Fan Games Hub General discussions about all things fan games. Topics relating to both ROM hacks and custom games are welcome here. Posting links to ROMs is illegal and is not tolerated anywhere on the forum.

View Poll Results: What's more important to you?
Playable Maps 71 63.39%
Beautiful Maps 41 36.61%
Voters: 112. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #1    
Old July 31st, 2009 (3:52 PM).
Conan Edogawa's Avatar
Conan Edogawa Conan Edogawa is offline
One Truth Prevails
     
    Join Date: Jan 2009
    Location: Massachusetts
    Nature: Relaxed
    Posts: 1,061
    This is something I've seen coming up a lot so I thought I would get opinions. What is more important to you? A beautiful map or a playable. No in betweens here. I vote for Playable. Just because a map looks good by itself doesn't mean it will be fun to play. If you look at the original Nintendo maps most are "poor" as far as looks go but they're fun to play. Also since they're hacks that are meant to be played I think playability comes first. What do you think?
    __________________
    Reply With Quote

    Relevant Advertising!

      #2    
    Old August 1st, 2009 (5:01 AM).
    Pokepal17's Avatar
    Pokepal17 Pokepal17 is offline
    More cowbell~
    • Silver Tier
     
    Join Date: Oct 2008
    Location: Steeltown
    Age: 22
    Gender: Male
    Nature: Modest
    Posts: 1,511
    Id say playable maps since the look of a map will not always tell us it's playability.
    __________________
    Pokémon Stardrop
    Reply With Quote
      #3    
    Old August 1st, 2009 (6:52 AM).
    Chibi Robo's Avatar
    Chibi Robo Chibi Robo is offline
    of the entire epoch!
    • Silver Tier
     
    Join Date: Aug 2008
    Location: Cali
    Age: 21
    Gender: Male
    Nature: Jolly
    Posts: 853
    Well a map always has to be practical like an entrance and a end
    But In my opinion I like beautiful maps who doesn't like strolling by a city when it looks gorgeous
    __________________
    Pair: Vrai
    Reply With Quote
      #4    
    Old August 1st, 2009 (6:59 AM).
    Vrai's Avatar
    Vrai Vrai is offline
    can you feel my heart?
    • Crystal Tier
     
    Join Date: Jun 2008
    Age: 23
    Gender: Male
    Nature: Adamant
    Posts: 2,893
    Playability is the most important aspect of mapping. Who cares if it looks beautiful if you can't get through the map?
    __________________
    Reply With Quote
      #5    
    Old August 1st, 2009 (8:16 AM).
    sasquatchd00d's Avatar
    sasquatchd00d sasquatchd00d is offline
    welcoming a clean head.
       
      Join Date: Nov 2008
      Location: barracuda, capital of the world
      Age: 25
      Nature: Relaxed
      Posts: 265
      I'm not going to vote because it's both. A beautiful map without playability is still awful and vice versa. Aesthetics and playability go hand in hand really. A map that's beautiful, but only gives me one tile of walking space? No thanks. A map that gives me a wide variety of things to do as well as giving me space to move, but looks terrible? I'll pass. But people tend to lean towards beauty for some reason. Take Pokémon Crono for example. The routes give the player little room to move, yet they look aesthetically pleasing. And this is a very well made hack and quite popular.
      __________________
      [ [???="Not so good artwork. If you can even call it that."]deviantART[/???] | [???="No thread yet. Maybe eventually."]Pokémon Apollo[/???] | [???="SkythurBathandBeyond151"]Pair[/???] ]
      Reply With Quote
        #6    
      Old August 1st, 2009 (8:27 AM).
      sab's Avatar
      sab sab is offline
      Now too much of a life.
         
