30, 2022
I'm not cultist'/maf. Simple huh?
Actually, I claim Abby as the Lemon Sorbet, not EMS. Does anyone even pay attention to what happened on Night 0? That was the only night a role was mentioned.
"The two Choc Mints went about their investigations, like the know-it-alls they are. They were like two scoops in a cone, even though they never spoke to each other. It was kinda cute! Customers had previously commented that even though one was vegan, you couldn't taste the difference at all. The wonders of modern gelato science!
Double Scoop made a double scoop out of two flavours that really had no business being together. Meanwhile, one of the ice cream flavours seemed to convert into a froyo flavour overnight. Peculiar.
Speaking of peculiar, screams and angry threats were heard from the freezer, but Vanilla made it out completely unscathed. A rainbow mess that was once Abby was found in that freezer in the morning."
EMS's role is something else, and making me more suspicious about EMS being Froyo. But first I'll deal with Bidoof since I think even now he wants me dead, then probably will do bad cream, then froyo cream, then bad cream, then froyo cream, and so on and so on.
EDIT: The scum readings are getting stronger for me regarding L'Belle, especially since he is just saying things, but otherwise is not doing much either to defend himself or try to even redirect suspicion to someone else. Because of what I have taken to be fact at this point, I'm also having to question what Lycan is saying, though the role is not something that I believe to be made up.
EDIT2: I might as well take a look myself at the list Miah has posted, and I will make a few changes to it.
EDIT3: I was wrong about how Oracle worked, so I have edited my information on Abby and EMS.
"The two Choc Mints went about their investigations, like the know-it-alls they are. They were like two scoops in a cone, even though they never spoke to each other. It was kinda cute! Customers had previously commented that even though one was vegan, you couldn't taste the difference at all. The wonders of modern gelato science!
Double Scoop made a double scoop out of two flavours that really had no business being together. Meanwhile, one of the ice cream flavours seemed to convert into a froyo flavour overnight. Peculiar.
Speaking of peculiar, screams and angry threats were heard from the freezer, but Vanilla made it out completely unscathed. A rainbow mess that was once Abby was found in that freezer in the morning."
EMS's role is something else, and making me more suspicious about EMS being Froyo. But first I'll deal with Bidoof since I think even now he wants me dead, then probably will do bad cream, then froyo cream, then bad cream, then froyo cream, and so on and so on.
EDIT: The scum readings are getting stronger for me regarding L'Belle, especially since he is just saying things, but otherwise is not doing much either to defend himself or try to even redirect suspicion to someone else. Because of what I have taken to be fact at this point, I'm also having to question what Lycan is saying, though the role is not something that I believe to be made up.
EDIT2: I might as well take a look myself at the list Miah has posted, and I will make a few changes to it.
EDIT3: I was wrong about how Oracle worked, so I have edited my information on Abby and EMS.
Spoiler:
Last edited:
Nakuzami
[img]https://i.imgur.com/iwlpePA.png[/img]
- 6,896
- Posts
- 13
- Years
- Age 25
- The Forgotten Crossroads
- Seen Nov 15, 2023
oh my goodness, I go to sleep and then look at all the absolutely shitty logic that pops up in my absence
gimme a sec kiddos, this is ridiculous and need a moment to type
gimme a sec kiddos, this is ridiculous and need a moment to type
Nakuzami
[img]https://i.imgur.com/iwlpePA.png[/img]
- 6,896
- Posts
- 13
- Years
- Age 25
- The Forgotten Crossroads
- Seen Nov 15, 2023
It literally just means what is says. That y'all are a mess. It's something I say fairly often in games and I guess I'm just a trendsetter
The cult would have a chat just like the mafia does, so they would have zero need for code words.
Yo, just because a role can't be physically roleblocked, does not mean it can't be "roleblocked," aka the roleblocker attempts to but simply fails. And since Syn's night action hasn't really come into play, there's absolutely nothing that would have suggested whether the roleblock was successful or not at that point
That's literally not how the oracle role works. When an oracle dies, their target has their role clearly revealed next to their username and it stays there permanently on the cast list.
You've lost me. That conclusion makes zero sense from the evidence that you all have proposed. Or is it just that it's convenient for you?
Yes, we were paying attention lmfao. Again, that's literally not how the oracle role works
If the Oracle action had revealed Vanilla, as you just implied, the post would have said, in big, bold letters
[Player] is Vanilla!
and then every instance of the cast list from then on would have that clearly stated
so that did not happen
the oracle legit has to be alive, or either was culted or never used their night action for whatever reason
There's nothing to suggest that Syn is lying about his role
Again, this feels like y'all using extremely flawed logic to try to push a narrative that suits you, and at this point I'm simply not having it
Nakuzami
[img]https://i.imgur.com/iwlpePA.png[/img]
- 6,896
- Posts
- 13
- Years
- Age 25
- The Forgotten Crossroads
- Seen Nov 15, 2023
Blame PC being so slow for not responding quickly enough, I got the idea the first time and you saw the post while I was trying to figure out how to remove it.
So if Abby was not the Lemon Sorbet, what roles can reveal a role, but not the person owning the role? Cause I still believe Abby was tailored and that Desox was the real Rainbow.
So if Abby was not the Lemon Sorbet, what roles can reveal a role, but not the person owning the role? Cause I still believe Abby was tailored and that Desox was the real Rainbow.