        Join Date: Jul 2008
        Location: Midgar
        Age: 21
        Gender: Male
        Nature: Timid
        Posts: 995
        I think that a map that looks ugly but has great playability stinks, and a map that looks great but you can only get to one or two parts is also worth-less. It is essencial to make a nice map that has lots of side passages to explore while still keeping shape and good placement.
        __________________
        Reply With Quote
          #7    
        Old August 1st, 2009 (9:33 AM).
        Luck's Avatar
        Luck Luck is offline
        ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
           
          Join Date: Nov 2007
          Posts: 6,771
          It's a mix of both. They are connected, because you cannot have a truly great map without both of them. Of course, they matter differently in their respective areas. Whenever someone just makes a map they don't plan on using in a game, I lean more on the aesthetics side, as long as the path gives the player space to move. The rating is reversed when someone plans to use the map in a hack, as long as the map doesn't look awful.
          Reply With Quote
            #8    
          Old August 1st, 2009 (2:41 PM).
          Griin.'s Avatar
          Griin. Griin. is offline
             
            Join Date: Aug 2008
            Posts: 275
            I'd say playability. Sure that map has to be beautiful but you won't see its full beauty in game. So this is why i vote for playabillity.
            __________________
            It's comming...
            Reply With Quote
              #9    
            Old August 1st, 2009 (2:43 PM).
            lucas_irineu lucas_irineu is offline
               
              Join Date: Dec 2008
              Location: Brazil
              Gender: Male
              Nature: Relaxed
              Posts: 4
              There is no reason that you cant have a map that is both playable and beautiful. Someone skilled enough to make a beautiful map can easily make it good to play in.
              Reply With Quote
                #10    
              Old August 1st, 2009 (2:55 PM).
              Disturbed's Avatar
              Disturbed Disturbed is offline
              O.o
                 
                Join Date: May 2008
                Age: 23
                Posts: 659
                Finally, this is my kind of thread.

                Alright, first of all... I originally thought (like, 6 months ago) that a beautiful map was the most important thing to make, and the aspect of playability had never occurred to me. Alright, (sorry Neti) but playing Legend of Fenju, which was a hack entirely based around beauty, with limited sense of playability, I thought to myself, 'is this really what I want to strive for?' Sure, looking at a map on a thread like the MRT, what we really enjoy seeing is a beautiful map... but people need to imagine how much it would really suck to be a person who is playing the hack. Now, if the map has a mixture, it may go nicely... but it is near impossible to have a nice map, with a good sense of playability, unless your mapping style is exactly like Rijon Adventures', and Liquid Ocean's. Those two hacks are the only ones I can name off the top of my head, that truely combine playability, and beauty.

                (I know people will hate me for this) Nintendo had it right, we had it wrong. I'll say it right now, EVERY SINGLE MAP I MADE THAT I POSTED ON MRT IS BAD. Nintendo's style is really what we should strive for.

                Honestly, I can say... Nintendo has made very beautiful maps, and very playable maps.
                Reply With Quote
                  #11    
                Old August 2nd, 2009 (2:49 AM).
                hunterzhorizon's Avatar
                hunterzhorizon hunterzhorizon is offline
                Noob, Needs Teacher.
                   
                  Join Date: Jul 2009
                  Location: ANCHORAGE, ALASKA
                  Age: 25
                  Gender: Male
                  Nature: Calm
                  Posts: 33
                  it can be pretty as hell, but not work.
                  id rather it be playable as hella, and ugly.
                  though, looks are somthing that will catch the eye.
                  this is sort of a tricky question.
                  but i voted playable.
                  __________________
                  I'm not a video gamer, I'm a Pokémon trainer!

                  [FONT=Comic Sans MS]FC: 0861 2268 1652

                  (Made by: GodofPH)
                  Reply With Quote
                    #12    
                  Old August 2nd, 2009 (5:57 AM).
                  Pokepal17's Avatar
                  Pokepal17 Pokepal17 is offline
                  More cowbell~
                  • Silver Tier
                   
                  Join Date: Oct 2008
                  Location: Steeltown
                  Age: 22
                  Gender: Male
                  Nature: Modest
                  Posts: 1,511
                  Quote:
                  Originally Posted by Disturbed View Post
                  Finally, this is my kind of thread.

                  Alright, first of all... I originally thought (like, 6 months ago) that a beautiful map was the most important thing to make, and the aspect of playability had never occurred to me. Alright, (sorry Neti) but playing Legend of Fenju, which was a hack entirely based around beauty, with limited sense of playability, I thought to myself, 'is this really what I want to strive for?' Sure, looking at a map on a thread like the MRT, what we really enjoy seeing is a beautiful map... but people need to imagine how much it would really suck to be a person who is playing the hack. Now, if the map has a mixture, it may go nicely... but it is near impossible to have a nice map, with a good sense of playability, unless your mapping style is exactly like Rijon Adventures', and Liquid Ocean's. Those two hacks are the only ones I can name off the top of my head, that truely combine playability, and beauty.

                  (I know people will hate me for this) Nintendo had it right, we had it wrong. I'll say it right now, EVERY SINGLE MAP I MADE THAT I POSTED ON MRT IS BAD. Nintendo's style is really what we should strive for.

                  Honestly, I can say... Nintendo has made very beautiful maps, and very playable maps.
                  This is probably one of the best posts iregarding mapping ever. You're totally right, even I've played hacks with beautiful maps which aren't very playable. However, we shouldn't all just copy Nintendo's style, we should tweak it a bit so it would suit us.
                  __________________
                  Pokémon Stardrop
                  Reply With Quote
                    #13    
                  Old August 2nd, 2009 (2:41 PM).
                  Conan Edogawa's Avatar
                  Conan Edogawa Conan Edogawa is offline
                  One Truth Prevails
                     
                    Join Date: Jan 2009
                    Location: Massachusetts
                    Nature: Relaxed
                    Posts: 1,061
                    Quote:
                    Originally Posted by Pokepal17 View Post
                    This is probably one of the best posts iregarding mapping ever. You're totally right, even I've played hacks with beautiful maps which aren't very playable. However, we shouldn't all just copy Nintendo's style, we should tweak it a bit so it would suit us.
                    That's exactly how I feel. People should try and map with a balance similar to the one Nintendo has.
                    __________________
                    Reply With Quote
                      #14    
                    Old August 2nd, 2009 (3:29 PM).
                    Pokepal17's Avatar
                    Pokepal17 Pokepal17 is offline
                    More cowbell~
                    • Silver Tier
                     
                    Join Date: Oct 2008
                    Location: Steeltown
                    Age: 22
                    Gender: Male
                    Nature: Modest
                    Posts: 1,511
                    Quote:
                    Originally Posted by Gir? View Post
                    That's exactly how I feel. People should try and map with a balance similar to the one Nintendo has.
                    Yep, but since a lot of us have been told to do more beautiful looking maps, we're all used to it. Nintendo make a lot of good maps and we (including myself) all say they are rubbish, even though we may not be able to do better.
                    __________________
                    Pokémon Stardrop
                    Reply With Quote
                      #15    
                    Old August 2nd, 2009 (4:11 PM).
                    .Seth's Avatar
                    .Seth .Seth is offline
                    .explorer.
                    • Crystal Tier
                     
                    Join Date: Jun 2008
                    Location: A capacitor in a power supply board.
                    Gender: Male
                    Nature: Quiet
                    Posts: 1,645
                    I agree with Disturbed entirely. I prefer simple, playable maps, with a few touches. Like a fence, or something subtle.
                    Reply With Quote
                      #16    
                    Old August 2nd, 2009 (4:23 PM).
                    burakcem's Avatar
                    burakcem burakcem is offline
                    I will become a pokemon Champ!
                       
                      Join Date: Jul 2009
                      Location: Amsterdam
                      Gender: Male
                      Nature: Relaxed
                      Posts: 3
                      i'd say playable because a map doesn't always have to look good to be fun and i think you play a game for fun !

                      The beauty is just something extra
                      Reply With Quote
                        #17    
                      Old August 3rd, 2009 (1:51 PM).
                      PiplupGHacker's Avatar
                      PiplupGHacker PiplupGHacker is offline
                      Keeping the dream alive.
                         
                        Join Date: Mar 2007
                        Location: New Lenox, IL
                        Age: 20
                        Gender: Female
                        Nature: Lonely
                        Posts: 125
                        Beautiful - Exactly why Hoenn is my favorite region
                        __________________
                        Click above for my collab YouTube Let's Play channel!
                        Featuring games like Pokemon SoulSilver, Mystery Dungeon, and Persona 3: FES!
                        Reply With Quote
                          #18    
                        Old August 3rd, 2009 (6:21 PM).
                        Chimchar 9's Avatar
                        Chimchar 9 Chimchar 9 is offline
                        (:
                        • Silver Tier
                         
                        Join Date: Jan 2008
                        Location: England, London
                        Age: 23
                        Gender: Male
                        Nature: Calm
                        Posts: 1,618
                        Well, i prefer beautiful maps.
                        I can see what Disturbed is saying, but i think playable maps should be maps with quite alot of scripts in, otherwise well it'll be pretty boring with hardly anything around.

                        In a hack you should make afew beautiful maps & afew Playable maps, just to equal it all out.
                        __________________
                        Pokemon Green Diamond
                        Status: cancelled
                        Reply With Quote
                          #19    
                        Old August 3rd, 2009 (11:49 PM).
                        Luck's Avatar
                        Luck Luck is offline
                        ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
                           
                          Join Date: Nov 2007
                          Posts: 6,771
                          Quote:
                          Originally Posted by Disturbed View Post
                          Finally, this is my kind of thread.

                          Alright, first of all... I originally thought (like, 6 months ago) that a beautiful map was the most important thing to make, and the aspect of playability had never occurred to me. Alright, (sorry Neti) but playing Legend of Fenju, which was a hack entirely based around beauty, with limited sense of playability, I thought to myself, 'is this really what I want to strive for?' Sure, looking at a map on a thread like the MRT, what we really enjoy seeing is a beautiful map... but people need to imagine how much it would really suck to be a person who is playing the hack. Now, if the map has a mixture, it may go nicely... but it is near impossible to have a nice map, with a good sense of playability, unless your mapping style is exactly like Rijon Adventures', and Liquid Ocean's. Those two hacks are the only ones I can name off the top of my head, that truely combine playability, and beauty.

                          (I know people will hate me for this) Nintendo had it right, we had it wrong. I'll say it right now, EVERY SINGLE MAP I MADE THAT I POSTED ON MRT IS BAD. Nintendo's style is really what we should strive for.

                          Honestly, I can say... Nintendo has made very beautiful maps, and very playable maps.
                          I disagree. Nintendo is a far cry from beautiful maps, at least to me. It was very playable, but I think a beautiful map has to look natural as well as be playable. square patches of grass, straight lines of trees, and mountain tiles that almost perfectly follow each other just doesn't cut it as natural.
                          When we use the Nintendo style of mapping, we have a void where originality used to be. you should use your own style instead of mimicking another style. I actually tried to make a Nintendo style map, and I hated it. Maybe I don't have the touch that Cirno has, but I absolutely hated my Nintendo maps, and I'm sure others would as well.
                          Reply With Quote
                            #20    
                          Old August 4th, 2009 (12:17 AM).
                          Ninja Caterpie's Avatar
                          Ninja Caterpie Ninja Caterpie is offline
                          Sitting by the back window
                             
                            Join Date: Mar 2008
                            Location: Best City OCE
                            Age: 21
                            Gender: Male
                            Nature: Bold
                            Posts: 5,945
                            All of the above.

                            Well, some things can still be beautiful without screwing with gameplay. Mountains and trees and water can have nice, awesome, beautiful, natural shapes without screwing with gameplay. The only thing that poses a problem is when the mapper makes it so natural that it restricts the player.

                            But both together is good. Sasquatchd00d does this brilliantly, and Thrace does too. So do I, if I say so myself. 8D

                            And Disturbed, most of your maps are awesome-looking to play in too, stop putting yourself down.
                            __________________
                            Brony represent.
                            Reply With Quote
                              #21    
                            Old August 4th, 2009 (4:44 AM).
                            Kyouya's Avatar
                            Kyouya Kyouya is offline
                            "baddest of the bad"
                               
                              Join Date: Jan 2009
                              Location: Drazil
                              Nature: Rash
                              Posts: 338
                              nintendo did it so you can have both but if i could only chose 1 playabilty since the whole map isnt shown in game to see that it is beatiful
                              __________________
                              Thing I've learned
                              I couldn't leave Pc if I tried
                              If nippon ichi isn't making soul nomad 2 I will This I swear

                              Favorite games
                              1.Soul Nomad
                              2.Shining force exa
                              3.most dbz fighting games
                              4.naruto ultimate ninja 2 (shino chidori ftw)
                              5.God eater/Disgaea/Mass effect
                              Thing I've Noticed
                              That I'm coming up with Random stuff to make the scroll bar activate
                              I'm an angry person
                              Random quotes

                              "Who's the baddest of the bad, maddest of the mad, killer of kings, and destroyer of worlds"-gig
                              "Everyone needs to die."-revya
                              Alt account
                              Kyo The pro


                              Reply With Quote
                                #22    
                              Old August 4th, 2009 (8:33 AM).
                              NarutoActor's Avatar
                              NarutoActor NarutoActor is offline
                              The rocks cry out to me
                              • Silver Tier
                               
                              Join Date: Jan 2009
                              Location: Brooklyn/Marlboro
                              Age: 23
                              Gender: Female
                              Nature: Bashful
                              Posts: 1,979
                              there intertwined if the map is ugly I dont want to play it so its not playable if the map is not playable its not beautyful
                              __________________
                              ~There are those people who understand hex, F the rest
                              Reply With Quote
                                #23    
                              Old August 4th, 2009 (1:06 PM).
                              Disturbed's Avatar
                              Disturbed Disturbed is offline
                              O.o
                                 
                                Join Date: May 2008
                                Age: 23
                                Posts: 659
                                Quote:
                                Originally Posted by Ninja Caterpie View Post

                                And Disturbed, most of your maps are awesome-looking to play in too, stop putting yourself down.
                                I doesn't like mah old maps though.

                                And to what you said, Munchlax... who says the maps can't be filled with scripts?
                                Reply With Quote
                                  #24    
                                Old August 5th, 2009 (4:28 AM).
                                Full Metal's Avatar
                                Full Metal Full Metal is offline
                                C(++) Developer.
                                • Silver Tier
                                 
                                Join Date: Jan 2008
                                Location: In my mind.
                                Age: 22
                                Gender: Male
                                Nature: Timid
                                Posts: 806
                                OOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHH interesting...
                                well here's what i say.
                                1)If your posting the map on MRT you want to post a BEAUTIFUL map but where it isn't obviously unplayable (make it atleast somewhat playable, people can tell)
                                2)If you are doing a hack, you want a little bit different type of map.
                                Well, you are playing a game so you want playable maps right?
                                BUT that's not saying that they can't look good either.
                                I reccomend setting the map and block view size to double
                                then look at things the way a player would, 15 square blocks (i think that's the right number)
                                and make a "min-map" without necessarily random big tree placement, but rather a few small trees (i'm talkin 1 or 2 here) and decide if that area should have wild-grass or not.
                                After you make the map go to regular size and check to see if you missed anything or not.
                                Make sure the map makes sense.
                                E.G. your path(s) connect, and that you didn't "misplace" any trees or nothing. Those sort of things, then it's not a bad map necessarily (just remember the little trees aren't necessary every 15 tiles OK?
                                __________________

                                ★ full metal.

                                I like to push it,
                                and push it,
                                until my luck is over.
                                Reply With Quote
                                  #25    
                                Old August 5th, 2009 (4:51 AM).
                                Crimson Stardust's Avatar
                                Crimson Stardust Crimson Stardust is offline
                                Anime Addiction
                                   
                                  Join Date: Mar 2009
                                  Location: It is for me to noe and all of you to find out
                                  Age: 24
                                  Gender: Male
                                  Nature: Relaxed
                                  Posts: 1,300
                                  I have an answer to this..its short and sweet...
                                  a map{if you are making for a hack}must have bothe qualities..its what make the maps look great and nice to play in..
                                  __________________



                                  Reply With Quote
                                  Reply
                                  Quick Reply

                                  Sponsored Links
                                  Thread Tools

                                  Posting Rules
                                  You may not post new threads
                                  You may not post replies
                                  You may not post attachments
                                  You may not edit your posts

                                  BB code is On
                                  Smilies are On
                                  [IMG] code is On
                                  HTML code is Off

                                  Forum Jump


                                  All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:16 AM.